Kessel Trade Rumours

Why is there any talk about Horton returning, from what I've read he can barely walk. The Leafs knew his career was over but were happy to get rid of 71. I wonder how players feel when they are simply given away?
 
I forgot to mention, one more thing about Strome he is not a great skater, a little slow but he makes up for it in heart, size, character, Great hockey IQ, a future leader which the Leafs are lacking.
 
I forgot to mention, one more thing about Strome he is not a great skater, a little slow but he makes up for it in heart, size, character, Great hockey IQ, a future leader which the Leafs are lacking.

The exact opposite of Gardiner.

I don't know if the trade is worthy for the Leafs or if its even true, but I fundamentally disagree that Shanahan should be making this kind of hockey trades as that's something he has absolutely no experience in. He should let the to be hired GM to decide how this team is going to be rebuilt. This will be a key trade that can have a profound impact on the fortune of the team for the next ten years that a novice like him should be messing with.

If he's relying on Hunter's advice on the trades, then why not officially make him the GM of the team ? Unless he only wants the new GM to be just a puppet with him and Hunter pulling the strings.
 
Nathan Horton is a heart and soul player, that's why he's in his current condition. If he recovers his health, he'll lead the youngsters by example.

If he doesn't, by guaranteeing his contract we'll have cache with the NHLPA. For what that's worth.


Nathan Horton's condition is a result of a degenerative disease.

All NHL contracts are guaranteed.
 
Strome looks to me like a Dave Andreychuk type player while Mitch Marner looks more like a Doug Gilmour or Denis Savard type player even though he's a winger.

Strome might be a better skater than he looks just because he's a big guy.
A lot of big guys have been faster skaters than they appear to be just because they have a longer stride and cover more ice with each stride compared to a guy with shorter legs.


For a trade with the Canes I have a feeling the Leafs would have to give up Morgan Rielly instead of Kadri to get a deal with the Canes for the number 5 pick this year.
 
Why The Fuck would the leafs give up a 40 goal scorer and a former 1st round draft pic for Semin and and the 5th round draft pic , that would be a step backwards

And mentioning Morgan Rielly is that trade is just crazy
 
Why The Fuck would the leafs give up a 40 goal scorer and a former 1st round draft pic for Semin and and the 5th round draft pic , that would be a step backwards

And mentioning Morgan Rielly is that trade is just crazy

Isn't that the goal .. To go backwards ie rebuild .. Morgan isn't going anywhere . Morgan Rielly alone may fetch the 5th pic overall ..

If the Oilers could guarantee they get Noah Hanifin .. Would they trade their 1st for Rielly and Leafs 1st ... To have two young stud defenseman maybe better then another forward to your roster
 
Isn't that the goal .. To go backwards ie rebuild .. Morgan isn't going anywhere . Morgan Rielly alone may fetch the 5th pic overall ..

If the Oilers could guarantee they get Noah Hanifin .. Would they trade their 1st for Rielly and Leafs 1st ... To have two young stud defenseman maybe better then another forward to your roster

The Oilers already have Darnell Nurse(young stud D) in the system.
Oilers keep their pick, take McDavid and if they think another top young D is necessary they can land him by trading some of their other youth.


but ... if the Leafs can pull off a Rielly and Leaf's first(2015 4th overall) for the Oilers first overall(2015) ... go for it Leafs !
 
strome looks to me like a dave andreychuk type player while mitch marner looks more like a doug gilmour or denis savard type player even though he's a winger.

Strome might be a better skater than he looks just because he's a big guy.
A lot of big guys have been faster skaters than they appear to be just because they have a longer stride and cover more ice with each stride compared to a guy with shorter legs.


For a trade with the canes i have a feeling the leafs would have to give up morgan rielly instead of kadri to get a deal with the canes for the number 5 pick this year.

why the fuck would the leafs give up a 40 goal scorer and a former 1st round draft pic for semin and and the 5th round draft pic , that would be a step backwards

and mentioning morgan rielly is that trade is just crazy

The trade mentioned, if it went through, would be Carolina's first round(fifth overall) pick.
The idea being the Leafs take Semin off their hands, give up Kessel and get a top pick in the coming draft.
 
Why The Fuck would the leafs give up a 40 goal scorer and a former 1st round draft pic for Semin and and the 5th round draft pic , that would be a step backwards

And mentioning Morgan Rielly is that trade is just crazy


The trade rumour involved the Leafs getting the number 5 overall pick in the draft.
Not the Leafs getting the Canes fifth round pick.
 
