Hockey in decline

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
45,734
11,193
113
Roger Lajoie did this topic recently on the Fan 590; he used Scarborough as a focal point for his argument. Enrollment in hockey in Scarborough has collapsed by 75%, while enrollment in soccer and basketball is booming. I've known this for years but it's never been discussed openly. So why is hockey in decline?

The cost is prohibitive, for anyone making less than a six figure income the cost of putting a child into a hockey program is a real financial strain.

If the child has talent he may become the target of a white trash goon who has no business being on a rink.

Due to the supposedly advanced protective head gear, players are no longer taught to control their sticks.

Due to rock hard elbow and shoulder pads, the incident of concussion has never been higher.

The system gives too much power to agents and coaches over prospects; it allows wastes of skin like Craig James and David Frost to thrive.

At the top level the NHL is being grossly missmanaged. Gary Bettman is driving the NHL into the ground in the same manner that Harold Ballard pulverized the Maple Leafs.

Hockey is being promoted as a warrior sport and goonery is being glorified. IMHO fighting in hockey looks stupid and cheapens a fast and exciting game. Hockey has become the trashy cousin of the WWE.

Goons have no business in hockey. If the officials were allowed to do their jobs properly fighting could be taken out of the game. Goons like Peters, Laraque and Boogard should ply their trade in the UFC.

Cocaine use in the NHL has reached epidemic proportions. Last summer I attended a charity event with an ex-Leaf as guest of honour. I could barely contain my anger when I went to shake his hand and saw the red ring of cocaine use on his nostril.

I have more points to make but this may be enough to get me roasted on a spit by hockey fans. This is my opinion and I'm sticking to it. I recently attended a St Mike's Majors game, after the third fight I left the Hershey Center in disgust.
 
Insidious Von said:
Roger Lajoie did this topic recently on the Fan 590; he used Scarborough as a focal point for his argument. Enrollment in hockey in Scarborough has collapsed by 75%, while enrollment in soccer and basketball is booming. I've known this for years but it's never been discussed openly. So why is hockey in decline?
Scarborough is a bad example. The demographic of the area has changed over the years and the current demographic in that area has their roots in other areas of the world where soccer is king.

When I lived in Scarborough the guy organized baseball had the same complaint that all the kids wanted to play soccer but few were interested in baseball.
 
Insidious Von said:
So why is hockey in decline?

The cost is prohibitive, for anyone making less than a six figure income the cost of putting a child into a hockey program is a real financial strain.

If the child has talent he may become the target of a white trash goon who has no business being on a rink.

Due to the supposedly advanced protective head gear, players are no longer taught to control their sticks.

Due to rock hard elbow and shoulder pads, the incident of concussion has never been higher.
I think you make some good points. I believe all of the above represent barriers to some children taking up the sport. On the other hand, Canada is on a 5 year gold winning streak at the World Junior Championships. This would suggest that what happens in Scarborough is not the same as what happens in the rest of the country.

Insidious Von said:
The system gives too much power to agents and coaches over prospects; it allows wastes of skin like Craig James and David Frost to thrive.

At the top level the NHL is being grossly missmanaged. Gary Bettman is driving the NHL into the ground in the same manner that Harold Ballard pulverized the Maple Leafs.

Hockey is being promoted as a warrior sport and goonery is being glorified. IMHO fighting in hockey looks stupid and cheapens a fast and exciting game. Hockey has become the trashy cousin of the WWE.

Goons have no business in hockey. If the officials were allowed to do their jobs properly fighting could be taken out of the game. Goons like Peters, Laraque and Boogard should ply their trade in the UFC.

Cocaine use in the NHL has reached epidemic proportions. Last summer I attended a charity event with an ex-Leaf as guest of honour. I could barely contain my anger when I went to shake his hand and saw the red ring of cocaine use on his nostril.

I have more points to make but this may be enough to get me roasted on a spit by hockey fans. This is my opinion and I'm sticking to it. I recently attended a St Mike's Majors game, after the third fight I left the Hershey Center in disgust.
I would agree that the prevalence of violence in hockey is a turnoff for many parents and kids. I grew up idolizing hockey heroes and played organized hockey right through high school. While I wouldn't necessarily prohibit a kid from playing, there are other sports that I would encourage a kid to play before I took him to the neighbourhood hockey rink.

Your other points, while they may be valid, surely have little to do with the decline of popularity of hockey in Scarborough and other areas. You are saying that parents of an 8 year old in Scarborough think about how much power coaches and player agents have and tell their kids to play soccer because of it? Seems a little far fetched to me. Same with cocaine use. Ever heard of Maradonna?

