If Microsoft Does Buy Yahoo!, What Then?

jwmorrice

Gentleman by Profession
Jun 30, 2003
7,133
2
0
In the laboratory.
This article from the NYTimes makes one wonder about the wisdom of Microsoft's bid for Yahoo!

jwm

February 18, 2008
Of All the Hurdles to a Merger, View on Technology Is the Highest
By JOHN MARKOFF and MATT RICHTEL

SAN FRANCISCO —
If Microsoft succeeds in its conquest of Yahoo, what then?

Microsoft would face the task of integrating the culture of Yahoo into its own. Merging corporate cultures is generally a major undertaking in any acquisition. What would set this integration apart, though, is where the culture clash is likely to occur — in the two companies’ basic philosophies on technology.

Yahoo, based in Sunnyvale, Calif., in the Silicon Valley, is a generation younger than Microsoft, based in Redmond, Wash., but it is no longer a freewheeling start-up. With almost 14,000 employees, Yahoo still has rock concerts and Ultimate Frisbee tournaments on its campus. But both Yahoo and Microsoft, with well over 84,000 employees spread around the world, are bureaucratic and rife with fiefdoms.

So any cultural conflict may not be over the way the two sides dress, eat or play. It probably will not even be about those bureaucracies.

A smooth integration also will not be a matter of simply swapping one set of software or hardware for another — though that is a daunting part of the task. It may hinge on changing deep-seated mindsets.

When it comes to technology, Microsoft and Yahoo “are completely at odds with one another,” said Rob Solomon, chief executive of SideStep, a travel-related search engine. He was a Yahoo executive in charge of shopping, auctions, travel and real estate before leaving the company in 2006.

Microsoft must figure out how to integrate the two complex and almost entirely incompatible software systems that the companies use to run their vast Internet data centers.

The companies have raced to build those data centers in what has been a futile effort to catch Google. Microsoft’s data centers run on proprietary software that is incompatible with the open-source programs and applications adopted by Yahoo. (Neither company discloses how many data centers it has or how big they are.)

Such integration challenges have in the past hampered other big technology mergers. Sprint and Nextel, for example, have struggled to combine forces after their merger three years ago.

Several investors and technologists said that because of the risks involved, Microsoft might decide to keep the Yahoo services largely separate, or sell off parts that overlapped.

“Yahoo is just too big to switch over,” said Brady Forrest, who holds the title of “technical evangelist” for O’Reilly Media, a publisher of books and other media that focus on technology.

Mr. Forrest was part of MongoMusic.com, a small music start-up acquired by Microsoft in 2000. At that time, Mr. Forrest said, programmers spent the better part of a year rewriting MongoMusic’s technology infrastructure to make it compatible with that of Microsoft. “It was painful,” he said.

Yahoo’s size may force Microsoft to take an unprecedented step and allow Yahoo to continue to operate its own infrastructure. For instance, the two companies have a large customer base for their free e-mail services that combined could be as large as 500 million accounts.

Disrupting that service or forcing customers to change Internet messaging or e-mail addresses would alienate customers and decimate that base. But failing to find synergies could reduce some of the $1 billion in cost savings that Microsoft has said would result from the merger.

Skeptics of Microsoft’s ability to eventually digest Yahoo’s infrastructure point to the initial embarrassing failure that occurred when Microsoft tried to absorb the Hotmail electronic mail service it acquired in 1997.

At the time the service ran on the open-source FreeBSD and Sun Solaris versions of the Unix operating system. Microsoft tried to move the service to its Windows NT operating system, but that was unsuccessful.

Later it was able to move it to a more advanced version of its Windows Server software, but was still chagrined when open-source advocates found that FreeBSD was still being used for portions of the service that required performance and stability. Microsoft acknowledged that Hotmail’s transition took 3 ½ years, but some analysts say they think it took even longer. While Microsoft has built its Web services largely using its proprietary tools like the .Net programming system, Yahoo has a well-known open-source culture.

Yahoo principally uses FreeBSD, which is well regarded for its stability and its strong security.

Yahoo also uses the Java programming language as well as the PHP scripting language, which is widely accepted as a tool for rapidly building and maintaining the dynamic Web pages that are at the heart of its many Web services. Indeed, the creator of the PHP language, Rasmus Lerdorf, is an infrastructure architecture engineer at Yahoo.

Finally, Yahoo relies heavily on a parallel programming tool that will take a program that is written for one computer and extend it to run on hundreds. This allows Yahoo to scale up the power of a search engine algorithm, for example. (The program was invented at Google, but Yahoo uses an open-source version called Hadoop.) Microsoft uses its own competing system, developed in its research labs, called Dryad.

Microsoft and Yahoo have drastically opposite philosophies on open-source software. While Microsoft has used some open-source code, it has generally not contributed technology to the open-source community. In contrast, Yahoo has been an extensive contributor and has built its internal computing platform almost entirely from open source.

