How to regulate indoor sex work

Jennifer_

Active member
Sep 14, 2003
3,438
2
38
Downtown Toronto / Mississauga/ Markham
http://www.thestar.com/news/article/1152791--how-to-regulate-indoor-sex-work?bn=1
Kate Allen and Jayme Poisson

Legal brothels in Toronto are at least a year away, if they arrive at all. Monday’s Ontario Court of Appeal ruling that decriminalized bawdy houses won’t come into effect until 2013, or later in the likely case the matter goes to the Supreme Court.

But that hasn’t stopped residents from wondering where licensed brothels might go. The city, predictably, can’t comment yet. “Licensing would not be involved until a council decision was made and bylaws are put in place,” said city spokesman Bruce Hawkins.

Here are three ways to regulate indoor sex work, and what they would mean for Toronto neighbourhoods.

Seeing Red

The best-known way to regulate brothels is instituting a legal red-light district like Amsterdam’s. City Councillor Giorgio Mammoliti, to great uproar, last year suggested setting one up on the Toronto Islands.

After the appeal court’s decision was released, Mammoliti didn’t backtrack on his island proposal, noting that the ideal location would be somewhere out of the way. But he also broadened his scope, suggesting the city look at industrial parks.

Any number of sites that fit that bill dot the GTA, including the chameleonic Port Lands, which was also bandied about as a possible location for a future casino. The further from pre-existing neighbourhoods, the better to placate enraged residents.

But even the most distant, secluded red-light district would be problematic.

Leaving aside for the moment whether any sex workers want to do business there, council would have to vote to zone one area as a red-light district, a politically risky move. Parts of the city that host many licensed massage parlours, which are perceived to operate as brothels, already upset residents.

Stripped away

In March 2011, Tim Lambrinos, executive director of the Adult Entertainment Association of Canada, sent a letter to the city’s municipal licensing division to request a meeting.

Chatter about installing a red-light district on Toronto Islands had recently hit the news, and Lambrinos, as a strip-club spokesman, wanted to share his industry’s position: not a good idea.

“The red-light district on Toronto Island is unworkable — the demand for sex doesn’t stop at the 5 o’clock ferry,” Lambrinos said.

What Lambrinos suggested to the city a year ago, and what he maintains is the smart way forward now, is to simply allow strip clubs to apply to add a brothel — they’re already licensed for erotic services.

“We propose the clubs would apply for an enhanced licence, a separate part in the club, where there is a different work force and different regulations,” he explained.

Strip clubs have a strong incentive to play by the rules, he said, because they’ve invested so much in complying with regulations. (A strip club licence costs thousands of dollars).

Lambrinos said his industry was not pushing for the ability to sell sex. But if it’s going to happen anyway, “we want a piece of the action, too.”

A mixed-use neighbourhood?

Worried about a brothel setting up shop on your tree-lined street? Don’t be. You probably already got one and haven’t noticed, says Valerie Scott of Sex Professionals of Canada.

“There have been brothels in practically every condo and apartment building in Toronto. . . . People have no idea they exist, we are so discreet,” said the 53-year-old former prostitute.

If the bawdy house law stands, five-storey monstrosities with people fornicating on the lawn won’t follow, said Scott, adding that with zoning, loitering and harassment laws, a joint like that “would be shut down in a minute.”

Scott is musing about opening up her own brothel. She’d like a small shop with three or four women, a receptionist and a female retired military officer for security because “no one messes with those babes.”

It would be in a commercial area but far enough away from schools and community centres. Mostly, brothels would be peppered across the city because red-light districts breed organized crime and ghettoize sex workers.

Sydney, Australia — which decriminalized prostitution in 1992 and has about 100 brothels operating at any given time — should be the bar, said Scott, adding, “I did work over there, but just briefly. It was great.”

In one area of Sydney, which she likened to upscale Yorkville, brothels mingle with chic boutiques and restaurants. And there are no blinking neon signs.
 
