Kerry on Iraq

The_Jaded_One said:
OTB, do you honestly think George Bush doesn't flip flop? I know that you are extremely biased in favour of Dubya and all but surely you don't think your boy is a straight shooter. If you honestly think that you are too dumb to live.

Yet another balanced and intelligent post from the far left.

Don said:
No confusion. So it looks like:

Dubya got intelligence on WMD.
Dubya believed intelligence.
Dubya didn't check on "spin" of intelligence.
Dubya believed intelligence report telling was the truth.
Dubya supported the intelligence on that basis.

Kerry got info from Dubya on WMD.
Kerry believed Dubya.
Kerry didn't check on "spin" of intelligence.
Kerry believed Dubya was telling the truth.
Kerry suppored Dubya on that basis.

Kerry, like Dubya and the rest of the planet, finds out intelligence was wrong and both were lied to.

That’s about right although Kerry would have gotten his info from the CIA just as W did, don’t forget that the last CIA director was a Clinton appointee and Kerry would have gotten intelligence from them before W was elected.

The_Jaded_One said:
Nah Don, that's not what happened. It's amazing that most people don't understand the concept "power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely".

Wow, that’s deep, anyone else think that’s deep…..

The_Jaded_One said:

What happened was this:

Dubya cherry picked for intelligence and put pressure on the CIA and other intelligence agencies to give him justification to go to war.


Some other “cherry pickers�:

"If Saddam rejects peace and we have to use force, our purpose is clear.
We want to seriously diminish the threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass
destruction program."
- President Clinton, Feb. 17, 1998

"He will use those weapons of mass destruction again, as he has ten
times since 1983."
- Sandy Berger, Clinton National Security Adviser, Feb, 18, 1998

"[W]e urge you, after consulting with Congress, and consistent
with the U.S. Constitution and laws, to take necessary actions
(including, if appropriate, air and missile strikes on suspect Iraqi sites) to respond
effectively to the threat posed by Iraq's refusal to end its weapons of
mass destruction programs."
- Letter to President Clinton, signed by Sens. Carl Levin, Tom
Daschle, John Kerry, and others Oct. 9, 1998

"Saddam Hussein has been engaged in the development of weapons of
mass destruction technology which is a threat to countries in the
region and he has made a mockery of the weapons inspection process."
- Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D, CA), Dec. 16, 1998

All PRE W you will notice, I guess Clinton was “Cherry Picking� intelligence spin as well.

The_Jaded_One said:

You see Bush wanted to make money for big business as well as stabalize the region and he planned (or more likely Dick Cheney did and pulled Bush's puppet strings) on attacking Iraq well before 9/11. That's why he completely ignored Hans Blix and ran roughshod over the UN.

Ah yes, another grand Liberal conspiracy, it’s interesting that people who know nothing about business think it’s so corrupt.

The_Jaded_One said:

Kerry just voted mainly with the goal of running for the president of the United States. Unfortunately he is/was too wishy washy and did a piss poor job of it b/c he didn't have the balls to vote against Bush when it was unpopular to do so but was the right thing.

BINGO, point of thread Mensa star!


The_Jaded_One said:

Most Canadians I know knew it was a transparent pack of lies to begin with or at least heavily massaged "expert" findings starting with the conclusion that Iraq must have WMD and working backwards. I'm pretty sure most countries in the UN thought so too based on how they voted. Your assertion that the "rest of the planet" was fooled is ridiculous.

Just the British, Italians, Australians…. I would dare say the French, Germans and Russians were fooled as well but were too greedy (and with such a Napoleon complex) to act.

OTB
 
blitz said:
inmybottom,

can't you spread your propoganda in your own divided country?

there's no need to rake around more of your manure up here. certainly, you have found it is not fertile ground for your misguided ideals.

peace.

Very cleaver, I have an idea, just change the channel if you don't like what is on.

