Halifax principal - Too much?

I'm kind of on the fence for this one. I looked at the video and it looks to me like the principal was the one that started the shoving.

actually, the principal just tried to stop the kid from getting past him, then the kid shoved the principal. I for one was taught that if an an adult, especially a person of authority, tells me to stop, I stop. What I don't do is physically confront him. If a kid did that to me? I'd put him to the ground too.

Protecting this kid only reinforces the concept that kids do not have to respect authority......
 
Protecting this kid only reinforces the concept that kids do not have to respect authority......

Yes. I don't know when things changed, but have they ever. When I went to school, no student would ever dream of physically confronting any teacher or principal. When my parents said "no", it was no, not "ask again in a minute and I might change my mind". We listened, and did what we were told, or the consequences were swift to follow. We were scared of our parents, teachers, principals and the law. We were even scared of the neighbors, because we knew that they were adults. Scared in a good way, too...a way that made us tow the line.

Protecting this kid does reinforce the concept that the principal need not be respected. Way to totally make that position of authority an impotent one.
 
Once the student pushed the principal the principal really had no choice. Just imagine what would have happened if the principal had not taken swift and serious action.
So far nobody has mentioned the other student ( in the checked white hoodie) who tried to intervene and went so far as to touch or push the principal. Notice that he appears to even be considering following up as the principal is dragging the student away. He should also be expelled!
If the school has sunk to the level that students think they can act in the manner shown in the video that school needs some serious disipline and control.
 
what I saw on the video is what someone wanted me to see. Not the entire story

its really hard to know what happened here from just this video. I didn't see the kid "taking a photo of the girl's ass" from this video (but I am not a video- analyst like some here). It's hard to understand why the principal felt the confrontation had to happen like this.
 
As much as I don't think teachers should ever lay a hand on students.... what can teachers do to make students listen? Children know that they have all the power these days and just flaunt that power in the face of teachers/police and other authority.

We need to give teachers and police the power to make judgement calls sometimes, and support them when they do. We also need to understand that they won't/can't always be right. We can't have them wondering if their job will be in jeopardy if they try to act. People should at the very least respect others in a position of authority, which is not the case these days.

Exactly.

The principal showed a tiny bit of restraint by putting his arm out to prevent the student from going back and then really threw him down (maybe TOO soon). lol
But regardless, the kid needed to be shown who was boss and he clearly wasn't going to listen.
 
its really hard to know what happened here from just this video. I didn't see the kid "taking a photo of the girl's ass" from this video (but I am not a video- analyst like some here). It's hard to understand why the principal felt the confrontation had to happen like this.

If you read the story it doesn't say that's what happened. It does however say that the principal wanted his cellphone and had been following the student through the halls before this. Presumably the principal had politely asked then demanded the phone be handed over before this confrontation ended up on video. I can see how someone might infer that inappropriate pictures had been taken, but they shouldn't. We should just assume that the principal was acting in good faith and on good intel that the phone should be confiscated.
 
Once the student pushed the principal the principal really had no choice. Just imagine what would have happened if the principal had not taken swift and serious action.
So far nobody has mentioned the other student ( in the checked white hoodie) who tried to intervene and went so far as to touch or push the principal. Notice that he appears to even be considering following up as the principal is dragging the student away. He should also be expelled!
If the school has sunk to the level that students think they can act in the manner shown in the video that school needs some serious disipline and control.

Expulsion isn't really the answer for either student. It makes them hate authority more and just makes them a bigger a problem for any future schools they attend. They will shut down and ruin their lives.

The problem is that accountability in regards to rights/respct is only one way in this society. If someone in authority uses a racial slur/too much force/disrespect they have swift and SEVERE consequences in terms of their job, one mistake could mean everything to them even if everything they had done prior was by the book and perfect. The person that is being confronted by the teacher/police does not have to abide by these rules at all, and will suffer no consequence to their career. Maybe if police officers with enough evidence (3strikes maybe?) have someone removed from their job/profession for such indiscretions, then maybe it would be a fair playing field.