Hamas supports two state Peace - almost

Palestine would be foolish to even think of such a thing. The head prosecutor has already stated that he would have to investigate both sides.

It is time for the Pali people to stop dreaming of non-existent boycotts and foreign white knights, and do some state building with all those handouts they get.

The PA is much more likely, and charges against them would be much less likely.
Hamas may have charges pressed, but stand to gain much more if Israel were forced to act according to international law, so maybe they would.
Its all conjecture at this point.

Which path would you prefer?
ICC charges on all sides
Apartheid
One state solution with equal rights for all
Two state solution

I expect you'll go with the now, near impossible, two state solution. If you do, I'd like to hear how you think it could possibly happen.
 
How about the Palestinians stop their naked aggression and accept the existence of the Israeli state?
 
The PA is much more likely, and charges against them would be much less likely.
Hamas may have charges pressed, but stand to gain much more if Israel were forced to act according to international law, so maybe they would.
Its all conjecture at this point.

Which path would you prefer?
ICC charges on all sides
Apartheid
One state solution with equal rights for all
Two state solution

I expect you'll go with the now, near impossible, two state solution. If you do, I'd like to hear how you think it could possibly happen.

You don't realize how the ICC works. There are a number of reasons that they could not and would not proceed against Israel. However they might well be willing to put some Pali leaders behind bars for a long time, because Palestine does not have a functioning justice system. The PA and many Palestinians could well be prosecuted under that jurisdiction and Hamas is a prime candidate for international justice.

Personally I prefer a two state solution. I think a one state solution is impractical.
 
You don't realize how the ICC works. There are a number of reasons that they could not and would not proceed against Israel. However they might well be willing to put some Pali leaders behind bars for a long time, because Palestine does not have a functioning justice system. The PA and many Palestinians could well be prosecuted under that jurisdiction and Hamas is a prime candidate for international justice.

Personally I prefer a two state solution. I think a one state solution is impractical.

The evidence is pretty clear against Israel, the settlements and wall, for instance are pretty clear violations, as per the UN report. Charges on those matters could help settle the question of whether Israel would ever give back the settlements and allow a two state solution or if a one state solution is really the only way.
 
...
It will take a long time, since Palestine still has to apply to the ICC and press charges.
....

I wonder how the ICC will compare Israel having built houses on 1% to the West Bank to the majority of Palestinians supporting attacks on Israeli civilians?


It's amazing that grog and family want to go after Israel for what are essentially violations of zoning bylaws while ignoring Palestinian terror attacks and Hamas once again refusing to accept a two state peace.
 
The evidence is pretty clear against Israel, the settlements and wall, for instance are pretty clear violations, as per the UN report. Charges on those matters could help settle the question of whether Israel would ever give back the settlements and allow a two state solution or if a one state solution is really the only way.

ICC does not have jurisdiction over border disputes, land claims, or other state to state disputes, it deals in specific acts by individuals against civilians. Those state to state issues are ICJ territory, or more generally the Security Council.

ICC handles individual crimes, things like firing rockets at school busses and towns, blowing up wedding parties and pizza parlors, bombing public transit buses, or massacring Olympic athletes.

It is also the venue that Turkey realized would have acquitted Israel of any wrongdoing had they brought a complaint about the just as proper way in which Israel dealt with the Gaza flotilla.
 
ICC does not have jurisdiction over border disputes, land claims, or other state to state disputes, it deals in specific acts by individuals against civilians. Those state to state issues are ICJ territory, or more generally the Security Council.

ICC handles individual crimes, things like firing rockets at school busses and towns, blowing up wedding parties and pizza parlors, bombing public transit buses, or massacring Olympic athletes.

It is also the venue that Turkey realized would have acquitted Israel of any wrongdoing had they brought a complaint about the just as proper way in which Israel dealt with the Gaza flotilla.

Not according to the UN report.
The settlements are clear violations of the Geneva Conventions, which makes them within the jurisdiction of the ICC.
 
