Is Obesity a modern problem??

The point is that picture was taken in 1921. What the heck did she eat to get that fat?

No clue... I wasn't born until the 60's.

But I do know that "look" is way more prevalent today than it was in the 20's!
 
Um actually no I haven't. It really is not my thing. I honestly didn't even know it was a thing. Why would you want to look into someone else's cart anyway? Like what is the purpose?

It doesn't have to be 'a thing'. It's just called not walking through life with blinders on or some might call it situation awareness. Maybe it's a left over action from my formative years in the late 60's and early 70's in Montreal.
 
Before WW2, most people starved. Heck, starvation was a weapon in WW2 (i.e. Leningrad).

When you found food, you pigged out. Because you'd be starving again.

After WW2,

no more food scarcity problem
+ technology which makes walking/climbing/lifting unnecessary (sedentary jobs)
+ centuries old instinct to pig out
+ modern day stress
 
Too much sugar. Sugar use to be worth more than gold by weight. i t was a sign of wealth for someone to have sugar in the table. People use to work 60-70 hours a week, walked almost everywhere. Most people today couldn't work a regular work week of times past. Most people died of disease and malnutrition, not often overwork.
 
Not my fault

and for many it has become an addiction...

Always the easy way out !!!

"I'm addicted to killing myself, and to wasting funds of health care that could be spent on people that really need it."

Have some will power,...people.

FAST
 
You think the 'poor' consuming excess calories three time and more a day aren't a sign of their society's vast and wasted wealth? They may be living on ChocoPuffs, CheezWiz and HungryMan salisbury Steaks but what sans-culottes or Indian peasant farmer or working-class family of the '30s, '40s, or '50s ever had that many calories to waste on their waistline.

It used to be that being prosperously large, like JP Morgan or Cecil Rhodes was something only a few could afford, but today in North America even the bottom-rung folks can buy and eat more sugar than is good for them. How is that not rich?

What you're pointing out is another historical; truism, that the rich always buy the best health and do whatever they can to distinguish themselves from those not of their class. So if every factorygirl's got a studio tan, rich people discover the horrors of melanoma, and bring back the parasols they abandoned when only they could afford to play outside, and peasant-farmers went to work in factories. And the truly rich of our day all try to look like athletes (indoor-type), because the 'poor' of our day whose lifestyle kings of the past would envy are looking fat.

If you're prosperous, and almost all Americans are very prosperous by any world or historical standard, then eating and staying thin and healthy takes effort, and thoughtful choices.

It always did.

You have a theory and you are sticking to it.

The facts are that industrial food is very high in fat, sugar and salt, which are the three things humans crave. Countless thousands of chemists toil away in laboratories trying to find new ways of combining these three ingredients with something else to create a new food item.

You are ignoring the fact that europeans are much less obese than americans. That is NOT because they are poorer, so your theory does not explain that.

You are also mislabeling the effect of poverty on obesity. We are not here concerned with the 1%ers, but with the middle class and the poor. The poorest live more on industrial food than on real food than the middle class people. Your theory does not explain that either.
 
It doesn't have to be 'a thing'. It's just called not walking through life with blinders on or some might call it situation awareness. Maybe it's a left over action from my formative years in the late 60's and early 70's in Montreal.

WTF are you talking about? Blinders? Blinders to what? What business is it of mine what another person puts in their shopping cart?

And because I don't play peeping tom into said person's cart, I am now somehow not socially aware of some society based issues?

Give me a break. Do you even read what you write? :rolleyes:
 
to me, this is the simplest thing to understand. u eat too much, you gain weight. if you're a physical worker (like on a farm or a roofer), you get strong. if you're not, you get fat. if u eat less, you lose. everybody knows this but it's in bad taste to blame a fattie for being fat. so we say it's genetics. or an addiction. or mcdonalds makes tasty food so they can't help themselves. choices. that's what it's all about.
 
Always the easy way out !!!

"I'm addicted to killing myself, and to wasting funds of health care that could be spent on people that really need it."

Have some will power,...people.

FAST

That should go for all addictions, smokers , drinkers , drug addicts. There is a reason its called addiction, people get hooked. Do you think people just sit there and let themselves become diabetics, high blood pressure, crack heads, alcoholics that drive repetitively intoxicated? I'm not excusing it and the only thing that I'm addicted to is pussy. :D

Its not an easy thing to stop addictions, quitting smoking was very hard. Some people can't help themselves, need external help. Its a simple but complicated issue. Everyone that has quit an addiction understands this.

People like to talk about the West but India has now become the capital of the world for diabetes. (from food of course)
People will do anything to feel good.

Why is sugar so addictive http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/0/21835302
 
If it hasn't been said already, lack of exercise.

A lot of sitting in front of the computer, TV or game console etc for hours at a time.

I grew up on McDonalds but I also stayed active all year round.
 
WTF are you talking about? Blinders? Blinders to what? What business is it of mine what another person puts in their shopping cart?

And because I don't play peeping tom to into said person's cart, I am now somehow not not scoially aware of some of society based issues?

Give me a break. Do you even read what you write? :rolleyes:

Blinders to what's going on around you, not a hard concept for most to understand. I'm not saying looking into people food carts my save your life but just paying attention to what is around you might or even more importantly someone around you. It's all a matter of degree. You remind me a bit of the three monkeys, see no, hear no and hear no.