The Star just loves this issue. The paper had a big story yesterday, as well, on how the changes could be implemented:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ict-Models-for-legalizing-prostitution-abound

By the way, did anyone catch the Toronto Sun`s headline yesterday on the court ruling? The headline was: "Long time coming". There was also a sidebar story with a headline that said the Ontario government wouldn`t take the decision "lying down."
 
"Worried about a brothel setting up shop on your tree-lined street? Don’t be. You probably already got one and haven’t noticed, says Valerie Scott of Sex Professionals of Canada.

“There have been brothels in practically every condo and apartment building in Toronto. . . . People have no idea they exist, we are so discreet,” said the 53-year-old former prostitute."

And that's the attitude that will get the industry in trouble. They are discrete now for a reason. Doubtful that will be the case once they are "mainstreamed". Look at spas and how aggressive their advertising has become.
 
"Worried about a brothel setting up shop on your tree-lined street? Don’t be. You probably already got one and haven’t noticed, says Valerie Scott of Sex Professionals of Canada.

“There have been brothels in practically every condo and apartment building in Toronto. . . . People have no idea they exist, we are so discreet,” said the 53-year-old former prostitute."

And that's the attitude that will get the industry in trouble. They are discrete now for a reason. Doubtful that will be the case once they are "mainstreamed". Look at spas and how aggressive their advertising has become.

I agree completely. What an unwise thing for that lady to say.
 
Toronto Island as the red light district!

The fixed link would happen in a blink.
 
Potential new head lines: Prostitute business is coming to Toronto. Tories are not up for Red Light District. Harper blows hot and cold over potential new prostitute legislation. Federal Court to review prostitute legislation.
 
Nobody wanted to be the Prime Minister who's legacy was to legalize prostitution, but now that it's decriminalized at least, he doesn't have to be. I can absofuckinglotely guarantee you he sure as hell wants to be the Prime Minister who balances his budget while taxing and regulating the shit out of it though.

True capitalism at it's finest. That's what the Conservative Party is all about, isn't it?
 
Nobody wanted to be the Prime Minister who's legacy was to legalize prostitution, but now that it's decriminalized at least, he doesn't have to be. I can absofuckinglotely guarantee you he sure as hell wants to be the Prime Minister who balances his budget while taxing and regulating the shit out of it though.

True capitalism at it's finest. That's what the Conservative Party is all about, isn't it?

A Machiavellian approach might be to fight the case in the Supreme Court of Canada but put the government's worst lawyers on the case.

Which may not be too difficult.

I could be wrong, but how often do government lawyers ever win in court? My sense is not often, although that's just a guess. Perhaps one of TERB's legal experts can let us know.
 
"Chameleonic" port lands. My new word today lol.
Probably the less said about this subject until it goes through in a year, the better.
 
Thanks for posting the article, Jennifer.
Nobody wanted to be the Prime Minister who's legacy was to legalize prostitution, but now that it's decriminalized at least, he doesn't have to be. I can absofuckinglotely guarantee you he sure as hell wants to be the Prime Minister who balances his budget while taxing and regulating the shit out of it though.

True capitalism at it's finest. That's what the Conservative Party is all about, isn't it?
The PM who enacted laws of automatic jail time for anyone growing more than 6 pot plants is more interested in punishing behaviour he doesn't like, than developing new 'sin tax' revenue.

Scott is musing about opening up her own brothel. She’d like a small shop with three or four women, a receptionist and a female retired military officer for security because “no one messes with those babes.”
Rent, licenses, taxes, staff...I don't think her math works. Maybe 4 women working all the time could make a go of it but that would require a larger roster.

I think that all these mainstream press articles and discussion is good and will help normalize hobbying. Whether that affects the legislators is another matter. In the words of The Gang of Four:
Save me from the people who would save me from myself.

 
A Machiavellian approach might be to fight the case in the Supreme Court of Canada but put the government's worst lawyers on the case.

Which may not be too difficult.

