Jerry Seinfeld On Palestine

The fact that you're comparing a 79-year-old man allegedly pursuing a 15-year-old, someone who cannot legally consent, to a 39-year-old dating a 17-year-old, where the relationship was legal, demonstrates your bias once again.

You're collapsing two very different scenarios into one because it supports your biased antisemitic racist conclusion you've already decided on.

Disliking a relationship doesn't make every age-gap relationship equivalent, and pretending there's no meaningful distinction between a 15-year-old and a 17-year-old isn't a serious argument.

Do you agree there are pedophiles among the Arab population, or is it just a Jewish fetish?

People are people, there are creeps, losers and pedos in every culture.
Seinfeld is a zionist and that attitudes within that movement need to looked at closely.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
For example, would you say it's wrong for a 75-year-old man to be in a consensual relationship with a 25-year-old woman? That's a 50-year age gap, larger than the gap we're discussing here.
I think there is a difference between adult relationships even one with a large age gap, and a relationship between an adult and a child, even if that child has reached age of consent.
Also, the peculiarity you note, with age gaps being tolerated more when the individuals are older, probably has to do with maturity and power dynamics of the ones involved.
 
I think there is a difference between adult relationships even one with a large age gap, and a relationship between an adult and a child, even if that child has reached age of consent.
Also, the peculiarity you note, with age gaps being tolerated more when the individuals are older, probably has to do with maturity and power dynamics of the ones involved.


Yes, but legally speaking, if a 17-year-old is above the age of consent in that jurisdiction and freely consents, there is nothing that can be done to prevent a 75-year-old from dating them.

People are free to judge it, criticize it, or give it the side-eye. They can consider it creepy, inappropriate, or morally questionable. That's all fair game.

What they cannot do is treat it as if it were a crime simply because they disapprove of it. In fact, if someone decides to take matters into their own hands and physically interfere, threaten, or assault the older person, it would be the self-appointed vigilante, not the couple, who ends up facing legal consequences.

The reality is that legality and morality are not always the same thing. You're entitled to your moral opinion, but that doesn't give you the authority to redefine the law or punish people for conduct that is legal.

Be honest: a new girl pops up at your favorite agency, and she's 18; would you book her? No offense, but I also guess you are older than 39? ;)
 
1781444023717.png

HKuXbiwWUAA0FHG.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Yes, but legally speaking, if a 17-year-old is above the age of consent in that jurisdiction and freely consents, there is nothing that can be done to prevent a 75-year-old from dating them.

People are free to judge it, criticize it, or give it the side-eye. They can consider it creepy, inappropriate, or morally questionable. That's all fair game.

What they cannot do is treat it as if it were a crime simply because they disapprove of it. In fact, if someone decides to take matters into their own hands and physically interfere, threaten, or assault the older person, it would be the self-appointed vigilante, not the couple, who ends up facing legal consequences.

The reality is that legality and morality are not always the same thing. You're entitled to your moral opinion, but that doesn't give you the authority to redefine the law or punish people for conduct that is legal.

Be honest: a new girl pops up at your favorite agency, and she's 18; would you book her? No offense, but I also guess you are older than 39? ;)
I don't disagree, but what am saying is when people call someone a pedo, they aren't making a legal argument.
 
I don't disagree, but what am saying is when people call someone a pedo, they aren't making a legal argument.

Fair enough, but words still have meanings. If someone wants to say they find a relationship creepy, inappropriate, or morally questionable, that's their opinion. Calling someone a pedophile, however, is a specific accusation, and I don't think it's helpful to blur the distinction between things or a group of people we dislike and actual pedophilia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Fair enough, but words still have meanings. If someone wants to say they find a relationship creepy, inappropriate, or morally questionable, that's their opinion. Calling someone a pedophile, however, is a specific accusation, and I don't think it's helpful to blur the distinction between things or a group of people we dislike and actual pedophilia.

Fine, that's a difference of opinion.
The way your opinion appears to be that Palestinians deserve no human rights or justice, that those rights are race based.
 
Fine, that's a difference of opinion.
The way your opinion appears to be that Palestinians deserve no human rights or justice, that those rights are race based.


It amazes me how you can leap from a discussion about whether a 17-year-old can legally consent to dating someone older who by legal definition, is NOT A PEDO, to claiming that I somehow believe Palestinians deserve no human rights or justice.

Please show me one post where I have made this statement.

Those two topics have absolutely nothing to do with one another.

At this point, it feels like you're not responding to what I'm actually saying, but to a caricature you've created in your own head. Disagree with my position all you want, but at least address the argument being made instead of inventing views I don't hold.

Seriously, Frankie, where did that even come from? Have a coffee, maybe an espresso with a little Sambuca and calm down.
 
It amazes me how you can leap from a discussion about whether a 17-year-old can legally consent to dating someone older who by legal definition, is NOT A PEDO, to claiming that I somehow believe Palestinians deserve no human rights or justice.

Please show me one post where I have made this statement.

Those two topics have absolutely nothing to do with one another.

At this point, it feels like you're not responding to what I'm actually saying, but to a caricature you've created in your own head. Disagree with my position all you want, but at least address the argument being made instead of inventing views I don't hold.

Seriously, Frankie, where did that even come from? Have a coffee, maybe an espresso with a little Sambuca and calm down.

Of course you haven't made an overt statement, what you've done is articulate a position through your posts.
What you have done is back the destruction of all Palestinian human rights through apartheid, illegal occupation and now genocide.
You back a state where Palestinians now have almost no rights.

For instance, the UN and ICC say the occupation of Palestine is illegal.
Do you think Palestinians, including Hamas, have the right to self defence?
 
Of course you haven't made an overt statement, what you've done is articulate a position through your posts.
What you have done is back the destruction of all Palestinian human rights through apartheid, illegal occupation and now genocide.
You back a state where Palestinians now have almost no rights.

For instance, the UN and ICC say the occupation of Palestine is illegal.
Do you think Palestinians, including Hamas, have the right to self defence?



First off, this thread had nothing to do with Israel and Palestine. I've told you before that it's nearly impossible to have a rational discussion with you on that subject because you have a habit of dragging it into conversations where it isn't relevant.

My original point was about the absurdity of trying to paint Jewish men as pedophiles by claiming that Jerry Seinfeld is a pedophile because he dated a 17-year-old. That's a serious accusation, and in my view it's both inaccurate and slanderous.

As for Palestine, since you've brought it up yet again, I do believe Palestinians have a right to their own state and to live with dignity and security. I also believe Hamas should be destroyed as a political and military force and never be allowed to hold power again.

For the sake of consistency, I'm also not a fan of Bibi. I think he has been a disaster for the prospects of long-term peace, and I'd be perfectly happy to see him removed from power through the democratic process as well.

The problem is that you seem to assume that anyone who opposes Hamas must therefore oppose Palestinian rights, and that anyone who supports Israel's right to exist must support everything Netanyahu does. The world isn't that binary. It is entirely possible to support Palestinian statehood, oppose Hamas, support Israel's right to exist, and believe Netanyahu should no longer be leading Israel.