ISO: Dating advices

gentle_lover

Banned
Mar 5, 2005
2,077
0
0
Ok. I met a girl last night whom I met through Eharmony. It was the first meeting. We have been texting each other for at least a couple of weeks before we met last night. She claimed that her friend put her profile on eharmony, and she was kinda hesitated about the idea. Not even a year ago, she ended up her 4 years relationship. He was cheating on her for 2 years. She said she got over him (though I kinda believe she is not over him yet 100%, and she is trying to). She said that from time to time she thought about him. Online, she said that she is not looking to date anyone right now. On the other hand, I hope she change her mind and give me chance. We went out for coffee and movie. We coincidentally bump at each other on the way to the theatre. I was expecting a hug or a handshake. We said hi and continued to walk to the theatre together briskly since it was cold. She was complaining how cold her hands were. At the theatre, I offered her to treat her movie foods, and she said I don't have to do it, but I said it's ok I don't mind. I was trying to be a gentleman anyway. So she said, ok how about I pay the fries and you pay the drink. So, we share fries and drink. We paid our own tickets, btw. Before we went to the movie, she said that she would like to watch Avatar 3D again and she asked me if I want to watch it with her. After the movie, we went for a coffee and talk for at least 2 hours. This time she let me paid for the coffee. I think we had a good talk, and she asked me to tell her more about me, and i asked her the same thing. We also talked about work related issues, and etc. I think it was good talk. When we walked to the subway, I asked her if she had a good time, and she said yes. She asked me the same question, and I said yes. We agreed that we should do it again sometime. She said we'll do it again on her day off. I mentioned to her that Monday is my day off. I asked her if she wants to do something on Monday, and she said yes. I suggested the avatar 3d, then she said how about a dinner. I went along. Now this next part kinda threw me off a little bit. She asked me if she can bring a friend, and told me I can bring a friend too. In my mind, I went..."a friend"? I didn't agree with her right away. So, I asked her, why she wants to bring a friend. But we didn't get to finish the conversation, since we got disturb by an elderly lady who seem having a hard time bringing her stuffs up the stairs. Then we said goodbye and we hugged. When I got home, I texted her and asked her if she got home alright. She replied “yes, thank you. I’m online on MSN if you wanna talk”. It was around 11pm. So, we chatted until around 2 am. She asked me again if I have a fun time. Then she asked me on what was my first impression of her. She liked my answer, and she said she was flattered. She said that I look better in person.

My question is what could be the motive behind “bring the friend” thing?
I know she was in a long term relationship before and ended up bad. It wasn’t that long ago. I understand, and I’m willing to take it slow.

How can I tell her that I would like the next meeting will be a date only two of us without coming out too strong or anything creepy?

What do you think about the whole date? I’m not sure if it was a date, or it was an initial in-person meeting moving from online to real life thing.
I didn’t bring anything when I saw her, since I looked at it as a preliminary meeting and just to see what will happen. When I see her again, I’m thinking to bring either a yellow/white rose or/and box of chocolate since she likes chocolate. IMO, I think the second meeting I can call it a first date.

I know I’m going to have people say “good luck finding dating advice on escort forum” responses. They will be ignored. I know there are real decent people with real life on this board as well.
And no, I'm not looking just to sleep with her or anything. I'm looking something serious.
 
