Here's my perspective from someone who has quite a bit of experience with online hookups and dating:
...The reason for bringing a friend with you is mostly to ensure your safety, but also to get an outsider and trusted opinion on the person you are meeting. As we all know, lust can very often clauds our judgement, and this is where the friend's perspective come in play.
....I can't tell you how many times I thought I've met someone I thought was really great, only to realize later once I met their friends or they met mine that they were a completely different -- and not as great -- person in a social context.
Gen, first off, I love your posts, they are some of the most thoughtful, intelligent ones I have come across, plus I tend to agree with your points of view, even if my perspective on women differ. I'm not a big fan of women from Toronto, but I am a huge fan of women from Quebec.
I think this is the first time I would disagree with what you have written. The
only time a girlfriend will approve of her friend's new love interest, is if she wants to fuck him also. Whether that is a problem or not depends on perspective. For example, you bring your girlfriend with you on a romantic date, and she's says "he's a wonderful guy" what she really means is, "If I ever get the chance to be alone with him, I will fuck him". Turn your back on your girlfriend and within seconds she'll be sucking your new love's cock.
The other time is when she doesn't approve. This can be because she's secretly a hater of anything good in your life, including a new love, or jealous. Also, if she is protective, she may feel the new guy is encroaching on her friendship with her girlfriend and may do whatever she can to discourage it. Maybe also she's not as open-minded as her girlfriend is, and maybe wouldn't consider the same guy (i.e. maybe the guy is of a different race, one that she doesn't like, but her girlfriend does, maybe the guy is older than who she'd go out with etc.). The point is, when you are attracted to a guy, your girlfriend will not see them the same way that you do, and if she does, it's because she secretly wants to fuck him too. Girlfriends cannot be trusted. They will either undermine your relationship with your new love, or be supportive of it, only because they secretly want him too, and would fuck him if they got the chance to in front of, or more than likely, behind her friend's back.
Also a girlfriend cannot see the guy in the same way you do, because the emotional investment isn't there or hasn't been developed, otherwise the guy would like her and her girlfriend too. Thus when a girl invites her girlfriend out on a romantic date with a new guy, inevitably, the girlfriend will not see him in the same light, and will only approve if she herself secretly wants him too. If she doesn't she'll find any stupid excuse to discourage the budding relationship.
The short answer is that girlfriends fuck each other over - especially when it comes to guys, and everybody loses in the end. My advice is to keep girlfriends out of the equation, because they can color one's judgement, with often very selfish motivations. If you want to be happy, have confidence in your own ability to make good judgments about a guy. If you like him, you like him. If you like him, spend more time with him. If it works out, great, if it doesn't, well, lesson learned. But throw in a girlfriend's "advice" into the equation, and you have just cost yourself and the guy a potential opportunity for love to grow. I mean eventually, if the love grows stronger, it would mean the replacement of time from your girlfriend to this new guy, and for many girls, this can be quite threatening.
By the way, I am not directing this in particular to you Gen, I don't know your friends, or the context in which they view guys, but I generally think including your girlfriend's advice is a recipe for disaster. It's hard to say why she wants to invite her friend along. Maybe she read that in a stupid magazine like Cosmopolitan in an article about how to date a guy, written by a girl. There's a whole industry dedicated around men and women dating, and yet to keep them perpetually single, because two single people who are perpetually dating are more profitable and marketable consumers, than a stable complete couple. Which is why magazines like Cosmo flourish. They have these articles written on dating, but written by who? I don't know. But because it is in Cosmo, the assumption is that they are the expert. So many girls read stupid advice from ladies they have never even met (if they are ladies and not men in fact writing those articles), telling them how to treat the relationships they are in with men these "experts" have never had a conversation with. The advice ends up usually being bad, backfires, and the girl is single again, ready to buy more Pantene products to make her hair shinier than the next, and Loreal Elnett hairspray to give her hair that extra hold, so she stands out from the crowd ready to find the next guy to date. This advice keeps people perpetually single. Bringing a girlfriend on a date with a romantic partner undermines their potential growth. It is a really stupid idea, but most women believe it is a great idea. If you didn't trust the guy you're out on a date with, then why would you bring a girlfriend along?
I would be really interested in hearing how this works out. I don't know, maybe it would be a good thing. But my instincts tell me it's her way to bail out, and she's setting him up for a bailout out strategy. Either that, or she's undermining her future progress with him, by not taking ownership of her own decision making ability to choose a good mate, and passing that process on to, and leaving it in the hands of, her girlfriend.