I could be wrong, but how often do government lawyers ever win in court? My sense is not often, although that's just a guess. Perhaps one of TERB's legal experts can let us know.
you are way off on more than one level
 
http://www.thestar.com/news/article/1152791--how-to-regulate-indoor-sex-work?bn=1
Sydney, Australia — which decriminalized prostitution in 1992 and has about 100 brothels operating at any given time — should be the bar, said Scott, adding, “I did work over there, but just briefly. It was great.”

In one area of Sydney, which she likened to upscale Yorkville, brothels mingle with chic boutiques and restaurants. And there are no blinking neon signs.

Here's just a sampling of recent news headlines on the state of legalized prostitution in Australia:

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/more-than-500-sydney-prostitutes-are-offering-unprotected-sex-to-clients-in-brothels/story-e6frg6o6-1226240361118

Catchy headline right? Too bad the article forgets to mention that it's unprotected ORAL sex until a few sentences
in. Zealots who want to see prostitution banned/new laws to restrict it...will now begin referring
to BBBJ as simply "Unprotected sex".

If you think the public is 'too smart' to get snookered by this, think again.

and of course, what I've been claiming will happen here in Ontario: HAS already happened
in Australia: The Brothels (agencies/more expensive services) want 'new laws' to stamp
out the indies:

http://www.goldcoast.com.au/article/2012/01/19/383301_tweed-byron-news.html

Like how this article muddies up the waters in regards to oral/vaginal unprotected intercourse?

So what happens if new laws come out banning BBBJ? Who will win?


THE BROTHELS/GOVERNMENT OF COURSE.
 
you are way off on more than one level

It wouldn't be the first time.

To be honest, I have no idea what the government lawyers' track records look like (I'm talking about lawyers fighting cases for the government, not Crown counsels). My sense is they haven't done too well in recent years but maybe that was just the situation in cases I noticed. I don't claim to really know.
 
It wouldn't be the first time.

To be honest, I have no idea what the government lawyers' track records look like (I'm talking about lawyers fighting cases for the government, not Crown counsels). My sense is they haven't done too well in recent years but maybe that was just the situation in cases I noticed. I don't claim to really know.
umm I wonder how exactly do you figure that the lawyer fighting case for the government would not be Crown counsel? Is it because the style of cause is not Regina versus Bedford but Attorney General of Canada vs. Beford?
 
umm I wonder how exactly do you figure that the lawyer fighting case for the government would not be Crown counsel? Is it because the style of cause is not Regina versus Bedford but Attorney General of Canada vs. Beford?

I may not have the terminology right.

I'm talking about the government lawyers who argue cases defending challenges to government legislation (such as the prostitution laws), rather than the ones who are prosecuting cases on behalf of the state where people have been charged with a crime (the Americans would call them prosecutors).

I'm wondering about the track record of the government lawyers who have to defend challenges to legislation.
 
I may not have the terminology right.

I'm talking about the government lawyers who argue cases defending challenges to government legislation (such as the prostitution laws), rather than the ones who are prosecuting cases on behalf of the state where people have been charged with a crime (the Americans would call them prosecutors).

I'm wondering about the track record of the government lawyers who have to defend challenges to legislation.
jokes aside, these would be the same Crown counsel from http://www.attorneygeneral.jus.gov.on.ca/english/about/artcl/cld_crownlawoffice_criminal.asp
they do serious appeals, as well as most serious trials
 
OK.

My question is what kind of track record do the attorneys have who argue cases such as challenges to the prostitution laws? My sense is it isn't good, although I admit I don't really know.
it's very difficult to track record like this
let's say an unrepresented inmate appeals from jail bringing all kinds of ungrounded challenges on an advise of a jailhouse lawyer...this would be a fairly typical case, and one easily won by the crown...now, is that a case that is worthy to even mention in the statistics?
 
it's very difficult to track record like this
let's say an unrepresented inmate appeals from jail bringing all kinds of ungrounded challenges on an advise of a jailhouse lawyer...this would be a fairly typical case, and one easily won by the crown...now, is that a case that is worthy to even mention in the statistics?

Point taken.

I'll say this. If the prostitution case goes to the Supreme Court of Canada, my money is on Alan Young and the people who started the challenge. I'll forget trying to get any stats and go with my gut.