Immigrants and learning English

...
When I use my VOIP voicemail I have to choose English or Spanish. ...

In that case and many others, it's driven by the free market. It would be only government documents where I would be concerned with waste (and I'm sure that in most cases they are more worried about their message getting through than the extra printing cost).
 
The real question is, why are we letting immigrants in the country that don't have a moderate to deep grasp of either of our two official languages?

I know I posted this already but except for refugees we don't. All other immigrants are required to show proficiency in French of English.

And I'm okay with letting a reasonable number of refugees in rather than letting them die in a war zone. I find it a waste when they choose not to make use of ESL classes but I also see it as a waste when Canadian born youth don't take advantage of the education system.
 
Ahhh yes. The good old days of William Lyon Mackenzie King, where Hitler be-damned, Juden refugees should go back to Europe.

I have to ask... Why should “passing ESL” be mandatory?

I’m sure there are tons of people who don’t want to talk to you. If they “can’t” talk to you, why would it matter to you?

[Countdown to “They’re only here for welfare...” zingers.]

Passing ESL = demonstrating proficiency. Why? Because you are planning to live, work, and vote in this country.

If you work as a CSR, you would be required to speak to your customer. I've worked in jobs where performance is measured and time spent with a customer is measured. That time increases the moment there is a communications barrier. I am pretty good in understanding what people are trying to say and most accents are comprehensible. But if a person says up when they mean down, that interaction will last long.

In the grand scheme of things, these are silly things to get peeved about. They are the definition of first world problems IMO.

1) As a business owner, you are getting paid to deal with customers with poor language skills.
2) If you are the customer, you can always take your business elsewhere if you're unhappy.
3) If they are ahead of you in line and it causes a delay, it's a minor inconvenience at best
4) It's not your problem to solve if someone cannot maintain a job because of poor language skills.

At the end of the day, you have no control over how other people conduct themselves. Complaining about them will not change immigration policy nor does it enrich your life. It basically amounts to a bunch of old angry white men that have nothing else better to complain about. Take that frustration and better your own situation rather than shit on someone else.

Silly perhaps but it's generally the reasons people would get peeved. Other than these, would you ever be interacting with these people?

1) I don't think anyone is ever paid to deal with anything except in some circumstances. In most cases, that just ends up being a sad fact or "comes with the territory" - similar to an SP not being paid to deal with bad breath but sometimes it's part of the job.
2) True but not always possible. If you are renting and the landlord wants to use his repair person, an individual who cannot communicate with you, it's very frustrating.
3) Situationally dependent. I know doctors who say their patient wait times increase as a result of poor communication skills with patients. My Service Ontario experience is an example. Perhaps in some cases it's fairly minor so no one really cares but there are a few times where your wait time is significantly increased.
4) It is if you are related to them in some way and have to support them.

I have been in school projects with people who took ESL but their communication was extremely poor. It was difficult to work with them, they couldn't contribute as much (meaning you have to pick up the slack) and their work required a once-over to correct the grammar. In some cases they were extremely smart and patience was definitely rewarded with some bright ideas originating from them but things were much more difficult than they perhaps should have been.

To me it comes down to attitude and effort. My grandparents were in their 50's and picked up the language. My parents were teens when they came here and picked up the language. But I know others who arrived in similar circumstances and the communication is terrible because they chose to avoid communicating with others and trying to learn the language. They relied on their native tongue and translators.

Again, it's mostly a situation of it being their problem. My list is simply a minor grievance. They have only made life more difficult for themselves.
 
Passing ESL = demonstrating proficiency. Why? Because you are planning to live, work, and vote in this country.

If you work as a CSR, you would be required to speak to your customer. I've worked in jobs where performance is measured and time spent with a customer is measured. That time increases the moment there is a communications barrier. I am pretty good in understanding what people are trying to say and most accents are comprehensible. But if a person says up when they mean down, that interaction will last long.

Voting is a right, not an obligation. Living in this country doesn’t mean you’re necessarily going to work here. Plenty of Nona’s that I knew growing up barely left the house and did just fine. Not all jobs require English.

On a personal level, knowing a little or even better a lo of the local language makes MY life easier and usually better.

But FORCING a language on someone new to Canada, particularly a refugee?

Wow.
 
