Is Obesity a modern problem??

You have a theory and you are sticking to it.

The facts are that industrial food is very high in fat, sugar and salt, which are the three things humans crave. Countless thousands of chemists toil away in laboratories trying to find new ways of combining these three ingredients with something else to create a new food item.

You are ignoring the fact that europeans are much less obese than americans. That is NOT because they are poorer, so your theory does not explain that.

You are also mislabeling the effect of poverty on obesity. We are not here concerned with the 1%ers, but with the middle class and the poor. The poorest live more on industrial food than on real food than the middle class people. Your theory does not explain that either.
I am well aware of how industrial scientists create 'foods' that trigger desire and suppress satiety signals. But a whole nation cannot claim to be be helpless victims of a few clever guys in lab coats. Those industries are part of the economy that gave them the disposable income to buy more fats, sugars and salts than any nation before them. Until realtively recently Europeans depended on a very tightly knit food production and distribution network that efficiently delivered high quality fresh food to consumers who shopped often. We americans quickly replace our versions of that with car-dependent suburbs and supermarkets that the world envied. Then copied as soon as they could. Increasing prosperity has since put American-style refrigeration in most European homes, and put supermarkets selling manufactured 'food' engineered to last longer into every neighbourhood. Along with the KFC, and Golden Arches and Pizza Huts. And they're making money because Europeans are learning how to eat like Americans, though entrenched locavores and heritage-proud chefs are fighting as they retreat. And they are getting fatter.

The iron laws of statistics say we're a fat nation (Disclaimer: I've never worn pants with a waist bigger than 32) because the foods we choose make us fat. Rich folks get to choose what they eat, the poor do not. Obesity is not a disease of poverty, it's a disease of prosperity.

The real question is what we do to curb its prevalence and get more people making healthy choices instead of just pleasing their taste-buds. Your recognition of the huge industrial 'food' enterprises and how heavily invested they are in having as many people as possible eat as much as they can of the cheapest 'food' they can manufacture, ship, and leave on store shelves without fear of it ever spoiling, points to where any social action will find its heaviest resistance.

If poor Americans couldn't afford to eat as much fat, sugar and salt as they wanted, they might notice they were poor—except when compared to all the truly poor foreigners they've never cared about anyway—and try to do something about that. Historically that sort of social consciousness has always been very troublesome.

Going back to the OP's general question: Ther have always been obese people, but they were few because you had to be rich to get fat. If they died early likely rejoiced in secret, but early or not, they went with all the best care and comfort, and still likely lived better and longer than their slimmer tenant farmers eating root veggies and kale. You tell me if that obesity was a problem; it certainly was just as much a cause of diabetes, heart attacks and all that.

What we face now is the price of everyone being able to piut as much fat, sugar and salt on the table as only the rich could just a few generation ago. It's the number of obese folks, the statistical reality of the epidemic of fat-caused ills and treatment difficulties that is the modern problem. We have all become too rich for our own good. You can say it's the 'fault' of the corporations relentlessly lowering the prices and increasing the ease of consumption of the foods we call rich. But when I see antique sugar safes where the precious stuff used to be kept under lock and key, and the key tied on her ladyship' waist, and I see ordinary folk of today flinging it around in mock battles, i say we're all rich now.
 
Wow... the world must truly be coming to an end... I find myself in agreement with Blackrock for once!

I do not believe you for a second.. how could you not notice what someone ahead of you was putting on the conveyor at the register when they are right in front of you??? Are you looking up at the ceiling the whole time you are in the store???

Seeing what is in someone's cart is far from peeping... Even subconsciously you notice what people are buying.. it is impossible for you not to.

You are living in denial.

That's what I was going to say. I mean it's out in the freakin' open, how can you not notice? I've often looked at items on the conveyor belt ahead of me and thought, hmmmm I'll have to try that next time.
 
That's what I was going to say. I mean it's out in the freakin' open, how can you not notice? I've often looked at items on the conveyor belt ahead of me and thought, hmmmm I'll have to try that next time.

Ever looked in the fridge or shopping cart of a family of fat folk? Genes play a role in a few cases but it's not the main reason.

^^^ Please re-read the above. ^^^

That is not at all what Blackrock said. Not even close to what he said. He said he looks into the cart, not in line on the conveyor. He said at first looking into a persons fridge as well. This is not something that I do and that is what I was shocked about and commenting on. There is a big difference between glancing at some food on a conveyor in front of you and purposely checking out what is directly in people's carts which is precisely what Blackrock was speaking about.


Now again, don't really care who believes me or not, but I do not a} go into other people's fridges checking out their food and b} I do not go walking up and down aisles looking into people's carts while doing my shopping. It is not my thing.

