Lies about drunk driving?

Is having a drink your reason to live? Are you able to leave the house if you don't have one?
Is being safe and less of a threat to other people unmanly? :rolleyes:

On something entirely unrelated, Brill I have to say your sig video is starting to creep me out. Just saying.
 
Most won't bother....and blowing under the limit will also create a probable cause defence.
Not to keep going with this, but that depends upon how you were trying to "Screw with the Breathalizer" and what the law is regarding implied consent in Canada and Ontario.
 
Almost everyone over-estimates their ability to drive while intoxicated, especially people who are intoxicated. While it's true that there are people who can drives safely at 0.08, there are also people who cannot drive safely at that level. Those who cannot of course believe they are safe to drive, even when they really are not.

At the end of the day we had to draw the line somewhere. We drew it at 0.08, and everybody knows it. No matter where you put the line, you could argue that it's unfair to someone--but what makes it fair is that we ALL know where the legal limit is.

There are many other examples in law of safety regulations that are very conservative, and there is nothing wrong with that. We also had to set speed limits, and while there are some people who can drive around safely at much higher speeds than the ones we posted, we picked a level that is generally safe for most people. Given that everybody knows what the rules are, so what?

Also I don't see how this is onerous. If I'm going to have more than one drink, I'm probably going to have more than a couple. Personally, I really don't like getting half-way drunk. I wind up tired and with a headache. Either I stop after one drink anyway, or else I'm gong to drink a quantity of alcohol that would make me unsafe to drive by any standard.

The law as it stands allows you to accept a drink from your host and sip away at it, and then drive home. That's all that's needed. There is no real need to get half drunk and then drive, in my opinion. If you are actually planning on getting intoxicated, don't plan on driving. If you are not planning on getting intoxicated, WTF are you doing in the 0.09 or 0.10 range?
 
Last edited:
I think this chart brings into question your theory:

http://www.alcoholalert.com/drunk-driving-statistics.html

the .08 BAC limit has existed for a long time...yet alcohol related fatalities as a % have not really declined notably. MADD says the TOTAL number of Alcohol related fatalities is declining, but the chart shows the total number of fatalities is ALSO declining. I think you can give full credit for this one to safer vehicles. The more troubling issue is what is considered an "alcohol related" fatality. ANYONE involved in the accident...including a pedestrian,has greater then 0.01% BAC... it is considered "alcohol related". Pretty farcical IMHO.

Which chart are you looking at???

From the page you linked, at top 1982 43,000 fatalities, 26,000 drunk all the way down to 33,000 fatalities, 12,000 drunk.
The rate of drunk fatalities is decreasing FASTER than overall fatalities
Also there is a very clear correlation to PERCENT of fatalities including alcohol 60% down to 38%; pretty much every year it is dropping

And from a pure math standpoint in statistics as you approach the limit each percentage point carries more value (in other words, 38 to 37 % is HARDER than dropping 60 to 59%)
 
Not to keep going with this, but that depends upon how you were trying to "Screw with the Breathalizer" and what the law is regarding implied consent in Canada and Ontario.

Do what you want. I have done it before. The cop looked at me funny, but could do nothing.
 
Is having a drink your reason to live? Are you able to leave the house if you don't have one?
Is being safe and less of a threat to other people unmanly? :rolleyes:

No I actually drink very little, but when I do go to a pub I like to have a drink or 2. What annoys me more is the millions of dollars being spend through our justice system to destroy people who are not a threat to our society. I think my driving record of 29 years with no accidents stands for itself.
 
I love this imaginary world where intoxicated drivers aren't a threat to society.
Drunk drivers are a threat. I personally have loved ones that have lost lives because they got behind the wheel drunk, and others who have been maimed by others hammered when driving.

However. How "impaired" does one drink make you. Or 2. In 2-3 hours. Is it the same as 0.08?? Obviosly not. Is it the same as only having 3 hours sleep the night before? Probably not as bad. Is it the same as changing the song on your ipod or the radio station? Is it the same as arguing with your gf in the passenger seat? The same as yelling at youe misbehaving kids in the back?
The point is, there are numerous things we all do while driving that "ipair"'us. The qhestion is what is our intolerance of impairment? In fact the most dangerous act while driving is to get behind the wheel inthe first place. Why dont we focus more on getting people off the road??

