Hamas affirms goals

They are not a political adversary.. they are a military adversary. Israel had no problems boarding a Turkish ship in international waters that was headed to Gaza..yet somehow you say they only respond to direct threats? What about the strike on the Iraqi nuclear reactors? Iraq was not remotely close to having a bomb yet Israel acted.. so your position that they were somehow constrained by policy simply does not hold water.

Israel boarded that ship , and every other, to ensure weapons are not shipped to Hamas. Nuclear capable Iraq would also be an existential threat to Israel.

Hamas, in light of the security measures and the ceasefire has clearly been contained.
 
Israel boarded that ship , and every other, to ensure weapons are not shipped to Hamas. Nuclear capable Iraq would also be an existential threat to Israel.

Hamas, in light of the security measures and the ceasefire has clearly been contained.

Why did the attack Lebanon over 1 kidnapped soldier? You don't think Hamas will kill a single Israeli over the next year?
 
Why did the attack Lebanon over 1 kidnapped soldier? You don't think Hamas will kill a single Israeli over the next year?

If there was actionable intelligence about a specific plan they would act. As they have the morals that you lack they do not go about killing people indiscriminately based on speculation.
 
If there was actionable intelligence about a specific plan they would act. As they have the morals that you lack they do not go about killing people indiscriminately based on speculation.

There was actionable intelligence. You think they don't have people in Gaza? They CHOSE not to act because they decided it was strategically beneficial to divide the Palestinians.
 
Bzzzz wrong, Hamas exists because it was allowed and supported by Israel in the late 80's by Israel to weaken their enemy at the time Fatah. It thrived because Israel continues to treat Palestinians like sub humans in the West Bank and Gaza, and Fatah is more intertested in shopping sprees for the wives of party officials than their people.

There was actionable intelligence. You think they don't have people in Gaza? They CHOSE not to act because they decided it was strategically beneficial to divide the Palestinians.

I would see this as the same kind of racism as the Victorian era 'White Man's Burden' (or another attempt to blame Israel for everything). Hamas exists because some Palestinians want it to exist. To say that it exists only because of Israel is saying that Palestinians aren't capable of making their own decisions. Many Palestinians have chosen to back a hateful war of destruction instead of peace.
 
And the words of Meshaal:
"Palestine is our land and nation from the [Mediterranean] sea to the [Jordan] river, from north to south, and we cannot cede an inch or any part of it," he said.

"We fight Zionists, not Jews. We fight whoever occupied our land, regardless of religion ... Statehood will be the fruit of resistance, not negotiations," Meshaal told cheering fans.

http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2012/12/20121284378161786.html

Sounds reasonable and would be considered reasonable had not some other country decided that they should split it all up.
Now you've got two unreasonable parties.

And once again grog advocates terror attacks on civilians and the hateful agenda of Hamas.
 
There was actionable intelligence. You think they don't have people in Gaza? They CHOSE not to act because they decided it was strategically beneficial to divide the Palestinians.

Citation needed for this claim that IDF failed to respond to actionable intelligence about a specific attack on Israeli citizens.

I imagine if you have such proof it will go on to dominate the headlines of all Israeli newspapers for at least a few weeks.
 
Citation needed for this claim that IDF failed to respond to actionable intelligence about a specific attack on Israeli citizens.

I imagine if you have such proof it will go on to dominate the headlines of all Israeli newspapers for at least a few weeks.

No there was actionable intelligence that Israel could have used to prevent Hamas from controlling Gaza... there was no specific actionable intelligence in the case of the Lebanese war.. a soldier was kidnapped, there was no impending major attack by Hezbollah on Israel, it was just a form of collective punishment against Lebanon....hundreds of civilians were murdered and dozens of Israeli soldiers were killed. NOTHING was achieved.
 
No there was actionable intelligence that Israel could have used to prevent Hamas from controlling Gaza... there was no specific actionable intelligence in the case of the Lebanese war.. a soldier was kidnapped, there was no impending major attack by Hezbollah on Israel, it was just a form of collective punishment against Lebanon....hundreds of civilians were murdered and dozens of Israeli soldiers were killed. NOTHING was achieved.

