Hermann Goering: The truth

That plus the fact that the Allied forces outmanned and outgunned Rommel's force.


[TABLE="class: infobox vevent, width: 315"]
[TR]
[TH="bgcolor: #B0C4DE, colspan: 2, align: center"]Commanders and leaders[/TH]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TD] Erwin Rommel
Georg Stumme †
Ettore Bastico[/TD]
[TD] Harold Alexander
Bernard Montgomery[/TD]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TH="bgcolor: #B0C4DE, colspan: 2, align: center"]Strength[/TH]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TD]116,000 men[SUP][1][/SUP][SUP][nb 1][/SUP]
547 tanks[SUP][nb 2][/SUP]
192 armoured cars[SUP][2][/SUP]
770[SUP][4][/SUP] – 900 aircraft (480 serviceable)[SUP][nb 3][/SUP]
552 artillery pieces[SUP][6][/SUP]
496 anti-tank guns[SUP][nb 4][/SUP] – 1,063[SUP][6][/SUP][/TD]
[TD]195,000 men[SUP][2][/SUP]
1,029 tanks[SUP][nb 5][/SUP]
435 armoured cars[SUP][2][/SUP]
730[SUP][nb 6][/SUP] – 750 aircraft (530 serviceable)[SUP][nb 7][/SUP]
892[SUP][6][/SUP] – 908 artillery pieces[SUP][2][/SUP]
1,451 anti-tank guns[SUP][2][/SUP][SUP][nb 8][/SUP][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]

Sun Tzu was able to fight an army 10 times it's size just through strategy and tactics, that is way before code breaking to gather intel, though I am certain that in his day he used the best means available to gather intel. Rommel was certainly outgunned and outmanned but nowhere near a 10 to 1, Rommel's edge was not strategy nor tactics, it was all 100% based on being able to read Allied messages.
 
Sun Tzu was able to fight an army 10 times it's size just through strategy and tactics, that is way before code breaking to gather intel, though I am certain that in his day he used the best means available to gather intel. Rommel was certainly outgunned and outmanned but nowhere near a 10 to 1, Rommel's edge was not strategy nor tactics, it was all 100% based on being able to read Allied messages.

Really? I always thought that the Desert Fox was one of Hitler's most brilliant commanders.

What say you of Patton?
 
Correct, Rommel was over-rated and he left my father to rot in Tobruk.

Had Heydrich lived there would have been at least six variations of the Enigma Machine, Turing and his team would have been overwhelmed. And he would have anticipated every move the Allies made prior to D-Day. He was killed by Czech commandos on June 4 1942, at the time Nazi Germany looked unstoppable. The Czechs paid a heavy price for the assassination, Nazi reprisals were brutal. And they were initially sold down the river by Chamberlain. The Czech contribution to win the war against the Nazis cannot be downplayed. Had they failed the war in Europe would have endured past 1948.

So raise a toast to the Czechs:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gcCrwrLAD4

The nazis were very laxed when it came to using Enigma, they were supremely confident that it could not be broken, truth is that the germans were right; Enigma could not be broken if it was properly used. Sloppy use of Enigma, reusing old enigma settings, was the break the Allies needed to break Enigma in addition to actually capturing a working Enigma machine and code book. Had there been several variations of Enigma with the same usage sloppiness, Turing would have been able to break all the variations eventually. D day would have been greatly delayed, but even so time was not on Germany's side, Russia was comming for them and the Allies were making nukes, but maybe Germany would have been able to negotiate a peace that still gave germany some of the land it captured and perhaps germany today would be like the North Korea we know now but with a strong economy and much more advanced technology.
 
The nazis were very laxed when it came to using Enigma, they were supremely confident that it could not be broken, truth is that the germans were right; Enigma could not be broken if it was properly used. Sloppy use of Enigma, reusing old enigma settings, was the break the Allies needed to break Enigma in addition to actually capturing a working Enigma machine and code book. Had there been several variations of Enigma with the same usage sloppiness, Turing would have been able to break all the variations eventually. D day would have been greatly delayed, but even so time was not on Germany's side, Russia was comming for them and the Allies were making nukes, but maybe Germany would have been able to negotiate a peace that still gave germany some of the land it captured and perhaps germany today would be like the North Korea we know now but with a strong economy and much more advanced technology.

