how to get a phd without really trying

red

you must be fk'n kid'g me
Nov 13, 2001
17,551
10
38
A former child prodigy who became a math professor at age 24 has been suspended from the University of Manitoba for protesting its decision to award a PhD to a student who failed to meet the formal requirements, in part because of an anxiety disorder.

In a test case for how universities accommodate the diagnosis of “extreme examination anxiety,” Gabor Lukacs, now 28, will be in court later this month, arguing that the school disregarded its own policies and undermined the value of a U of M doctorate by waiving the written exam after the student failed it twice.

“I don’t think it’s appropriate for an administrator to overrule a panel of academic experts,” said Prof. Lukacs, who was born in Hungary and grew up in Israel before moving to Toronto for a PhD at York University.

In turn, the school accuses Prof. Lukacs of insubordination, harassment of the student, and violation of privacy, and has suspended him, without pay, for the remainder of this calendar year.

The last UofM faculty member to be suspended without pay was facing a sexual assault charge, a school spokesman said.

The case has bitterly divided the campus. The head of the math department, David Gunderson, said it has “nearly torn my heart out.”

“It is too painful to let continue ad infinitum,” he wrote in an email to his faculty, which urged them to accept the student’s controversial degree because “everybody... screwed up.”

Many have sided with Prof. Lukacs. His students signed a petition in his support, and 10 of his colleagues wrote to the dean of science, saying Prof. Lukacs never violated the student’s privacy, and in fact “acted out of his deep conviction that the academic interests of the Department were compromised.”

The scandal began last year, when the student twice failed his comprehensive exam in analysis, which ordinarily requires the student to leave the program, but he appealed to the dean of graduate studies, John Doering.

The department refused Prof. Doering’s suggested compromise of an oral exam, saying it would not meet academic standards. Prof. Doering refused the department’s suggestion to give the student twice the time in two sessions on different days.

Prof. Doering broke this stalemate by deciding to waive the exam completely, which led one math professor to resign from the committee that oversees graduate mathematics work. He was replaced by Prof. Lukacs, who coordinated the faculty’s opposition to this unusual accommodation.

In court documents, Prof. Lukacs alleges that Prof. Doering wrote in an email about the proposed oral exam: “In the event that failure is reported, alternative testing will likely be explored.”

Like many schools, the University of Manitoba accommodates students with documented medical disorders, by offering such aids as extra time, a quiet room, a reader or a scribe.

And if it were only about the written exam, this case might have remained a private academic bunfight, with no more scandal than the letter of reprimand placed on Prof. Lukacs employee file for violating the student’s privacy by raising the issue among math department colleagues.

This past August, however, after Prof. Lukacs returned from a leave in Europe, it was discovered the student had also not completed the required graduate courses.

Prof. Doering’s solution to that problem -- to retroactively upgrade his undergraduate courses to the graduate level, with no extra study -- led Prof. Lukacs to seek a court injunction in September against the awarding of the PhD.

In doing so, the university alleges he continued his “insubordination” and “harassment,” and violated the student’s privacy by filing court documents that refer to the anxiety disorder. For this, Prof. Lukacs was suspended without pay for the rest of the year, a penalty his union is contesting. A threat of further punishment followed his filing of a supporting affidavit from a colleague.

The doctorate was in fact awarded to the student, and so in some ways the case is now moot, even as its next court date looms later this month. But the parties are entrenched in seemingly irreconcilable positions, and the time for compromise seems to have passed.

Prof. Lukacs’ recent leave in Europe was “overshadowed” by health problems, he writes in an affidavit, diagnosed as “’relative immune deficiency’ as a result of a recent Cytomegalovirus infection.” But it also inspired him to continue this fight on his return to Winnipeg.

“Discussions with my 80-year-old Holocaust-survivor grandmother in Budapest, and the aftermath of the landslide victory of the extreme ultra-right in Hungary in the April 2010 elections, brought me to the conclusion that I must act in accordance with my conscience, even if it may have severe personal consequences for me,” he wrote in an affidavit.

For a mathematician, let alone one as young as him, Prof. Lukacs spends an unusual amount of time in court. Some of his litigation is mundane. In 2007, he settled a small claims suit against IKEA over some damaged furniture. In 2008, he failed to have a protection order brought against a Winnipeg man over threats, in a case that was dealt with by police.

But Prof. Lukacs is also an advocate, almost a crusader, for the rights of airline passengers. As such, he has brought legal action against United Airlines, Air Canada and Skywest Airlines. He also won two judgments at the Canadian Transportation Agency, which established that WestJet and Air Canada are legally liable for lost baggage.



Read more: http://www.nationalpost.com/news/Campus+torn+dispute+over/3767102/story.html#ixzz14KDGD7DX
 
Sounds like Prof. Lukacs has disorders of his own. But he is right. I had to quit a course due to the death of my father. I was not handed the credit but I was relieved of academic and financial responsibility that year and permitted to start over when ready. No free rides. I wouldnt trust a PhD from an institution that hands them out for sympathy.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like Prof. Lukacs has disorders of his own. But he is right. I had to quit a course due to the death of my father. I was not handed the credit but I was relieved of academic and financial responsibility that year and permitted to start over when ready. No free rides. I wouldnt trust a PhD from an institution that hands them out for sympathy.
Agreed. Any institution that grants a Ph.D. must do so in a way that the Ph.D. is recognised worldwide. That is one reason they have external examiners at the thesis defence at any credible university.

BTW, I am sorry about your father's passing away, especially during your candidacy for the doctorate.
 
Agreed. Any institution that grants a Ph.D. must do so in a way that the Ph.D. is recognised worldwide. That is one reason they have external examiners at the thesis defence at any credible university.

