Kidney Stones

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,049
1
0
I have a friend who is quickly racking up repeat attacks of kidney stone, now totally 3 this year alone, but less in past years. Some pass and some need hospitalization and treatment. She is petrified it will lead kidney failure, dialysis, and much worse. I cannot find anything noteworthy that can help her with this and to top it off she dislikes doctors and hates hospitals. That kind of makes it an adventure as she need them but hates them. s

She really hates Apple Cider Vinegar, which I take shots of every day for my health and barely stomachs cranberry juice which I had her cut half and half with water. I'm researching other supplements like Alphalpha tabs and bean sprouts but she's a picky eater.

Is her fear of dialysis or worse based on facts?
 
Some is hereditary and some is diet related. She's going to have to drastically alter her diet. Tell her to check it out online. As much as she doesn't like it, she's going to have to face it and deal with it.
 
Some is hereditary and some is diet related. She's going to have to drastically alter her diet. Tell her to check it out online. As much as she doesn't like it, she's going to have to face it and deal with it.

I got the same sermon after my one teeny weeny stone and my teeny weeny hiatus hernia, although my advise was tempered; cut back on coffee, cut back on spicy food, no eating food after 9:00 and no late night alcohol. After I made some comment about which arm he wanted cut off, I said fair enough. It's working, but I slip every so often. Don't we all
 
I have a friend who is quickly racking up repeat attacks of kidney stone, now totally 3 this year alone, but less in past years. Some pass and some need hospitalization and treatment. She is petrified it will lead kidney failure, dialysis, and much worse. I cannot find anything noteworthy that can help her with this and to top it off she dislikes doctors and hates hospitals. That kind of makes it an adventure as she need them but hates them. s

She really hates Apple Cider Vinegar, which I take shots of every day for my health and barely stomachs cranberry juice which I had her cut half and half with water. I'm researching other supplements like Alphalpha tabs and bean sprouts but she's a picky eater.

Is her fear of dialysis or worse based on facts?

Chinese herbal medicine should be of help. She might not
find the medicine to dissolve the stone out of her system
completely in a short time. But in all likelihood a decent
Chinese herbalist would be able to provide her with safe
and effective relief from her symptoms.

Note that I am not suggesting her to turn to one of those
naturalpathic doctor. It is a bona fide Chinese herbal doctor
preferably one who has some understanding of western medicine
I would recommend.

Feel free to PM me if you want further details.
 
I have had a multitude of stones for about 30 years. Unfortunately i am prone to them and the only remedy i have is a strict diet and drink plenty of water. At least 8 full glasses a day. Not coffee, pop or other drinks. Apparently water has some sort of cohesive property which helps move stones when they are very small. They are commonly called "sand" at this stage. There are meds she can take but they have serious side effects.

She first needs to collect some stones and submit them for analysis. From there she can determine a course of action. If the stones are uric acid based she needs to alter her diet and raise her body PH. If its calcium based she may need to reduce dairy etc. If the stones report "nothing significant" she may be up a creek like myself and then must do everything to reduce the frequency of stone formation. Water, water, water and more water.

Cranberry juice is the worst thing you can take since it is full of oxolates which can precipitate a stone. Cranberry juice may be good for a bladder or kidney infection.

Have her see a urologist because trying to deal with this on her own may in fact do more harm than good.

Your kidneys can take some abuse but they are fragile and need the care of a doctor when you have stones.

Before the stones become too large and then pass into the ureter and become lodged and cause obstruction (painful and damaging) they can be found with a simple xray and can be broken up into passable stones with a process called lithotrypsy. Basically you are given an anesthetic, a conductive bag is placed against the kidney that contains the stone and it is wacked by sound waves which almost always breaks up the stone. You wake up 30 minutes later, have a bite to eat and go home. I have had the procedure 4 times with success.

Drink lots of water and see a urologist is my advice to her.

Good luck
 
Chinese herbal medicine should be of help. She might not
find the medicine to dissolve the stone out of her system
completely in a short time. But in all likelihood a decent
Chinese herbalist would be able to provide her with safe
and effective relief from her symptoms.

Note that I am not suggesting her to turn to one of those
naturalpathic doctor. It is a bona fide Chinese herbal doctor
preferably one who has some understanding of western medicine
I would recommend.

Feel free to PM me if you want further details.

What is a bona fide Chinese herbal doctor? Where did they get their credentials? I'll take a naturopath any day, thanks.
 
I have had a multitude of stones for about 30 years. Unfortunately i am prone to them and the only remedy i have is a strict diet and drink plenty of water. At least 8 full glasses a day. Not coffee, pop or other drinks. Apparently water has some sort of cohesive property which helps move stones when they are very small. They are commonly called "sand" at this stage. There are meds she can take but they have serious side effects.