Thank God.
 
Really? I always thought that the Desert Fox was one of Hitler's most brilliant commanders.

What say you of Patton?

He may have been Hitler's most brilliant commanders, if so then it just makes all of Hitler's commanders look bad. Hitler always put party and loyalty before anything else, so any commander/general under Hitler was more often than not; not suitable for the job.

When Rommel was not able to read Allied intel anymore and started to take huge losses, Hitler continued to force him to fight the war as if he was winning. A brilliant military commander really shows his brilliance when the chips are down, Hitler never let Rommel use strategic retreats as a tactic/strategy, so weather Rommel was truly brilliant or not is still up for debate, though if he was super duper brilliant he would have been able to continue to gain ground in spite of not being able to read Allied Intel and Hitler would not have had the opportunity to dictate how Rommel should fight his war.

I have no idea about Patton.
 
Can't help thinking about this cartoon reading this thread:
 
That plus the fact that the Allied forces outmanned and outgunned Rommel's force.
..

In my eyes, the simple factor in the North Africa campaign was logistics. North Africa was lower on the German's agenda so they weren't getting the bulk of supplies. For the first part, Rommel had to rely heavily on Italian troops and materials. Even when he started to get better German equipment, the inability to capture a functioning Eastern Med. port, the lengthening of supply lines and the inability of the Luftwaffe to control the air in Egypt meant that the best Rommel could do would have been a draw (and that was before the US entered the theater with Torch).
 
Germany become North Korea like does not make me shudder as much as the thought of Japan turning into a North Korea, thank god.

I'm not sure about that. Germany might have invented nukes and cruise missiles much sooner than Japan would.

If Germany did not fight many fronts, do you think they were superior militarily than Japan? (When I was a kid, me and my friends would read about the military might of these axis powers. I remember reading about the fates of the Bismarck and Yamato.)
 
I'm not sure about that. Germany might have invented nukes and cruise missiles much sooner than Japan would.

If Germany did not fight many fronts, do you think they were superior militarily than Japan? (When I was a kid, me and my friends would read about the military might of these axis powers. I remember reading about the fates of the Bismarck and Yamato.)

It has nothing to do with military might, Japan for the most part of it's existence has been a pariah in the region, they have a super strong "warrior" mentality, and worse of all they have incredible faith in their god king the emperor. I am not talking about faith like the North Koreans have faith in their god king, which is a mix of ignorance and fear, but the type of faith that we see with the 911 hijackers, it is a very different quality of faith. Even after the Allies firebombed the sh*t out of Japan they still fought on, even without oil and fuel they still fought on, even after the first nuke they still fought on, I took a 2nd nuke to bring them to reality. Mind you Germany fought on even after many disasters, but they fought on so that they could surrender to the Americans rather than surrendering to the Russians, there is a logical justification for Germany's continued struggle even when all hope is lost. Japan just fought on because they had faith in their emperor and they were certain that they were under the good graces of whatever god they worshipped.

When the US invaded okinawa and some other island I forget the name of, every Japanese man, women, and child fought to the death. Such a stomach for war and death is without precedent.
 
It has nothing to do with military might, Japan for the most part of it's existence has been a pariah in the region, they have a super strong "warrior" mentality, and worse of all they have incredible faith in their god king the emperor. I am not talking about faith like the North Koreans have faith in their god king, which is a mix of ignorance and fear, but the type of faith that we see with the 911 hijackers, it is a very different quality of faith. Even after the Allies firebombed the sh*t out of Japan they still fought on, even without oil and fuel they still fought on, even after the first nuke they still fought on, I took a 2nd nuke to bring them to reality. Mind you Germany fought on even after many disasters, but they fought on so that they could surrender to the Americans rather than surrendering to the Russians, there is a logical justification for Germany's continued struggle even when all hope is lost. Japan just fought on because they had faith in their emperor and they were certain that they were under the good graces of whatever god they worshipped.

When the US invaded okinawa and some other island I forget the name of, every Japanese man, women, and child fought to the death. Such a stomach for war and death is without precedent.


No wonder there were movies made about long-lost and forgotten Japanese warriors on secluded islands years after the end of WWII.