Im not argung that driving drunk isnt a scourge and should be abolished. However, having a pint after work and drivng home likely doesnt impair one much more than the other thngs i said. Driving is dangerous period. We can try to minimize risk, but at some point , these efforts impact on the rights and frredoms of everyday folks. Should we pass a law that you cant drive while tired? Or drinking coffee??
 
I don't understand this argument

The new limit is 0.05 I believe. According to BAC charts from Virginia Tech University, for the average male (180 lbs) one standard drink is worth about 0.02 in terms of BAC. Two drinks is 0.04, still under the limit. Now let's say you go out to dinner. That's usually about 2 hours if it's a sit-down dinner with a date or colleagues. So you have two glasses of wine (or 2 beers or 2 mixed drinks) over 2 hours. You're still comfortably under the limit. No 'abuse of power' by the police or government has occurred, you're still able to drink, but you're under the limit and even on the rare chance you get pulled over by RIDE, you're still under the limit. Sure they can be dicks and hassle you, but who cares? You're under the limit and can't be charged or penalized. And 9/10 times if you're truly under the limit and have no ill effects, no cop is going to hassle you anyway. You're no danger to yourself or passengers or any one on the road. How is that placing any undue restrictions on your freedom? Sure MADD is a tad annoying with their constant ads, but the fact is, there is no realistic excuse for you to have more than the legal limit anyway. Being a designated driver is not a big deal. There are very few social occasions when one needs to have more than 2 drinks in a hour anyway. I'm a big drinker myself, but I don't drive. It isn't even an issue. You have so many options (bus, cab, TTC, friends) that there's no excuse. And if you have enough money to blow at SCs or regular bars, you have enough money to take a cab.

I've seen some impressive drunken driving in my university days, and I know that the BAC chart is ridiculously conservative, but it's for a good cause. There's little political agenda aside from saving lives involved, and in the end it doesn't infringe on anyone's freedom. Alcohol is a luxury, not a necessity. And any one who plots how to beat a Breathlyzer is clearly not intending to just stop at 0.06. There are many other ways that the government infringes on people's freedoms, this is most assuredly not it. Cops can be assholes and abuse their power, but this is not an example of it at all.
 
How "impaired" does one drink make you. Or 2. In 2-3 hours.

One drink will not put you over the limit, nor will two drinks in 2-3 hours. The average ~180lbs male can metabolize one drink per hour, so if you limit yourself to a drink an hour you should be fine. If you're a little guy you may need to slow down a bit from that. There are tables you can look up the rate at which you can metabolize alcohol based on body weight.

Is it the same as changing the song on your ipod or the radio station? Is it the same as arguing with your gf in the passenger seat? The same as yelling at youe misbehaving kids in the back?

What's different about all of those things is you can choose the moment to do them. You will not fiddle with your iPod and you will pause your argument when you get to a complex situation, like an intersection with multiple things going on, or a merge situation. You see people do this all the time--they start to say something, pause for a moment to check their mirrors, execute a merge, and then finish their sentence. People do it unconsciously--but they do it. On the other hand, if you are intoxicated you are intoxicated during the merge, at the complex intersection, everywhere--you can't "pause" being intoxicated.

Moreover, being intoxicated is not just about having a slow reaction time or being distracted. It is about having poorer judgement, and attempting to execute maneuvers that you shouldn't attempt because alcohol impairs your judgement, not just your reflexes. No matter how pissed you are at your girlfriend, being pissed off doesn't impair your judgement in the same way. In fact, you're probably likely to drive a little more cautiously in that case because your judgement is still good and you will be conscious that your argument is stretching your ability to drive.
 
This whole topic is a loaded question as far as I'm concerned. For starters, if the goverenment and police were really serious about this, the ride programe would be completely different. They should have 1 or 2 cars undercover outside every bar 7 days a week as opposed to 5 cars on some random intersection hoping to catch the odd person.

