Is CAA Membership Worth It?

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
I received an offer to join the CAA for $10 off the first year and waiver of the $12 enrollment fee. So it would be $54 for the first year and $64 each year after that (on a basic membership).

Seems like a pretty good deal. One tow, battery charge, or unlocking of the doors will pay for it.

Thoughts?

http://www.caasco.com/membership-savings/member-benefits/
 
Nope.
Because when you really need them they are too busy to help.
You'll need them for a tow in a snowstorm and because everybody else needs help too they'll tell you it'll take 6 hours.
IMHO, CAA is a scam.
 
I think it is worth it.

I joined a year ago, about a week before Easter, was driving across the province to see family, had a flat tire, they arrived, had it changed within 40 minutes, it was about midnight, in pouring rain.

The membership paid for itself there (I have a premium membership, it's about $95 or $105 for the year, but they'll tow you a much longer distance, and you get more free services).
 
CAA is peace of mind. one call every 2 years and it's probably worth it. (IMO)
I just recently had an oxygen sensor short & engine stalled on a vehicle with 300,000 K on it, towed it to the repair shop , waited no more than 30 minutes for them to arrive. Back in the summer I left a door open & killed the battery, within 30 minutes boosted me & off I went.
HAd CAA for decades, infact I was a member when it was called OML (Ontario Motor League) . MY now Ex and I traveled a lot through ought Canada & US, it was piece of mind. $70 per year on the grand scheme of things isn't a whole lot of money
 
100% worth it

Just yesterday morning, my car wouldn't turn over. I knew i was in need of a new battery so I called CAA. I wondered if it was just the new battery, or possibly something else. I am a plus member which gets me 4 roadside assistance visits per year, which include a tow up to 200km per tow, a battery jump, battery replacement (with me paying only the cost of the new battery), change of tire etc.
The guy that came sold me a good battery for $100, which i see advertised elsewhere for $150, and changed it on the spot. Car still wouldn't start, so I got it towed all the way across toronto, to my favourite garage. This counted as one visit! So I got a battery for $50 cheaper than I could have bought it at crappy tire, he put it in for free (would have been $40 labour and an hour at crappy tire), then when my car still wouldn't start, he called for a tow truck. The truck came within 15 mins, and towed me from downtown to north york. The tow would have cost me $150-$200, the battery change $40, and I would have paid $50 for the battery, had i not been a CAA member
 
Not to mention discounts on hotels. I recently traveled to the States, and they accepted CAA at the comfort inn. I saved about ten bucks...

Plus, there are a host of other benefits... For example, you earn much more petro points when you link it to your CAA account. This can earn you many points, and if you buy enough gas, you can even pay for your CAA membership.
 
Nope.
Because when you really need them they are too busy to help.
You'll need them for a tow in a snowstorm and because everybody else needs help too they'll tell you it'll take 6 hours.
IMHO, CAA is a scam.

They'll tell you if they're too busy you can call any towing company and they will reimburse you in full. Also your card can be used on towing another's vehicle as long as your a passenger.
 
I have both the Premium membership and the RV add-on. I would not travel without it. Its more than paid for itself over the years.
 
Definitely worth it! I have a CAA Plus membership. Got towed from Erie Penn., by AAA and then transferred to CAA at the border to my mechanic in Flamborough, cost me $50 for the extra mileage. I get 3 tows a year I believe. Plus all the other stuff, gas delivery, locked keys in vehicle etc.
 
Absolutely. Only once did I have to wait a long time during a snow storm but it was with my date inside her warm home, heh heh.

You can also use it for a friend's car that you're with.
 
Nope.
Because when you really need them they are too busy to help.
You'll need them for a tow in a snowstorm and because everybody else needs help too they'll tell you it'll take 6 hours.
IMHO, CAA is a scam.

If you need a tow because of weather you shouldn't have gone out in the first place, and CAA can't help you with that, nor all the other people who made the same mistake except one-by-one. And the other tow services will be the same.
 
Just yesterday morning, my car wouldn't turn over. I knew i was in need of a new battery so I called CAA. I wondered if it was just the new battery, or possibly something else. I am a plus member which gets me 4 roadside assistance visits per year, which include a tow up to 200km per tow, a battery jump, battery replacement (with me paying only the cost of the new battery), change of tire etc.
The guy that came sold me a good battery for $100, which i see advertised elsewhere for $150, and changed it on the spot. Car still wouldn't start, so I got it towed all the way across toronto, to my favourite garage. This counted as one visit! So I got a battery for $50 cheaper than I could have bought it at crappy tire, he put it in for free (would have been $40 labour and an hour at crappy tire), then when my car still wouldn't start, he called for a tow truck. The truck came within 15 mins, and towed me from downtown to north york. The tow would have cost me $150-$200, the battery change $40, and I would have paid $50 for the battery, had i not been a CAA member

Why would you pay for someone to install a battery? disconnect and unfasten the old one, put the new one in and fasten, then connect the cables?

I have the membership...good for emergencies, however, when I did have a flat I just changed it myself (didn't want to wait for the response time).
 
Been a member for years. It's worth it. (It was great when you could use your card at Sunoco and it would take money off your renewals - one year I paid about 10 bucks for my CAA Premium Renewal. Sadly, those days (and Sunoco) are gone.)

When I used to drive GM (POS), that Buick was on the hook more times than I could count. I believe you are entitled to 5 free tows. I think it was 2002 I used every one of my free tows because my stupid Buick was so terribly unreliable and kept breaking down.

Even now with my current car (not a GM product!) I still maintain my CAA membership.
 
Been a member for years. It's worth it. (It was great when you could use your card at Sunoco and it would take money off your renewals - one year I paid about 10 bucks for my CAA Premium Renewal. Sadly, those days (and Sunoco) are gone.)

Most Sunoco's are now Husky, and they take the CAA card.
 
Been a member for 20+ years, and always buy the premium membership so I can get towed further, to the garage of my choice. They have helped me in some very unlucky situations (the Audi wasn't all that reliable in its final years), towed me at least 3 times, tested a battery and proved it to be the alternator (in the middle of the night, on the side of the road), unlocked me once. I find the agents and drivers go out of their way to be helpful. Worth it? Depends......you may never need them. But one tow pays for a year or two's membership. I'd go for it mon ami.