HomeStars Contractor Reviews

ironkok

New member
Apr 2, 2009
27
0
0
How can you trust the contractor reviews on HomeStars?

It seems all the highest rated reviews on contractors (you know...the ones with all 10/10's) have nearly identical writing styles and content.
One guy had 25 10/10 reviews that all had the word "professional" in the first 2 lines, referred to the owner by their first name etc.

Another reviewer said this was the first time they used "so and so" and they were so happy, but also posted a review years earlier for the same contractor.:confused:
They can't even keep their own lies straight.

Seems the site is more advantageous to scammers who want to build up an instant reputation.
 
I have a friend who is one of those contractors. He has a specialist hired consultant to manage his Homestars ratings. He asks me to allow his consultant to create fake reviews and them just have me submit them so as not to be traceable etc. No thanks. He insists that ALL the Homestars contractors do the same and he simply has to keep up so he appears in the first part of the listings for his category.

But here is the thing.... he is a FANTASTIC contractor in his specialized field! His prices are probably ever so slightly higher than an average price but his employee's work is TOP quality.

If nothing else, the creation of such fake reviews MIGHT be an indicator that the contractor is cognizant of his reputation.
 
Marketplace did a study of on-line reviews: http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/episodes/2014-2015/online-reviews-faking-it The conclusion was most reviews are fake, with many published by professional reviewers who've never seen the product. In addition, many review sites modify review content or completely remove unfavourable reviews.

I have tried using HomeStars for a roofing contractor. When I was doing my research, one contractor in particular was doing many homes in my neighbourhood. I spoke to several of the home-owners and their feedback was universally mediocre. Complaints ranged from poor clean-up, shingles weren't laid parallel, cost overruns, ugly flashing installation and one guy didn't get his ice dam installed (he demanded they stop work, remove the shingles already laid and install it). Anyway the contractor has 20+ 10/10 reviews. Makes you wonder .........

I'm a believer in word of mouth, as long as the person providing you the recommendation is known to you and has reasonable knowledge of the subject. Too many people offer an uninformed opinion!
 
I have a friend who is one of those contractors. He has a specialist hired consultant to manage his Homestars ratings. He asks me to allow his consultant to create fake reviews and them just have me submit them so as not to be traceable etc. No thanks. He insists that ALL the Homestars contractors do the same and he simply has to keep up so he appears in the first part of the listings for his category.

But here is the thing.... he is a FANTASTIC contractor in his specialized field! His prices are probably ever so slightly higher than an average price but his employee's work is TOP quality.

If nothing else, the creation of such fake reviews MIGHT be an indicator that the contractor is cognizant of his reputation.

I completely agree with what you are saying. I ended up selecting a contractor based on trusted opinions. The contractors price was also on the high side of the quotes I got. I was thrilled with the quality of work - lol, I watched everything and pre-educated myself on what to look for. Anyway, he was saying he had the same problem and admitted he added fake reviews to his profile. Interestingly, he's a personal friend of Mike Holmes (Holmes on Homes) and Mike told him he dropped his Home Depot relationship and Holmes recommended contractors program over all the BS in the review industry and the problems with contractors sub-contracting and/or adding lesser-skilled poorly supervised crews as they got busy.
 
Exactly what I suspected...

Too bad it is so hard to filter through the bull to find the best.
And when you are new to the neighborhood, word of mouth is hard to come by.

The one time I hired via Home Depot for kitchen cabinets, it actually worked out quite well.
When you have an issue with the work, you call HD and they handled the contractor.
If they did not fix it, they did not get more work from HD.

Had a well rated door and window guy over last week, and he was either coked up or on 20 red bulls.

Going to "interview" Da Vinci Stucco next.
 
I use Home Service Club (50 buck a year membership). Prices are a bit higher but the work is guaranteed. You get three quotes and they have excellent follow up.

Beyond that it's all about word of mouth. It's how ow I found a good electrician.
 
I work for a company that is very highly listed on Homestars. All reviews are NOT written by the company owners themselves. We have over 100 reviews and most are positive. I even went to one client and she said she read most of the Homestars reviews. This lady commented that she could tell that the reviews were not written by one person as she was a literary editor and she commented that it would be impossible to write these reviews with all the different writing styles. If you do the work correctly and treat the customer the proper way there is no need to write fake reviews.
I have also used Homestars twice for contractors; an electrician and an HVAC contractor. Both times I received exactly what the reviews stated. For the electrician I received 5 quotes. Prices ranged widely from the lowest quote on the back of a business card to much higher. In the end I choose the 2nd highest quote from Homestars and received an excellent job. Just my experience. If you choose a company with 20 reviews with an obvious similar writing style you should not expect a quality job. Not all companies are dishonest on Homestars. Once again, just my experience.
 
I found a well reviewed contractor on homestars and got a ludicrously overpriced quote. Eventually found a contractor a coworker recommended and got the work done for significantly less.

A close look at the "well reviewed" guy showed all his reviews posted around the end of the month, every month, like clockwork.
 
Have also used a contractor with what appeared to be too many positive reviews and found their service and price was exceptional. I often sort reviews and read the less positive reviews to get a feel for if they have merit or are nitpicking. Contractors with some history who are working the internet would be making an effort to avoid negative reviews.
 
You can't completely trust them. Like any review - including, hotel, resort and SP - I look at the number of negative reviews and ignore all the positive (possibly shill) reviews .
 
Eventually you have to pick some...so 3 from each trade I need have been booked for quotes.
A couple will be here at the same time for the same job...that should be interesting :eyebrows:

In addition to referrals, previous jobs I can inspect and confer with customer, overall character assessment, I will be wary of any down-payment requests over 10%, unwritten quotes, etc.

I met with a well reviewed interlock installation company last year a few times.
I never managed to talk to anyone else in the company, he always showed up in an unmarked personal vehicle, was pushing certain brands and made me go miles away to the stone manufacturer to view samples.
All the warning flags were flying !
 
Let's turn this around. I have written reviews on contractors for HomeStars. No one paid me, and my reviews are as candid as my TERB reviews. But if I were choosing a contractor from that website - and I have - I would choose one with fewer reviews, rather than dozens of raves. Plus I prefer smaller firms anyway. I just hired a plumber off the HomeStars board the other day. He's coming next week, so we'll see.
 
I used a guy there for basement waterproofing and he did decent work and was a good value IMHO
 
I worked for a Builder who had crappy ratings on home stars.Some employees bought a house, so the employee and the spouse wrote glowing endorsements. One guys wife went on a couple of times and made glowing comments. Here's the real kicker, if the builder becomes a member of Home stars, he can remove negative comments sooner, post rebuttals to the bad ones and exercise more control over where the good glowing posts show up. Its not about free speech and consumer rights-its about using a supposed forum not for the consumer but as a an extortion tool to pry protection money and instead of getting ads, you get circumspect reviews.