Ok. I met a girl last night whom I met through Eharmony. It was the first meeting. We have been texting each other for at least a couple of weeks before we met last night. She claimed that her friend put her profile on eharmony, and she was kinda hesitated about the idea. Not even a year ago, she ended up her 4 years relationship. He was cheating on her for 2 years. She said she got over him (though I kinda believe she is not over him yet 100%, and she is trying to). She said that from time to time she thought about him. Online, she said that she is not looking to date anyone right now. On the other hand, I hope she change her mind and give me chance. We went out for coffee and movie. We coincidentally bump at each other on the way to the theatre. I was expecting a hug or a handshake. We said hi and continued to walk to the theatre together briskly since it was cold. She was complaining how cold her hands were. At the theatre, I offered her to treat her movie foods, and she said I don't have to do it, but I said it's ok I don't mind. I was trying to be a gentleman anyway. So she said, ok how about I pay the fries and you pay the drink. So, we share fries and drink. We paid our own tickets, btw. Before we went to the movie, she said that she would like to watch Avatar 3D again and she asked me if I want to watch it with her. After the movie, we went for a coffee and talk for at least 2 hours. This time she let me paid for the coffee. I think we had a good talk, and she asked me to tell her more about me, and i asked her the same thing. We also talked about work related issues, and etc. I think it was good talk. When we walked to the subway, I asked her if she had a good time, and she said yes. She asked me the same question, and I said yes. We agreed that we should do it again sometime. She said we'll do it again on her day off. I mentioned to her that Monday is my day off. I asked her if she wants to do something on Monday, and she said yes. I suggested the avatar 3d, then she said how about a dinner. I went along. Now this next part kinda threw me off a little bit. She asked me if she can bring a friend, and told me I can bring a friend too. In my mind, I went..."a friend"? I didn't agree with her right away. So, I asked her, why she wants to bring a friend. But we didn't get to finish the conversation, since we got disturb by an elderly lady who seem having a hard time bringing her stuffs up the stairs. Then we said goodbye and we hugged. When I got home, I texted her and asked her if she got home alright. She replied “yes, thank you. I’m online on MSN if you wanna talk”. It was around 11pm. So, we chatted until around 2 am. She asked me again if I have a fun time. Then she asked me on what was my first impression of her. She liked my answer, and she said she was flattered. She said that I look better in person.

My question is what could be the motive behind “bring the friend” thing?
I know she was in a long term relationship before and ended up bad. It wasn’t that long ago. I understand, and I’m willing to take it slow.

How can I tell her that I would like the next meeting will be a date only two of us without coming out too strong or anything creepy?

What do you think about the whole date? I’m not sure if it was a date, or it was an initial in-person meeting moving from online to real life thing.
I didn’t bring anything when I saw her, since I looked at it as a preliminary meeting and just to see what will happen. When I see her again, I’m thinking to bring either a yellow/white rose or/and box of chocolate since she likes chocolate. IMO, I think the second meeting I can call it a first date.

I know I’m going to have people say “good luck finding dating advice on escort forum” responses. They will be ignored. I know there are real decent people with real life on this board as well.
And no, I'm not looking just to sleep with her or anything. I'm looking something serious.


You've hit it on the head right here. The advise you'd get here in the most part will be skewed a lot. you've been a member long enough to know that and probably have a good idea whose advise to accept.

My advice is go with the flow. She's may be into you, but has some little nagging doubts about you/her, whatever . It won't hurt to say yes to the 'friend' thing, but it does take it out of the realm of a date for now. That may be the level that she's comfortable with at this time. It may be a test to see if your the sharing, caring, easy going kind. You'll share her friendship with others people (yours and hers), you care about her feelings, and you can deal with a little curveball now and then.

Go with it. What's the worst than can happen. I don't see a down side as long as you're ok in your head, because that will show.
 
Go for it, maybe her friend will be a blast too. Maybe she really likes you but like to get a second opinion from her friend.
 
Maybe I missed it, but did you ask her about the reason for wanting to bring a friend?

I thought your date went well, sounds pretty typical to me-which is not a bad thing. Just a nice calm comfy evening.

There could be several reasons why she wanted to bring a friend, and I am just going to venture a guess. I am guessing that due to what happened in her last relationship, there is a bit of doubt on her end about trust and also trusting herself in judging characters-hence wanting a friend to observe you, and also observe your friend as well as you can tell a lot about a person by who their friends are. Another possibility-and this is a good thing, is that she really enjoyed spending time with you but is afraid of thing progressing too quickly. It kinda goes hand in hand with the first reason-like she thought she didn't want a relationship for now, but she enjoyed herself so much that she's afraid she'll just jump into it, so she doesn't trust herself to know what's best for herself, and deciides that a "chaperone" might be a good idea.
 
