I loved Shanahan as a player. I wish he had been a Leaf and I would dearly love to see him succeed as a Leaf executive.
However, from what I've seen so far, his influence on the team has not been encouraging.
The team has become IMHO the worst team in the league, considering the performance of the big team and the talent level of their prospects.
He fired Carlyle, obviously thinking Carlyle could not bring out the best in the team, and that was a wrong decision as the team went from a playoff contending team to a lottery team.
The team has become a soft and gutless team with all the changes made from the Burke era. I'm pretty sure a lot Nonis's decisions were influenced by Shanahan and his left/right hand men (Hunter & Dubas).
He has passed up on some experienced GMs, and from what I've read in the media, he's going after some lower level personnel in some other team (Rangers maybe ?).
He's trying to hire a coach before he hires a GM. Can anyone tell me if that order of hiring has ever worked to produce a successful team in the history of the league ?
Why would any well established GM want to work in an environment where he has so much messing around from above ?
If Shanahan plans on having a hands on approach, why doesn't he just make himself or Hunter the GM ? Does he only want someone to be the scape goat (like Nonis) down the road when the team fails again ?
I'm very concerned if he's the right man for the job.