Hitler ordered Luftwaffe to spare Blackpool

Rockslinger said:
Maybe 225,000 was the original German attack force and 134,000 were killed, escaped or MIA. 91,000 captured alive.

I read that in total 5000 German soldiers came back alive after the war from Stalingrad. Which means that almost all the 91,000 captured soldiers died one way or a nother.
 
oagre said:
I think you're may be referring to Cossack units who had switched sides to fight with the Nazis and were then captured by the British. It would be pretty standard for all nations to shoot such traitors in the 40's.

Ordinary Soviets who had been captured were treated unkindly when freed by their comrades later. But they were not shot. The death rate for Soviet PoW's in German hands was astronomical anyway. Few ever survived to be rescued.
Certainly your last point is true. As to your first still "we" should have known better, and given the Russian Revolution, the little and Great Terrors etc. . . the use of the word "traitor" is problematic.
 
oagre said:
Source for that?

Not sure I can ever find an official source. This was one of those unpleasant post war suppressed facts. I learned about it from a mother whose son served in the British 8th Army. He said that the oridinary soldiers were ordered by their superiors to put these poor souls on trains to be delivered to Stalin and that their fate was sealed. Given what we now know about Stalin, it is more than plausible that the story is true.
 
Rockslinger said:
Not sure I can ever find an official source. This was one of those unpleasant post war suppressed facts. I learned about it from a mother whose son served in the British 8th Army. He said that the oridinary soldiers were ordered by their superiors to put these poor souls on trains to be delivered to Stalin and that their fate was sealed. Given what we now know about Stalin, it is more than plausible that the story is true.

Perhaps you're referring to this? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victims_of_Yalta

jwm
 
jwmorrice said:
Perhaps you're referring to this?

Yes, this must be it. Sad, so sad, those poor souls. In letters home to his mom, the British soldier said he and his fellow soldiers carried out the repatriation orders with an extremely heavy heart. He said that some of the Russians actually threw their bodies in front of the trains.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Certainly your last point is true. As to your first still "we" should have known better, and given the Russian Revolution, the little and Great Terrors etc. . . the use of the word "traitor" is problematic.

Point taken. Although most Russians would have agreed with what Stalin did to the returnees at the time.

The Ukrainians are far more ambivalent and seem to find at least some of the pro-German auxiliary fighters are heroes.

Given that Hitler's eventual aim was the extermination of all but a few Slavs and given the gross brutality of German behaviour in the USSR, Stalin was a better choice than Hitler.
 
oagre said:
Point taken. Although most Russians would have agreed with what Stalin did to the returnees at the time.

The Ukrainians are far more ambivalent and seem to find at least some of the pro-German auxiliary fighters are heroes.
Particularly in the Western ethnically Ukrainian part of Ukraine, they are seen not as pro-German, but rather as anti-Soviet. Recall the huge artificial famines (created by the Soviet Government) which decimated Ukraine.

Yes, there is a huge desire in the Russian Psyche for "the Man on the White Horse." It is quite curious one can talk with people who had relatives who were executed (murdered) on the direct order of Stalin who will give you the "but he made the Country great" argument. I could go on, but it gets personal (failed-marriage) for me. I hasten to say that not all Russians, buy into this, but unfortunately far too many do.
 
oagre said:
Stalin was a better choice than Hitler.

OMG what a choice. Take your pick of poisons. Very few people on Earth have suffered as much as the Russians. Now, Russia is actually depopulating at a fairly quick pace. Also, Russian men rarely live to see their 58th birthday.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
Many Russian women I know would probably say that's not a bad thing... ;)

I should edit my post to read: "Russian men rarely live to see their 55th birthday."

Does anybody know how Volka was invented? Here's a hint: potatos.
 
Rockslinger said:
Did German bombers have fighter escorts (you know what I mean) during the Battle of Britain? Or, was Britain out of range for German fighter planes?

Also, late in the war the German launched the ME-262 (check name) jet fighter plane. Did the Americans or Brits or Russians have an equilvalent?
german fighters had ten minutes over london more over the south east (kent) where most of the british fighter bases were. up north and the midlands manchester liverpool coventry etc no german fighters there bombers came from norway but the fighters did not have the range thats what brings up the kill ratio the bombers up north really got hammered
 
Captain Fantastic said:
Many Russian women I know would probably say that's not a bad thing... ;)
Our experiences may be different. But the situation is more complex than that. Not all Russian men are drunks, and there probably is not a shortage of decent men for decent girls in the ranks of the 20-somethings particularly in the major cities.

