Homeopathy Oooops!

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,049
1
0
In a recent thread I believe I made an erroneous reference to homeopathy and my using it on occasions when the proper term should have been naturopathy.

Earlier this evening i caught an episode of Marketplace on CBC and they investigated the practice of homeopathy especially when it will soon be receiving the support of the government of Ontario.

In short, Homeopathy is almost total bunk, consisting of offering medicines that containing such small amounts of the advertised active ingredient that modern science can't measure it. Modern analysis can measure down to 1 part in 5 million million. The medicine are basically sugar pills and and sugar water.

One group of inquiring citizen decided to test these medications they were prescribed.
They stood in the parking lot in front of a Vancouver hospital and downed all the pills given them . One person downed over 20 pills each of Belladonna and the same of Arsenic. Not one person experienced any side affect except at noticeable sugar rush.

As for it being a long standing traditional form of medicine. It has a history going all the way back 200 years. Traditional would not be my first choice of words to describe it.

What else can I say, but not for me.
 
I don't think the government is "supporting" it, as much as it is regulating it. There's quite a difference. If anything regulation is designed to address some of your concerns. BTW - I too am not much for homeopathy or homeopaths - however, I've started taking oil of oregano when I start feeling sick. It has worked like a charm twice this year already.

You absolutely right. That word escaped me at the time of posting. After hearing the government explain how regulating the product would be beneficial. I wish I had your faith. He was a total automaton.
 
I don't think the government is "supporting" it, as much as it is regulating it.
I have another choice of wording. They should be "outlawing" it. It's a scam. It does absolutely nothing except for give people false hope of a cure. Any benefit a patient may derive is simply due to placebo effect or coincidence. People are just throwing their money away.

I'm sure many people have anecdotes of miracle cures etc. etc. etc. Placebo/coincidence.
 
A week ago I challenged you specifically on HOMEOPATHY.

I posted a video by James Randi specifically debunking homeopathy.

You continued to be ignorant of the facts presented to you on a silver platter yet alluded to watching the video by saying "I have great respect for James Randi in a lot of his work.".

As if to say, ..."but not in this case".

Nonetheless, in the face of this information presented to you, you continued to yap on about a medical philosophy you don't even know what it is CALLED!

Just proving yet again that you cannot resist holding forth on topics that you clearly only know enough about to make yourself look like an ignorant fool. And then when more knowledgeable members try to educate you, you escalate your image to that of an obstinant goof.

Here was my measured response, kindly trying to educate you. As usual, to no avail. Do you realize that you can indeed learn from others and don;t have to discover everything on your own?



I've known of James Randi since his earlydays as a magician and before he debunked many faith healers, mind readers, and psychics. I made no suggestion of ever seeing the video.

In my initial post in this thread I said I confused homeopathy with naturopathy, and of course you've never made that kind of error, so in my comments in the other thread you have to keep that in mind.

At least I've admitted to the error unlike some members on TERB.
 
Admittedly a good first step there boy!

Feels good doesn't it?

Don't get too used to it or Fred is going to get killed on bandwidth charges!!!!

This is not the first time I've admitted being wrong or commented on actually learning something and it won't be the last.
 
I would like to see their regulation of claims, evidence and training.
I was going to suggest cigarette package-like labelling in my post. Too lazy.

But still, if somebody believes in it and it is available, they may resort to that instead of seeking out proper medical attention. Even worse, if they deny their young children access to proper care because they believe in these witch doctor cures. That is where the real danger lies.
 
Sure they could outlaw it if they wish, but I don't think that's necessary. I would like to see their regulation of claims, evidence and training.

I haven't heard about this business till now, but isn't regulating the first step towards having our already overburdened health care system starting to cover it?

The claims of homeopathy are preposterous. The essences, are 100% distilled water.

The proof is non-existant. Some people here, (it would have been mostly chicks ten years ago but probably 50-50 now) swear by echinacea. Saying "It seems to work for me, I don't care about the science." does NOT do a person credit. It simply means they are too dumb to understand the concept of the placebo effect, and the fact that given time, the body heals itself of most colds/flus eventually, regardless.

The largest homeopathic college in the US did a massive study on echinacea a few years back. They were totally convinced that echinacea was the real deal, and that a real test of the drug, would go a long way to supporting the whole general retardism of their profession. They were counting on it.

