Heavy Snowfall + Ice Dams = leaking roof

punter

New member
Oct 13, 2002
2,376
0
0
Toronto
With the recent Heavy Snowfall and then partial thawing, my roof started to leak in my living room. From reasearch I did on the web, there is nothing wrong with my roof (the house is only 6 years old), but the problem is one of inadequate drainage due to ice dams on the eaves. From what I've read, one possible solution is to install snow-melt cables all around the roof. I've seen these at Home depot before but funny how I've never met anyone who installed them on their house or seen a house with them. I can't be the only one experiencing this. Does anyone have any experience or information about this?
 
I'm sure Rubmeister will comment further but this isn't as uncommon as you may imagine especially in our climate where you could get +10 one day and a blizzard the next at -10.

What happens is as the snow melts it wants to run down your eaves troughs but can't and then when the temp drops it builds up. When it thaws again you can have the water wick up under your shingles. This happens a lot on lower pitched roofs (steeper pitched roofs cause the snow to slide right off).

Now I'm not an expert on this but just adding the cables along the edges won't solve all the problems. The melted snow/ice has to go somewhere so you have to clear the ice jam in the eavestroughs too.

I've seen quite a few of these heating cables along many roofs in and around toronto. Not like every second house mind you but enough to remember them.....
 
Depending on the slope of your roof you can get away with just running the cables along the eaves troff and melt away a path for the water to escape.

If you want to install them on the roof the cable come with clips to attach to your roof's shingles. Again depending on the slope of your roof you could try to place the cables in the correct position and attempt to melt the ice now. clipping to the shingles at this time is difficult for obvious reasons.

Good luck.

Cheers.
 
I am a contractor and see this frequently. The ice dam is a result of the insulation blocking the soffit area of your roof ( the area from the outer wall to the edge of the roof) This stops air flow under the roof deck and creates heat which melts and freezes the snow on the roof. The ice pushes up under the shingles and loosens them up. This causes deck damage and eventually rot. The easy solution is to go up into the attic in the spring ( everything will be frozen now) during the day, you should be able to see light streaming up around the edge of the roof line, where you can not the insulation has blocked the soffit and needs to be removed. The heating cables tend to shorten the life of the shingles due to the constant heating, the shingles are and asphalt product and soften up with heat. When they cool off they crack
 
punter said:
With the recent Heavy Snowfall and then partial thawing, my roof started to leak in my living room. From reasearch I did on the web, there is nothing wrong with my roof (the house is only 6 years old), but the problem is one of inadequate drainage due to ice dams on the eaves. From what I've read, one possible solution is to install snow-melt cables all around the roof. I've seen these at Home depot before but funny how I've never met anyone who installed them on their house or seen a house with them. I can't be the only one experiencing this. Does anyone have any experience or information about this?
I go thru this every year in one spot of my house. heating coils work wonders (i found out this winter) and so far no leaks. there is likely nothing wrong with your roof...but trust me put some coils along the valley of the roof and in the gutters and above the gutters about a foot up or so (valley if you have one I do)
 
De-icing Cables

I lived in a house in the outer GTA with the ice-melting cables and they work great! I think they need to be in the eaves as well, and the downspout. With heavy accumulation, you may have to get out there to pull some of the snow/ice down. Since it is not frozen to the roof, area's over porches, walkways & doors could be dangerous when it finally slides off the roof. I would suggest finding a manufaturer and speak directly with them, as opposed to trusting some pimply Home Depot CSR who justs wants to finish his shift & get out of there.

Here are a couple of resources I Googled:

The following paragraphs are an excerpt from The Canadian Building Digest, published by the Institute for Research in Construction, of the national Research Council of Canada: http://irc.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/pubs/cbd/cbd089_e.html

"When no, or only partial, action is possible in relation to the above considerations, the designer may have to consider the use of electric heating cables to maintain drainage channels through ice dams that form at the eaves and to keep gutters and downspouts open. These may be specially designed and fabricated for the job. Ready-to-install units, however, consisting of the heating cable, cold wire leads, and attachment plug are also available, usually as a kit complete with roof attachment clips. Heating cables may be single-wire or two-wire types of varying lengths, usually power rated at from 5 to 7 watts per lineal foot.

Heating cables are considered most effective when fastened along the eaves in a zig-zag fashion extending up the roof with points about 2 feet apart along the eave. The lower points should extend over the eaves to prevent icicles from forming at the end of the drainage channels. The cable is usually carried up the roof so that the upper points of the zig-zag are at least 6 inches past the interior wall line. With wide overhangs, this may not be necessary if the installation is operated to prevent an ice dam from growing. Where there is a gutter, cable should also be laid lengthwise in the gutter and carried down the downspout to keep them free of ice.