Now if Blackrock would like to amend his posts and now express conveyor belts into the mix, that would again be a different situation. He is free to do that and if I feel I want to, I will comment on that specifically. Right now I am addressing the specific posts of looking INTO carts and fridges as originally stated.

Hopefully that at least helps clarify.
 
^^^ Please re-read the above. ^^^

That is not at all what Blackrock said. Not even close to what he said. He said he looks into the cart, not in line on the conveyor. He said at first looking into a persons fridge as well. This is not something that I do and that is what I was shocked about and commenting on. There is a big difference between glancing at some food on a conveyor in front of you and purposely checking out what is directly in people's carts which is precisely what Blackrock was speaking about.


Now again, don't really care who believes me or not, but I do not a} go into other people's fridges checking out their food and b} I do not go walking up and down aisles looking into people's carts while doing my shopping. It is not my thing.

Now if Blackrock would like to amend his posts and now express conveyor belts into the mix, that would again be a different situation. He is free to do that and if I feel I want to, I will comment on that specifically. Right now I am addressing the specific posts of looking INTO carts and fridges as originally stated.

Hopefully that at least helps clarify.


So you've never seen inside someone fridge? No one has ever opened their fridge in your presence? Exploring fridges is not my bag, but this observation ahas been made by a many nutritionist and i'm just passing it on. Grocery store line ups are ore public and no less informative. As far as the conveyor belt/shopping cart cart debate, nice side step. I really didn't think I'd need to dumbing it down for others and include all possibilities. It should have been quite clear to most, but apparently I was wrong.

Maybe we should have mention trunks of cars when the people are loading their cars to leave.
 
So you've never seen inside someone fridge? No one has ever opened their fridge in your presence? Exploring fridges is not my bag, but this observation ahas been made by a many nutritionist and i'm just passing it on. Grocery store line ups are ore public and no less informative. As far as the conveyor belt/shopping cart cart debate, nice side step. I really didn't think I'd need to dumbing it down for others and include all possibilities. It should have been quite clear to most, but apparently I was wrong.

Maybe we should have mention trunks of cars when the people are loading their cars to leave.

At least you can admit it. You gave the impression of one thing and now have side stepped yourself. Trying to deflect that on to me is simply not going to work. Either say what you mean or back up what you say.

Also no, I don't go into people's fridges. I have gone into a family members fridge OF COURSE, but not into a non-family members fridge, no. I have not. I am sorry if this is a shocking concept for you to understand, but it is what it is. I think again that is something that is rude. As a guest in someone's home, I don't just "help" myself to their fridge and often if they have opened said fridge in front of me, I am again, not purposely looking in said fridge to judge what the person is eating. Most times, I am busy engaging in conversation with said person and that would happen to be my focus at the time. Not what kind of quick peek I can get.

I don't know why this is such a big issue. I know the many reasons that people in general are obese. Seems like common sense to me. Eat more then you burn off. Be that junk food, pop, over processed food, whatever. I don't need a personal confirmation. You have stated that you directly and purposefully look directly into their cart. That is you. This is me. You do it. I don't.


EOD :rolleyes:
 
i love visiting chubbers. i have no cookies at home and they always have the best. i pig out!
 
At least you can admit it. You gave the impression of one thing and now have side stepped yourself. Trying to deflect that on to me is simply not going to work. Either say what you mean or back up what you say.

Also no, I don't go into people's fridges. I have gone into a family members fridge OF COURSE, but not into a non-family members fridge, no. I have not. I am sorry if this is a shocking concept for you to understand, but it is what it is. I think again that is something that is rude. As a guest in someone's home, I don't just "help" myself to their fridge and often if they have opened said fridge in front of me, I am again, not purposely looking in said fridge to judge what the person is eating. Most times, I am busy engaging in conversation with said person and that would happen to be my focus at the time. Not what kind of quick peek I can get.

I don't know why this is such a big issue. I know the many reasons that people in general are obese. I don't need a personal confirmation. You have stated that you directly and purposefully look directly into their cart. That is you. This is me. You do it. I don't.

No ones asking you to rummage through fridges uninvited, gee. I guess you aren't asked to cook in others home either or get a beer during intermission. Let the hired help do it. What I claim is that i've looked in others cart while waiting for check out not stared, explored, rummaged and dissected the contents, just observed. The subtleness of the difference obviously escapes you.
 
No ones asking you to rummage through fridges uninvited, gee. I guess you aren't asked to cook in others home either or get a beer during intermission. Let the hired help do it. What I claim is that i've looked in others cart while waiting for check out not stared, explored, rummaged and dissected the contents, just observed. The subtleness of the difference obviously escapes you.

I have never been asked to cook in someone's else home. I have been asked to bring something for a pot luck thing or if I want to cook for them then I invite them to my house. My brother does the Sunday football games and has a separate fridge for just drinks. Like WFT is with hired help comment? Throwing out more lame ass pompous insults because why? I simply don't do the same thing you do. Really? Are you also implying that because I don't cook at other people's homes, I some how have no purpose for being there? How about simply visiting a person, having a conversation....????