When the preliminary results came back form the double blind study, there was a very minor, practically statistically insignificant difference in the echinacea group and the placebo control group, and they went ballistic with ecstacy, and duly notified the press.

Guess what? When the results came back it found that the placebo group had the slight actual improvement.

Ooops.

I'm for outlawing the shit too. But should stupid people have the right to spend their own dough however they like?

Its a tough ethical question. I'd like to see psychics outlawed too, but I'm not holding my breath.
 
I haven't heard about this business till now, but isn't regulating the first step towards having our already overburdened health care system starting to cover it?

The claims of homeopathy are preposterous. The essences, are 100% distilled water.

I'm for outlawing the shit too. But should stupid people have the right to spend their own dough however they like?

Its a tough ethical question. I'd like to see psychics outlawed too, but I'm not holding my breath.

The only problem is that the believers may use it and think they are protected against the basic the common contagious deceases, but they run the risk of passing it onto others. Do they have the right to make others sick? Claims such as curing polio and cancer are made for some concoctions.
 
Let me ask you this as a good analogy. Licensed MP's are regulated by the city in terms of municipal codes they have to follow. Further, given the legal limbo of the prostitution laws, it is possible that MP's may be regulated by Act of Parliament. Do you think that our provincial insurance systems and private insurance will accept our MP bills just because they are regulated? I don't think so.

Look, chiropractic, physiotherapy, naturopathy, occupational therapy and many other professions are not even covered under OHIP - you get small amounts from private insurers. I don't think OHIP will ever cover homeopathy.


I'm not sure naturopathy, and physiotherapy should be referenced in the same sentence.

Different plans, different coverage. My 'others' city Manulife coverage pays 100% of unlimited physiotherapy, up to $500 bucks a year for Chiro (that's for $40 bucks a visit, with OHIP covering some) and up to $500 for RMT massage. I don't know what the OT coverage is, but its a real science, and probably covered as well.

Chiro used to be covered by OHIP. May be again sometime down the road.

I don't expect to see MP massage ever covered, licensed or not, unless regulated under a REGISTERED massage therapist, but naturophaths and homeopaths have powerful, well funded lobby groups, and lots of chick voters who believe those practices SHOULD be covered. You may be ultimately right, but I wouldn't bet real money on it myself, given the kind of lunatics who run our asylum. Remember the fuss kicked up when the province wanted to regulate Chinese herbalists? I don't know what I'd do without my daily dose of ground-up animal penis from nearly-extinct animals.
 
I haven't heard about this business till now, but isn't regulating the first step towards having our already overburdened health care system starting to cover it?

The claims of homeopathy are preposterous. The essences, are 100% distilled water.

The proof is non-existant. Some people here, (it would have been mostly chicks ten years ago but probably 50-50 now) swear by echinacea. Saying "It seems to work for me, I don't care about the science." does NOT do a person credit. It simply means they are too dumb to understand the concept of the placebo effect, and the fact that given time, the body heals itself of most colds/flus eventually, regardless.

The largest homeopathic college in the US did a massive study on echinacea a few years back. They were totally convinced that echinacea was the real deal, and that a real test of the drug, would go a long way to supporting the whole general retardism of their profession. They were counting on it.

When the preliminary results came back form the double blind study, there was a very minor, practically statistically insignificant difference in the echinacea group and the placebo control group, and they went ballistic with ecstacy, and duly notified the press.

Guess what? When the results came back it found that the placebo group had the slight actual improvement.

Ooops.

I'm for outlawing the shit too. But should stupid people have the right to spend their own dough however they like?

Its a tough ethical question. I'd like to see psychics outlawed too, but I'm not holding my breath.
I don't want to come out in defense of homeopathy as I don't know enough about it. But for someone who just learned about it now, you seemed to have attained expert status rather quickly. By the way, echinacea is not a homeopathic remedy. It is an herb and would fall under the rather broad category of "herbal medicine." This has nothing to do with homeopathy. So exactly what are you talking about here? Homeopathy or herbal medicine? Or in your expert opinion, are they all voodoo because they are not drugs prescribed by a doctor?
The only problem is that the believers may use it and think they are protected against the basic the common contagious deceases, but they run the risk of passing it onto others. Do they have the right to make others sick? Claims such as curing polio and cancer are made for some concoctions.