OTB
 
blitz said:
inmybottom, can't you spread your propoganda in your own divided country? there's no need to rake around more of your manure up here.
Based on the recent Federal election I'd have to say that we are the last country that should be slagging the U.S. for being 'divided'.
We might get more respect if we cleaned up our own backyard first.
 

"If Saddam rejects peace and we have to use force, our purpose is clear..."
- President Clinton, Feb. 17, 1998

"He will use those weapons of mass destruction again..."
- Sandy Berger, Clinton National Security Adviser, Feb, 18, 1998

"[W]e urge you, after consulting with Congress, and consistent
with the U.S. Constitution and laws, to take necessary actions... to respond effectively to the threat posed by Iraq's refusal to end its weapons of mass destruction programs."
- Letter to President Clinton, signed by Sens. Carl Levin, Tom
Daschle, John Kerry, and others Oct. 9, 1998

"Saddam Hussein has been engaged in the development of weapons of mass destruction technology..."
- Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D, CA), Dec. 16, 1998


Note the dates.

Are you trying to say that Dubya relied on information that was four to five years out of date?

How quickly the "right" forgets. The UN had gone in to supervise the destruction of those weapons with American support, but Bush and his lackies simply didn't believe Hans Blix... yes, that same Hans Blix who was actually in Iraq, on the ground, getting his hands dirty.

From The Scotsman:
Prime Minister Tony Blair and US President George Bush acted like salesmen trying to shift a product in the run-up to war with Iraq... Hans Blix accused the two leaders of exaggerating intelligence on Saddam Hussein’s arsenal... “From our leaders in the West I think we expect more than that. A bit more sincerity,� he (Blix) added.
 
OTB,

Do you think you could be any more biased in favour of Bush? You believe the worst when it comes to Kerry but anything bad said about Bush is a liberal conspiracy theory. Do you have any idea how ridiculously biased you sound?

Oh yeah, stop cherry picking your quotes like your hero Bush. Couldn't you do a little better than outdated quotes that didn't necessarily apply to the situation 4 years later? Everyone knew that Saddam Hussein was contained big time by the US but nothing was gonna appease the big business hawks in the administration b/c their agenda was to go to war. George Bush's decision to go to war COST lives not saved lives (you have to consider all the lives lost at war and the additional anger at the States now that is going to manifest itself in the form of terrorism). Of course a rabid Republican like yourself will refuse to see that.

Why don't you try reading this Hans Blix article with an OPEN mind?

Hans Blix Article

Edit: I see HG beat me to the punch. OTB left himself way too open with his sloppy arguments and reasoning.
 
The_Jaded_One said:
What happened was this:
Dubya cherry picked for intelligence and put pressure on the CIA and other intelligence agencies to give him justification to go to war. You see Bush wanted to make money for big business as well as stabilize the region and he planned (or more likely Dick Cheney did and pulled Bush's puppet strings) on attacking Iraq well before 9/11. That's why he completely ignored Hans Blix and ran roughshod over the UN.

Kerry just voted mainly with the goal of running for the president of the United States. Unfortunately he is/was too wishy washy and did a piss poor job of it b/c he didn't have the balls to vote against Bush when it was unpopular to do so but was the right thing.
A fair and balanced analysis of the situation I'd have to say.
I'm inclined to agree on both points.
(the latter which makes me wonder why some actually think Kerry will be any better and/or different than Bush.)
To me he comes across as some kind of pre-fab poser. A rent-a-president.
Is Kerry really the best that the Dems could come up with?
If I was an American this guy would scare me.
 
onthebottom said:

Just the British, Italians, Australians…. I would dare say the French, Germans and Russians were fooled as well but were too greedy (and with such a Napoleon complex) to act.