As faulty electric installations can create a fire or shock hazard, care must be exercised in the installation, with frequent checking for safe operation. Electrical connections should be moisture-proof and outlets installed in dry locations. The branch circuit supplying the cable must have sufficient capacity to carry the heating load, and all metal gutters and downspouts and all metal siding should be properly grounded. If the cables become twisted and overlap there is a danger that the insulation will melt at the overlap, causing a short circuit.

The usual recommendation for operation is that the power should be turned on whenever it snows, except when temperatures are above 45°F. Ice should never be allowed to form in the channels because the heat from the cables may not be sufficient to clear large ice dams once they have formed."



http://www.snowmeltcables.com/?ad=GAW&gclid=CJrvpb721ZECFQUqlgodIStMbQ

http://www.bylinusa.com/roof_ice_melt/RIM.html

http://www.canadianhomeworkshop.com/quickfix/deice.shtml
 
punter said:
Thanks very much, guys!

I love this country (being an immigrant) but I hate the Canadian winter!

LOL well, you're not alone! But to really be Canadian you have to learn to love it lol (ok, stop laughing now, really, lol)
 
And 2¢ more: Soffit vents are only half the picture, check that the vents at the top of your roof are still open too. What you're trying to do is keep the roof deck as close to ambient outside air temperature as possible. This minimizes melting. In a perfect world, snow would stay on your roof all winter, but if there's a dormer through the roof, or it's got a sunny exposure, melting will be encouraged, and goshdarnit, we get the odd warm day too..

Trouble is, when the melt-water gets to the bottom edge of the roof under the snow, where there's no warm house underneath, it freezes, and then the next day's melt can't get by and freezes farther up. And then you have a damn dam. The cables make a drainage path.

My roofer recommends using a snow rake to pull the bottom few feet of snow off the edge of the roof right after the storm. And I have the single cable in the gutters like rubmeister suggests.
 
All of the advice above is good. When a roof is reshingled a better alternative is to install 3 feet (or 6 feet if your soffits are 2 feet or larger) of ice and water shield with a drip edge. Also consider installing ice and water shield under the metal in the valleys as valleys can be a problem also. The standard 30 lb. vapour barrier required by the building code is better known as tarpaper is only the minimum of protection. Ice and water shield is virtually impervious to leaking. Even with ice and water shield I've still seen ice damming 10 feet up a slope. So even if you go the extra mile you can still have problems. I'm in the roofing business and I see these problems everyday.
 
I agree with the fixes offered by wawa and landscaper.

In addition the the Ice and Water Shield and adequate ventilation through the attic, also consider upgrading the attic insulation to the maximum recommended. This will prevent house heat from leaking into the attic and keep the underside of the roof deck cooler. This in turn will minimize the amount of snow melt, which is the major cause of the damming.

Incidentally, in spite of the popularity of the "heating cable solution", it is the least effective of the remedies offered.
 
johnnyone1 said:
Incidentally, in spite of the popularity of the "heating cable solution", it is the least effective of the remedies offered.

I think this mistakenly implies it does not do a sufficient job. That assumption would be incorrect. The cables will provide a cost-effective solution until you can afford $5000+ to tear up your roof for the other suggestions.
 
A.J. Raven said:
I think this mistakenly implies it does not do a sufficient job. That assumption would be incorrect. The cables will provide a cost-effective solution until you can afford $5000+ to tear up your roof for the other suggestions.

I do have credentials. I know what I am talking about.

I didn't say that the cables are "ineffective" I said that they are the "least effective" of the solutions.

For someone who has a serious ice-damming problem on a low-sloped roof, the insulation upgrade and improved ventilation are the better options.
 
johnnyone1 said:
I do have credentials. I know what I am talking about.

I didn't say that the cables are "ineffective" I said that they are the "least effective" of the solutions.

For someone who has a serious ice-damming problem on a low-sloped roof, the insulation upgrade and improved ventilation are the better options.

I never suggested anything about your "credentials", and that hardly trumps anyone else's experiences. But you definitely needed to clarify your point, and my post led you to do that. Thanks.
 
A.J. Raven said:
I never suggested anything about your "credentials", and that hardly trumps anyone else's experiences. But you definitely needed to clarify your point, and my post led you to do that. Thanks.

Point taken -- Thanks, Johnny:)
 
If you are leaking right now you need to clear a path to drain the water. If not it will leak by day and freeze by night when things cool down. Not only will this case issues with stains and rot but also possibly mold. Another thought is physical damage with freeze / thaw cycles. Analogous to pot holes in the road.

A quick and semi effective drainage aid till it is warn or safe enough for a permanent fix is to put ice melt into thin stockings and lay them on top and perpendicular to the dam to make troughs for water drainage.