Another potential conflict is the companies’ approach to the industry organizations that set protocols that all companies can use in order to speed the adoption of a technology. Yahoo has generally not participated, instead establishing its own standards. Microsoft has been an active participant, although its critics charge that it has tried to subvert the standards process to its competitive advantage.

Despite these differences, both companies share a heritage of software engineering, said a Yahoo technologist, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the company had not authorized him to speak publicly.

“I was trying to think about how different the two firms are as engineering and marketing companies,” he said. “I really don’t think at the operating level the companies are that different when it gets right down to it.”

Inside Yahoo there are roughly three camps of employees, in terms of attitudes about the takeover, he said. One group, which he estimated was 5 percent to 10 percent of the employees, would not work for Microsoft under any circumstances.

A second group, he said, was taking a wait-and-see attitude and generally thought, “I wouldn’t apply to work at Microsoft, but I won’t resist.” The final group believes that Microsoft could significantly aid Yahoo with access to well-financed research labs, a higher stock price and the willingness to invest over longer time periods.

His own attitude is one of wait and see. “It depends on what they are willing to agree to in terms of not interfering,” he said.

Ellen Siminoff, a former Yahoo executive who is now chairwoman of a search engine marketing firm called Efficient Frontier, said she believed that Yahoo employees would be more likely to stay and embrace the takeover if it were blessed by Yahoo’s well-loved founders: Jerry Yang, the chief executive, and David Filo, who is one of the company’s key technologists.

“If I were Microsoft and I could find a way to get Jerry and Filo to be supportive, that would make a big difference.”

She added, “When a country is invaded, people don’t necessarily think they want to embrace the conqueror. There will be some element of resistance.”
 
Here's another nice article, from the NYTimes, on the folly of Microsoft's pursuit of Yahoo. I'm glad I no longer own MS shares.

jwm

February 24, 2008
Digital Domain
Maybe Microsoft Should Stalk Different Prey
By RANDALL STROSS


OVER the years, Microsoft has pummeled countless rivals, including the superheavyweight I.B.M. But it has never faced a smaller foe as formidable as Google. The tale of the tape gives Microsoft a $100 billion advantage in market capitalization, but it counts for little: Google appears to be its superior in strength, speed, smarts.

Having exhausted its best ideas on how to deal with Google, Microsoft is now working its way down the list to dubious ones — like pursuing a hostile bid for Yahoo. Michael A. Cusumano, who has written several books about the software industry and about Microsoft, is not impressed with Microsoft’s rationale for its Yahoo offer. He said the bid seemed to be a pursuit of “an old-style Internet asset, in decline, and at a premium.”

Determined to match Google in search and online advertising, Microsoft has managed to overlook a plain-vanilla strategy, the oldest one in the book: build on its own strengths. What it does best is to sell software to corporations, for all sorts of applications, visible and not so visible, at a handsome profit.

If Microsoft thinks this is the right time to try a major acquisition on a scale it has never tried before, it should not pursue Yahoo. Rather, it should acquire another major player in business software, merging Microsoft’s strength with that of another. This is more likely to produce a happier outcome than yoking two ailing businesses, Yahoo’s and its own online offerings, and hoping for a miracle.

For an illustration of how Microsoft could select targets more judiciously, Mr. Cusumano, who is a professor at the Sloan School of Management at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, pointed to the Oracle Corporation’s strategic acquisitions and its prudent use of capital to “roll up firms with similar products and customers to its own.” With impressive regularity — 13 strategic acquisitions in 2005, another 13 in 2006 and 11 in 2007 — Oracle has picked up key products and customers while avoiding an “oops” slip, venturing too far away from its core business, or paying too much. At no point along the way has it acted in a fit of desperation.

Last month, Oracle pulled in another major prize, BEA Systems, a leading software company, for about $8.5 billion. You’ve probably never heard of BEA: it’s doubly obscure, producing the behind-the-scenes infrastructure that large companies use to build behind-the-scenes software systems for their entire business, or “enterprise software.” Both Oracle and BEA are based in Silicon Valley, but their side of the street is not lit by klieg lights and does not get the same attention as the Googles and Yahoos.

And, to be honest, it’s not much fun hanging out on the enterprise side of the software business. BEA says its software helps organizations “ensure that business processes are optimally defined, managed, executed and monitored.” Unless you’re playing Business Jargon Bingo, it’s hard to sit still and remain attentive. You have to admire Oracle’s ability to remain focused on the business that serves business and to not be distracted by the buzz of the Web crowd gathered across the street.

Microsoft does business software well. Approximately half its revenue comes from business customers for its e-mail infrastructure, database systems, developer tools, Office productivity applications and other mainstays. It has also assembled, through acquisitions, a fledgling line of enterprise software that it calls Microsoft Dynamics. Microsoft would like Dynamics to be viewed as competing head to head with the No. 2 name in enterprise software, Oracle, or the No. 1, SAP of Germany. For the moment, however, Microsoft Dynamics’ parity with those big names is nothing more than wishful aspiration.

