Language, self-esteem, and society

fall

Well-known member
Dec 9, 2010
3,146
1,072
113
I remember there was a thread about how to call SPs: SP, sex worker, prostitute, etc. Most (if not all) ladies said that the word "prostitute" is derogatory. Actually, I thing there are many similarity in the history of words "negro" and "prostitute. Both were completely neutral words just a few decades ago: their derivatives "nigger" and "whore" or "hooker" were derogatory, but "negro" and "prostitute" were normal words that was just used to correctly identify black people and people who have sex for money. It seems that even now "prostitute" is a normal word used by everybody (except the ones who are involved in buying or selling sex), but, for some reasons, SPs think it is derogatory. My though that it is because they cannot own what they do and be proud of their chosen profession. They cannot simply say "I am a prostitute" because they think that this is somehow bad. Instead, they come up with new words like Service Provider, Escort, Sex Worker. IMHO, until the girls themselves are ashamed to say that their job is prostitution, there is little hope to make prostitution legal and socially acceptable. Why society should think that prostitution is normal if even SPs are ashamed to name their profession?

I have similar thoughts about the word "negro". It is hard to fight racism when black people call themselves "nigger" but get offended by a scientific word "negro" and inventing other words like "black", "African-american", etc. Anyone who is proud of who he is should not feel that the scientific word that describe his/her race or profession is derogatory.

So, what I am trying to say: until SPs are not willing to openly say that they are prostitutes and be proud of it, prostitution will not be accepted by society. Until black people will not proudly call themselves negro, the racism will exist. To have someone to respect you, you must first respect yourself and be proud of who you are.
 
Last edited:
Another one - At one time it was acceptable to call a person who is from the orient, oriental but now it is seen as an unacceptable name.
 
It became a dirty word when it became a verb.

Usually when applied to your average politician.........nothing taints a word than when it's applied to a politician.
 
Think about how gay people took the word "queer" and took the sting out of it and in fact made it a word of pride. I think black people started that by in-group use of the n word. But I think anytime you exalt a term to be so odious, so offensive, that the mere mention of the word by a non african can traumatize, then i think you cede power to the morons who use the term to belittle. I know I'd sort out but quick my biracial kids if they fall apart because some idiot called them that name (btw so would their mother who is black). Take away the tools of the ignorant. And do it on your terms by making yourself bullet proof (so to speak.) No better way to say "fuck you idiot" than to be unfazed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knuckle Ball
Think about how gay people took the word "queer" and took the sting out of it and in fact made it a word of pride. I think black people started that by in-group use of the n word. But I think anytime you exalt a term to be so odious, so offensive, that the mere mention of the word by a non african can traumatize, then i think you cede power to the morons who use the term to belittle. I know I'd sort out but quick my biracial kids if they fall apart because some idiot called them that name (btw so would their mother who is black). Take away the tools of the ignorant. And do it on your terms by making yourself bullet proof (so to speak.) No better way to say "fuck you idiot" than to be unfazed.

Actually, gays are a very good example how to do it: instead of demanding respect or hiding who they are, they proudly claimed who they are and restored the pride (or, at the very least, eliminate the stigma) associated with it. I wish our smart and beautiful prostitutes (at least established ones) do the same and make prostitution and buying and selling sex to be just another activity accepted by society.
 
This kind of thing is really tricky. Sometimes reclaiming works, sometimes it doesn't.
Language always changes, because language depends on how it is used.
There's no one set of rules to make it work.
 
Another one - At one time it was acceptable to call a person who is from the orient, oriental but now it is seen as an unacceptable name.
Because it should be capitalized. The Orient is a recognized part of the world and people from there are Oriental. It is simply a geographical reference and has nothing to do with racial characteristics.

Nobody would say that calling someone from the Maritimes a Maritimer is unacceptable.
 
Because it should be capitalized. The Orient is a recognized part of the world and people from there are Oriental. It is simply a geographical reference and has nothing to do with racial characteristics.

Nobody would say that calling someone from the Maritimes a Maritimer is unacceptable.

That's not how language works, though.
 
Because it should be capitalized. The Orient is a recognized part of the world and people from there are Oriental. It is simply a geographical reference and has nothing to do with racial characteristics.

Nobody would say that calling someone from the Maritimes a Maritimer is unacceptable.
Yes...but calling them a “Newfie” might not be cool.
 
Yes...but calling them a “Newfie” might not be cool.

True. The problem is no that some derogatory names are invented, the problem is that people start to use regular names as derogatory and people who are described by these names agrees with the derogatory meaning of the original word instead of defending their original neutral use (and, by doing so, they de-facto agree that who they are is something to be ashamed of)
 
Because it should be capitalized. The Orient is a recognized part of the world and people from there are Oriental. It is simply a geographical reference and has nothing to do with racial characteristics.

Nobody would say that calling someone from the Maritimes a Maritimer is unacceptable.
The Orient is anything east of Europe
The word literally means east

Everything from Egypt to Japan is Oriental

But the Oriental caricatures are just as offensive as the blackface ones from the south
Times change and some words are no longer PC
 
That's not how language works, though.
But it is how logic works. Not any difference whatsoever about referring to someone in terms of their regionality. From the Maritimes=Maritimer. From the Orient=Oriental.

Not one single Asian/Oriental person I've asked thinks that Oriental is racist and I've asked dozens.
 
The Orient is anything east of Europe
The word literally means east

Everything from Egypt to Japan is Oriental
That is the first I ever heard of that and think that you are wrong. Please provide a documented definition. East of Europe is Asia. The Orient is considered the FAR East. People of India are Asian but they are not Oriental.
 
There is basically no racism in Canada today. I grew up here my entire life. There are some radicals, true, but that will exist until the end of time. 99% of the time there is nor racism in Canadian society. This whole BLM movement of 2020 has started to unravel that though. And things seem to be getting worse because of the alt left. But before things were really good for almost everybody.
 
But it is how logic works.

Language isn't logical.
You want a logical language, try a constructed one like loglan. (They don't work for a reason.)

Just because a word had a simple, innocent origin doesn't mean it can't become a slur.
 
Language isn't logical.
You want a logical language, try a constructed one like loglan. (They don't work for a reason.)

Just because a word had a simple, innocent origin doesn't mean it can't become a slur.
The term makes zero reference to any physical characteristics of someone from the Far East AKA, the Orient. 100% geographical like European, African, South Asian, Maritimer etc.

Should I name some examples of clearly racist terms of people from the Far East to show the difference?

Like I said earlier, of the dozens of people from the Far East that I have asked, not one of them said that they consider the term Oriental to be racist or a slur. It is an example of Political Correctness overkill.
 
Oooh. Dozens.
It may also be regional. For the people you know it isn't a problem. These things are not logical. They aren't bound by rules. Things become slurs or they don't by how people use them and receive them. They stick or they don't due to all kinds of factors.

I don't see why this would be a hill you would want to die on.