Many people don't realize that drinking and driving is the most difficult and technical law in Canada. There is a whole book on the law which is constantly changing because so many cases are you unique and different.

Part of the biggest problem is that what starts out as legal, at some point crosses over to illagel and that grey area is extrmemely hard to pinpoint.

The law is also not supposed to take intent into account.

This I have a problem with. A good friend on mine is currently going through this charge. (impaired driving)

He knew he was going out drinking with some friends and made arrangments to stay at a mutual friend of ours house to do the responible thing.

Woke up in the morning to a bit of an emergency, ran out door before he had time to assess himself. Just bolted out the door thinking he wasn't fully awake yet and would be fine in a few minutes.

Now his life is up side down because of it. Did he drink iresponsible? yes. Did he intend to break the law or put people's life in danger? no.

Now if he losses his trial, his whole lively hood is screwed up. Not to mention he considered a criminal which also can be a royal pain in the ass.

The worst part is we go out all the time and he always does the the responsible thing by taking a taxi home or making arrangements to stay at someone else's house. This was just a freak situation that has made his life a living hell. Mean while, the last few times we've gone out to a pub we watch tons of people knocking them back and getting in there car afterwords.

So, my point being, I don't know what the answer is in terms of who should get what penalties or would be done to tailgate the problem, but it sure is a bit more difficult to tackle then I think people realize and that's why the government stuggles with it so much.
 
Can you challenge the facts presented or is that just an unfounded opinion?

Quite happy to. IT is a very selective review of statistics and studies. Go back and read it with an open mind, and carefully consider the wording and approach used. If you can't spot it yourself I can set aside some time later in the week to walk you through it.
 
Yeah that's right. We should be all allowed to drink and drive.

Those damn nazi's telling us what we can't do. Bunch of idiots. If I want to drink my beer and get in a car, that should be nobody's business. And if I happen to inflict injury or death on someone because my perception was a bit blurred, my judgment a bit impaired, or my reflexes were a bit slowed, hell that's the price we pay for living in a free society.

Okay, enough with the sarcasm.

Look idiot, it's all a numbers game. There simply are many, many, many, more people driving at any given time sober than drunk. There is no reason to expect that they will not be involved in more accidents simply given the numbers. The point is that when you take into account the proportion of people driving sober versus drunk, you have a SIGNIFICANTLY higher percentage of accidents due to those drunken idiots. Furthermore, this is something that can be prevented by simply not getting behind the wheel if you chose to drive or not drinking prior to having to drive. People have to drive in most situations to make their living and accidents will consequentially happen. People do not need to drink and drive and place others (and themselves) at risk.

There are very few things that I read on this board that make me mad. This is by far the most infuriating posting I've seen. You're either an alcoholic in denial of reality, evil, or simply retarded.
 
Most won't bother....and blowing under the limit will also create a probable cause defence.

"probable cause" is not a defense.

If the officer is not satisfied with how you blow he can charge you with failure to blow. It is up to his discretion.

I don't know if anyone here has ever done a proper Impaired/0ver 80 defense in Ontario, but the gold standard is to hire a toxicologist who then has you drink in controlled conditions and will then do blood and breath testing on an ongoing basis to establish your baseline from which you can then develop the various defenses open to these charges.

But what we do know from that testing by thousands of toxicologists in controlled conditions that driving skills begin to be affected in most individuals around .04 or .05. After that the rest is subjective. The question is how much risk does society want to take from drunk drivers, and at what level or impairment do we want to set the baseline to drive. The government has set the limits at .05 and .08 for which there is a ton of evidence that your ability to drive is impaired.
 
"probable cause" is not a defense.
If the officer is not satisfied with how you blow he can charge you with failure to blow. It is up to his discretion.
I don't know if anyone here has ever done a proper Impaired/0ver 80 defense in Ontario, but the gold standard is to hire a toxicologist who then has you drink in controlled conditions and will then do blood and breath testing on an ongoing basis to establish your baseline from which you can then develop the various defenses open to these charges.
I think when he says the probable cause defense he means that low readings can indirectly help to establish a charter argument that there was no reasonable and probable grounds for demand (search) and or detention because the accused was not sufficiently impaired and did not exhibit enough criteria of impairment etc.
Re gold standard: man you are old...the toxicologists don't do that for ages. There was a couple of cases where the courts frowned upon this practice, and then there was a bill c-2 ( constitutionality of which went all the way up to SCC and hopefully we will have a decision soon). Toxicologists still do many things but drinking in controlled conditions is not one of them.
 