OTB
Get real! This has been hashed over time and again. The coalition of the willing had their own agendas why they hooked up with the US. And for most it had nothing to do with the threat of WMD. Remember the huge anti-war protests? Remember when the UN inspectors said they were within weeks of clearing Iraq of WMD? Remember just before the war when they said there was only about 5% of the WMD unaccounted for? Well there still is only 5% unaccounted for. But I guess they were destroyed without documentation, just as the Iraqis claimed. Was the world fooled? No. Was the US media fooled? No. Much of the US media is claiming now that they never put enough emphasis on the negative evidence of WMD. And that's possibly because they were following the lead of both sides of their government, -both sides chomping at the bit for war. The media in the rest of the world however was more balanced. So who was fooled? Maybe much of the US population, but not the world.
 
The_Jaded_One said:
I see HG beat me to the punch. OTB left himself way too open with his sloppy arguments and reasoning.
No problem.

What the political "right" in America tends to forget is that elections are about getting the proper person for the job, regardless of party affiliation. However, in their blinkered view of the world, the "right" would seem to choose to believe the sewage spouted by the likes of Lott, Limbaugh, O'Reilly and others, instead of seeing the world as it really is.

Why, for goodness sakes, the GOP and Bush specifically won't come clean and say that they erred in judgement is beyond me. Can you imagine the goodwill that an admittance of fault would generate? But, in true conservative style, they choose to disregard facts for a perceived short-term gain. It doesn't surprise me, but it sure disappoints me.

Is this the best they can do??

sighs in exasperation
 
The_Jaded_One said:
OTB,

Do you think you could be any more biased in favour of Bush? You believe the worst when it comes to Kerry but anything bad said about Bush is a liberal conspiracy theory. Do you have any idea how ridiculously biased you sound?

This from the postcard of fair and balanced, give me a break.

The_Jaded_One said:

Oh yeah, stop cherry picking your quotes like your hero Bush. Couldn't you do a little better than outdated quotes that didn't necessarily apply to the situation 4 years later?

Sure, how about:

"Hussein has ... chosen to spend his money on building weapons of
mass destruction and palaces for his cronies."
- Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999

or

"There is no doubt that ... Saddam Hussein has invigorated his
weapons programs. Reports indicate that biological, chemical and
nuclear programs continue apace and may be back to pre-Gulf War status. In
addition, Saddam continues to redefine delivery systems and is doubtless
using the cover of an ilicit missile program to develop longer-range missiles
that will threaten the United States and our allies."
- Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL,) and
others, December 5, 2001

and two years ago:

"We begin with the common belief that Saddam Hussein is a tyrant
and a threat to the peace and stability of the region. He has ignored
the mandated of the United Nations and is building weapons of mass
destruction and the means of delivering them."
- Sen. Carl Levin (D, MI), Sept. 19, 2002

along with this from the inventor of the Internet:

"We know that he has stored secret supplies of biological and
chemical weapons throughout his country."
- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

or from Jabba the Hut:

"We have known for many years that Saddam Hussein is seeking and
developing weapons of mass destruction."
- Sen. Ted Kennedy (D, MA), Sept. 27, 2002

tada:

"I will be voting to give the President of the United States the
authority to use force-- if necessary-- to disarm Saddam Hussein because
I believe that a deadly arsenal of weapons of mass destruction in his
hands is a real and grave threat to our security."
- Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002

The_Jaded_One said:

Everyone knew that Saddam Hussein was contained big time by the US but nothing was gonna appease the big business hawks in the administration b/c their agenda was to go to war. George Bush's decision to go to war COST lives not saved lives (you have to consider all the lives lost at war and the additional anger at the States now that is going to manifest itself in the form of terrorism). Of course a rabid Republican like yourself will refuse to see that.

I don’t know, do the math, 35,000 or more people were dying in Iraq annually (25,000 of them children under the age of 10). I’d say France Germany and Russia stayed out of the war for economic reasons and we went to war for security reasons. You can have another opinion / conspiracy theory if you like but it will be just that.

No one who knows me would consider me a rabid Republican, unlike yourself (rabid part anyway.