It's clear from your post that you are very inxperienced with woman. She has excess baggage, and my advice is to let this one go and find another. She aslo sounds like she would make you work hard in a relationship. Next time, you should give your date a goodnight kiss on the lips (with no tounge action), instead of a hug. This is a potential girlfriend, not your mom.

No chocolates, flowers or gifts on a 2nd or third date. Save that for AFTER you've had sex with her.
 
Yeah better to pay $250 an hour for a hottie
 
My question is what could be the motive behind “bring the friend” thing?
I know she was in a long term relationship before and ended up bad. It wasn’t that long ago. I understand, and I’m willing to take it slow.

How can I tell her that I would like the next meeting will be a date only two of us without coming out too strong or anything creepy?

What do you think about the whole date? I’m not sure if it was a date, or it was an initial in-person meeting moving from online to real life thing.
I didn’t bring anything when I saw her, since I looked at it as a preliminary meeting and just to see what will happen. When I see her again, I’m thinking to bring either a yellow/white rose or/and box of chocolate since she likes chocolate. IMO, I think the second meeting I can call it a first date.

I know I’m going to have people say “good luck finding dating advice on escort forum” responses. They will be ignored. I know there are real decent people with real life on this board as well.
And no, I'm not looking just to sleep with her or anything. I'm looking something serious.

My $.02:
All and all it sounds like the date went pretty well, and she agreed to a second date. Good on you.

In the interim:
Don't try to hover about her too much online, but DEFINITELY don't make it seem like you're playing it cool like it's some sort of game. There's a fine line there... If you e-hover you'll seem creepy, if you play it too cool you'll seem like a dick.

About the friend thing:
She probably just wants a second opinion from a source she trusts. You're some dude she met online and she wants to expose you to some trusted friend of hers. You are being judged by a 3rd party. Yay! Oh the joys of life! A little odd on a second date, but not too freakish. I'd take it in stride and find out if her friend is a she, and if her friend is a single she. The bigger question is if you want to bring a friend. I'd be a little iffy on that because it's a whole other set of variables in the mix on a second date, but if you do bring a friend make him single if her friend is 'a she' and 'single', MAKE SURE HE'S NORMAL, AND MAKE SURE HE'LL BUILD YOU UP AND HAS YOUR BACK. You want normal, will build you up, and has you back more than cool and exciting...

Back to in the interim:
To take your mind of things glance at a couple of websites like Toronto.com and try to find things that she'd like and you'd tolerate. Try to figure out of few various date plans. Toward the end of the second date (no sooner-- You'll make it look like you're moving too fast), if it goes well, whip out the plan that seems the most appropriate. Given that date two is 'with friends', with a little luck date 3 should spill over into some mutual lusting. (If you get to date #3.)

That's my cheap advice.

edit: Civi dating is equal parts practise, planning, and being present in person. You can muddle by on 2 out of 3.

I wouldn't think too much about the money thing. Most of the women I date make the same as or more than me-- I've always been far more comfortable with women who will accept 'treats' in the spirit they're given, and then split or alternate bills, than a woman who expects 'free meals and amusement for the duration'. Being a gentleman is fine, and in fact the offer is usually what matters more than who actually pays what. Any woman who does online dating could probably use it as a source of free food and events for life... The fact that she isn't looking for that is a good thing, in so far as it isn't a way for her to distance herself from you. (As long as it isn't her way of saying, "I don't want to owe him anything.")

edit: DEFINITELY not DEFIANTLY, though I rather like the change in meaning.
 
Bringing a friend is a good thing. It may be a 2nd opinion, it may be her way of keeping it slow. Either way its a good thing. Her telling you she had fun but isn't ready for a commitment yet would have been the bad thing.

Cheers!
 
From the POV of a lady your first meeting went very well. She is interested in you and you mentioned all the things that point to that - she got more and more comfortable with you, she let you buy her the coffee, she gave you a hug, she invited you to chat and chatted for hours. If she wasn't interested in getting to know you well enough to potentially date she wouldn't have done any of that. Another good signal is asking for a dinner instead of movie, at dinner you can talk more and observe the other person's mannerisms more. She is not looking to rush things and it will take time to get to know each other well enough in person to get to the stage where a relationship is on the table.

