Impaired driving

More data:

Your odds of being solely to blame for an accident resulting in serious injury is strongly correlated with BAC, beginning with BAC .01 and rising linearly with BAC:

http://freakonomics.com/media/injury_prevention_blame_paper.pdf

So at even 0.01 BAC drivers are significantly more likely to cause an accident.

Conclusion: a rational person would want to be as near as possible to 0.00 BAC before driving. If you have a drink with friends after work stick to one drink and hang around for an hour or so afterwards before driving.
 
More data:

Your odds of being solely to blame for an accident resulting in serious injury is strongly correlated with BAC, beginning with BAC .01 and rising linearly with BAC:

http://freakonomics.com/media/injury_prevention_blame_paper.pdf

So at even 0.01 BAC drivers are significantly more likely to cause an accident.

Conclusion: a rational person would want to be as near as possible to 0.00 BAC before driving. If you have a drink with friends after work stick to one drink and hang around for an hour or so afterwards before driving.

That is only the conclusion of a child. The fact is, even if you accept those figures and say at 0.08% BAC that a person is 5x more likely to cause a fatal accident, and alarmist like you will think OMG!!! That is like walking around with a freaking hand grenade with no pin!! But the fact is, vehicle fatality rates in the USA are about 1..08 per 100 million miles driven. So if you drive around at 0.08% BAC your likelihood of a fatal accident is increased to 1.08 per 20 million miles. So based on the study the 0.01 BAC allegedly double the risk to 1.08 per 50 million miles. So you say that is enough to stop you from driving with ANY alcohol in your body. But driving at night increases the risk by a factor of 3 so are you now not gonna drive at night? You have the choice. As I said the risk is increased but not extreme to the point of a goddamn crisis. Even when people are approaching SHIT FACED the risk is 10 x or 1.08 every 10 million miles. At this point it is getting quite high but still not the horrendous carnage we hear of. So I guess no more night driving Fuji. Best to stay in bed fearing life. The fact is, taking a cab at night is just as risky as having a single drink and driving home in the day.
 
You've lost. You have conceded that even 0.01 BAC significantly increases the risk of fatalities and serious injuries. You have abandoned false claims above and been forced to admit that drunk drivers between .008 and .014 cause a very large share of the fatalities on the road.

Your claim about the night falls absolutely flat since day or night it's clearly drunks that are causing the crashes

You're done. You have no point left.

You have been reduced to the PATHETIC claim that a5x increase in fatalities is no big deal. Fuck that. If you put these statements into actions as I suspect you do, and drive around drunk on a regular basis, then you are a felon. You belong in prison, you have no respect for the lives of other people.
 
Ten percent of the driving population isn't driving around over the legal limit. If they were one person in ten at a ride stop would get arrested.

That is HUGE increase in fatalities.

You're assuming that those driving aren't being caught while doing so. Yesterday while with friends and watching a game on a patio, I noticed a couple of guys who were intoxitcated, got up and left to their cars after the game and then drove off.
 
You're assuming that those driving aren't being caught while doing so. Yesterday while with friends and watching a game on a patio, I noticed a couple of guys who were intoxitcated, got up and left to their cars after the game and then drove off.

If you saw them go to their cars, and cared, you could have called 911 and provided the make of car and license number.

I would
 
You're assuming that those driving aren't being caught while doing so. Yesterday while with friends and watching a game on a patio, I noticed a couple of guys who were intoxitcated, got up and left to their cars after the game and then drove off.

One in ten drivers on the road at any given time aren't drunk. Obviously. RIDE checks aren't arresting that many people. They stop hundreds of drivers and arrest one or two, can and these are checks that target places and times likely to have drunks . For example, the morning commute isn't often RIDE stopped yet the stats on drunk fatalities cover ALL driving.
 
You've lost. You have conceded that even 0.01 BAC significantly increases the risk of fatalities and serious injuries. You have abandoned false claims above and been forced to admit that drunk drivers between .008 and .014 cause a very large share of the fatalities on the road.

Your claim about the night falls absolutely flat since day or night it's clearly drunks that are causing the crashes

You're done. You have no point left.

You have been reduced to the PATHETIC claim that a5x increase in fatalities is no big deal. Fuck that. If you put these statements into actions as I suspect you do, and drive around drunk on a regular basis, then you are a felon. You belong in prison, you have no respect for the lives of other people.

No I haven't the fact is this is analysis of sole assigned blame. In many jurisdictions, blame is automatically assigned to those with positive BAC, and most definitely in cases where BAC is > 0.08. That is the legislative bias. Then there is the personal bias of the investigator that is going to assign blame based on positive BAC. The fact that a test is administered already indicates bias. On top of that an infinitesimal risk, doubled or quadrupled is still infinitesimal. You assume the same or greater risk by driving at night, or taking a cab at night. So based on your rationale no one should go out at night. You are right that impaired driving is a risk factor at night, but it is fatigue and night vision that are the main reasons for risk. If it were alcohol then the morning would be just as bad because so many people are still drunk.
 