The Lebanese war occurred because Hezbollah was actively attacking Israel, firing rockets into Israeli towns and killing several soldiers on the border. Your qualification "major" is not correct, Israel is not required to suffer the death of any of its soldiers or civilians nor suffer terror attacks either. Apologists for Arab aggression often try to downplay the impact of rocket attacks on civilians, suggest Israel should shrug off the killing of its soldiers, and quietly suffer intolerable acts of violence.

You just don't get that international law and common morality give Israel a right to defense.
 
Last edited:
Don't you get it fuji? When Israel attacks Hamas, they are war criminals. When they don't they are criminals for allowing Hamas to exist.
 
The Lebanese war occurred because Hezbollah was actively attacking Israel, firing rockets into Israeli towns and killing several soldiers on the border. Your qualification "major" is not correct, Israel is not required to suffer the death of any of its soldiers or civilians nor suffer terror attacks either. Apologists for Arab aggression often try to downplay the impact of rocket attacks on civilians, suggest Israel should shrug off the killing of its soldiers, and quietly suffer intolerable acts of violence.

You just don't get that international law and common morality give Israel a right to defense.

Give your head a shake. Israel had been kidnapping Lebanese citizens for the past 20 years. Israel has also invaded Lebanon and created a proxy terrorist army in Lebanon. Israel has also occupied Lebanese territory. Israel violates Lebanese air space on an almost daily basis. Israel also engineered a massacre of Palestinians in Lebanon.

Given those facts, Lebanon is not required to suffer the death of its soldiers or civilians nor suffer terrorist attacks, bombings, kidnappings, and violations of its territory. Apologists for Israeli aggression often downplay the attacks on civilians, kidnappings, theft of Lebanese land, indiscriminate use of cluster bombs, attacks on civilian infrastructure, massacres, and violations of Lebanese territory. They suggest that Lebanon should shrug off all the murderous acts committed against its citizens and quietly suffer intolerable acts of violence.

Lickspittle, you just don't get that international law and common morality give Lebanon a right to defense.
 
Gryfin, the immediate cause of the 2006 war was that Hezbollah initiated a series of attacks on Israel, killing a couple of soldiers, and launching rockets into Israel. Whatever historical backgrop we may disagree about, that's a fact.

You are a good illustration of the cause of the war: You froth at the mouth in your hatred of Israel, and so do they, and that's the reason for their ongoing aggression against Israel, which ultimately causes these wars.
 
Gryfin, the immediate cause of the 2006 war was that Hezbollah initiated a series of attacks on Israel, killing a couple of soldiers, and launching rockets into Israel. Whatever historical backgrop we may disagree about, that's a fact.

You are a good illustration of the cause of the war: You froth at the mouth in your hatred of Israel, and so do they, and that's the reason for their ongoing aggression against Israel, which ultimately causes these wars.

No, the cause was the hundreds of Lebanese and Palestinian prisoners that had either been kidnapped, held without trial, or convicted in Israeli kangaroo courts. This was intended to help gain their release.
 
Don't talk when your mouth is full of lies. You have no reasons to say any of those things, you are just completely full of shit.

Your only reason for writing any of that is "I hate Israel", go away troll.
 
Don't talk when your mouth is full of lies. You have no reasons to say any of those things, you are just completely full of shit.

Your only reason for writing any of that is "I hate Israel", go away troll.

All sputter, no content.
 
For one of few occasions, I agree with Netanyahu that the lack of reporting on Meshaal's statements more than a bit unusual.
 
All your posts are like that. Particularly the last few in this thread--you have no reasons for the things you think. You just spew hate.


Really, you should read your own posts before you make that accusation.
Check out your last post:
Don't talk when your mouth is full of lies. You have no reasons to say any of those things, you are just completely full of shit.

Your only reason for writing any of that is "I hate Israel", go away troll.