She first needs to collect some stones and submit them for analysis. From there she can determine a course of action. If the stones are uric acid based she needs to alter her diet and raise her body PH. If its calcium based she may need to reduce dairy etc. If the stones report "nothing significant" she may be up a creek like myself and then must do everything to reduce the frequency of stone formation. Water, water, water and more water.

Cranberry juice is the worst thing you can take since it is full of oxolates which can precipitate a stone. Cranberry juice may be good for a bladder or kidney infection.

Have her see a urologist because trying to deal with this on her own may in fact do more harm than good.

Your kidneys can take some abuse but they are fragile and need the care of a doctor when you have stones.

Before the stones become too large and then pass into the ureter and become lodged and cause obstruction (painful and damaging) they can be found with a simple xray and can be broken up into passable stones with a process called lithotrypsy. Basically you are given an anesthetic, a conductive bag is placed against the kidney that contains the stone and it is wacked by sound waves which almost always breaks up the stone. You wake up 30 minutes later, have a bite to eat and go home. I have had the procedure 4 times with success.

Drink lots of water and see a urologist is my advice to her.

Good luck

Your advice is dead on. I have the same situation as you. Maybe we have the same urologist.

The best advice is go see a urologist instead of asking people on here.
 
Your advice is dead on. I have the same situation as you. Maybe we have the same urologist.

The best advice is go see a urologist instead of asking people on here.

Likely we do have the same specialist and as for seeking advice here on Terb i think its a start and a lot better than searching the web. There is so much bullshit out there, especially the wive's tale about cranberry juice. Lets hope she takes the advice. As for naturopaths and homeopaths, i have used them with moderate success.
 
What is a bona fide Chinese herbal doctor? Where did they get their credentials? I'll take a naturopath any day, thanks.

Chinese herbal medicine is not a recognized profession technically
in that there is no provision of its certification in North America. By bona
fide I meant someone who was schooled and has practiced in China.
It could be difficult for you to verify the credentials of a herbal doctor
from a foreign country. But if the doctor has a more or less established
reputation in the local Chinese communities you probably won't go
wrong. Actually some of the senior Chinese herbal doctors might not
even have any formal schooling in the art. Most of these doctors are
from Hong Kong not mainland China. They learned their skills mainly from
apprenticeship. Doctors with such background I believe mostly work in those
very old Chinatown herb shops in the downtown area. Majority of the Chinese
herbalists in TO were trained in mainland China but you will have to worry
more about their English than their credentials.

BTW, I did not mean to denigrate the certified naturalpathic
doctors. I just don't think they can pass as a Chinese herbal
doctor. If your kidney stone disease is cured by naturalpathic
medicine it won't be because the doctor knows Chinese herbal
medicine better.
 
Likely we do have the same specialist and as for seeking advice here on Terb i think its a start and a lot better than searching the web. There is so much bullshit out there, especially the wive's tale about cranberry juice. Lets hope she takes the advice. As for naturopaths and homeopaths, i have used them with moderate success.

That's interesting, because homeopathy in particular is absolutely 100% unscientific. It has been routinely debunked as the worst kind of junk superstition. Chinese medicine, although unregulated, has been used to treat people for centuries, with often incredible results. I've seen many naturopaths in my years, and because it is a grab bag term for a doctor who may practice many modalities, you're as likely to get quackery there as anywhere. Vibrational healing and dousing are particular quack favourites of naturopaths. Not true of all naturopaths, but just remember the term only refers to the program they complete to become ND's, not what they practise after they graduate. :)

I see a Chinese doctor (who also teaches) who straddles East and West, and has "cured" me of ailments that no one else could touch--and I mean over 20 years. Migraines, liver problems, allergies...you name it. He relieved jaw pressure (TMJ) that had tortured me for years and years in about two sessions.

There is lots of quackery and expensive herbal nonsense in Chinese Medicine. There are also formulations that literally will change your life, and a wise practitioner can change your life around in just a few sessions with acupuncture and herbs. Don't knock it until you've tried it.

PM me if you want my guy's name. He grew up here so speaks perfect English, and is a very wise man.
 
I have had a multitude of stones for about 30 years. Unfortunately i am prone to them and the only remedy i have is a strict diet and drink plenty of water. At least 8 full glasses a day. Not coffee, pop or other drinks. Apparently water has some sort of cohesive property which helps move stones when they are very small. They are commonly called "sand" at this stage. There are meds she can take but they have serious side effects.

She first needs to collect some stones and submit them for analysis. From there she can determine a course of action. If the stones are uric acid based she needs to alter her diet and raise her body PH. If its calcium based she may need to reduce dairy etc. If the stones report "nothing significant" she may be up a creek like myself and then must do everything to reduce the frequency of stone formation. Water, water, water and more water.