I understand you are are a successful photographer, so you aren't a total eremite (that's for DM).
 
Blinders to what's going on around you, not a hard concept for most to understand. I'm not saying looking into people food carts my save your life but just paying attention to what is around you might or even more importantly someone around you. It's all a matter of degree. You remind me a bit of the three monkeys, see no, hear no and hear no.


I understand you are are a successful photographer, so you aren't a total eremite (that's for DM).


I don't need to look into people's carts to know what is going on around me in the world. :rolleyes:

Now let's call it what it really is shall we?? You want to be noisy and judgmental and a peer into people's carts, so go ahead but call it was it is. I will refrain as I was brought up with manners.

However carry on...... Thanks
 
Ever looked in the fridge or shopping cart of a family of fat folk? Genes play a role in a few cases but it's not the main reason.

In the fridge no, never thought of doing that. lol But, I do look at the food obese people put in their carts and yes, there's a reason they're obese. Pop, chips, pasta, sugary cereals, junk, junk, junk. Just like the overweight people I know, they're always snacking on chips, eating pizza, have desert with lunch and dinner.

Here's one for you, next time you go to a fast food joint, walk along and check out the size of the people lined up in the drive-thru lane. More often than not they're overweight.

I don't need to look into people's carts to know what is going on around me in the world. :rolleyes:

Now let's call it what it really is shall we?? You want to be noisy and judgmental and a peer into people's carts, so go ahead but call it was it is. I will refrain as I was brought up with manners.

However carry on...... Thanks

It has nothing to do with being nosy FF, it's merely an observation. Basically proving my point that overweight people make poor food choices. Take a deep breath and you'll feel better.

Now, must look in my overweight friend's fridge tonight. :D
 
It has nothing to do with being nosy FF, it's merely an observation. Basically proving my point that overweight people make poor food choices. Take a deep breath and you'll feel better.

Now, must look in my overweight friend's fridge tonight. :D

I disagree. I don't think people need to be looking in some strangers cart. We all know the different reasons why people are obese. Some is medical, most is diet and lifestyle. There is no need to purposefully go around being noisy and peeping in cart in my opinion. It was never something that even crossed my mind do before it was mentioned today. Let alone to purposefully look in someone's fridge and judge what they eat. I think it is noisy, rude and for some people an excuse to be overly judgmental. To some, not you, such types of behaviour like this used to big up their own ego at the expense of others. You don't need proof that poor food choices lead to being over weight. It is something that is already factually proven.

And to be told that because I don't choose to "merely observe" what complete strangers eat, I am somehow walking around with blinders on to the plague that is obesity is not only absurd but coming for blackrock it is also a lame jab at trying to be insulting. Something I don't just sit back and take.
 
In the fridge no, never thought of doing that. lol But, I do look at the food obese people put in their carts and yes, there's a reason they're obese. Pop, chips, pasta, sugary cereals, junk, junk, junk. Just like the overweight people I know, they're always snacking on chips, eating pizza, have desert with lunch and dinner.

Here's one for you, next time you go to a fast food joint, walk along and check out the size of the people lined up in the drive-thru lane. More often than not they're overweight.



It has nothing to do with being nosy FF, it's merely an observation. Basically proving my point that overweight people make poor food choices. Take a deep breath and you'll feel better.

Now, must look in my overweight friend's fridge tonight. :D

I actually haven't gone rummaging through someone fridge, but where do you think a lot of the food goes, besides down the gullet and in the cupboard.
 
I disagree. I don't think people need to be looking in some strangers cart. We all know the different reasons why people are obese. Some is medical, most is diet and lifestyle. There is no need to purposefully go around being noisy and peeping in cart in my opinion. It was never something that even crossed my mind do before it was mentioned today. Let alone to purposefully look in someone's fridge and judge what they eat. I think it is noisy, rude and for some people an excuse to be overly judgmental. To some, not you, such types of behaviour like this used to big up their own ego at the expense of others. You don't need proof that poor food choices lead to being over weight. It is something that is already factually proven.

And to be told that because I don't choose to "merely observe" what complete strangers eat, I am somehow walking around with blinders on to the plague that is obesity is not only absurd but coming for blackrock it is also a lame jab at trying to be insulting. Something I don't just sit back and take.

You really do come across as having thin skin FF. I truly don't believe you've never looked at a food cart next to you in the line up. i also suspect GB feels the same way, we'll agree to disagree.
 
You really do come across as having thin skin FF. I truly don't believe you've never looked at a food cart next to you in the line up. i also suspect GB feels the same way, we'll agree to disagree.

I don't care if you believe me or not. I am not a noisy busy body that way. Now I may strike up conversation with the people in line because I am friendly like that, but no I have never looked into someone's cart, checking out the food they buy. Like I said, it is not my "thing" and something that never even entered my mind before today.

Enjoy though. Peep and judge all you want. All the power to ya!
 
Food is being used as an anti-depressant, just like cigarettes and alcohol. This is why cigarette smokers gain weight when they quit.

Unlike drugs, junk food is cheap, fully legal, widely available at any age, and heavily encouraged by the media. Hard to go out anywhere, without encountering restaurants and unhealthy food at every corner.

Generally, the rich have less stress and a more enlightened life. They have less reason to gorge on food in an effort to make their problems go away (they have less misery to begin with).