Something that confuses me a little, that I haven't really seen addressed yet - if you have HSV-1 which apparently 90% of people already have, you shouldn't then be able to contract HSV-1 AGAIN - via someone else's mouth onto your genitals, right?
To clarify, other posts have already explained that if you have HSV-1 ie; cold sores, you can still get HSV-2 on your genitals via coitus. I get that. And I get that you can even get (first time you're infected) HSV-1 on your genitals, not necessarily HSV-2.
With that said, wouldn't a BBBJ infection as OP suggests be an HSV-1 infection not HSV-2, as it's coming from his partner's mouth and not the genitals? Assuming he is of the 90%, he shouldn't be able to contract HSV-1 twice just in a whole new area?
If he wasn't of the 90% then, yeah, it makes sense.
Apologies if I'm misunderstanding this whole thing. I might just be confusing myself.