Leafs - Bruins

Ranger68 said:
In any case, there are other things wrong with the NHL that bother me much more - specifically, the lack of discipline for totally over-the-line behaviour (Boulton, Sutton, Bertuzzi, et al.).
I disagree.

No, wait, I don't. Dammit.
 
shootouts are a beautiful thing.
 
21pro said:
shootouts are a beautiful thing.
I agree, I like them as well. The penalty shot during the game is one of the most exciting things to watch. Now we will get to see 5 or six of them on a regular basis. Get used too it, it is here to stay like it or not.
 
A-ROD said:
I agree, I like them as well. The penalty shot during the game is one of the most exciting things to watch. Now we will get to see 5 or six of them on a regular basis. Get used too it, it is here to stay like it or not.
They're only exciting when A) they're a rarety (which they no longer will be, they'll be commonplace) and B) when everything is on the line (like an Olympic gold) which it isn't because even if you "lose" you STILL get a point.

Overtime in the playoffs is one of the most tense situations in sport because it's all or nothing. Overtime and shootouts in regular season are dumb. After 60 minutes I change the channel.
 
A-ROD said:
I agree, I like them as well. The penalty shot during the game is one of the most exciting things to watch. Now we will get to see 5 or six of them on a regular basis. Get used too it, it is here to stay like it or not.

How do you know that?
You don't. None of these rule changes may last.
 
shack said:
Overtime in the playoffs is one of the most tense situations in sport because it's all or nothing. Overtime and shootouts in regular season are dumb. After 60 minutes I change the channel.

Agreed.

It's like watching the end of a scrimmage.

Will be interesting if there are shootouts at the end of the year that will determing playoff spots.
 
Ranger68 said:
How do you know that?
You don't. None of these rule changes may last.

probably a safe bet that they will remain for the most part, except for the odd minimal necessary tweaking that needs to be done.

one such instance is the fact that goalies are injuring their fingers on their glove hand because they don't have enough padding. it is common to see the goalies icing their hands during the intermissions as their fingers swell up.
 
shack said:
They're only exciting when A) they're a rarety (which they no longer will be, they'll be commonplace) and B) when everything is on the line (like an Olympic gold) which it isn't because even if you "lose" you STILL get a point..

well, i don't change the channel... i watch overtime... i watch the shootouts...

i can also say that out of 135 games played already this year, only 12 have seen a shootout.

the last season 2003-2004, after the first 100 games played there were already 16 OT's. too many to make it worth watching, imho.

so which is more commonplace?
 
Last edited:
21pro said:
probably a safe bet that they will remain for the most part, except for the odd minimal necessary tweaking that needs to be done.

"Probably a safe bet" vs. "they're here to stay".

Time will tell.
 
21pro said:
well, i don't change the channel... i watch overtime... i watch the shootouts...

i can also say that out of 135 games played already this year, only 12 have seen a shootout.

the last season 2003-2004, after the first 100 games played there were already 36 ties. too many to make it worth watching, imho.

so which is more commonplace?

Your number is waaaaaay wrong.
Of the first hundred games played in 2003-2004, there were 16 games that went to overtime. This is primarily a function of lower scoring.
Of those 16 games, 4 of them were decided in the OT, and 12 ended in ties.

Of the first 143 games in 2003-2004, 27 of them went to overtime, and 8 of them were then decided - which means that 19 would have gone to shootout.

Again, more games were being tied in 03-04 due to lower scoring games.
 
thanks for the correction. typo on my part. i'll try and post links to my evidence from now on; that way you still know what i am getting at.

but, even with those numbers, shootouts are even more rare... blame it on the fact that scoring is up or not (i agree it has something to do with less OT's and therefore less shootouts)... However, it's still true that shootouts are rare when compared to the number or ties.
http://www.nhl.com/news/2005/10/237702.html
especially when an increase of 41% only means 1.9 more goals per game. and the presumption is that more goals scored (up 41% over 03-04 through first 40 games) means less chance for a tie so in effect, ranger, you're absolutely right. but the variables that make those chances less is very miniscule, but accurate, so much that the difference in ties after 60m between 05 and 03-04 is exactly the variation amount that a 41% increase in goals scored would amount to. but, historically, when goals were higher, ties were way down for some strange reason... there must be something in the collective present day team mentality that makes players want to play for a tie... i think we need to address that issue, and the shootout does do that. but, more important is that scoring isn't really up at all. it is in fact more in line, but lower, than the averages over the entire history of the nhl.... and therefore, the goals need to go up even more. if this does happen, then, by all means, we can take the shootout out of there. even though i do enjoy it on rare occasion. some say shootouts should be saved for the playoffs... ie, only when a tie won't do... personally, i like the chance that a playoff game can go 6 periods... it really shows who wants it more when it really counts.

leafs fans broke an all-time record!!!
http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/Co...e&cid=1130277007486&call_pageid=1044442959412
 
Last edited: