HST, Native peoples, Caledonia, etc

Worf

Well-known member
Sep 26, 2001
1,890
28
48
In a house somewhere
To begin, let me quote a section of the Toronto Sun article of December 4:

The plan to harmonize federal and provincial sales tax brought traffic to a halt in downtown Toronto yesterday afternoon.

Members of the First Nations community, who stand to lose their point-of-sale provincial sales tax rebate under the proposal, repeatedly blocked cars on Queen's Park Circle.

Drivers honked with frustration at the protest, which occurred during rush hour.

Grand Council Chief Patrick Madahbee said First Nations are drawing a "line in the sand" over the proposed HST which he said will add 13% on the cost of most purchases.

Aboriginals are exempt from paying sales tax but are required to cover the GST at the cash register and then apply for a rebate.


I don’t like the HST. I don’t know who does (maybe the die hard liberals among us). Now, the 1st Nations organized a protest, and it seems that they are only ones who have done so significantly or successfully to date. I am an immigrant. The non-native Canadian peoples, who have been here for generations, seem to be content with what Dalton and Co. wants to dish out. However, am I the only one who find that the reason that the 1st Nations don’t want the tax, i.e. so that they will lose their exemption, totally and utterly ridiculous? Why are they not paying taxes like the rest of us? How is it that, after all these years and billions of dollars, they as a people are still in the state that they are in? They are living on vast swaths of land that are rich in minerals, resources, and so on. Yet they continue to live below the poverty line and in constant need of government handouts. Whether it is tax exemptions, federal grants, a full fledged federal ministry, and so on. And they are protesting the HST because they don’t want to lose their exemption? The ways things are going, they might just very well be the only group of people who will succeed in getting the right to not pay the HST. The provincial and federal governments seem to be powerless to do or say anything to them.

And Caledonia is ongoing. The current court case is another joke. Why does someone have to sue the government for not doing what they are supposed to, i.e., uphold the law. The law should apply equally. If you block the roads, and deny people their right to their homes, you should be arrested. If I did it, I certainly would be. But they do it without any repercussions. My personal belief is that the army should be called in. They should be given 1 day to move; otherwise all hell should break loose. But that will never happen. We as a society will continue to subsidize them, maintain separate laws for them, while all the while they will be demanding better treatment, more money, more of everything.

Well folks, that is my Friday night rant. Just had to get it off my chest. I would love somebody to explain why this form of subsidy is still going on. I realize that centuries of oppression might have something to do with it. Well, black people were oppressed for the longest while, and we have moved on. Slavery has officially ended. We now take responsibility for our actions. And if we don’t, we suffer the consequences. Maybe I just don’t understand.
 
There is a Caladonia couple right now taking the OPP ,Government etc to Court over the Caledonia fiasco. They live next to the Douglas Creek Estates development where the natives blocked access and chased the developers away on land they had purchased legaly. The Ontario Govt paid them something like 14 million bucks for. You drive by it and its just a flat piece of land with smoke shacks all around it.

There have been several skirmishes between Caledonia residents and natives with the OPP standing by and letting natives do what they want. This issue will be three years old in February.Neither Govt Fed or Prov. want to take responsability for it.

There is obvious a two tier justice system in Caladonia one for natives one for whites. Its time the Governments(both) stepped in and ended this fiasco.Its gone on long enough.What ever happened 2-300 years ago should have no bearing on today.

We used to burn people at the stake,woman had no vote etc. Life goes on. If the natives want to cry foul etc maybe the Catholic Church should sue the First Nations for the torture and murder of many Priests during the 1700's
 
"I don’t like the HST. I don’t know who does (maybe the die hard liberals among us). Now, the 1st Nations organized a protest, and it seems that they are only ones who have done so significantly or successfully to date ... Why are they not paying taxes like the rest of us?"

The question is why is anyone paying these taxes if no one likes them?

Hats off to the 1st Nations for protesting this shit tax.
 
At the moment the first nations have a free pass to basically do what ever they want . The provincial govt is panic stricken at the thought of another Ipperwash and as a result does nothing , they don't or don't want to realize that doing nothing is a decision with consequences, now some of the consequences are appearing.

The HST is a tax grab that in the long term could help ( given teh recoed of theis govt additional money from teh tax will be pissed down the drain) but enacting it during a reccession is the epitomy of stupid. They could not control their spending and no rquire us to pay for it , well perhaps at teh next election we can make them pay for it.
 
The question is why is anyone paying these taxes if no one likes them?

Hats off to the 1st Nations for protesting this shit tax.

I agree with you on that one. They seem to be the only ones with the attitude to go out there and protest. And they also seem to be the only ones who can (will) get away with it. We (non-native Canadians) complain a lot, but after a few months just roll over and play dead. The politicians know this, business leaders know this, everyobdy knows this. As a result, we take whatever gets dished out to us. But I don't like their reason for protest. And I have this funny feeling that the tax WILL be introduced, with an exemption for 1st Nations. At that time, we will all complain again, and just go ahead paying the tax.
 
"I don’t like the HST. I don’t know who does (maybe the die hard liberals among us). Now, the 1st Nations organized a protest, and it seems that they are only ones who have done so significantly or successfully to date ... Why are they not paying taxes like the rest of us?"

The question is why is anyone paying these taxes if no one likes them?

Hats off to the 1st Nations for protesting this shit tax.
This exactly what I am wondering. Why there is no outrage of this taxgrab by Dalton and co.? Why I don't see regular everyday people protesting on the street? Are we going just to bend down and take it from the back? This HST will just kill the mood to spend money, and that is the last thing we need in getting out of the recesssion. The way we see it, recession and tax raise don't go hand and hand. HST will just benefit the corporations, not everyday people like you and me.

If anyone wants to protest, you can count me in for sure.
 
The Provincial Sales Tax was not allowed to be deducted from business expense like the GST is. With the HST it will now be allowed to be deducted just like the GST is. The HST will make our corporations more competitive especially those that export. The HST just like the GST is a consumption tax, the more you spend the more taxes you pay. It might not be good for the general consumer but it is good for business owners. Cheers GB
 
The HST is a tax grab

exactally!
but darling dalton said there was going to be no extra taxes when he got elected!
oh yes the health tax does not count because it is not a tax!!
one lie or one broken promise gets you in big trouble but hundreds of them will get ignored
you gotta love the politicians!!!!!!
 
Why does someone have to sue the government for not doing what they are supposed to, i.e., uphold the law. The law should apply equally.

I think the Natives would agree with you and point to broken promises and violated treaties.

I remember hearing about the Native land claims for the lands making up the City of Toronto and thinking, what a fucking joke! But then I actually looked at what the Natives were claiming and what the original treaty was and I was like, uh-oh! :eek:

The Natives got hosed. It's a fact. All that's left to do is figure out what the proper settlement/compensation is. And that's the fight. Whatever the amount is it's so GINORMOUS that no government wants to be the one that has to sign off on it. So we get endless disputes with the Natives who, somewhat understandably, are pissed off that the Feds continue to drag their feet. Of course the Feds do because there's so much money at stake that no one wants to be the one that has to ultimately sign the cheque. And on and on it goes. And lets be honest, until/unless the Natives get in your face, the average Canadian doesn't give two fucks about them or their claims. And so they're in our face.
 
OK what would have happened if WHITES closed down the Gardner like the I believe the Tamils did last year or barricaded the CN main line like was down by Mohawks in Eastern Ontario???????
 
The Natives got hosed. It's a fact. All that's left to do is figure out what the proper settlement/compensation is. And that's the fight. Whatever the amount is it's so GINORMOUS that no government wants to be the one that has to sign off on it.

I agree with you. It would be great to just pay them all off in one big lump sum. It wouldn't cost as much as you think. You see from my experiance with Indains (Lived in Caledonia for 13 years) they are very bad at economics. None of them would save that money and they would all foolishly spend it on rediculous things. (I actually had a sure fire way to recoup all that money but, although true, it sounded racist, so i removed it) All that money would be pumped back into the economy fairly quickly. Very little would be left for the future generations in the form of inheritence.

The only way I would agree to a mass payout would be the for no more special treatment for taxes, no more reservations, no more free schooling. Treat them like shit, you know, the way the government treats every one else.
 
I think the Natives would agree with you and point to broken promises and violated treaties.

I remember hearing about the Native land claims for the lands making up the City of Toronto and thinking, what a fucking joke! But then I actually looked at what the Natives were claiming and what the original treaty was and I was like, uh-oh! :eek:

The Natives got hosed. It's a fact. All that's left to do is figure out what the proper settlement/compensation is. And that's the fight. Whatever the amount is it's so GINORMOUS that no government wants to be the one that has to sign off on it. So we get endless disputes with the Natives who, somewhat understandably, are pissed off that the Feds continue to drag their feet. Of course the Feds do because there's so much money at stake that no one wants to be the one that has to ultimately sign the cheque. And on and on it goes. And lets be honest, until/unless the Natives get in your face, the average Canadian doesn't give two fucks about them or their claims. And so they're in our face.

Actually, my understanding is that there were never any permanent native settlements in the current Toronto. The lone exception being some sort of summer encampment around the current day Baby Point area along the eastern shores of the Humber River.

Whether or not they got hosed is irrelevant in my eyes. My Great Grandparents got hosed by the Bolsheviks in Russia. Whadda ya going to to do about it.

It's time the natives started dealing with their own problems and stopped blaming something that happened 300 years ago.
 
Actually, my understanding is that there were never any permanent native settlements in the current Toronto. The lone exception being some sort of summer encampment around the current day Baby Point area along the eastern shores of the Humber River.

What I saw (and I'm going from memory here) was a treaty document that said the British Crown ceded all lands within the boundaries of certain rivers (including most of the land that's now the City of Toronto) with the exception of certain lands to be surveyed and included as amendments to the treaty. Those surveys were never done and therefore never included in the treaty.

In legal land, that's a major problem...
 
If you think about it the First Nations could pretty well set up ANYWHERE and claim it as their land and bang we have another OKA IPPERWASH CALEDONIA etc. Its got to stop sometime.
 
I would suggest they should just grow up, and move on. Remember the past, yes. We should never forget that. But move on. Can't the 1st nations call it quits and try to do what is best for their people going forward? And where did all the past government money go? And yes, please protest the HST for the rest of us, but let us all have that special exemption.
 
Treat them like shit, you know, the way the government treats every one else.
Rather than ask for another group to be treated like shit,
I would prefer for the government to stop treating me like shit.