The best thing you can do is be direct. That is what she needs especially since she has trust issues. She probably wants to bring the friend as a second judge of your character but probably mainly as a buffer so the friend can add to the conversation and whatnot. That is really all it probably is. If you really just want the next date to be the two of you tell her so, and why but I think she is signaling that she would like to take things slower than that. Or tell her you think it's a great idea to bring a friend (only if you mean it) during the new stages of your growing friendship, that you hope it will help you get to know one another better, BUT ask if you can bring one also.

I admit, the wanting to bring a friend thing is a bit weird. I would want my prospective date to be more confident in herself and her judge of character. But, because you met online it kinda changes things because she has to figure out if you are the same person/personality you put forth in chat as you are in person. These things are easier to chat than perform in real life. Her asking you if she can bring someone is direct and great, kudos to her, but did you ask or want to ask why?

This dinner wouldn't really be your first date if friends are there. But it opens the door to possibility. If it goes well, take her aside and ask her, "Whatever her name is - I have really enjoyed chatting with you, I've enjoyed meeting you in person even more. I like this and that and we seem to have chemistry, and now that we know a bit more about each other I would like to ask if you would like to go on a first date."

Good luck with it!! Oh I would bring either a orange or yellow rose - orange means desire and excitement, or an "expression of fervent romance"; yellow is friendship. White represents innocence, purity and often associated with weddings - this is a little much for a first date. I would probably save the flowers till the real first date when you are alone, but at dinner bring chocolates or even a movie or cd you think she would like based on your chats and a little note telling her why you thought she would like it. It's kinda corny but she'll love it. Hope I helped a little.
 
You say that she was cold, did you rub her arms or give her a hug? If there was no physical contact or touching at all, then you are done my friend. Maybe go see Avatar and check out her friend. If the E-Harmony girl thinks you're a good guy but not for her, maybe she's trying to set you up with her friend.
 
From my experience, a girl that tells you her last BF cheated on her is not looking to give it up right away. You should know going in you will have to earn it and jump through hoops for it. You've been warned.
 
You have a great opportunity to find out if she is interested in you. Tell her you prefer to have
dinner with her alone, so you can get to know each other better bla bla bla.
 
Here's my perspective from someone who has quite a bit of experience with online hookups and dating:

Many online dating tips directed at women suggest that you bring a friend with you for the first date. While this wouldn't be the first time you meet, my first guess would be that she is following this advice. The reason for bringing a friend with you is mostly to ensure your safety, but also to get an outsider and trusted opinion on the person you are meeting. As we all know, lust can very often clauds our judgement, and this is where the friend's perspective come in play.

Another potential motivation for suggesting that you both bring a friend along would be to take some of the pressure off of a "real date", and play it more casual and relaxed. Personally, I think it can be a good idea. I can't tell you how many times I thought I've met someone I thought was really great, only to realize later once I met their friends or they met mine that they were a completely different -- and not as great -- person in a social context.

Those are only two guesses of mine of course, and she could haave other motivations to suggest you bring friends to your second meeting. But my suggestion would be to play along, and see where it goes. As for the gift, I don't know many women who wouldn't appreciate the attention. For a second date, I would stick to a small and inexpensive gift. I'm not a fan of flowers myself, but many women are. But if you are meeting somewhere rather than picking her up at her place, a flower may not be the best idea as she would have to carry it along with her all night long. Chocolates would be better in this case: I suggest you get them somewhere where you can pick each chocolate yourself to make her a personalized box. You could even try to pick each one to fit some aspect of her personality that you like: a spicy one, a subtle and delicate one, a very sweet one, etc.

Good luck, and have fun.
 
I agree with some had said already. I think she's looking for a 2nd opinion. She has been burned before so she's a bit gun shy now. You'll have to go slow with her. GL and I hope you do find what you're looking for.
 
