The hardware doesn't matter as much as the software, and iOS is in my opinion par excellence. Jelly Bean doesn't even come close in terms of user-interface intuitiveness (to say nothing of older Android versions), and there is a clear difference of culture in the respective app ecosystems.
iOS apps generally tend to be of better quality on average, and the App Store fares much better against malware than the Android Market. AFAIK, there has been only one instance of malware making its way into the App Store, and that was a proof-of-concept made by a security researcher that was quickly revoked by the App Store custodians. The Android Market, on the other hand,
still has issues with malware.
iOS software updates also aren't held hostage by North American carriers, unlike all but 3 Android models (namely, the Nexus line).
That said, I do wish the iPhone's screen were bigger. Rumours suggest that this might happen with the next model, which should be out by early October.