Not according to the UN report.
The settlements are clear violations of the Geneva Conventions, which makes them within the jurisdiction of the ICC.

The ICC isn't going to take Arab League propaganda any more seriously than the UNSC does.
 
The ICC isn't going to take Arab League propaganda any more seriously than the UNSC does.

Well then you have nothing to worry about again.
I'm sure that makes you feel much better.

Though I would think that you should support charges at the ICC, since its the only real chance of Israel being embarrassed enough to negotiate a two state solution.
And if that doesn't happen....
 
...
Though I would think that you should support charges at the ICC, since its the only real chance of Israel being embarrassed enough to negotiate a two state solution.
And if that doesn't happen....
And even if this were the case, how does that address the problem of Hamas refusing to accept peace?
 
That is supposed to be an ICC indictment? Back to ESL classes for you.

It is amazing how the Palis keep hoping for a white knight to save them from their own bad policies. They keep engaging in terrorism and war crimes, and whine a lot. All the while they ignore building a state or approaching the idea of peace. Disasterous leadership looks like it is going to waste a couple of more generations of those poor people.

Drinking again? No one said it was an ICC indictment...just a War Crimes indictment approved by a British Court.

You zionists just keep thinking a white knight is going to come along and save them from their crimes. They keep engaging in violence, ethnic cleansing, assassinations and they whine incessantly. All the while, they ignore building a state and society based on equality and rationality.
 
I wonder how the ICC will compare Israel having built houses on 1% to the West Bank to the majority of Palestinians supporting attacks on Israeli civilians?


It's amazing that grog and family want to go after Israel for what are essentially violations of zoning bylaws while ignoring Palestinian terror attacks and Hamas once again refusing to accept a two state peace.

You might want to educate yourself on the issues.

Area C, which is completely Israeli controlled, covers 60% of the West Bank.
 
You might want to educate yourself on the issues.

Area C, which is completely Israeli controlled, covers 60% of the West Bank.

Which isn't inconsistent with his point. The military exclusion zones would be reduced or eliminated in a comprehensive peace deak. The actual land occupied by settlements is a tiny fraction of that.
 
Which isn't inconsistent with his point. The military exclusion zones would be reduced or eliminated in a comprehensive peace deak. The actual land occupied by settlements is a tiny fraction of that.

All settlements are illegal.
Currently, they create bantustans in the West Bank, making a continuous Palestine state impossible.
Creeping annexation, as the UN calls it.
 
Which isn't inconsistent with his point. The military exclusion zones would be reduced or eliminated in a comprehensive peace deak. The actual land occupied by settlements is a tiny fraction of that.

Lickspittle...you always seem to find new ways to debase yourself. The claim from Basketcase was that the settlements took up only 1% while, in fact, Area C (which is under complete Israeli administration) that holds all of the settlements comprises 60% of the West Bank.

Nobody thinks that 60% is consistent with 1%.
 
Lickspittle...you always seem to find new ways to debase yourself. The claim from Basketcase was that the settlements took up only 1% while, in fact, Area C (which is under complete Israeli administration) that holds all of the settlements comprises 60% of the West Bank.

Nobody thinks that 60% is consistent with 1%.

The settlements are only a very small part of that area, as your own link so clearly illustrates.
 
Your link also showed that settlements are only a tiny fraction of that area.

How stupid are you??

Lickspittle...read...read!

"Area C contains all the Israeli settlements, roads used to access the settlements, buffer zones (near settlements, roads, strategic areas, and Israel), and almost all of the Jordan Valley and the Judean Desert."

Further, it states:
 
Clearly, "Area C" contains a lot more than just settlements. It also contains buffer zones, roads, strategic areas, the Jordan valley and the Judean desert, in addition to the settlements.

Sounds like the settlements are hardly any of it--and hey, your link had a map, and the map clearly showed how little of it was made up of settlements.

So I guess what BC wrote was true, settlements only comprise about 1% of Palestine, and that seems more or less confirmed by the link you provided. Thanks Gryfin!