Lakers Vs. Magic series.

Plan B said:
Kobe, the most skilled??? Not by a long shot... the truth is that Kobe has 1 MVP of the Year, where as Jordan had 5, and should've had more. Kobe was lucky to play with Shaq, and get 3 titles, and the ungrateful bastard ran him out of town

Kobe and the Lakers were extremely lucky this year to generate such a weak field...had Houston been healthy with Yao Ming and McGrady, they would have taught the Lakers a lesson...even a healthy Boston with Garnett would've beat the Lakers...

Besides the refs are completely on Kobe's side, and let him do anything he wants, so his skill is overrated.


I agree with you on your point about Houston , I think Houston would have beaten the Lakers if healthy but also injuries are a part of sports it happens to all teams at some point or another.

But I would also argue that Kobe could have easily had more than one league MVP as well. I'm not gonna get into debate about numbers because I hate using stats to back up my arguments but I do know that I watch a lot of basketball games of a lot of teams, in fact I rarely watch Raptors games I mostly watch the other teams and I'll say that Kobe could have won the MVP award more than once.

You are right though Kobe was fortunate to play with Shaq but the converse is also true, Shaq was fortunate to play with Kobe. Basketball is a team game but if you have 2 solid stars with some nice complementary pieces and a good coaching staff then you go a long way.
 
ckupets04 said:
I agree with you on your point about Houston , I think Houston would have beaten the Lakers if healthy but also injuries are a part of sports it happens to all teams at some point or another.

But I would also argue that Kobe could have easily had more than one league MVP as well. I'm not gonna get into debate about numbers because I hate using stats to back up my arguments but I do know that I watch a lot of basketball games of a lot of teams, in fact I rarely watch Raptors games I mostly watch the other teams and I'll say that Kobe could have won the MVP award more than once.

You are right though Kobe was fortunate to play with Shaq but the converse is also true, Shaq was fortunate to play with Kobe. Basketball is a team game but if you have 2 solid stars with some nice complementary pieces and a good coaching staff then you go a long way.

I agree that the Lakers were fortunate to have Shaq and Kobe, but I think Kobe benefited much more from the arrangement. Yes, Kobe was a very good player back then, but let's be serious; he's much better now. Shaq was the MVP of all three finals. Look at it like the situation with the Spurs. When Duncan arrived, Robinson was the better of the two. Sure, Duncan was good at the time, but he matured to become 'Batman' and the Admiral became 'Robin'. If Kobe had kept he overzealous pride in check back then, he'd have more than the four he has, much more respect from the basketball world, and he would still be the man in L.A. today. Not to mention that team had the possibility to be considered a dynasty as great as the Bill Russel Celtics.

Congrats on the ring Kobe, but your attitude towards 'the hands that fed you' (Phil Jackson and Shaquille O'Neal), will be part of your NBA legacy.
 
Toke said:
I agree that the Lakers were fortunate to have Shaq and Kobe, but I think Kobe benefited much more from the arrangement. Yes, Kobe was a very good player back then, but let's be serious; he's much better now. Shaq was the MVP of all three finals. Look at it like the situation with the Spurs. When Duncan arrived, Robinson was the better of the two. Sure, Duncan was good at the time, but he matured to become 'Batman' and the Admiral became 'Robin'. If Kobe had kept he overzealous pride in check back then, he'd have more than the four he has, much more respect from the basketball world, and he would still be the man in L.A. today. Not to mention that team had the possibility to be considered a dynasty as great as the Bill Russel Celtics.

Congrats on the ring Kobe, but your attitude towards 'the hands that fed you' (Phil Jackson and Shaquille O'Neal), will be part of your NBA legacy.

Oh no question. Shaq was the better player (between the two) back then in those years and Kobe has gotten better since. I think they complemented each other well back then because Shaq was great for 3.5 Quarters but then they couldnt go to Shaq late in games because of his poor FT shooting but thats where Kobe thrived, he could make shots down the stretch in a game when the Lakers couldnt run the offense through the Big Aristotle.
 
ckupets04 said:
Oh no question. Shaq was the better player (between the two) back then in those years and Kobe has gotten better since. I think they complemented each other well back then because Shaq was great for 3.5 Quarters but then they couldnt go to Shaq late in games because of his poor FT shooting but thats where Kobe thrived, he could make shots down the stretch in a game when the Lakers couldnt run the offense through the Big Aristotle.

As much as a Kobe-basher as I've been; you've summed it up well. They complimented each other well. When I try to figure out who is the best/MVP of a team/league, I replace the player in question with an average (or at best, second tier) player of the same position and look at the team's chances then. In my eyes, removing Shaq for Luc Longley would be far more detrimental than removing Kobe for someone like John Starks. Even look at this year's MVP voting, to take Lebron away and sub in Mo Pete is much more crushing than removing Kobe and adding Anthony Parker.
 
Kobe's elbow on Jameer Nelson was the turning point

I still can't believe that Kobe got away with that elbow to the face of Jameer Nelson within the final 30 seconds of OT in game 4 with the score tied at 91 points apiece. That allowed the Lakers Derek Fisher to score a crucial 3-pointer and pretty much put the Magic out of the series. Had they called it, maybe the series would have been tied 2-2 instead of it being 3-1 in favour of LA. Horrible officiating, and if anyone on Orlando complained too loud about it, David Stern would no doubt give them a hefty fine for criticizing the officiating.
 
Frank Fingers said:
I still can't believe that Kobe got away with that elbow to the face of Jameer Nelson within the final 30 seconds of OT in game 4 with the score tied at 91 points apiece. That allowed the Lakers Derek Fisher to score a crucial 3-pointer and pretty much put the Magic out of the series. Had they called it, maybe the series would have been tied 2-2 instead of it being 3-1 in favour of LA. Horrible officiating, and if anyone on Orlando complained too loud about it, David Stern would no doubt give them a hefty fine for criticizing the officiating.

I totally agree , that was a missed call. That being said Dwight Howard got away with a push on Gasol at the other end on the previous possession before that.
 
Plan B said:
Kobe, the most skilled??? Not by a long shot... the truth is that Kobe has 1 MVP of the Year, where as Jordan had 5, and should've had more. Kobe was lucky to play with Shaq, and get 3 titles, and the ungrateful bastard ran him out of town

Shaq ran his own fat ass out of town. Kobe played Robin to Shaq's Superman and when time came to allow Kobe to be the "man", Shaq wouldn't allow it. The Lakers chose Kobe and based on where the two players are now they chose wisely despite the early returns on their decision and many fans . Shaq should have handed over the reigns, like the Admiral did to Tim Duncan and there is no doubt they would have had more titles in LA.
 
Plan B said:
Kobe, the most skilled??? Not by a long shot... the truth is that Kobe has 1 MVP of the Year, where as Jordan had 5, and should've had more. Kobe was lucky to play with Shaq, and get 3 titles, and the ungrateful bastard ran him out of town

Kobe and the Lakers were extremely lucky this year to generate such a weak field...had Houston been healthy with Yao Ming and McGrady, they would have taught the Lakers a lesson...even a healthy Boston with Garnett would've beat the Lakers...

Besides the refs are completely on Kobe's side, and let him do anything he wants, so his skill is overrated.

Kobe is great but Jordan is legendary. Jordan is the greatest player to have played the game. No question about it. That being said, there is no doubt in my mind that Kobe is the second best shooting guard in history. Kobe is one of the most skilled players I have ever seen and to say that he is not by a long shot is a bit far fetched. He is close man.
 

Similar threads