The_Jaded_One said:

Why don't you try reading this Hans Blix article with an OPEN mind?

Hans Blix Article

….

I will, but haven’t yet. Heard an interview with him on NPR a couple of months back (probably pushing a book) that was very good. He defiantly made the point that he believed that Iraq was disarmed but many would not believe him (including the US). He also said that the only reason inspectors were allowed back into Iraq (you do of course remember that no inspections were active when all of this started) was the US buildup in Kuwait.

OTB
 
bbking said:
Ah this has nothing to do with the Auto Industry of the late 70's and early 80's - those problems where caused by the arrogance of the Auto Executives of the time believing that Americans would buy any shit as long as it was American. When they woke up to reality the industry roared back.
As for economics - you really don't have to have a degree in economics to uderstand that if you are competing in a global economy for a job - salary becomes a big issue. If salary and benefits are low or non-existent offshore, how long will it be before salaries/benefits drop in the States - we are already seeing more and more companies drop health care as a benefit.

Well if this is true it will happen everywhere (Canada, EU, US) there is expensive labour and there is little you can do about it other than find a new area in which to compete. Remember that 70% of the US economy is Services based, the high value jobs in those industries are harder (not impossible) to outsource.

bbking said:

If the top 2% is made up of the upper middle class - you guys are in bigger trouble than I thought lol. the 200K number is what Bush says the benchmark for income for the top 2%, again lots of trouble if true.

Give me that source, if you make 200k in the US you are not in the top 2%.

bbking said:

Your in the software dev. biz and you know as well as I do that your industry was held up as the source of new jobs to replace the jobs lost by free-trade. While your industry has created a lot of new jobs the latest trend of sending jobs to India in the software industry is hurting this assumption. Don't get me wrong, while I do believe it is a normal course of events, little or nothing has been done by the Bush Administration to retrain dis-place workers or alter your/our (I'll include Canada here) education system.

I think you missed a major point of my post which was that many of these jobs were filled by Indians moving to the US on the H1B program to fill demand. Why not have those same people fill those jobs in India at Indian wages (or Chinese…) and save money. I don’t know that many Americans loose their jobs.

This is an emotion and anecdote driven issue, you will have a hard time finding substantial NET job loss due to off-shore activities (believe it or not the US IMPORTS more jobs than it exports).

bbking said:

I think steps need to be taken to give Comanies incentives to keep employment in the US at least for the short-term. The world is going thru a major economic change, one that I would think you see every day, the questions becomes do you want that change to occur quickly and painfully as Bush seems to want to do, or the gradual and somewhat painless approach that Kerry wants to take. Somehow I think the painful approach will cause other problems.
bbk

You are a classic socialist! It is inefficient and a waste of money to try and stop this, we should make investments in training and education (area’s in which in many ways we lead the world which is why we are in the position we are in) to prepare for the brave new world (there is always a brave new world). But creating incentives to pay companies to hire workers in a less efficient location is just stupid, it’s a waste of money and effort, and once implemented will be impossible to rip out, to say nothing of trading partner objections….

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
This from the postcard of fair and balanced, give me a break.

Hey even you said my critique of Kerry was bang on and Tiger Williams said my analysis was "fair and balanced" and all just in this thread. Now you are becoming wishy washy like Kerry and backpedaling to suit your rabid Bush agenda (isn't that why you started this thread?). Shame on you OTB. What you do amounts to intellectual dishonesty w/o the intellectual part.


"Hussein has ... chosen to spend his money on building weapons of
mass destruction and palaces for his cronies."
- Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999

This quote lacks relevance because of the date.

"There is no doubt that ... Saddam Hussein has invigorated his
weapons programs. Reports indicate that biological, chemical and
nuclear programs continue apace and may be back to pre-Gulf War status. In addition, Saddam continues to redefine delivery systems and is doubtless using the cover of an ilicit missile program to develop longer-range missiles that will threaten the United States and our allies."
- Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL,) and
others, December 5, 2001

Who are the others?