Professor Cusumano has a suggestion: Rather than acquire Yahoo, Microsoft should pursue SAP.

It’s not an outlandish idea. The two companies held merger talks in late 2003, and perhaps since then, too. Microsoft is in an enviable position: it is a nearly universal presence in corporate data centers, and large enterprise customers are arguably the best customers a software company can have. Clients pay very dear prices for the complex, semicustomized software that runs their business. And once they’ve got their systems running — a process that can take years to complete — they aren’t inclined to change vendors lightly.

A few dozen well-paying Fortune 500 customers may actually be more valuable than tens of millions of Web e-mail “customers” who pay nothing for the service and whose attention is not highly valued by online advertisers.

Today, SAP’s market capitalization is about $59 billion, and a sizable premium to get a deal done would send its price well north of that. Microsoft cannot put both SAP and Yahoo in its shopping cart, deals that together might run well over $120 billion. Microsoft must pick one or the other.

Suppose that Lawrence J. Ellison, the chief executive of Oracle, were the head of Microsoft and was doing the shopping. Which deal would he choose? Past experience suggests that it would not be Yahoo. That acquisition would bring little but duplication headaches — and no large enterprise customers.

It’s amusing to note that the most Larry-like choice, Microsoft’s acquiring of SAP and leaving it alone as an autonomous division to avoid a cross-cultural integration fiasco, is the course that would be most discomfiting to Oracle. Frank Scavo, president of Computer Economics, an information technology research firm, in Irvine, Calif., said that “a Microsoft-SAP combination would be Oracle’s worst nightmare.”

Google would not be happy with a conjoined Microsoft and SAP, either. It has made a pro forma expression of its own opposition to a Microsoft-Yahoo merger, but we can speculate that it may be cheering that deal on. Working in Google’s favor are the hostile nature of Microsoft’s bid, the colossal potential for integration problems, and organizational paralysis in, and exodus of talent from, Yahoo.

But were Microsoft to turn and head in SAP’s direction, Google would have reason for concern. Whatever strengthens Microsoft is bound to influence, later if not sooner, its continuing competition with Google. For its own part, Google is keen to expand its foothold inside large companies. Last year, it acquired Postini, whose software filters corporate e-mail. Google has not done so well with corporate customers on its own, however. Google Apps has conspicuously failed to win adoption quickly.

If Microsoft is to rededicate its attention to its most valuable assets, business customers, a prerequisite is dropping its ill-advised bid for Yahoo. And to find the best acquisition strategy, ask, “What would Larry do?”

If Microsoft tries to fight Google with wobbly legs, scared witless, it will lose.

Randall Stross is an author based in Silicon Valley and a professor of business at San Jose State University. E-mail: stross@nytimes.com.
 
Yahoo has come under tight scrutiny over the last two years for its dealings in communist China. In particular, Jerry Yang, founder and CEO, underwent a blistering tongue lashing in Congress in 2007 when it was discovered that Yahoo had assisted the Chinese government collect evidence against journalist Shi Toa. Shi Toa had emailed information with his Yahoo email account to a New York based website, which communist China felt contained "state secrets". China demanded that Yahoo turn over the emailer's identity. Yahoo obliged.

Yahoo's Jerry Yang justified its actions by saying, ""To be doing business in China, or anywhere else in the world, we have to comply with local law."

Source: http://www.slyck.com/story1667_The_Pirate_Bay_Returns_to_Yahoo

There wouldn't appear to be a problem merging corporate philosophies between these two entities.
 
Microsoft + Yahoo?

= MicroHOO? :cool:
 
bobistheowl said:
China demanded that Yahoo turn over the emailer's identity. Yahoo obliged.

Yahoo's Jerry Yang justified its actions by saying, ""To be doing business in China, or anywhere else in the world, we have to comply with local law."

Source: http://www.slyck.com/story1667_The_Pirate_Bay_Returns_to_Yahoo



Money talks. Google's the same shit.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4645596.stm

I have never been a fan of Micro$oft, use their shit because I have to. The only thing I worry about, as a yahoo user is that, how much bigger a target Yahoo will become for hackers if it ever gets taken over by Bill and co.

I am sure yahoo isn't perfect but I really hate to see it getting ruined after the take over, if ever.
 
I'm hoping that either the MS bid for yahoo s just a one time thing, or that Yahoo can stand up to MS. Honestly, I like MS. They have done great things to make PC's a household item, but as with anything, there is a dark side. MS taking over yahoo would mean integrating Yahoo into the MS way of thinking ("we can do no wrong"), and that is what I object to. In any case, I use either Google or www.vivisimo.com for my searches. Yahoo is good for mail.