The trade rumour involved the Leafs getting the number 5 overall pick in the draft.
Not the Leafs getting the Canes fifth round pick.
It is still a stupid trade.

Since Kessel has been here he has consistently put up very good numbers, barring last year's 2nd half when almost the whole team quit. He had tons of company. Nobody questions JVR's fortitude and he sucked as well. Kessel on his own is worth a 1st rounder. The "expert" fans in TO love to denigrate him, yet he is much more highly regarded throughout the rest of the league.

Kadri, who I think is a selfish punk and would love to see him gone is probably worth a 2nd rounder. No worse than 3rd.

And then we're supposed to swallow Semen's salary as a favour to the Hercs and we get 5th overall?

Sorry. That is an idiotic proposition. It plays into the salivary glands of the Kessel haters.
 
At a minimum Dany Heatley... Sorry Phil Kessel is a large risk who is likely to be massively overpaid by the end of the deal. But he has produced, so he has value. But a team will look to mitigate that risk of giving up a valuable pick, with a bad contract in return.

I don't understand how it's a stupid trade the leafs will likely have the best asset from this deal in 5 years which is what really matters. You have to add a bit, ansd buy some garbage for a great asset.

It's as good as your going to get for Kessel, and you may be a few points worse next year. You build some nice cornerstones and then count on your scouts to rip out the team with the right young and vet depth by 2019.
 
It is still a stupid trade.

Since Kessel has been here he has consistently put up very good numbers, barring last year's 2nd half when almost the whole team quit. He had tons of company. Nobody questions JVR's fortitude and he sucked as well. Kessel on his own is worth a 1st rounder.

I am not a Kessel hater, I think he is worth a first rounder but you have to think of players like the stock market, All NHL GMs do. After his worst season his stock has dropped. I think the option is to let Kessel rebound and have a good first half season and when his stock has risen then trade him.
 
It is still a stupid trade.

Since Kessel has been here he has consistently put up very good numbers, barring last year's 2nd half when almost the whole team quit. He had tons of company. Nobody questions JVR's fortitude and he sucked as well. Kessel on his own is worth a 1st rounder. The "expert" fans in TO love to denigrate him, yet he is much more highly regarded throughout the rest of the league.

Kadri, who I think is a selfish punk and would love to see him gone is probably worth a 2nd rounder. No worse than 3rd.

And then we're supposed to swallow Semen's salary as a favour to the Hercs and we get 5th overall?

Sorry. That is an idiotic proposition. It plays into the salivary glands of the Kessel haters.

I don't hate Kessel, in fact, I think he can be a top notch player under a great coach on a winning team.
Having said that, his lack of leadership and his work ethic are garbage. A 5th overall pick might be as good as we get for Kessel.
I don't know if the Leafs have another 1st round pick, or if that was given to Boston for Kessel.. Perhaps they can dangle both their first round
picks to move up to #2. I say #2, because I dont' think that the Oilers are giving up their #1.

Maybe we can give up Phaneuf, Kessel and our #4 pick for Edmonton's #1???
 
If the Oilers could guarantee they get Noah Hanifin .. Would they trade their 1st for Rielly and Leafs 1st ... To have two young stud defenseman maybe better then another forward to your roster

I think going into the lottery Edmonton was set to take Hanifan, he fills a need. Now, if we offered the 4th to them (assuming he's still available) for Pittsburgh pick (16th) and one of their extra forwards (Yakupov, Hopkins or Draisaitl) maybe its a match for both teams. I'd love to see what a top end talent like Yakupov could do in a bigger role here.
 
Kessel has never scored 40 goals and has a career Plus Minus of -75 in the NHL regular season...hardly a star and not worth his contract. Get what you can for him.
 
Kessel has never scored 40 goals and has a career Plus Minus of -75 in the NHL regular season...hardly a star and not worth his contract. Get what you can for him.

I thought you were wrong in that he never scored 40 goals but after a quick search the most hes ever scored was 37.

But if trying to unload him will cost us a prospect or a good player, than i say keep him till we get a good offer.

We traded 2 good draft pics to get him now we have to trade another one to get rid of him ????

In terms of Kadri give him another year to develop -then evaluate him - to determine if they keep him or trade him

Morgan Reily - should be untouchable unless they can get a proven YOUNG superstar in return

What ever trade we try to make with Edmonton , Peter Chiralli we try to rape Toronto cause hes a shark

It should cost toronto $$$$$ to get rid of Kessell and Phaneuf , because $$$ they have tons of

but prospects / draft pics and talent we are a little on the short end