This was all conjecture w/o a shred of proof. THat is why language such as "indicate", "may" and "doubtless" is used instead of stronger words of fact. Iraq did not have the capabilities to put a missile on the United States. That is laughable to anyone who isn't suffering from acute paranoia.

"We begin with the common belief that Saddam Hussein is a tyrant and a threat to the peace and stability of the region. He has ignored the mandated of the United Nations and is building weapons of mass destruction and the means of delivering them."
- Sen. Carl Levin (D, MI), Sept. 19, 2002

Notice how the senator even states that he begins with the conclusion and then tries to prove it. You can't take anyone seriously who does that. He also doesn't state that Iraq has WMD only that they are in the process of building them but he can't even put a time frame on that. Is this what you call intelligence?

"We know that he has stored secret supplies of biological and
chemical weapons throughout his country."
- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

That is awfully vague and doesn't really tell you anything about his capabilities and whether Saddam is any kind of threat or not. In the 1992 Gulf war Saddam couldn't even put a missile on Tel Aviv and most people realized that he hadn't advanced his weapons arsenal since that time. So yeah he had some chemical/biological weapons but he was easily containable and hardly a threat to the United States.

"We have known for many years that Saddam Hussein is seeking and developing weapons of mass destruction."
- Sen. Ted Kennedy (D, MA), Sept. 27, 2002

That doesn't prove anything. For Saddam to be an immediate threat you have to prove he has WMD which can be used effectively against the US and not just a desire to have them. Again, is this what you call legitimate intelligence that is enough justification for war?!?!?

"I will be voting to give the President of the United States the
authority to use force-- if necessary-- to disarm Saddam Hussein because I believe that a deadly arsenal of weapons of mass destruction in his hands is a real and grave threat to our security."
- Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002

Note the words "if necessary". It wasn't. Kerry also said that he believed which means he didn't know for sure. That's not enough justification for Kerry's "if necessary" clause to use force.

I don’t know, do the math, 35,000 or more people were dying in Iraq annually (25,000 of them children under the age of 10).

Can you back this statement up please!!

I’d say France Germany and Russia stayed out of the war for economic reasons and we went to war for security reasons.

Of course. Everyone else acts in their economic interest but the United States who is the farthest away from Iraq and has the least possible chance of being threatened by WMD was the only one acting for security reasons. What the fuck are you smoking?

You can have another opinion / conspiracy theory if you like but it will be just that.

Have you ever noticed that any thing you don't want to believe that reflects badly on Bush you label a "conspiracy" theory. Are you that paranoid?

I will, but haven’t yet.

I don't think you will either. I mean with an open mind that is.
 
The_Jaded_One said:
Hey even you said my critique of Kerry was bang on and Tiger Williams said my analysis was "fair and balanced" and all just in this thread. Now you are becoming wishy washy like Kerry and backpedaling to suit your rabid Bush agenda (isn't that why you started this thread?). Shame on you OTB. What you do amounts to intellectual dishonesty w/o the intellectual part.

You identified Kerry as a flipflopper, which agreed with me. Take out the insults and you’ve said nothing, yet again.

While you found a way to nitpick the quotes, what they show is that both before and after many important people (and Al Gore) though Iraq was armed with WMD, which is counter to your original argument – you do remember that don’t you?

The_Jaded_One said:


Can you back this statement up please!!

How about:

http://www.thenation.com/doc.mhtml?i=20011203&s=cortright

The grim question of how many people have died in Iraq has sparked heated debate over the years. The controversy dates from 1995, when researchers with a Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) study in Iraq wrote to The Lancet, the journal of the British Medical Society, asserting that sanctions were responsible for the deaths of 567,000 Iraqi children. The New York Times picked up the story and declared "Iraq Sanctions Kill Children." CBS followed up with a segment on 60 Minutes that repeated the numbers and depicted sanctions as a murderous assault on children. This was the program in which UN ambassador (and later Secretary of State) Madeleine Albright, when asked about these numbers, coldly stated, "The price is worth it."