The study showed sole blame is strongly correlated with BAC at every interval starting at 0.01.

The fact is that the link you yourself posted shows an increase in fatalities even below 0.08.

The fact is that between 0.08 and 0.14 the link you posted shows drunks are responsible for a horrific number of fatalities far, far beyond their numbers on the road.

You lose.
 
The study showed sole blame is strongly correlated with BAC at every interval starting at 0.01.

The fact is that the link you yourself posted shows an increase in fatalities even below 0.08.

The fact is that between 0.08 and 0.14 the link you posted shows drunks are responsible for a horrific number of fatalities far, far beyond their numbers on the road.

You lose.

I have never said drinking and driving has no risks associated with it. That is not the point. The point is, we are focusing on the wrong area of the problem. For reasons I mentioned the data cannot be trusted. So where the heart of the problem lies is still not clear. It is a better study then I have seen in the past, but for the reasons mentioned, the data gathering methodology cannot really be trusted. If the data was solid and did not have the bias factors I mentioned, then yes it would indicate a correlation. But that is not the case,
 
Now YOU OWN LINK cannot be trusted?

No point debating with you, you are determined to be wrong.

I am talking about the freakanomics link you posted, but yes I pointed out real problems with the link I posted as an example of why the current current data we are presented with cannot be trusted. Clearly your english skills are limited of you cannot understand moderately complex trains of thought.
 
I am talking about the freakanomics link you posted, but yes I pointed out real problems with the link I posted as an example of why the current current data we are presented with cannot be trusted. Clearly your english skills are limited of you cannot understand moderately complex trains of thought.

So far ALL the links refute you, most of all the one you yourself posted. On the one hand we have hard data clearly showing that drunks are causing a horrific number of deaths, grossly out of proportion with their numbers.

On the other hand we have a lot of bombast and hot air from you.

The study is more believable than you are, particularly since it dovetails with the data showing disproportionate death results from driving drunk even between 0.01 and 0.08.
 
No I haven't the fact is this is analysis of sole assigned blame. In many jurisdictions, blame is automatically assigned to those with positive BAC, and most definitely in cases where BAC is > 0.08. That is the legislative bias. Then there is the personal bias of the investigator that is going to assign blame based on positive BAC. The fact that a test is administered already indicates bias. On top of that an infinitesimal risk, doubled or quadrupled is still infinitesimal. You assume the same or greater risk by driving at night, or taking a cab at night. So based on your rationale no one should go out at night. You are right that impaired driving is a risk factor at night, but it is fatigue and night vision that are the main reasons for risk. If it were alcohol then the morning would be just as bad because so many people are still drunk.

0.08 has been set as the limit in the Criminal Code in Canada and the United States and has withstood appeals at Supreme and Superior court. It is one of the highest levels in the civilized world.

People with more money than you have furiously fought in court that .08 was an unreasonable level and lost their battles because of the amount of information provided by experts backing .08 as a justified level. Do you think the Supreme and Superior courts just willy nilly set those levels? Do you think those courts and the lower courts before them were not given a room full of data and listened to an army of experts that the accused hired to examine when making their decision?

Based on how badly you are trying to defend a higher BAC level, and belief that the lack of intent to drink and drive should absolve someone of criminal responsibility, I think it's quite clear to the readers here that you regularly drive impaired.
 
I believe there should be penalties at 0.08, but they should be lesser, but they should escalate with BAC reading. Over 0.15 and you go to jail, first time or not.

Of a certainly the penalties should be progressive.

The difficulty at 0.08 is what is the officer supposed to do? Fine you, then let you drive away? That's not going to happen.

I don't get drunk and drive, so I've never taken a good look at the laws. But what's the point of having a "warn" range (0.05 - 0.08) when you're actually suspending licenses in that range anyway?
 
So far ALL the links refute you, most of all the one you yourself posted. On the one hand we have hard data clearly showing that drunks are causing a horrific number of deaths, grossly out of proportion with their numbers.

On the other hand we have a lot of bombast and hot air from you.

The study is more believable than you are, particularly since it dovetails with the data showing disproportionate death results from driving drunk even between 0.01 and 0.08.

No they do not. My biggest issue is that the data and how it has gathered does not provide concrete support for the conclusions. You seem to hold on to some childlike assertion that I do not believe alcohol consumption affects driving, that is IDIOTIC. My issue is when does it affect driving, how much and where can legislation and enforcement provide the most beneficial impact while doing the least harm. To me criminalizing someone for first time 0.08 DUI is not supported by the evidence. The manner in which the data is gathered makes it essentially useless. Non of the links you have provided have addressed that. All of them have a bias, and none of them even make a serious attempt to defend the integrity of their data.
 