Another potential motivation for suggesting that you both bring a friend along would be to take some of the pressure off of a "real date", and play it more casual and relaxed. Personally, I think it can be a good idea. I can't tell you how many times I thought I've met someone I thought was really great, only to realize later once I met their friends or they met mine that they were a completely different -- and not as great -- person in a social context.

He he-- That's why I said I'd be a little iffy about bringing a friend of my own. It adds a whole layer of additional considerations. (It's not just you that's being judged, but you and your whole network of friends.) Mind you if a person has a decent well of reasonably normal, reasonably socialized, trusted friends who have your back and will build you up that's a bit of a non-issue.

Ultimately, like Gen / I said, take her bringing a friend in stride and go with your instincts on if you want to expose her to your friends at this time. Mind you, since she mentioned it, you better plan on producing something resembling a friend in the near term. If you don't bring a friend, you should consider a double date with a couple you know... Cause she apparently wants 'that little bit of context'...
 
Here's my 2 cents.

The woman you're interested in may not be confident in her ability to judge character, based on choosing losers in the past. Her "friend" is probably someone she thinks is a good judge of character. If you win over the friend, then you will probably win the girl over. A lot of women, like men actually don't even know what they want. If it lands in their lap, they won't even recognize it. Hence, they need a second opinion.

My advice is be friendly and pleasant to both of them and keep in mind the "friend" will be looking for any flags or warning signs of a douche. This is pretty standard PUA stuff; win over the friend and you win the girl. It's even better if the friend is a guy.

good luck
 
Here's my 2 cents.

The woman you're interested in may not be confident in her ability to judge character, based on choosing losers in the past. Her "friend" is probably someone she thinks is a good judge of character. If you win over the friend, then you will probably win the girl over. A lot of women, like men actually don't even know what they want. If it lands in their lap, they won't even recognize it. Hence, they need a second opinion.

My advice is be friendly and pleasant to both of them and keep in mind the "friend" will be looking for any flags or warning signs of a douche. This is pretty standard PUA stuff; win over the friend and you win the girl. It's even better if the friend is a guy.

good luck

The girl may be bi, hence the friend. Happened to me once.


Yeah, I am an old grouch.
 
We could probably put this in Dungeons and Dragons terms:

Go forth and meet the gatekeeper. Choose your spells and your party wisely. If ye vanquish** or covert the gatekeeper a fair damsel will ripen to your admiring advances. Be forewarned, for the gatekeeper is subtle and resistant to crude charms, and she has the ability to transform the most heroic knight into a drooling idiot with nary a word. May a glorious victory be yours brave adventurer!

** Vanquish should not imply any actual violence against a human women. Speaking like this to any human woman while not playing an tabletop RPG, MMORPG, engaged in cosplay, or at the Medieval Times will pretty much preclude you from having consensual non-paid sex for the rest of your life.
 
It's clear from your post that you are very inxperienced with woman. She has excess baggage, and my advice is to let this one go and find another. She aslo sounds like she would make you work hard in a relationship. Next time, you should give your date a goodnight kiss on the lips (with no tounge action), instead of a hug. This is a potential girlfriend, not your mom.

No chocolates, flowers or gifts on a 2nd or third date. Save that for AFTER you've had sex with her.

I'm guessing this post will be filed in the category of ignore. FFS, unless we've lived in a bell jar we all have baggage. I'm not sure anything she said indicates excess baggage. Mind you with the handle of punter and a random selection of your past posts should give GL an idea what makes you tick/twitch. Most of the other advice is in line with go for gently.
 
I'm guessing this post will be filed in the category of ignore. FFS, unless we've lived in a bell jar we all have baggage. I'm not sure anything she said indicates excess baggage. Mind you with the handle of punter and a random selection of your past posts should give GL an idea what makes you tick/twitch. Most of the other advice is in line with go for gently.
If he's smart, and I know he is, (because he never TOFTT, preferring to always ask for reviews before diving in himself), He'll file my post for future use and ignore yours.