Albright's comments were shocking, as were the numbers, but doubts were soon raised about their validity. A January 1996 letter to The Lancet found inconsistencies in the mortality figures. A follow-up study in 1996, using the same methodology, found much lower rates of child mortality. In October 1997 the authors of the initial letter wrote again to The Lancet, this time reporting that mortality rates in the follow-up study were "several-fold lower than the estimate for 1995--for unknown reasons." While the initial report of more than 567,000 deaths attracted major news coverage, the subsequent disavowal of those numbers passed unnoticed in the press.

The two most reliable scientific studies on sanctions in Iraq are the 1999 report "Morbidity and Mortality Among Iraqi Children," by Columbia University's Richard Garfield, and "Sanctions and Childhood Mortality in Iraq," a May 2000 article by Mohamed Ali and Iqbal Shah in The Lancet. Garfield, an expert on the public-health impact of sanctions, conducted a comparative analysis of the more than two dozen major studies that have analyzed malnutrition and mortality figures in Iraq during the past decade. He estimated the most likely number of excess deaths among children under five years of age from 1990 through March 1998 to be 227,000. Garfield's analysis showed child mortality rates double those of the previous decade.

…….

Garfield has recently recalculated his numbers, based on the additional findings of the Ali and Shah study, to arrive at an estimate of approximately 350,000 through 2000.


Now back up your assertion.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
You identified Kerry as a flipflopper, which agreed with me. Take out the insults and you’ve said nothing, yet again.

No, that's not true. I have showed how biased your opinions are with regard to Bush and Kerry.

Originally posted by onthebottom
While you found a way to nitpick the quotes, what they show is that both before and after many important people (and Al Gore) though Iraq was armed with WMD, which is counter to your original argument – you do remember that don’t you?

The original points were some combination of these two statements:

1) Your assertion that the "rest of the planet" was fooled is ridiculous.

2) Dubya cherry picked for intelligence and put pressure on the CIA and other intelligence agencies to give him justification to go to war.

You replied to point number two. With that in mind, I have showed that the "intelligence" was not enough to justify going to war. I even used the quotes you posted to show that the people who were supposedly "fooled" by the intelligence didn't have any idea of the extent of Saddam Hussein's weapons program, didn't necessarily agree that he was an immediate threat and if they did think that it was only based on a hunch and not proof since they were ONLY surmising, and from what they said it couldn't be shown for sure that they thought that force was the only option available or the best option to pursue with regards to Iraq at that. Also, and I didn't mention this before, the people that you chose to quote hardly constitute expert testimony on the subject, nor did they base any of their opinion on hard facts and evidence or at least they didn't state it as such.

With regards to point number one, and if that is what you want me to respond to, you quoted ALL Americans. I know you tend to be close-minded and ethnocentric in your world views but that hardly constitutes fooling "the rest of the planet". I quoted Hans Blix a real expert who was actually in IRAQ and who wasn't an American politician with an agenda pulling facts out of his ass in order to cover it in a worst case scenario along with trying to appease a bunch of paranoid Americans who had been whipped into a frenzy of fear by Bush and his administration. To actually prove that the "rest of the planet" was fooled a smart person would actually quote from a representative sample that considered leaders and politicians from the rest of the countries (especially the G-7 ones) which showed a majority consensus that he was an immediate threat. You can't do that because most people outside America didn't agree that Saddam Hussein constituted an immediate threat that couldn't be contained through alternative means.


