http://www.thestar.com/news/article/1152791--how-to-regulate-indoor-sex-work?bn=1
Kate Allen and Jayme Poisson
Legal brothels in Toronto are at least a year away, if they arrive at all. Monday’s Ontario Court of Appeal ruling that decriminalized bawdy houses won’t come into effect until 2013, or later in the likely case the matter goes to the Supreme Court.
But that hasn’t stopped residents from wondering where licensed brothels might go. The city, predictably, can’t comment yet. “Licensing would not be involved until a council decision was made and bylaws are put in place,” said city spokesman Bruce Hawkins.
Here are three ways to regulate indoor sex work, and what they would mean for Toronto neighbourhoods.
Seeing Red
The best-known way to regulate brothels is instituting a legal red-light district like Amsterdam’s. City Councillor Giorgio Mammoliti, to great uproar, last year suggested setting one up on the Toronto Islands.
After the appeal court’s decision was released, Mammoliti didn’t backtrack on his island proposal, noting that the ideal location would be somewhere out of the way. But he also broadened his scope, suggesting the city look at industrial parks.
Any number of sites that fit that bill dot the GTA, including the chameleonic Port Lands, which was also bandied about as a possible location for a future casino. The further from pre-existing neighbourhoods, the better to placate enraged residents.
But even the most distant, secluded red-light district would be problematic.
Leaving aside for the moment whether any sex workers want to do business there, council would have to vote to zone one area as a red-light district, a politically risky move. Parts of the city that host many licensed massage parlours, which are perceived to operate as brothels, already upset residents.
Stripped away
In March 2011, Tim Lambrinos, executive director of the Adult Entertainment Association of Canada, sent a letter to the city’s municipal licensing division to request a meeting.
Chatter about installing a red-light district on Toronto Islands had recently hit the news, and Lambrinos, as a strip-club spokesman, wanted to share his industry’s position: not a good idea.
“The red-light district on Toronto Island is unworkable — the demand for sex doesn’t stop at the 5 o’clock ferry,” Lambrinos said.
What Lambrinos suggested to the city a year ago, and what he maintains is the smart way forward now, is to simply allow strip clubs to apply to add a brothel — they’re already licensed for erotic services.
“We propose the clubs would apply for an enhanced licence, a separate part in the club, where there is a different work force and different regulations,” he explained.
Strip clubs have a strong incentive to play by the rules, he said, because they’ve invested so much in complying with regulations. (A strip club licence costs thousands of dollars).
Lambrinos said his industry was not pushing for the ability to sell sex. But if it’s going to happen anyway, “we want a piece of the action, too.”
A mixed-use neighbourhood?
Worried about a brothel setting up shop on your tree-lined street? Don’t be. You probably already got one and haven’t noticed, says Valerie Scott of Sex Professionals of Canada.
“There have been brothels in practically every condo and apartment building in Toronto. . . . People have no idea they exist, we are so discreet,” said the 53-year-old former prostitute.
If the bawdy house law stands, five-storey monstrosities with people fornicating on the lawn won’t follow, said Scott, adding that with zoning, loitering and harassment laws, a joint like that “would be shut down in a minute.”
Scott is musing about opening up her own brothel. She’d like a small shop with three or four women, a receptionist and a female retired military officer for security because “no one messes with those babes.”
It would be in a commercial area but far enough away from schools and community centres. Mostly, brothels would be peppered across the city because red-light districts breed organized crime and ghettoize sex workers.
Sydney, Australia — which decriminalized prostitution in 1992 and has about 100 brothels operating at any given time — should be the bar, said Scott, adding, “I did work over there, but just briefly. It was great.”
In one area of Sydney, which she likened to upscale Yorkville, brothels mingle with chic boutiques and restaurants. And there are no blinking neon signs.
Kate Allen and Jayme Poisson
Legal brothels in Toronto are at least a year away, if they arrive at all. Monday’s Ontario Court of Appeal ruling that decriminalized bawdy houses won’t come into effect until 2013, or later in the likely case the matter goes to the Supreme Court.
But that hasn’t stopped residents from wondering where licensed brothels might go. The city, predictably, can’t comment yet. “Licensing would not be involved until a council decision was made and bylaws are put in place,” said city spokesman Bruce Hawkins.
Here are three ways to regulate indoor sex work, and what they would mean for Toronto neighbourhoods.
Seeing Red
The best-known way to regulate brothels is instituting a legal red-light district like Amsterdam’s. City Councillor Giorgio Mammoliti, to great uproar, last year suggested setting one up on the Toronto Islands.
After the appeal court’s decision was released, Mammoliti didn’t backtrack on his island proposal, noting that the ideal location would be somewhere out of the way. But he also broadened his scope, suggesting the city look at industrial parks.
Any number of sites that fit that bill dot the GTA, including the chameleonic Port Lands, which was also bandied about as a possible location for a future casino. The further from pre-existing neighbourhoods, the better to placate enraged residents.
But even the most distant, secluded red-light district would be problematic.
Leaving aside for the moment whether any sex workers want to do business there, council would have to vote to zone one area as a red-light district, a politically risky move. Parts of the city that host many licensed massage parlours, which are perceived to operate as brothels, already upset residents.
Stripped away
In March 2011, Tim Lambrinos, executive director of the Adult Entertainment Association of Canada, sent a letter to the city’s municipal licensing division to request a meeting.
Chatter about installing a red-light district on Toronto Islands had recently hit the news, and Lambrinos, as a strip-club spokesman, wanted to share his industry’s position: not a good idea.
“The red-light district on Toronto Island is unworkable — the demand for sex doesn’t stop at the 5 o’clock ferry,” Lambrinos said.
What Lambrinos suggested to the city a year ago, and what he maintains is the smart way forward now, is to simply allow strip clubs to apply to add a brothel — they’re already licensed for erotic services.
“We propose the clubs would apply for an enhanced licence, a separate part in the club, where there is a different work force and different regulations,” he explained.
Strip clubs have a strong incentive to play by the rules, he said, because they’ve invested so much in complying with regulations. (A strip club licence costs thousands of dollars).
Lambrinos said his industry was not pushing for the ability to sell sex. But if it’s going to happen anyway, “we want a piece of the action, too.”
A mixed-use neighbourhood?
Worried about a brothel setting up shop on your tree-lined street? Don’t be. You probably already got one and haven’t noticed, says Valerie Scott of Sex Professionals of Canada.
“There have been brothels in practically every condo and apartment building in Toronto. . . . People have no idea they exist, we are so discreet,” said the 53-year-old former prostitute.
If the bawdy house law stands, five-storey monstrosities with people fornicating on the lawn won’t follow, said Scott, adding that with zoning, loitering and harassment laws, a joint like that “would be shut down in a minute.”
Scott is musing about opening up her own brothel. She’d like a small shop with three or four women, a receptionist and a female retired military officer for security because “no one messes with those babes.”
It would be in a commercial area but far enough away from schools and community centres. Mostly, brothels would be peppered across the city because red-light districts breed organized crime and ghettoize sex workers.
Sydney, Australia — which decriminalized prostitution in 1992 and has about 100 brothels operating at any given time — should be the bar, said Scott, adding, “I did work over there, but just briefly. It was great.”
In one area of Sydney, which she likened to upscale Yorkville, brothels mingle with chic boutiques and restaurants. And there are no blinking neon signs.