Voting is a right, not an obligation. Living in this country doesn’t mean you’re necessarily going to work here. Plenty of Nona’s that I knew growing up barely left the house and did just fine. Not all jobs require English.

On a personal level, knowing a little or even better a lo of the local language makes MY life easier and usually better.

But FORCING a language on someone new to Canada, particularly a refugee?

Wow.

Voting is a right and a privilege. A voter though also has the responsibility to be informed and it's not easy to be informed if you can't understand what's going on because the debates, news stories, and discussions are taking place in a language you cannot comprehend.

And I have provided a list - a Nona wouldn't be an issue as she's not doing anything on that list.

And yes, everybody should learn the language, including refugees. We take them in, we provide the tools to succeed, and they eventually are expected to contribute to society just like every other citizen and not be a continuous burden to taxpayers.
 
Voting is a right and a privilege. A voter though also has the responsibility to be informed and it's not easy to be informed if you can't understand what's going on because the debates, news stories, and discussions are taking place in a language you cannot comprehend.

And I have provided a list - a Nona wouldn't be an issue as she's not doing anything on that list.

And yes, everybody should learn the language, including refugees. We take them in, we provide the tools to succeed, and they eventually are expected to contribute to society just like every other citizen and not be a continuous burden to taxpayers.

Sempel, you’re entire experience with immigrants in this country seems based on working with ELL’s at probably York or somewhere shittier.

21% of Canadians didn’t bother voting last election. Voting isn’t a requirement in this country. It seems like you want to change that, to justify your piss-poor example of why it’s necessary for a REFUGEE to be granted citizenship.

I’m not reading your lists. I’m sure your lists are just as good as your massages, but like your massages, you’d have to pay me first.

But let’s talk about this list which exempts Nona’s, but not refugees... WHY?

People can contribute to a country without being able to speak the language. I’m currently contributing in a country where I don’t speak the language.

How are “they” a continuous burden to taxpayers?

You were less odious when this was just a place for you to try to meet the future Mrs. Sempel.
 
In fact applicants for immigration must show functionality in either English or French. I believe the only exception are refugee claimants who are supposed to be judged on how dangerous it is for them in their homeland.
.

I doubt that's true, either immigration is doing a bad job or your story is not true. I Meet constantly people that are not refugees and don't speak english, just go to an asian supermarket....
 
Passing ESL = demonstrating proficiency. Why? Because you are planning to live, work, and vote in this country.

If you work as a CSR, you would be required to speak to your customer. I've worked in jobs where performance is measured and time spent with a customer is measured. That time increases the moment there is a communications barrier. I am pretty good in understanding what people are trying to say and most accents are comprehensible. But if a person says up when they mean down, that interaction will last long.

Silly perhaps but it's generally the reasons people would get peeved. Other than these, would you ever be interacting with these people?

1) I don't think anyone is ever paid to deal with anything except in some circumstances. In most cases, that just ends up being a sad fact or "comes with the territory" - similar to an SP not being paid to deal with bad breath but sometimes it's part of the job.
2) True but not always possible. If you are renting and the landlord wants to use his repair person, an individual who cannot communicate with you, it's very frustrating.
3) Situationally dependent. I know doctors who say their patient wait times increase as a result of poor communication skills with patients. My Service Ontario experience is an example. Perhaps in some cases it's fairly minor so no one really cares but there are a few times where your wait time is significantly increased.
4) It is if you are related to them in some way and have to support them.

I have been in school projects with people who took ESL but their communication was extremely poor. It was difficult to work with them, they couldn't contribute as much (meaning you have to pick up the slack) and their work required a once-over to correct the grammar. In some cases they were extremely smart and patience was definitely rewarded with some bright ideas originating from them but things were much more difficult than they perhaps should have been.

To me it comes down to attitude and effort. My grandparents were in their 50's and picked up the language. My parents were teens when they came here and picked up the language. But I know others who arrived in similar circumstances and the communication is terrible because they chose to avoid communicating with others and trying to learn the language. They relied on their native tongue and translators.

Again, it's mostly a situation of it being their problem. My list is simply a minor grievance. They have only made life more difficult for themselves.

1) In my business owner example, the job is servicing your customers no matter how difficult it is to communicate with them. No sane business owner would tell a customer that they need to learn more English. I am sure it happens, but the uproar will be instantaneous. So that does "come with the territory" as you said with being a business owner.