As to your proof that going to war saved lives that is retarded. The sanctions were not imposed by Saddam Hussein and that is what has caused the deaths. Lifting the sanctions would have resulted in stopping the needless deaths and it didn't have to be done by going to war. Going to war resulted in more American and Iraqis deaths than otherwise would have occurred by the direct actions of a contained Saddam Hussein. To date, the war has caused over 10,000 Iraqis deaths and almost 1,000 American. Those are more lives lost than the 9/11 tragedy and the war has only caused more hostility and hatred towards America which is the fuel for terrorism. The decision to go to war by Bush has been an absolute disaster!!

PS - Are you purposely drawing these false comparisons or are you really that stupid?
 
The_Jaded_One said:

As to your proof that going to war saved lives that is retarded. The sanctions were not imposed by Saddam Hussein and that is what has caused the deaths. Lifting the sanctions would have resulted in stopping the needless deaths and it didn't have to be done by going to war. Going to war resulted in more American and Iraqis deaths than otherwise would have occurred by the direct actions of a contained Saddam Hussein. To date, the war has caused over 10,000 Iraqis deaths and almost 1,000 American. Those are more lives lost than the 9/11 tragedy and the war has only caused more hostility and hatred towards America which is the fuel for terrorism. The decision to go to war by Bush has been an absolute disaster!!

PS - Are you purposely drawing these false comparisons or are you really that stupid?

Your childish insults are tiresome.

Fewer Iraqi's are dieing now than before the war (by a large number). If you end sanctions then Iraq reconstitutes his WMD program and invades a neighbor (it's happened twice in the last 30 years) and you are back where you started. If you continue sanctions MORE Iraqi's continue to die. If you invade less people die. It's not that hard to understand.

Now, a fool could believe that you could lift sanctions and SH would live in peace an harmony and take up knitting - but those who live in the real world knew that would never happen.

Why did the war happen when it did. France, Germany and Russia were pushing to have the sanctions lifted and the US/UK had a choice to make. They made the right one.

Now back to the original topic, we all know where Bush stands on this, weather we like it or not we know where he stands – not even Kerry knows where he stands.

OTB
 
bbking said:
As for Canada/ EU etc. we are not paying Companies to take jobs elsewhere well at least I know Canada isn't. But on the whole, yeah we are in the same boat, it's just no one in your boat is bailing the water out - yet.

Are we paying to export jobs, or are we just not subsidizing jobs at home? You would understand the difference of course.

bbking said:

200K - 2% I think I didn't word that right. My original point was a critic of Bush's comments, that small business would be hurt by Kerry's plan and by hurting small business you hurt job creation since most new jobs are created by small business. I think Bush is being a little misleading here in that a small business capable of generating an income in excess of 200K for it's owner would most likely be a corporation for tax purpose and past the rapid increase phase of job creation anyways. Sorry about that - brain fart..

You not only confused yourself but then you drew incorrect conclusions from those confused thoughts.

Very small, but successful, businesses pay many people in their companies more than 200k a year. I worked for a small (80 person) software firm in Toronto who paid at least 25% of the staff that much (and much more). To the people who hire people, 200k in income is not a lot of money, not subsistence but not a fortune either. Kerry is using classic class warfare by wanting to tax the other guy, the rich guy, the successful guy. The top 800 tax returns in the US pay about 25% of the income tax, the bottom half of tax returns pay about 25%. Small business is the economic engine in this economy - and it outsources fewer jobs ;-)

bbking said:

At this time I find it hard to believe that the wage paid in a lost job is the same or higher than an imported job. I think if you add it all up it's a net lost...

Not at all really, most jobs outsourced are lower paying, most jobs imported are jobs that can only be done here and thus are higher paying. In the software business the management and decision makers are in the US, the guys who write stuff to spec. take support calls and debug code are in Bangalore.

bbking said:

As for your original point on paying Indians in the US or in India, isn't your point a tad bit explotive. .

How is it exploitive to employ someone in their own country? I must say, you've completely lost me here, unless of course you think that any programmer in India has a right to move to California?

bbking said:

Anyways, I think the US looses more than jobs here - I assume with higher paying jobs in the US you are attracking the very best from other countries - the Brain Drain. This attraction of talent is what help build the US quickly into the techology and economic giant it became in the 20th century - loose this edge and things might slow down..

