Is Carey Price

Plante, Dryden and Roy are all HOF goalies. I think Price will make the HOF as well.

Bear in mind that Plante had Harvey and Johnson in front of him. Dryden had 5 HOF defensemen in front of him although Laperriere and Langway for only 4 and 1 year respectively. Bill Nyrop was not HOF but a solid defensive defenseman.

Two other post expansion Montreal goalies in the HOF are Rogatien Vachon and Gump Worsley. (Bunny Laroque was backup to Dryden for 5 of Dryden's 8 years.)
Carey Price is a lock for the HOF...standards for Montreal Canadien players are different than the rest of the NHL.

Just Kidding, Price deserves the honour on his own merit.
 
It is SOP (standard operating procedure) for that other poster. He had no clue we were comparing Price to other great Montreal goalies like Roy, Dryden and Plante. Orr and Gretzky are not goalies and never played for Montreal.
Talk about someone being clueless.

The concept, which you do not seem to grasp, stays the same regardless if we talk about goalies or skaters. If Dryden was overrated because of some other great teammates, then the same can be said of other players who also had great teammates.

Feel free to explain why Gretzky's assist totals were not enhanced to some degree by passing to great goal scorers like Kurri, Anderson, Coffey and Messier.
 
Last edited:
Carey Price is a lock for the HOF...standards for Montreal Canadien players are different than the rest of the NHL.

Just Kidding, Price deserves the honour on his own merit.
Do you think any goalie has ever or will ever in the future play behind 5 future HOF defensemen? (Just noticed that Plante had Bouchard for 4 years.) Patrick Roy's first Stanley Cup had two future HOF defensemen (Chelios and Robinson).

Would Andersen be a better goalie if he had 5 future HOF defensemen playing in front of him? The only current Leaf defenseman that might be HOF material is Rielly.

BTW: Brian Engblom's career also overlap Dryden's career for 3 years. HOF Chris Chelios arrived after Dryden had already retired.
 
Last edited:
Do you think any goalie has ever or will ever in the future play behind 5 future HOF defensemen?

BTW: Brian Engblom's career also overlap Dryden's career for 3 years. Chris Chelios arrived after Dryden had already retired.
Jacques Laperriere is border line HOF and Langway didn’t become HOF material until he came to Washington.

But to answer your question, probably not.
 
Jacques Laperriere is border line HOF and Langway didn’t become HOF material until he came to Washington.

But to answer your question, probably not.
It probably didn't happen but can you imagine if all 5 were ever on the team at the same time. I think the Canadiens managed to have 4 at the same time at least once (1978-79).
"1978-79 Montreal Canadiens Roster and Statistics | Hockey-Reference.com (hockey-reference.com)"


"Langway was drafted by the Montreal Canadiens of the NHL in 1977 and by the Birmingham Bulls of the WHA in the same year. He played one season for the Bulls (1977–78) before joining the Canadiens for the 1978–79 NHL season, and would win the Stanley Cup that year. He played for Montreal until he was traded to the Washington Capitals for the start of the 1982–83 season. The Capitals acquired Langway from the Canadiens in a blockbuster trade—going with Doug Jarvis, Craig Laughlin, and Brian Engblom in exchange for Ryan Walter..............."

10 members of that 1978-79 team are currently in the HOF.
 
Last edited:
Talk about someone being clueless.

The concept, which you do not seem to grasp, stays the same regardless if we talk about goalies or skaters. If Dryden was overrated because of some other great teammates, then the same can be said of other players who also had great teammates.

Feel free to explain why Gretzky's assist totals were not enhanced to some degree by passing to great goal scorers like Kurri, Anderson, Coffey and Messier.

I think Bernie Nicholls might argue that their goal totals were enhanced to some degree by playing with Gretzky
 
A reasonable question this season might be:
Is Carey Price the best goaltender on the Montreal Canadiens roster today?
 
A reasonable question this season might be:
Is Carey Price the best goaltender on the Montreal Canadiens roster today?

Another reasonable question is

Has Price‘s legacy surpassed that of Steve Shutt’s?
 
  • Like
Reactions: gcostanza
A reasonable question this season might be:
Is Carey Price the best goaltender on the Montreal Canadiens roster today?
Fun with figures:

Among NHL goaltenders who have played 10+ games this season:
Carey Price 40th in save percentage
23rd in goals against average
He has 5 years remaining on his contract at an average annual value (cap hit) of $10,500,000.
Mr. Price has a full no trade/no movement clause in his deal.
His contract is virtually buyout proof.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fun For All
Fun with figures:

Among NHL goaltenders who have played 10+ games this season:
Carey Price 40th in save percentage
23rd in goals against average
He has 5 years remaining on his contract at an average annual value (cap hit) of $10,500,000.
Mr. Price has a full no trade/no movement clause in his deal.
His contract is virtually buyout proof.
It's the Montreal "system". He understands it.