You never said anything about the check out line and kept fighting the issue. Going as far as saying I have blinders on because I don't do what you do as well. Is it not okay that others simply do not act the same way as you, or is everyone suppose to be a blackrock copycat???? You look in carts, or fridges or conveyor belts when convenient for your own personally reasons. Okay great! Clarified for the class. It is still not my thing. That is me. You are free to do what you want. I am not stopping you. Why would you have such a problem that I simply do not do that???
 

I have never been asked to cook in someone's else home. I have been asked to bring something for a pot luck thing or if I want to cook for them then I invite them to my house. My brother does the Sunday football games and has a separate fridge for just drinks. Like WFT is with hired help comment? Throwing out more lame ass pompous insults because why? I simply don't do the same thing you do. Really? Are you also implying that because I don't cook at other people's homes, I some how have no purpose for being there? How about simply visiting a person, having a conversation....????

You never said anything about the check out line and kept fighting the issue. Going as far as saying I have blinders on because I don't do what you do as well. Is it not okay that others simply do not act the same way as you, or is everyone suppose to be a blackrock copycat???? You look in carts, or fridges or conveyor belts when convenient for your own personally reasons. Okay great! Clarified for the class. It is still not my thing. That is me. You are free to do what you want. I am not stopping you. Why would you have such a problem that I simply do not do that???

One could infer that your cooking skills aren't up to scratch, if no one has ever asked yo to do the work or even help. I wouldn't say that, but someone might. I'm not a chef, but it happens a few times a year. I guess you and I hang in different circles.
 
One could infer that your cooking skills aren't up to scratch, if no one has ever asked yo to do the work or even help. I wouldn't say that, but someone might. I'm not a chef, but it happens a few times a year. I guess you and I hang in different circles.

Wow - okay so in total from you, 1. I visit people with no purpose, 2. have blinders on to society and its obesity problem and 3. possibly can't cook according your tongue in cheek postings. All because I don't peep into people's food carts, fridges or conveyor belts at the check out line.

LOL, I am thankful that we hang out in different circles. I mean one can infer a lot of things about you as well, but alas I don't give enough of a shit about you. Have a great day.
 
Wow - okay so in total from you, 1. I visit people with no purpose, 2. have blinders on to society and its obesity problem and 3. possibly can't cook according your tongue in cheek postings. All because I don't peep into people's food carts, fridges or conveyor belts at the check out line.

LOL, I am thankful that we hang out in different circles. I mean one can infer a lot of things about you as well, but alas I don't give enough of a shit about you. Have a great day.

Nope , but now we have some idea of the problem.
 
Wow - okay so in total from you, 1. I visit people with no purpose, 2. have blinders on to society and its obesity problem and 3. possibly can't cook according your tongue in cheek postings. All because I don't peep into people's food carts, fridges or conveyor belts at the check out line.

LOL, I am thankful that we hang out in different circles. I mean one can infer a lot of things about you as well, but alas I don't give enough of a shit about you. Have a great day.

LMAO - Whatever blackrock. You go boy! Whatever bullshit you need to come up with to help you feel better about your life. All the power to ya. LMAO!

Thought you were done, apparently not.
 
Thought you were done, apparently not.

I wished you a good day. I thought maybe, by some remote possibility that you would be a mature enough adult to move on and accept that not all people are like you and that does mean it is a bad thing. People are different. That is the reality to life. Clearly that is not possible for you. You came back with more BS.

However, I never said I was done with the thread. If I was done posting in thread I would have said, "I am done posting in this thread" Instead I did politely try to move past this little bullshit game you seem to be wanting to have and thought the well wish of having a nice day may have done that. That is all that was.

Yet you seem so eager to continue, so I can go post for you post with you. I really don't care. Or maybe you can put your big boy pants on, be a man and just accept that not everyone is like you and that is okay. Probably not, but there is always room for a little hope.

Personally I don't get why it is such a big deal to you. Care to explain that while you continue to ramble away about completely and utter bullshit? Like why are so emo woman right now because I don't peep into people's cart??? Is it really all that important? Is it some life and death thing? What is the big issue? I think it is kinda funny how involved you are in this but that is me personally. LMAO!
 
Wow - okay so in total from you, 1. I visit people with no purpose, 2. have blinders on to society and its obesity problem and 3. possibly can't cook according your tongue in cheek postings. All because I don't peep into people's food carts, fridges or conveyor belts at the check out line.

LOL, I am thankful that we hang out in different circles. I mean one can infer a lot of things about you as well, but alas I don't give enough of a shit about you. Have a great day.