As for Betteman, I am far from a fan. The way he has prioritized expansion into non-traditional markets in US has come at a cost to possible Canadian markets, especially places like Hamilton, Quebec City and Winnepeg. But this has got to be way down the list of reasons kids whose parents were born in places like Hong Kong, Mozambique, Pakistan or Colombia do not take up hockey.
 
While there are some good points raised, it may simply come down to cost.

The older your child gets in organized hockey the more expensive it gets. The equipment, extra ice time, team events, tournaments etc can really add up. Even more if your child is playing on a Rep team.

It would be interesting to see if this is just isolated to Scarborough.

Another factor may be the changing ethnicity of the area. Hockey may not be something that appeals to all ethnic groups.
 
As far as I'm concerned hockey can go the way of the dodo bird. Have absolutely no interest in it, but was addicted to it in the 70's, 80's and 90's. Not anymore. I wouldn't walk across the street to see a hockey game. I think the final straw was Bertuzzi suckering Moore.
 
This may or may not have anything to do with this thread, but it is a topic that I have been thinking about a lot lately. This afternoon, I was able to catch part of an interview on the Fan590. The guy being interviewed made reference to kids being able to simply go outside and play hockey on outdoor rinks. Then watching the recent Outdoor Winter Classic, you hear reference to how the game brings these players back to growing up playing outside, on the ponds, etc.

Well, where are all these ponds and outdoor rinks? Where I grew up back in the late 1960's, there were 4-5 great outdoor hockey rinks within 15 minutes drive in Hamilton. You could find them all over the city, nice rinks with boards set up for hockey, that were very well maintained. These rinks were packed from sun up til sundown. I can't find any in the city today and I would hazard a guess that there aren't any around. In fact, I can't remember the last time I saw one anywhere around here. Supposedly there are several in Toronto?

An outdoor skating rink (no hockey allowed) was built recently over in the town of Dundas. During the holidays I went out of my way to drive over a few times hoping to have a skate. Every time I went over, the ice was snow covered, the rink was empty and off I went.

So again, where are all these outdoor rinks that kids supposedly can go to today? Are there any in the city or town where you live? I know of one over at Bronte Creek, just off Burloak Drive, but I believe they charge you something like $13.00 just to drive into the park? WTF? I can go to the local indoor rink and play shinny for a lot less than that.
 
Due to fighting hockey is becoming a game played by morons for the amusement of morons. The junior world championships is quickly becoming the hockey highlight of the year for most Canadians. And I saw not one fight.
 
Thoughs from Abroad

Outside of Canada, hockey is a laughing stock. Especially the NHL. World Junior or Olympic hockey has some more cred but not much. Here, we're conditioned to think that everyone likes it. It's not true at all. My European relatives ask me if this is the game where if you punch another player, you get to relax in a box for a few minutes. (The red card rule should apply). The Bertuzzi episode was the last straw. Why isn't he in jail for assault? At the very least, he should not be allowed to play professional sports of any kind, anywhere. For those who think it's part of the game, those are fans of 'goonship' not hockey. Same as the European goons that wreck havoc with no connection to the sport. I have no interest in it anyway, no real sports fan should. The international view puts it all into clear, simple perspective.
 
first off, when it comes to incidents, such as the bertuzzi/moore fiasco, yes, stuff like that has no place in the game. but do not be naive to think that this nonsense only happens in the game of hockey.

boxing...mike tyson, biting ears off, threatening to eat children, raping women, etc;.

football...guys murdering their girlfriends/child (caruth), hall of famers murdering and getting away with it (o.j.), drugs, assault charges, etc;.

and the game that is the worst for poor sportsmanship and overpaying it's athletes, soccer. watch the italian diving, errr, soccer team play, whiny diving morons (if it offends you, fuck you). fans rioting, throwing fireworks and homemade pipe bombs in the stands, killing each other in the stadium and on the streets. overpaid bums. hockey fans don't kill players when they cost their own team the game...remember the colombian back in the 90's, during the world cup?

point being, you can pinpoint all types of garbage in any sport.

to those of you advocating the removal of fighting in the game, put on your panties, get your dress and purse ready with the matching shoes, and go to your nearest tree huggers support meetings, sip on your imported flavoured water, and STFU.

there are plenty of us that enjoy the game, warts and all. fighting has it's place in the game. the game also has no shortage of sublimely skilled players to sit back, watch and enjoy. watch ovechkin, kane, crosby, malkin, zetterberg, iginla, datsyuk, kovalev, nash, carter, vanek. etc;, and you will see the game is in good hands for the future. hockey is played with skill and passion, and things happen in the heat of the moment. if you have played the game, you will understand that, right or wrong, sometimes emotions do get the best of a player, and better judgement gets blurred. i do not advocate some of the incidents that do go over the top, the hitting from behind and the reckless use of sticks, but fighting has it's time and place.