I think when he says the probable cause defense he means that low readings can indirectly help to establish a charter argument that there was no reasonable and probable grounds for demand (search) and or detention because the accused was not sufficiently impaired and did not exhibit enough criteria of impairment etc.
Re gold standard: man you are old...the toxicologists don't do that for ages. There was a couple of cases where the courts frowned upon this practice, and then there was a bill c-2 ( constitutionality of which went all the way up to SCC and hopefully we will have a decision soon). Toxicologists still do many things but drinking in controlled conditions is not one of them.

That is odd, because I know some guys who still do this to establish the evidence to the contrary defense. While it is expensive, it is hard to imagine a more effective way of making this argument.

But...I am old.
 
From the posted link: "In 2009, there were 10,839 fatalities in crashes involving a driver with a BAC of .08 or higher – 32 percent of total traffic fatalities for the year."

As pointed out, the number of impaired drivers on the road throughout the day would be very small percentage, maybe 1% but likely lower, but impaired drivers account for 32% of the accidents. Seems clear that impaired drivers are responsible for a disproportionate number of deaths on the road.

The other stat that caught my attention: "In 2009, 5,851 passenger vehicle drivers killed had a BAC of .08 or higher. Out of those driver fatalities for which restraint use was known, 72 percent were unrestrained."

The percentage of people not wearing seatbelts would be low, but the few people not wearing seatbelts represent a high percentage of the deaths.
 
Almost everyone over-estimates their ability to drive while intoxicated, especially people who are intoxicated. While it's true that there are people who can drives safely at 0.08, there are also people who cannot drive safely at that level. Those who cannot of course believe they are safe to drive, even when they really are not.

At the end of the day we had to draw the line somewhere. We drew it at 0.08, and everybody knows it. No matter where you put the line, you could argue that it's unfair to someone--but what makes it fair is that we ALL know where the legal limit is.

There are many other examples in law of safety regulations that are very conservative, and there is nothing wrong with that. We also had to set speed limits, and while there are some people who can drive around safely at much higher speeds than the ones we posted, we picked a level that is generally safe for most people. Given that everybody knows what the rules are, so what?

Also I don't see how this is onerous. If I'm going to have more than one drink, I'm probably going to have more than a couple. Personally, I really don't like getting half-way drunk. I wind up tired and with a headache. Either I stop after one drink anyway, or else I'm gong to drink a quantity of alcohol that would make me unsafe to drive by any standard.

The law as it stands allows you to accept a drink from your host and sip away at it, and then drive home. That's all that's needed. There is no real need to get half drunk and then drive, in my opinion. If you are actually planning on getting intoxicated, don't plan on driving. If you are not planning on getting intoxicated, WTF are you doing in the 0.09 or 0.10 range?


Do some reading.. the limit is now 0.05.... geez!!!
 
From the posted link: "In 2009, there were 10,839 fatalities in crashes involving a driver with a BAC of .08 or higher – 32 percent of total traffic fatalities for the year."

As pointed out, the number of impaired drivers on the road throughout the day would be very small percentage, maybe 1% but likely lower, but impaired drivers account for 32% of the accidents. Seems clear that impaired drivers are responsible for a disproportionate number of deaths on the road.

The other stat that caught my attention: "In 2009, 5,851 passenger vehicle drivers killed had a BAC of .08 or higher. Out of those driver fatalities for which restraint use was known, 72 percent were unrestrained."

The percentage of people not wearing seatbelts would be low, but the few people not wearing seatbelts represent a high percentage of the deaths.




Another useful fact to know...whole be how many of those were slightly higher then 0.08? After all 0.2 is still higher then 0.08... but that would be pretty drunk (probably 5-6 drinks in 2hrs) How many of those fatalities were between 0.08 and 0.10 for example?