They do? I suppose I technically had one, but only because one of the professors on my committee had moved to a different school while I was working on my thesis. I thought my university was pretty credible, though; Ivy League and all.

The story doesn't actually mention the guy's thesis; presumably he still wrote one and it was accepted by his committee. Most schools consider any other requirements fairly secondary for the Ph.D.
 
The story doesn't actually mention the guy's thesis; presumably he still wrote one and it was accepted by his committee. Most schools consider any other requirements fairly secondary for the Ph.D.

really? no graduate courses are required?
 
They do? I suppose I technically had one, but only because one of the professors on my committee had moved to a different school while I was working on my thesis. I thought my university was pretty credible, though; Ivy League and all.

The story doesn't actually mention the guy's thesis; presumably he still wrote one and it was accepted by his committee. Most schools consider any other requirements fairly secondary for the Ph.D.
For a PhD in Mathematics? Maybe in Arts.

The court could be requested to rescind the award of the degree pending demonstration of the required skills (such as by giving twice the time, as suggested by the advisory committee).

A degree means nothing if the holder cannot apply the skills after the degree is awarded. A school awarding a meaningless degree is nothing more than a diploma mill.
 
I'm not sure that Prof Lukacs' has any case here. Clearly, he disagrees with the university's decision regarding their awarding this student a PhD. However, I don't see what standing he has to apply to the court for an injunction against the university's decision. Even if one agrees with his complaints, Prof Lukacs has not been harmed or injured in any way by the university's decision. I think the court should simply throw this case out.

Prof Lukacs sounds like a rather litigious personality.
 
For a PhD in Mathematics? Maybe in Arts.

The court could be requested to rescind the award of the degree pending demonstration of the required skills (such as by giving twice the time, as suggested by the advisory committee).

A degree means nothing if the holder cannot apply the skills after the degree is awarded. A school awarding a meaningless degree is nothing more than a diploma mill.
That's why as DocOdd said, the thesis is usually considered the most important requirement for a PhD. Most doctorate programms also include coursework, and qualification exams, but it's the research and dissertation that gets you the PhD.
 
They do? I suppose I technically had one, but only because one of the professors on my committee had moved to a different school while I was working on my thesis. I thought my university was pretty credible, though; Ivy League and all.

The story doesn't actually mention the guy's thesis; presumably he still wrote one and it was accepted by his committee. Most schools consider any other requirements fairly secondary for the Ph.D.

really? no graduate courses are required?

I didn't say that there were no other requirements, I said they were regarded as secondary. It is not infrequent for modifications and exceptions to be made for coursework requirements, or for any of the other requirements besides the thesis, for a variety of different reasons.
 
I have to assume that the unqualified candidate who got the degree was a member of some protected group or another, not just suffering from exam anxiety.
 
After some of the creative reasons I have heard for delaying awarding a PhD, I would be very surprised if this person got a PhD and had not completed some of the core journal paper requirements.
 
really? no graduate courses are required?
It depends on where one goes for the doctorate.
There is more emphasis at many institutions, for example, in European countries, on the thesis versus courses taken. This is opposite to teh US system where the candidate takes a lot of courses. In Canada, it i a balance between the two extremes.
 
It depends on where one goes for the doctorate.
There is more emphasis at many institutions, for example, in European countries, on the thesis versus courses taken. This is opposite to teh US system where the candidate takes a lot of courses. In Canada, it i a balance between the two extremes.

so someone with only undergraduate courses could get a phd with a thesis? I don't know anything about it. just curious.
 
so someone with only undergraduate courses could get a phd with a thesis? I don't know anything about it. just curious.

The PhD Comprehensive Exam is a test on the candidate's knowledge of undergraduate material. It is expected that the PhD candidate can develop new theory based on existing theory.

The thesis is the key to a successful PhD, however the thesis is supposed to be judged on the publishability of the material. Thus the first question often asked of a candidate is "how many publications?" Publications also affect the candidates ability to find an academic job after completing the PhD program.

However, if the University of Manitoba is granting PhD's with no coursework and no comprehensive exam, then how well is the thesis being reviewed?
 
so someone with only undergraduate courses could get a phd with a thesis? I don't know anything about it. just curious.
I didn't say it was just a thesis. As someone else here poinetd out, there are steps toward doing the thesis, such as the comprehensive exam, and also a thesis proposal that has to be defended. The theis itself is not just a paper one writes. It is much more than just a report. It involves a significant effort and takes a significant amount of time to do the research required to write the thesis, or dissertation,as it is called.
 
The PhD Comprehensive Exam is a test on the candidate's knowledge of undergraduate material. It is expected that the PhD candidate can develop new theory based on existing theory.

The thesis is the key to a successful PhD, however the thesis is supposed to be judged on the publishability of the material. Thus the first question often asked of a candidate is "how many publications?" Publications also affect the candidates ability to find an academic job after completing the PhD program.

However, if the University of Manitoba is granting PhD's with no coursework and no comprehensive exam, then how well is the thesis being reviewed?
The comprehensive exam is not just restricted to testing teh candidate on just undergraduate knowledge.

There have been theses written by candidates who have never published anything. The thesis is a work that stands on its own and is a significant contribution to the knowledge in the field of study that is applicable for that document.

I, too, would question the validity of a thesis from am institution that does not require a valid program to produce a document that is supposed to be a significant contribution to the knowledge. Any institution that I have dealt with requires a candidate to go through such a program. The program also involves the participation of external (to the institution) examiners to validate the work being defended by the candidate. After all, granting a doctorate would suggest that the candidate would be an authority in the field of study.