Language, self-esteem, and society

My argument is based on linguistics.
I'm sorry that you don't like that language doesn't follow the rules you think it does.
It just doesn't.
 
My argument is based on linguistics.
I'm sorry that you don't like that language doesn't follow the rules you think it does.
It just doesn't.
The only "rule" you've provided is that it is vague, which IMO is not much of a rule. Please tell me any other rules of language that I am not aware of that helps prove your point.

At the same time you have failed to address my question of why Nordic is ok but Oriental isn't. Both are based on geography and nothing else. Absolutely nothing about them can be considered racist. There are no descriptors other than where they come from. Your example of Redskin describes their skin colour. Racist. There are terms for people from the Far East that relate to the shape of their eyes. Racist. But saying where someone comes from? Nope. It is no more than misguided political correctness.

Everybody comes from somewhere, but somehow saying that someone from the Orient is Oriental is the only time that using geography is racist. TBH, I can't think of another area of the world where this is the case. Please name any other accepted geographical areas that people come from and those people are described using only that geographical designation and it is considered racist. If you cannot provide examples, I believe your argument is weakened.
 
I may be wrong, but White and Black refers to physical features of a race too :)
True. Valcazar would have a much better argument using those.

But Oriental names no physical features. It names a region of the world.
 
True. Valcazar would have a much better argument using those.

But Oriental names no physical features. It names a region of the world.

Which again, is entirely irrelevant.
A word's origin doesn't actually describe whether or not it is a racist term or a slur.
 
The only "rule" you've provided is that it is vague, which IMO is not much of a rule. Please tell me any other rules of language that I am not aware of that helps prove your point.

At the same time you have failed to address my question of why Nordic is ok but Oriental isn't. Both are based on geography and nothing else. Absolutely nothing about them can be considered racist. There are no descriptors other than where they come from. Your example of Redskin describes their skin colour. Racist. There are terms for people from the Far East that relate to the shape of their eyes. Racist. But saying where someone comes from? Nope. It is no more than misguided political correctness.

Everybody comes from somewhere, but somehow saying that someone from the Orient is Oriental is the only time that using geography is racist. TBH, I can't think of another area of the world where this is the case. Please name any other accepted geographical areas that people come from and those people are described using only that geographical designation and it is considered racist. If you cannot provide examples, I believe your argument is weakened.

Oriental is racist because it was used in a racist way. Nordic is not because it wasn't.

That's it. That's the whole thing. I'm sorry this confuses you, but you keep looking for a "rule" when there isn't one other than "that's how it is used".
 
... but get offended by a scientific word "negro" ...
Scientific word?

Sorry but language is constantly changing and the meaning and intent behind words changes.

In the 18th century, 'negro' may have had a scientific context in some circles but was also used to demean and as a derogatory term. That usage made the term not acceptable in general company (and science has become much more advanced since the 18th century).

Another significant factor in language change is global intercommunication. This has meant that regional usage of various terms has decreased and there has been a more universal consensus on language usage.

Sorry but this seems like just another thread complaining that things aren't the same as it was in the 1950's and upset that minority groups are now willing to speak up when they are offended.
 
True. The problem is no that some derogatory names are invented, the problem is that people start to use regular names as derogatory and people who are described by these names agrees with the derogatory meaning of the original word instead of defending their original neutral use (and, by doing so, they de-facto agree that who they are is something to be ashamed of)
You are making the assumption that the terms were originally neutral simply because the people in power at the time were cool with them.
 
The Orient is anything east of Europe
The word literally means east

Everything from Egypt to Japan is Oriental

But the Oriental caricatures are just as offensive as the blackface ones from the south
Times change and some words are no longer PC
Just like language, the definition of where 'East' begins changes based on time and context.

And maybe the language changes to become more precise and the saying someone is from Asia is far more informative than saying from the East.
 
...

Please tell me, what about the word makes it racist? ...
It's not the word itself but the context. When the description of 'Oriental' is connected with negative stereotypes then its usage is racist and when a racist context becomes common, society seeks better words.
 
Oriental is racist because it was used in a racist way. Nordic is not because it wasn't.

That's it. That's the whole thing. I'm sorry this confuses you, but you keep looking for a "rule" when there isn't one other than "that's how it is used".
I am not confused about anything. My points are completely rational and valid. Please name me another area of the world that gets the same designation as Oriental does from you. If not why is Oriental the only one? And if you can't, then man up and say you can't instead of just saying that I am confused. Name another area, please.

I sincerely consider you one of the best posters on the board and consistently respect your opinions that you back up with facts, but you have provided not one single fact to back up your opinion in this case. Overactive political correctness.
 
It's not the word itself but the context. When the description of 'Oriental' is connected with negative stereotypes then its usage is racist and when a racist context becomes common, society seeks better words.
There are much "better" words if one wants to slur someone from the Orient. I hear Oriental and I have mainly positive images.

Anyway, I think I am done.
 
Because it should be capitalized. The Orient is a recognized part of the world and people from there are Oriental. It is simply a geographical reference and has nothing to do with racial characteristics.

Nobody would say that calling someone from the Maritimes a Maritimer is unacceptable.

Oriental means something from the east. Occidental means from the west. Sierra Madre Oriental mountain range is on the east coast of Mexico. The Occidental range is on the west. Should we change the name to something like less offensive?
 
Sheesh, let's get back to prosttitution, shall we?

Clearly, there is a degree of denial of reality here. An escort accompanies someone.

"There was on old man walking through a dangerous area at night, so I escorted him safely to his house".

Not a hint of sexuality.

So prostitutes want to (IMO) fool themselves that they are accompanying someone and the sex just so happens to occur.

That's why so many talk about university educated, good conversationalist, which GENERALLY their clients regard as completely secondary to getting their rocks off.
 
Sheesh, let's get back to prosttitution, shall we?

Clearly, there is a degree of denial of reality here. An escort accompanies someone.

"There was on old man walking through a dangerous area at night, so I escorted him safely to his house".

Not a hint of sexuality.

So prostitutes want to (IMO) fool themselves that they are accompanying someone and the sex just so happens to occur.

That's why so many talk about university educated, good conversationalist, which GENERALLY their clients regard as completely secondary to getting their rocks off.

On the other hand, people do hire escorts to accompany them to parties or dinner or events.