Leaders' Debate

it is very scary that harper managed to shrug and half-smile his way through that debate without saying anything concrete in his own defence......if people are willing to forget the bungling and corruption that easily and give this guy a majority, we are in for a 4 year period which may destroy everything canada has achieved since pearson.
But , other than that, the debate was an interesting affair.....all 4 are skilled and clever.....at least we don't have the likes of palin or dubya spoutin' anti-intellectual rhetoric.
 
Frank Mckenna runs for and wins the liberal leadership.

In your dreams. (And many others I suspect...)

Frank Mckenna said:
"Although I have been deeply moved by expressions of support for me from across the country, I have not been persuaded to change my long-standing resolve to exit public life for good. My only regret is that I cannot honour the expectations of friends and supporters who have shown enormous loyalty to me," said McKenna in a statement released Tuesday.

"The challenge of winning the leadership, restoring the health of the Liberal party and returning a Liberal majority government requires a longer time commitment than I am prepared to make," the statement read.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/story/2008/10/28/mckenna-liberals.html
 
The smart money says..speak to the audience. Harper was quite smart in not engaging the other guys in the spat, but looking into the camera is a smart move. VERY SMART!!

I thought it was the STUPIDEST move that he could do during a debate. The other leaders would look at the person they were addressing during the debate and talk to them. Harper looked like he was removing himself from the debate and going into a soap box mode. This is when I thought the other leaders lost some initiative. I honestly would have snapped my fingers and said to Harper 'I'm over here .. or have we gone into a commercial break ?'

It would have added a little humour to the event, flustered Harper a little because of his previous coaxing and forced him to lie directly at the person that he is suppose to be talking to.

Of course if you if the purpose was to attract the gay/ female audience members - Harper does have an advantage ignoring the debate & staring into the camera. If Micheal Engima was staring in the camera, I think and pets in the room would immediately pee on the carpet and then run under the couch.
 
While 'some' may think that be should have looked at the person who asked the question....

Lets remember two things...

The other guys were throwing daggers at HARPER and trying to engage him in a spat...Why would he look back at them to engage in school yad bullying? He rose above it!

Secondly, I disagree with the communicators who think her should have looked at Layton, etal....I believe he was smart in looking into the camera and addressing the Canadian people. Sort of like a newscaster speaks to the camera. Sure some may disagree, but the POLLS suggest HArper did just fine!!
 
While 'some' may think that be should have looked at the person who asked the question....

Lets remember two things...

The other guys were throwing daggers at HARPER and trying to engage him in a spat...Why would he look back at them to engage in school yad bullying? He rose above it!

Secondly, I disagree with the communicators who think her should have looked at Layton, etal....I believe he was smart in looking into the camera and addressing the Canadian people. Sort of like a newscaster speaks to the camera. Sure some may disagree, but the POLLS suggest HArper did just fine!!
I think it is a good idea to look at the people you are trying to get through to.

Harper has already looked at those losers plenty of times discussing the same stuff so it makes sense that this was a good opportunity to look at the people he is actually trying to communicate to.
Plus a lot of times those morons were changing the subject from the question that came from the public.
 
I agree Mailbook

Harper was facing pitbulls...small yappy dogs at his heels..trying to engage him to upset him and throw him off.

Again smart money says...DO NOT ENGAGE IN THOSE TACTICS.....Oh it might be polite and all..but I would hasten to say the otherthree were not polite either..

HARPER DID as a good communicator should...not engage in thuggery, but remain ON MESSAGE and address Canadians.

Hence that is why he appeared more 'Prime Ministerial" as per the polls...and in fact, the polls would suggest he did quite well.

Now I am talking about the English debate...Did not see the Fench one..so cannot comment!!
 
I agree Mailbook

Harper was facing pitbulls...small yappy dogs at his heels..trying to engage him to upset him and throw him off.

Again smart money says...DO NOT ENGAGE IN THOSE TACTICS.....Oh it might be polite and all..but I would hasten to say the otherthree were not polite either..

HARPER DID as a good communicator should...not engage in thuggery, but remain ON MESSAGE and address Canadians.

Hence that is why he appeared more 'Prime Ministerial" as per the polls...and in fact, the polls would suggest he did quite well.

Now I am talking about the English debate...Did not see the Fench one..so cannot comment!!

Frank, make up your mind with your analysis. Were the other leaders pitbulls or small yappie dogs. a chihuahua or toy
Yorkie is a small yappie dog. I've heard anyone say the same about pitbulls.

Harper had it easy, stay cool, look prime ministerial, don't say anything important. Everyone knows the incumbent has that advantage. Now, then there's was this talking to the camera instead of the other leaders, dumb.
 
The polls would suggest it was not dumb....

Why look at a pitbull..when you can address the voters...

SMART!!!
 
HARPER DID as a good communicator should...not engage in thuggery,

It was a debate - what you are suggesting is that Harper is too much a coward to face his opponents (which I guess is true). The opposition were debating, Harper was preaching. As a Harper lover - you would have probably praised him if he ducked under the podium and answered on his phone so his opponents could not see him at all.

To suggest that the tactic has anything to do with result of the polls is a stretch. I could just as easily suggest the choice of eye glasses must have been perfect because his poll numbers are so high.

I really don't want a Liberal majority win but faced with irrational love of Harper with total stubborn refusal to acknowledge obvious errors in his judgment, I find myself fighting this bullshit conservative propaganda crap even though all the choices are so abysmal. As a minority government, Harper has wiped out all the deficit budget gains the Liberals left him, spent $1 billion dollars turning Toronto into a war zone, has been cited twice by independent accounting regulators for ignoring proper procedures, lots of irregular questionable acquisitions behind closed doors without public scrutiny AND THIS WHEN HE HAS A MINORITY GOVERNMENT! The thought of him being able to act with a majority government is scary shit.
 
It was a debate - what you are suggesting is that Harper is too much a coward to face his opponents (which I guess is true). The opposition were debating, Harper was preaching. As a Harper lover - you would have probably praised him if he ducked under the podium and answered on his phone so his opponents could not see him at all.

To suggest that the tactic has anything to do with result of the polls is a stretch. I could just as easily suggest the choice of eye glasses must have been perfect because his poll numbers are so high.

I really don't want a Liberal majority win but faced with irrational love of Harper with total stubborn refusal to acknowledge obvious errors in his judgment, I find myself fighting this bullshit conservative propaganda crap even though all the choices are so abysmal. As a minority government, Harper has wiped out all the deficit budget gains the Liberals left him, spent $1 billion dollars turning Toronto into a war zone, has been cited twice by independent accounting regulators for ignoring proper procedures, lots of irregular questionable acquisitions behind closed doors without public scrutiny AND THIS WHEN HE HAS A MINORITY GOVERNMENT! The thought of him being able to act with a majority government is scary shit.

Ooooh the boogey man! What a crock of left wing propaganda.

I was speaking to a 24 year old female who watched a debate for the first time. Her take was that Harper was the only one who said what he did and what he was going to do. She felt the others were rude and didn't have any plan or policies. She is switching her vote from Liberal to Conservative.

I believe she read it the same way the pollsters have, despite Liberal bias to the contrary.