Of a certainly the penalties should be progressive.

The difficulty at 0.08 is what is the officer supposed to do? Fine you, then let you drive away? That's not going to happen.

I don't get drunk and drive, so I've never taken a good look at the laws. But what's the point of having a "warn" range (0.05 - 0.08) when you're actually suspending licenses in that range anyway?

I have no problem with towing and 24 hour suspension. That is not a biggie. The issue I have is with criminal penalties when the data has satisfactorily supported many aspects of this. I would even be ok with criminal penalties for repeat serious DUIs but criminalization causes too much destruction which is unwarranted for first time offenders.
 
Of a certainly the penalties should be progressive.

The difficulty at 0.08 is what is the officer supposed to do? Fine you, then let you drive away? That's not going to happen.

I don't get drunk and drive, so I've never taken a good look at the laws. But what's the point of having a "warn" range (0.05 - 0.08) when you're actually suspending licenses in that range anyway?

In the warn range you don't get a criminal record.
 
I have no problem with towing and 24 hour suspension. That is not a biggie. The issue I have is with criminal penalties when the data has satisfactorily supported many aspects of this. I would even be ok with criminal penalties for repeat serious DUIs but criminalization causes too much destruction which is unwarranted for first time offenders.

The data clearly does show that people driving with BAC over .008 are a serious problem and have caused a horrific number of deaths and serious injuries.

The open question is really whether .008 is way too high considering the data also shows drivers below that are causing problems as well.

It seems we should begin criminal penalties at 0.05, and infractions (points/fines) as low as 0.01 really.
 
The data clearly does show that people driving with BAC over .008 are a serious problem and have caused a horrific number of deaths and serious injuries.

The open question is really whether .008 is way too high considering the data also shows drivers below that are causing problems as well.

It seems we should begin criminal penalties at 0.05, and infractions (points/fines) as low as 0.01 really.

People with 0.00 also cause a serious number of deaths and horrific accidents. Until you clear up the data integrity it is difficult to understand the extent of the problem. Since there are laws that always place blame on the drunk driver, the data is useless. If you don't understand why that is then you really don't understand the logic of the study. They do not address how they deal with this bias so essentially the whole thing is crap. The question is, when are you gonna stop driving at night since according to your prized study it would be the equivalent of driving with about 0.04 BAC
 
So now you want a private business to help regulate the law over their patrons? What if they don't? You going to introduce even more legislation to hold them accountable? Who is going to pay for these breathalyzer machines? You know that people can take a taxi, walk or call a friend if they have more than 2 drinks? Why should the bar limit their profits and incur costs of buying and maintaining a machine when there are at least 3 alternatives available? If they don't blow into the machine, who is going to stop them from leaving?

I'm the one with my head in the sand? You are the one that hasn't done your research. An administrative driving prohibition is NOT a criminal offense. You do not get a criminal record that will prevent you from crossing the border. It's a PROVINCIAL act.

Administrative driving prohibitions have reduced deaths by over 50%. They have also been upheld as constitutional since this article. I'd say that is pretty effective legislation.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...es-spared-bc-government-says/article17069711/

In post 60, you said I was spreading disinformation by posting government supplied statistics, implying they were inflated. Now you're saying there's carnage on the roads?

You need to do more research on the law. Not having the intention to do something (i.e. drinking and driving) does not absolve you of being criminally responsible. That's why there are Criminal Code charges of Unlawful Act and Criminal Negligence to cover off crimes other than drinking and driving. It's all on the internet and free.

Private businesses already do that. They are not supposed to serve intoxicated people. In the scope of operating a bar, you think the cost of the machine is really that significant? Walking is not always possible, calling a taxi..well not everyone has the cash and they won't take drunk people quite often, and call a friend? I guess not everyone has friends that are as tolerant as you. I will be happy to call you when I have drinks and cannot drive, just PM me your number. I don't oppose some of the programs BC has in place, and I would like to see how they gathered their stats. Its very easy to fudge the numbers to claim victory. If you ask me the REAL reason why BC highway fatalites have dropped so much is the redevelopment of the highway infrastructure for the Olympics. I understand intent is not necessary for a crime, but people should be give more tools as the current ones are clearly not enough. I don't see why you would be so against drunk driving and yet be so opposed to giving people another tool to verify their status before driving.?? But any law that allows police to hand out suspensions of 90 days without judicial review is not acceptable to me. Too many moronic cops out there to be trusted. 24 hour sure. But 90 days has serious consequences and should only be handed out after people are offered a right to trial.