This thread is a clusterf*ck.
Beyond that, has it been determined with strong confidence that the wife doesn't have some long-ago concerns relating to HSV-1 which have HER presently feeling guilty over all of this?
I read pages 1 through 5, and 9 through 11, but skipped the middle.
The lack of understanding by so many here would be laughable were it not so serious.
Herpes tends to nest near either end of the spine, and if one variety is already there, it is less likely that the other variety can make a home on that end as well.
(which means almost nothing to persons involved in this arena - as there are so many exponential opportunities for HSV1 and HSV2 to criss-cross among people who typically have multiple partners)
70-80% of everyone already has HSV1... potentially including assman's wife... so in fact SHE could be blaming herSELF for this new discovery.
Where if she knew herself to be sparkling clean and disease-free, she may have initiated a divorce by now.
It is entirely realistic that any of us could get genital HSV from bare contact with a partner, and so much so that to blame any particular provider for having HSV1 orally (like 70-80% of everyone) is quite stupid.
Anyone anywhere in this hobby should expect their next partner to already have HSV1 at the very least. Once there, you're playing a miniature game of Russian Roulette in which someone every now and then will be the one in Assman's present shoes.
It would be nice, however, that all of us would have enough common decency to at least refrain from intimate activity while cold sores are present.
And if you got HSV1 during childhood, from your MOTHER, then congratulations, you are of a higher moral fabric than are all other affected persons on TERB.