2) I'm not sure what tenant and landlord rights are when it comes to repairs i.e. can the tenant pick their own repair person? If a tenant can pick their own then there should not be a communication issue.

3) I do agree that patient wait times can come from poor communication skills. I would think that problem can be reduced by recognizing medical credentials from other countries to attract more doctors from certain ethnic groups.

4) If you are a blood relative, then the wise thing to do would be to work them to build their English skills. That could be as simple as immersing them in the culture: only speaking English at home, watching English only TV and movies, etc. Regardless of your support, the individual has to want to improve.

Who are we to say what is difficult or not for someone else? Assuming they want to increase their social stature then it's up to them to take that initiative to improve their English skills. On the other hand, some people are perfectly fine with not climbing the social or corporate ladder and can get by without much English.
 
I watch a lot of movies and shows originating from other countries. Sometimes I read comments online from those asking others to translate into English. Some even get to the point of being rude. If you want to enjoy things from other countries, learn the language. I work for a company where the majority of people speak at least 1 or 2 different languages in addition to English. Unfortunately for many of you English only speaking individuals you would not qualify to obtain a very good paying job where I work. That is your choice to only be English speaking. Just like it is the choice of others to not get fully immersed into Canadian society. Yes, their choice, not yours. And many of them are probably less of a drain on Canada than those who are only English speaking. Get over yourselves.
 
1) In my business owner example, the job is servicing your customers no matter how difficult it is to communicate with them. No sane business owner would tell a customer that they need to learn more English. I am sure it happens, but the uproar will be instantaneous. So that does "come with the territory" as you said with being a business owner.

2) I'm not sure what tenant and landlord rights are when it comes to repairs i.e. can the tenant pick their own repair person? If a tenant can pick their own then there should not be a communication issue.

3) I do agree that patient wait times can come from poor communication skills. I would think that problem can be reduced by recognizing medical credentials from other countries to attract more doctors from certain ethnic groups.

4) If you are a blood relative, then the wise thing to do would be to work them to build their English skills. That could be as simple as immersing them in the culture: only speaking English at home, watching English only TV and movies, etc. Regardless of your support, the individual has to want to improve.

Who are we to say what is difficult or not for someone else? Assuming they want to increase their social stature then it's up to them to take that initiative to improve their English skills. On the other hand, some people are perfectly fine with not climbing the social or corporate ladder and can get by without much English.

OK...

At the end of the day, this isn't even a blip on my radar - it isn't a major issue for me. I'm just highlighting why some get frustrated (e.g. number 4 is a relative's in laws - they complain about it all the time. At this point no real solution).
 
Ahhh yes. The good old days of William Lyon Mackenzie King, where Hitler be-damned, Juden refugees should go back to Europe.

I have to ask... Why should “passing ESL” be mandatory?

I’m sure there are tons of people who don’t want to talk to you. If they “can’t” talk to you, why would it matter to you?

[Countdown to “They’re only here for welfare...” zingers.]

Pretty critical for citizens to be able to read/speak a native language if they wish to function properly as a citizen. Being able to socialize is only one aspect. Being able to interpret our laws, customs, rules, etc., is another. Without knowing the native language, it's also next to impossible to be an effective worker in any job that requires communication.

And why shouldn't welfare be mentioned? If they can't be effective citizens because of the language barrier, chances are they'll be on welfare.
 
Pretty critical for citizens to be able to read/speak a native language if they wish to function properly as a citizen. Being able to socialize is only one aspect. Being able to interpret our laws, customs, rules, etc., is another. Without knowing the native language, it's also next to impossible to be an effective worker in any job that requires communication.

And why shouldn't welfare be mentioned? If they can't be effective citizens because of the language barrier, chances are they'll be on welfare.

How many Canadian born or native English speakers actually know how to interpret our laws, customs, rules, etc.? What exactly is an "effective" citizen? If an immigrant comes from a major city, then they would already know most if not all of our "Canadian" customs. Canada is not so unique that people would have difficulty grasping those rules, laws or customs.

It's up to the employer to determine if a worker is effective or not at their job be it language, technical, people, etc skills. So it's their job (not yours) to give them an action plan or terminate them.

I suppose that a language barrier could be a reason people might be stuck on welfare, but we don't know for sure. I don't think we even keep data about that issue.