how does Collins Key do this trick?

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
 
Last edited:
i see no switch from the paper he took from the box


why twitter the info does that have something to do with it?


i think the ladder might be key

why use a ladder when you can lower the box?

why have an assistant bring it out when the ladder could have been on stage beforehand?


the answers are written down by an assistant then put on the ladder ?

the box has a false bottom allowing collins to access the answers?
 
i see no switch from the paper he took from the box


someone must have wrote this stuff down then put it in the box ?

which was not hanging up on stage all along ? as he states



seems like cheating


why twitter the info does that have something to do with it?



I didn't pay attention but if the box was not hanging on stage after the tweets, then yes, someone else could have written those things in.

Why Twitter? Just a fancy way of relaying a message that anyone with a computer can access - like the Collins accomplice backstage?

Isn't all magic sorta cheating?
 
I didn't pay attention but if the box was not hanging on stage after the tweets, then yes, someone else could have written those things in.

Why Twitter? Just a fancy way of relaying a message that anyone with a computer can access - like the Collins accomplice backstage?

Isn't all magic sorta cheating?

tweeting also slows down the process allowing the accomplice to write the answers down in the exact way the judges did by copying their spelling

Why does he put the answers inside a tube?

i suspect the answer to Collins trick lies in the ladder which the accomplice has handled



on a side note, i suspect Chris Angel is a huge liar as some of his tricks on his show are camera tricks
 
Last edited:
the tube throws me off

why have the answers inside a tube?

a false top on the ladder would hide the tube nicely and a false bottom on the box would provide access to the tube but i can not see this being done on replay
 
The tube looks like one of those containers that was once used for delivering letters through pneumatic air pipes.

Maybe the box was connected somehow to a pipe to deliver the tube while it was hanging?
 
The tube looks like one of those containers that was once used for delivering letters through pneumatic air pipes.

Maybe the box was connected somehow to a pipe to deliver the tube while it was hanging?

perhaps but i suspect


the ladder seems the vehicle that is key because it was unnecessary

it appears he hung the box just out of reach as an excuse to bring in the ladder


AGT is in on it by choosing camera angles agreed to before hand
 
Last edited:
I think the tweeting is a way to slow down the process...the ladder is used to deliver the paper copy with the real answers - his left arm grabs the unseen back of the ladder and seems to push on the box from that side as well.

I think there is a switch of paper when he opens the tube as the tube is unnecessary and distracts the audience.

The two unnecessary components - the ladder and the tube allow for the switch


...I just clicked through the video...I believe the tube was horizontal and fixed in place so he could push the paper into it from behind the box
 
I think the tweeting is a way to slow down the process...the ladder is used to deliver the paper copy with the real answers - his left arm grabs the unseen back of the ladder and seems to push on the box from that side as well.

I think there is a switch of paper when he opens the tube as the tube is unnecessary and distracts the audience.

The two unnecessary components - the ladder and the tube allow for the switch


...I just clicked through the video...I believe the tube was horizontal and fixed in place so he could push the paper into it from behind the box

i believe you have given the final piece of the puzzle

but no paper switch is required

the tube is empty with no bottom

he grabs the answers from a hidden spot on the far side of the ladder we have not seen as you suggest

notice how his jacket swings open to hide this grab

(AGT is in on the camera angle allowing this to go unseen )

he places the tube on his left hand as though his left hand is needed to hold the tube but in reality he is placing the tube over the answers which are in his left hand


the darkness of the set and the colour of the background being the same as the paper and the tube helps hide the paper and the false bottom of the tube

i believe this is the complete answer


i see small, if any, originality in this trick

false bottoms were thought of long ago


this guy is not that good

what do you think?



another solution is the judges were in on it but i doubt that as all four of them would be tainting their reputation if discovered they had so cheated as well as AGTs reputation
 
It would be interesting to have a handwriting expert comment on whether that is his handwriting.

that is not his handwriting

if it was this would be a very good trick

also giving the tube to a judge before hand and allowing the judge to open the tube and read the correct answers would be a very good trick


this is somebody elses old trick