But if you don't factor in that warrior mentality, which can't trump superior military technology, was Germany better suited to beating Japan? Both sides had amazing armaments but Germany seemed to have made a deal with the devil and seemed to be on the cutting edge of military technology including rocketry, jet power and cruise missiles (buzz bombs).
 
Oh yes I read the story of a group of japanese commandos still operating in the jungles of the philipines like a decade after the war was over, they did not surrender until their old commander came out to tell them the war was over. It is batsh*t crazy, but it is illustrative of their warrior mentality.

In terms of military tech Germany was at the cutting edge, at the end of the war they even had jet fighters that could go twice as fast as propeller planes and even shipped out a few to the japanese for them to copy. So without a doubt if germany fought japan they would win based on conventional metrics; kill to loss ratio, amount of land gained/liberated, etc... but unless germany dropped 2 nukes on japan they would not be able to land the killing blow and if they tried to land the killing blow germany would probably end up losing. It is like punching a crazy guy in the head, you will end up breaking your fists before you can convince him that you won the fight.
 
Given the way the Duffy trial is going I predict the arrest of a terrorist cell in next few days
 
Oh yes I read the story of a group of japanese commandos still operating in the jungles of the philipines like a decade after the war was over, they did not surrender until their old commander came out to tell them the war was over. It is batsh*t crazy, but it is illustrative of their warrior mentality.

In terms of military tech Germany was at the cutting edge, at the end of the war they even had jet fighters that could go twice as fast as propeller planes and even shipped out a few to the japanese for them to copy. So without a doubt if germany fought japan they would win based on conventional metrics; kill to loss ratio, amount of land gained/liberated, etc... but unless germany dropped 2 nukes on japan they would not be able to land the killing blow and if they tried to land the killing blow germany would probably end up losing. It is like punching a crazy guy in the head, you will end up breaking your fists before you can convince him that you won the fight.

Excellent.

Fuji had mentioned that after the atomic bombs were dropped, The Soviet Union declared war against Japan. This could've been the impetus for Japan's surrender (I never heard this before but he gave some details about it).
 
When the US invaded Okinawa and some other island I forget the name of, every Japanese man, women, and child fought to the death.
Bishop, I think you make good points about the pre-1946 attitude of the Japanese people.

The other island you are thinking of is Iwo Jima.

One of the most fascinating conversations I've ever been party to were a married couple, family friends talking after dinner about the invasion of Okinawa, he was a U.S. Navy Officer on a Destroyer in the invasion fleet, she was from an Okinawian family.
 
Bishop, I think you make good points about the pre-1946 attitude of the Japanese people.

The other island you are thinking of is Iwo Jima.

One of the most fascinating conversations I've ever been party to were a married couple, family friends talking after dinner about the invasion of Okinawa, he was a U.S. Navy Officer on a Destroyer in the invasion fleet, she was from an Okinawian family.

Yes Iwo Jima.

If you ever watch war footage of the invasion it is stomach turning, American GI's with flame throwers burning every hole they come across because if they did not some kid would run out and stab them with some homemade bamboo spear.
 
Yes Iwo Jima.

If you ever watch war footage of the invasion it is stomach turning, American GI's with flame throwers burning every hole they come across because if they did not some kid would run out and stab them with some homemade bamboo spear.

Farking unbelievable.
 
Goering was a drug addict and a war criminal and an incompetent leader but in the statement of the op he was bang on. Give most people a map and flag of their home or ethnic country and a national anthem or a charismatic leader and they'll go to the depths of hell blidly fighting their fellow humans over some made up prehistoric barbaric idea that their county , leader , land , religion is the best most worthy cause in the history of ignorant humans.
Makes me sick sick sick.
I can see becoming a nihalist, an extreme nihalist. Is their a group I could join where we all sit around and do drugs and don't give a shit together. We can cheer for isis and North Korea and celebrate the assassinations of Kennedy brothers and ghandi and Rabin.
 
Yes Iwo Jima.
Iwo Jima was pretty bad but I think you were originally referring to Saipan and "suicide cliff".

Units of the Japanese Army were still fighting in the jungles of Malaysia into September 1945 (a month after the official surrender). Despite broadcasts from helicopters advising them to surrender they thought it was an American trick.