I don't think people who use homeopathic remedies are any more likely to pass on an infectious disease than people who use conventional western medicinal cures like drug therapy. If you are sick and contagious, you should stay away from others no matter what you are taking for the illness. btw, cancer is not contagious, and polio has not been present in Canada for decades. So I am not sure what the point of your post is. Could you be more specific please?
 
I don't think people who use homeopathic remedies are any more likely to pass on an infectious disease than people who use conventional western medicinal cures like drug therapy. If you are sick and contagious, you should stay away from others no matter what you are taking for the illness.

Yes but somebody may stay contagious for a longer period of time by not getting proper treatment. Not everybody can stay quarantined indefinitely. We sometimes have responsibilities that cannot be put off.

Again, there is the issue of young children who have no say in what treatment they receive.
 
Yes but somebody may stay contagious for a longer period of time by not getting proper treatment. Not everybody can stay quarantined indefinitely. We sometimes have responsibilities that cannot be put off.

Again, there is the issue of young children who have no say in what treatment they receive.

Well, again, I am not taking the position that homeopathy is good or bad. But I am not sure what your position is either. Conventional medical treatment should be mandatory? Parents should be arrested for giving herbal remedies to their kids who have cold symtoms? Or people should be arrested for being sick when they have a contagious disease in public? My position is this: people should not be in public when they have a contagious disease, but if they are, then there isn't much we can do about it except try to avoid them. And people should be allowed to choose their own form of treatment. But I am not sure how productive it is talking in generalities like this. Some diseases are contagious, others aren't. Some are fatal, others represent a minor inconvenience.
 
Well, again, I am not taking the position that homeopathy is good or bad. But I am not sure what your position is either. Conventional medical treatment should be mandatory? Parents should be arrested for giving herbal remedies to their kids who have cold symtoms? Or people should be arrested for being sick when they have a contagious disease in public? My position is this: people should not be in public when they have a contagious disease, but if they are, then there isn't much we can do about it except try to avoid them. And people should be allowed to choose their own form of treatment. But I am not sure how productive it is talking in generalities like this. Some diseases are contagious, others aren't. Some are fatal, others represent a minor inconvenience.

Herbal remedies is one thing, as many do work, but the sugar pills and sugar water that pass as homeopathy is another. You don't have to show symptoms to be contagious and that the problem. You can carry the contagion and not know it, then pass it on to others. Colds on their own aren't fatal, but it does open the door for other diseases that are.
 
But I am not sure what your position is either. Conventional medical treatment should be mandatory?
My position is that homeopathy should just be taken out of the equation.

I believe there are already precedents as to parents' responsibilities regarding health issues.

My point is to at least eliminate the possibility of choosing a blatantly useless treatment and thereby delaying treatment that has a potentially reasonable chance to be effective.
 
In fact, the regulations may prohibit homeopaths from treating certain conditions and certain people under severe penalty. Midwifes, for example, cannot treat women who have acquired diabetes during their pregnancy. Primary care must be transferred to a physician. So the regulations may actually limit the scope of practice for homeopaths in a similar way that midwives are limited. Similarly, the regulations may also say "treatment limited to those 18 and over only."
Can't argue with those provisions.

At least it is providing some protection for those who may be more at risk, small cross-section though it may be.
 
Never a believer on those alternative medicine, including TCM and Acupuncture since there are nothing to document and test their effectiveness. :rolleyes:
 
... BTW - I too am not much for homeopathy or homeopaths - however, I've started taking oil of oregano when I start feeling sick. It has worked like a charm twice this year already.

From what I've seen of things like oregano oil it is pretty damn strong tasting so it isn't homeopathy, just a natural product being used as a medication. Some herbs may have some medical benefits. With homeopathy, it is impossible for it to have any benefits (beyond placebo) since it is nothing but water.
 
Same with colloidal silver that is another current snake oil.


But if you ingest it, all you get is expensive shit!

Not quite, if you take enough of it, your skin turns blue.

It happened to this guy in the states, IIRC he was a libertarian politician preparing for Y2K.

So what, you got a problem with looking like a smurf.