I wished you a good day. I thought maybe, by some remote possibility that you would be a mature enough adult to move on and accept that not all people are like you and that does mean it is a bad thing. People are different. That is the reality to life. Clearly that is not possible for you. You came back with more BS.

However, I never said I was done with the thread. If I was done posting in thread I would have said, "I am done posting in this thread" Instead I did politely try to move past this little bullshit game you seem to be wanting to have and thought the well wish of having a nice day may have done that. That is all that was.

If you want to continue, I can go post for you post with you. I really don't care. Or maybe you can put your big boy pants on, be a man and just accept that not everyone is like you and that is okay. Probably not, but there is always room for a little hope.

Usually when most people say 'have a great day', it's a way of biding adieu. Apparently not in your circle. From your various post with others, you also don't appear to care about much on this BB.
 
Usually when most people say 'have a great day', it's a way of biding adieu. Apparently not in your circle. From your various post with others, you also don't appear to care about much on this BB.


And you do? Why do you care so much Blackrock?

Sorry but this is not my life. I post, I leave, and it is done. I come back an hour, a week, 2 months later and post again. It ain't that big a deal for me. If it is a big deal for you, again, that is fine. We are allowed to be different people with different opinions and different cares and concerns. It really is okay. The world is not going to end. Truly, I promise you. It is okay that we are different.

Did you know that we pee differently too and that is also okay? :rolleyes: LMAO
 
Wow - okay so in total from you, 1. I visit people with no purpose, 2. have blinders on to society and its obesity problem and 3. possibly can't cook according your tongue in cheek postings. All because I don't peep into people's food carts, fridges or conveyor belts at the check out line.

LOL, I am thankful that we hang out in different circles. I mean one can infer a lot of things about you as well, but alas I don't give enough of a shit about you. Have a great day.



And you do? Why do you care so much Blackrock?

Sorry but this is not my life. I post, I leave, and it is done. I come back an hour, a week, 2 months later and post again. It ain't that big a deal for me. If it is a big deal for you, again, that is fine. We are allowed to be different people with different opinions and different cares and concerns. It really is okay. The world is not going to end. Truly, I promise you. It is okay that we are different.

Did you know that we pee differently too and that is also okay? :rolleyes: LMAO

I don't believe most who say they don't care what they post, unless of course they don't care about whatever comes out of their mouth either. Make life simpler for others, stfu and stay on bed. I do care about what I post, but it's not a big deal, as I won't toss and turn in bed tonight because of what i posted, but i do believe in what i post, just as I believe in what i say in conversations with others.

As for our pissing differently, well it all depends how you measure it. We can both pee sitting or standing and can use our hands or not to varying degree and affect on what comes out of single hole. Not really studied it much but that's the basics, I've picked up by observing.
 
I don't believe most who say they don't care what they post, unless of course they don't care about whatever comes out of their mouth either. Make life simpler for others, stfu and stay on bed. I do care about what I post, but it's not a big deal, as I won't toss and turn in bed tonight because of what i posted, but i do believe in what i post, just as I believe in what i say in conversations with others.

As for our pissing differently, well it all depends how you measure it. We can both pee sitting or standing and can use our hands or not to varying degree and affect on what comes out of single hole. Not really studied it much but that's the basics, I've picked up by observing.

I am sorry. I am a strong enough person to know that the idle ramblings of a person on an internet board are not really worth me getting upset by. Especially when it is nothing more then false lame ass attempts at some sort of insult because said posters got his little panties in a bunch. I have no problem with people being different and actually accept that as a reality. Another one of our differences, I know. Sorry. Oh and quess what - you don't have to believe me. My existence, shockingly enough, does not require you too.

NOw - you can't accept that people are different for whatever reason. That is fine. Really and truly that is okay. I personally really don't care that you can't. It does not affect my emotional or physically well being and health. It does allow for some entertainment but nothing I can't live without should you decide to move it along. It will certainly not make me loose sleep either. However I don't know if I truly believe that for you. Which again is okay. You can live without me believe you or your BS. I think that if this board was one day gone, you would be lost. You would have no idea what to do. You have no way of coping with things. I am sure you would end up finding some other board to post on, so I guess as long as we don't go through some sort of total world wide internet/power shut down/WW3/apocalypse type thing, you will be okay for the remainder of your life. So not to worry. I am all good and you will be too. Ya You!

PS - Now and just so that you don't get things all twisted and confused again, I will be wishing you a good night. That is not to say, imply, direct, or dedicate me to refraining from further post in this thread. Just that it is now my dinner time, and I will be logging off temporary. Now when I come back to this thread, I don't quite know for sure yet, but please do not mistake my well wish of you enjoying the rest of your evening as some sort of official and permanent goodbye. I would hate to see you further confused.

Have a great evening, Mr. Blackrock13.

Thanks :D