Plyrs99
 
There was an interesting series in the Sun a few weeks back about the GTHL, the kids league in Toronto. The OMHA, for Ontario outside Toronto, is the biggest in the world, and similar. These leagues are run by 80-year-old guys who think that everyone wants to play hockey, and will put up with any crap from the league to do it. They assert their right to own players for a player's whole career based on where he lives, they spy on parents, and they are not accountable at all to the parents who pay for it. 30 years ago, people would take it because society worked that way, and it was the only game in town. Now parents will not take it, so they put their kids in soccer instead. Until the GTHL and OMHA recognize that it is not 1954 anymore, I think minor hockey will keep declining.
 
Insidious Von said:
Roger Lajoie did this topic recently on the Fan 590; he used Scarborough as a focal point for his argument. Enrollment in hockey in Scarborough has collapsed by 75%, while enrollment in soccer and basketball is booming. I've known this for years but it's never been discussed openly. So why is hockey in decline?.

What I find interesting though is that the TV ratings still seem to be sky high for hockey and very low for basketball. I wonder if any recent NBA ratings in Canada are available online. I am quite sure that basketball ratings are very low in Canada. That being said I cant remember the last time I watched a hockey game on TV, maybe 2006, I usually watch basketball or football instead of hockey.
 
So far no one has said they actually love the sport as a fan or as a current participant. Hockey like many team sports is one can play until they are ready for the cemetary. I played myself in rec leagues until I was over 50. Pick a sport or sports in general and play in a rec league or pickup and just enjoy it as many of us did when we were kids.
Chances are your kid isn't going to anywhere professionally and those who do they and their parents committed and devoted themselves to getting there with effort, sweat and the chequebook.
I had a kid go thru the MTHL to a junior league and university hockey and the best thing of those many years is that he is still playing rec hockey today winter and summer and he enjoys it for the love of the sport. The next best thing and the one I think is the most important is that his friends from the youth sport days are still his friends today and all are doing well in life.
Let your kids live their dreams not yours.
 
Having a kid playing triple A hockey myself what I think the decline comes down to is Time and Money..cost me 3600 a year just for the season, on top of that is the hotels and tourney fees, sticks over 100 bucks a pop and equiptment and then the time, 2 games a week and a minimum of 2 practices a week, with games and practices all over the GTA, it feels like a part time job just getting him around...on top of all the costs there is a 5 dollar entrance fee per player and each family member just to watch the kid play...not cheap at all....I fully support my son playing anything he has a passion for and will always have or make the time for it, but I can totally see how families on a tight budget would stick to soccer
 
Tao said:
Having a kid playing triple A hockey myself what I think the decline comes down to is Time and Money..cost me 3600 a year just for the season, on top of that is the hotels and tourney fees, sticks over 100 bucks a pop and equiptment and then the time, 2 games a week and a minimum of 2 practices a week, with games and practices all over the GTA, it feels like a part time job just getting him around...on top of all the costs there is a 5 dollar entrance fee per player and each family member just to watch the kid play...not cheap at all....I fully support my son playing anything he has a passion for and will always have or make the time for it, but I can totally see how families on a tight budget would stick to soccer
Thanks for the insiders view Tao. I am sure you are talking $5000 easy, with all expenses considered. And that's just for one kid. What happens if you have 3 or 4 kids?

Assuming limited income of parents, which do you choose? Soccer, and socking away a few bucks for retirement and the kids' education fund? Or hockey? One can see why a lot of parents steer kids to other sports and activities.

Good for you for supporting your kid, Tao. Triple A...that would be what age? And is it a recreational level or one of the more competitive leagues? $ bucks to watch your own kid play hockey. LOL So I'm guessing this is hockey at a fairly serious level. Mid teens.
 
Hockey has become an elite-ist sport. It is expensive to play. That's why you seldom see kids from the inner cities in the NHL.

But Scarborough is not a good barometer either of the popularity of hockey with its large working class immigrant population, the cost and lack of attachment to the game is a deterrent... ie. the cost is not worth it to parents who have no attachment to the game, unlike say to a parent who grew up loving/playing hockey and wants to pass that down to his kid even though it is expensive.
 