This is a good point, nothing is more important to the US than first generation immigrants, especially skilled ones. They are the most appreciative of the US way of life and opportunity, the rest of us are spoiled and lazy. 50% of PhD students in the US are from another country, if fact the most critical thing to get right in the homeland security implementation is speedy approval of the right student visas so these people can come here, learn, and stay to make us all richer :-)

bbking said:

Typical - I make some sense and out comes the classic socialist comment, you righties are alike. Look I can respect the Reagan/Goldwater view of conservatism - that people have more freedom when Government is smaller ( I don't lump Bush in this type of conservatism), but it doesn't mean I believe it. lol

Bush is not a small government conservative, but I am, and this is one area where I would disagree with him. I'd fire half the federal workers and see if anyone other than the labor unions and media noticed, if not I'd do it again - repeat until someone notices.

cont....
 
bbking said:

Look we are all going thru a major economic transformation, and I believe that Government needs to involve itself so that the transformation moves along as smoothly as possible - not the bumpy displaced road that true Capitalism brings. In the end I think it will make life easier for all. BTW since when are tax cuts classic socialism.

I firmly believe Governments f*ck things up, it's the worst way to do anything. I don't believe in government subsidies to engineer behavior, we have too many of them already in our tax code (my deduction for my mortgage interest payments would be the most widely used, this is how little I pay for mortgage money - I'm in the top tax bracket 35% so I pay 65% of 6% for money - it's awesome!)

bbking said:

Hey your going to love my next comment - I think we in the west need to get together a properly manage the global economy. Ok OTB you can let go of the ceiling now A good example would be farm subsidies, they should be stopped in the West immediately and this would give some of the poorer Nations of the world to develope a good Agraculture style economy and give a middle class a chance to grow - I believe it was your POTUS Bush that suggested this and in fact both Canada and the US have taken steps to reduce this type of socialism.
bbk

I would stop all farm subsidies as well (I can hear the screaming in French and Japanese, can you LOL) but that's not "properly manage the global economy" that's getting out of the way of the global economy and let it work. The f*cked up subsidies that rich countries is a "managed economy" and again if the government is involved it will be FUBR.

OTB
 
Re: OTB

DonQuixote said:
Read my story. It's all a mind game for you.
It's Americans like you that want me to ....!
You are a fool and destined for your own destruction.
Leave the patriotic to serve in an honorable and just war.
You're way off the top.

Not only do you not make any sense but you lack the capability to sustain real thoughts and express them in full sentences.

OTB
 
Re: OTB

DonQuixote said:
What universe do you reside in?
I'll avoid same if you tell me.

The real one, but no fear you're no where close.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Fewer Iraqi's are dieing now than before the war (by a large number). If you end sanctions then Iraq reconstitutes his WMD program and invades a neighbor (it's happened twice in the last 30 years) and you are back where you started. If you continue sanctions MORE Iraqi's continue to die. If you invade less people die. It's not that hard to understand.

Let me see if I have a handle on your warped thinking. The US couldn't end sanctions b/c Iraq would reconstitute their WMD program but in spite of sanctions the US went to war w/ Iraq b/c they had WMD. Does this make sense to you, really?

The only thing economic sanctions cause is the death of innocents. That is not how you contain a dictator and it causes needless deaths. You contain a dictator through bribery and boosting his economy. Saddam Hussein wasn't gonna bite the hand that fed him. Let's get real.

If you go to war people die b/c of it. If you lift sanctions, bribe SH, and boost his economy you can get him to do what you want and there is less hostility towards the United States. But since you have a dumb fuck like GB in office and easily manipulated sheep like yourself who vote for him you now have over 11000 dead people, no end in sight, and increased global hatred towards America. Yep, going to war was a brilliant move and the right one.