Where things turn bad for Russian women is when they are now in their 30s divorced with a child, now the good catch Russian men would pass up a living saint for someone younger without a child.
 
Meister said:
I guess the Brits never planned on using Dresden as a vacation resort after the war.
coventry,liverpool london........payback's a bitch guess you had to be there,but i got a lot of first hand stories over the years. my dad is 92 and he still hates germans
 
My Mom's small town in Wales got taken out as well - probably due to a navigation error. Half the kids in her high school class didn't show for school after that or ever again.

She doesn't feel sorry about Dresden either.
 
doggee_01 said:
coventry,liverpool london........payback's a bitch guess you had to be there,but i got a lot of first hand stories over the years. my dad is 92 and he still hates germans

I can't say anything because the usual suspects will accuse me of being anti-Loony Liberal Left.
 
The Houdini said:
I read that in total 5000 German soldiers came back alive after the war from Stalingrad. Which means that almost all the 91,000 captured soldiers died one way or a nother.

Yes, that is what I read as well:

"Of the nearly 350,000 men who had followed Paulus to Stalingrad, only 90,000 half-starved men survived to surrender to the Soviets. The Russians kept about 20,000 of that 90,000 to remain as forced labor in Stalingrad to work at rebuilding the city they destroyed. The rest were dispatched to numerous POW camps scattered from Siberia to Soviet Central Asia. Many died shortly after the surrender from a Typhus epidemic brought about by Lice and the unsanitary conditions experienced during the battle. Many more died of malnutrition, disease and neglect in the various prison camps run by the Soviets. Of the 90,000 who surrendered with Paulus, only 5,000 men survived to return home to Germany. Many of these men were held captive the longest by the Russians, as their release wasn't finally secured by W. German Chancellor Konrad Adenauer until 1955.

When you tally the figures for the German 6th Army and its allied auxiliaries which supported the march to the Volga, the numbers are both impressive and distressing. The Germans lost about 350,000 men, the Italians, Hungarians and Romanians about 100,000 men apiece. The Red Army also must have lost at least 500,000 men in Stalingrad and the surrounding areas which were adjunct to the battle. Also, Stalingrad was estimated to have had 850,000 residents in 1940. It isn't known how many of them may have escaped the carnage and vanished into the interior of Russia. But after 1945, a census showed only 1500 of these people still remained in the pile of rubble that had once been Stalingrad."
 
Aardvark154 said:
Our experiences may be different. But the situation is more complex than that. Not all Russian men are drunks, and there probably is not a shortage of decent men for decent girls in the ranks of the 20-somethings particularly in the major cities.

Where things turn bad for Russian women is when they are now in their 30s divorced with a child, now the good catch Russian men would pass up a living saint for someone younger without a child.
I was exaggerating as a form of humour.

But there are a lot of female Russian ex-pats who see a huge (positive) difference in Canadian/American men vs. Russian men. It's not just the drunkenness - although that doesn't help - it's the attitude towards women in general. Plus those Ruskie men are ugly as sin! :D (Kidding, sheesh.)

Having only visited Russia, I can't say for sure, but I can see how and why Russian women would think this. Yes, it's a generalization, but it also has a bearing in truth, like all stereotypes...
 
LancsLad said:
There was a very controversial book published some years back called "Other Losses", i think the author was a french guy.

It discussed how the germans captured by the various Allied Armies fared and what their post war treatment was like.

Seems that for the hun, being captured by the commies was less than ideal.


.

Pay-back is a bitch.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
But there are a lot of female Russian ex-pats who see a huge (positive) difference in Canadian/American men vs. Russian men.

To be perfectly candid, when a Russian woman looks at a Canadian or American male, they see MONEY. Cuban women see the same thing. Thai women see the same thing. It is the dream of every young Thai (or Cuban or Russian) lady to marry a white man from Canada or the United States. Ever heard the term: "Russian mail order bride"?