Hockey

I too grew up in Hamilton in the early mid sixties.We had scads of outdoor rinks. I learned to skate at Victoria Park where there were two hockey rinks with boards on the upper level and a pleasure rink below on the ball diamond area.My first orgainized hockey league was an outdoor facility down by the 403 by Cootes Paradise with no roof or zamboni We used to skate side by side with plywood shovels to scrape the ice. I wont talk about the wind chill factor coming off the lake!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Fire Dept. would flood a lot of the rinks for the kids back then.I can recall spending hours on the outdoor rinks as a kid.We had a little Italian mom who would come every night with a big pot of soup on a sled and give it to us because we taught her two boy how to skate and be Canadian boys.

The kids thesedays have no idea what fun is !!!!!!!!
 
Questor said:
Triple A...that would be what age? And is it a recreational level or one of the more competitive leagues? $ bucks to watch your own kid play hockey. LOL So I'm guessing this is hockey at a fairly serious level. Mid teens.

14 year olds and within the GTHL its pretty competitive at least amongst the parents anyway..lol but some good hockey is played, nice to see some ex nhler's children playing in the league, yes the cost skyrocket to over 5 grand when you tally all the totals of tourneys state side etc..

One bit the Toronto Sun article touched on that we have always found ridiculous within the league is WHY do our kids need new leather team jackets, 2 sets of warm up gear, spring jackets and pants, 3 team jersey's home away and vintage (they are 14) yes they out grow the stuff as they are at that age, but the 3600 bucks could be cut down quite a bit if they just cut back on all the extra crap...I have a closet full of leather team jackets from the age of 5 to 14..
 
Tao said:
Having a kid playing triple A hockey myself what I think the decline comes down to is Time and Money..cost me 3600 a year just for the season, on top of that is the hotels and tourney fees, sticks over 100 bucks a pop and equiptment and then the time, 2 games a week and a minimum of 2 practices a week, with games and practices all over the GTA, it feels like a part time job just getting him around...on top of all the costs there is a 5 dollar entrance fee per player and each family member just to watch the kid play...not cheap at all....I fully support my son playing anything he has a passion for and will always have or make the time for it, but I can totally see how families on a tight budget would stick to soccer

what a bunch of bullshit

hockey is too fucking expensive

Parents have to be real dedicated. I have respect for you Tao and all the other hockey parents in Toronto who in addition to costs and hours of commitment have to brave the traffic driving across the GTA.

Its definitely different outside big cities, where most kids grow up playing hockey and the arena is the place to be etc...

When I was a kid I would have loved to play hockey. My father didn't want to deal with the time and money efforts involved. Of course I hated him for it, but looking back, I now understand.
 
They should tie all sports to the school system. What better way to babysit your kid from when the school bell rings, until you can pick them up after work ( or vice versa in the morning)? Plus, you don't have knucklehead parents around. And you allow kids from low incomes to participate...I could go on and on.

I really don't understand how hockey managed to get to this point. Especially junior hockey. Even if I had a son had w/ incredible talent, there's no way in hell I'd let him leave home at 14 yrs of age, allow him basically quit school, and let him be a slave to some rich team owner. And to top it off, have the great unwashed stand and cheer him on to punch another child in the face. Insanity!
 
eighthsamurai said:
I really don't understand how hockey managed to get to this point. Especially junior hockey. Even if I had a son had w/ incredible talent, there's no way in hell I'd let him leave home at 14 yrs of age, allow him basically quit school, and let him be a slave to some rich team owner. And to top it off, have the great unwashed stand and cheer him on to punch another child in the face. Insanity!

Kids don't leave home at age 14 to play in the CHL. In the Ontario Hockey League a player must be 16 to be drafted. John Tavares was granted 'exceptional player status' when Oshawa selected him as a 14 year old and he was 15 when he began his OHL career (less a few days that is). The only other 14 year old I can think of to have played in the OHL was Bobby Orr. Tavares was a very special case and I'd say it all turned out okay for him.

As for the kids being allowed to 'basically quit school', that couldn't be further from the truth. The CHL has very strict policies on education across all three leagues.

In the OHL, players get all their expenses, education and otherwise, fully covered by their teams during their junior careers, and afterwards, provided they don’t turn pro, they receive an education package to continue their studies at a Canadian university. Teams employ Educational Consultants and all players are expected to be in school.

Fighting is down in the OHL and David Branch has just implemented new rules regarding fighting. Players will now receive a game misconduct plus one game suspension for removing their own helmets prior to a fight as well as removing an opponents helmet durng a fight.

There is nothing wrong with the CHL. Surely you are thinking of how it was many years ago when brawling was commonplace and schooling was not enforced as it is today. You also will not see a bunch of runaway 14 year old high school dropouts playing in these leagues.