Cranberry juice is the worst thing you can take since it is full of oxolates which can precipitate a stone. Cranberry juice may be good for a bladder or kidney infection.

Have her see a urologist because trying to deal with this on her own may in fact do more harm than good.

Your kidneys can take some abuse but they are fragile and need the care of a doctor when you have stones.

Before the stones become too large and then pass into the ureter and become lodged and cause obstruction (painful and damaging) they can be found with a simple xray and can be broken up into passable stones with a process called lithotrypsy. Basically you are given an anesthetic, a conductive bag is placed against the kidney that contains the stone and it is wacked by sound waves which almost always breaks up the stone. You wake up 30 minutes later, have a bite to eat and go home. I have had the procedure 4 times with success.

Drink lots of water and see a urologist is my advice to her.

Good luck

When i had the stone, two doctors/one specialist recommended cranberry juice, so we are at a crossroads, so......

The rest of your advise makes sense. Collecting stones makes some people squeamish and I don't know which she is. I remember that wonderful sound of PING as mine, which had finally settle in my bladder for the last couple of day, decide to hit the bowl. The euphoria was till there as I reach into the bowl, easy stuff for me. i once had the pleasure of reaching into a cow to turn the calf the right, so this was a piece of cake.

I believe she's had that lithotripsy procedure and something isn't fun for her.

Thanks so much.
 
Chinese herbal medicine should be of help. She might not
find the medicine to dissolve the stone out of her system
completely in a short time. But in all likelihood a decent
Chinese herbalist would be able to provide her with safe
and effective relief from her symptoms.

Note that I am not suggesting her to turn to one of those
naturalpathic doctor. It is a bona fide Chinese herbal doctor
preferably one who has some understanding of western medicine
I would recommend.

Feel free to PM me if you want further details.

I'm not against traditional medicines, but find it hit and miss. I have had good results from Tibet medicine, but it is hard to find a practitioner in TO.
 
Your advice is dead on. I have the same situation as you. Maybe we have the same urologist.

The best advice is go see a urologist instead of asking people on here.
+1. I am happy to report that I have not had a kidney stone since about 1996, or thereabouts. My advice echoes that of prior posters. I have also suspected that tap water where I used to live had an effect on my renal colic. Ensure that you drink good quality water that is not hard or too loaded with minerals. But, do not drink distilled or demineralised water, as it can leach the calcium out of your bones and the viatmins from your body.
 
Cranberry juice is good for the bladder but don't know about kidneys. She should see a urologist ASAP.
Cranberry juice is a diuretic and contains ascorbic acid that can complex (dissolve0 some kidney stones. Howeverm, the oxalic acid as one poster mentioned can cause bad stones.

Renal colic is said to be as painful or more painful than childbirth.
 
I drank destilled water only since I had problems with kidney stones.I don't have any problem in the past years.
 
My thoughts based on a lot of reading (i am not a doctor), is that "things" precipitate out in the kidney when they cannot stay in solution. so lots of water is the simplest fix. i'd stay away from the quacks on this one.
 
I've had a number of bouts with kidney stones over the past 26 years. The last time was just this year and I sought a different kind of treatment, initially for the pain.
I called my acupuncturist to see if she could at least temporarily ease the pain, which she did. Beyond that, she gave me an herbal drop, Sankol. Within 20 minutes of taking my first dose, I was peeing like a 20 year old gain and less than a week later, I passed a 7mm stone, that had been giving me fits. The Sankol is also supposed to work at breaking the stone sown, for easier passage. Normally, a 7mm stone would be treated differently, but I was glad to see it go.
Since then, I have been taking Liu Wei Di Hau Huang Wan tablets. These are to promote better kidney health. So far so good, but it's only been a few months.
I was never a big believer in alternative types of medicine, but this practitioner has won me over on a number of occasions now.
 
I've had a number of bouts with kidney stones over the past 26 years. The last time was just this year and I sought a different kind of treatment, initially for the pain.
I called my acupuncturist to see if she could at least temporarily ease the pain, which she did. Beyond that, she gave me an herbal drop, Sankol. Within 20 minutes of taking my first dose, I was peeing like a 20 year old gain and less than a week later, I passed a 7mm stone, that had been giving me fits. The Sankol is also supposed to work at breaking the stone sown, for easier passage. Normally, a 7mm stone would be treated differently, but I was glad to see it go.
Since then, I have been taking Liu Wei Di Hau Huang Wan tablets. These are to promote better kidney health. So far so good, but it's only been a few months.
I was never a big believer in alternative types of medicine, but this practitioner has won me over on a number of occasions now.

You might want to google Sankol, but the other has promise.