Gym Membership Tax Writeoffs?

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
508
113
The Keebler Factory
I was reading that Alberta is considering making part of gym memberships a tax rebate. Now keep in mind that Alberta is the only deficit & debt free province, so they can afford it.

Personally, I think this is a good idea... to a point. I don't think the whole membership should be a write-off and I certainly think there needs to be an upper limit (say $20-25 a month), otherwise gyms will hike their fees through the roof.

I see two big problems. The first is that there will be little to no immediate impact and it will be damn near impossible to measure how much impact the tax break is having. The second is cost. Of course, in theory, the extra cost would be more than made up by the amount of health care dollars saved. But it's almost impossible to directly link the two. And where the money for the tax break would come from is also questionable. Actually, there's a third problem: most people quit going to the gym after a few weeks/months; so the gov't would be giving a tax break for nothing.

But it sounds like an interesting idea, at least to me...
 
Good idea

Some Supplemental Health plans covers Gym membership with Flex-credit if you have $ left over from buying Medical/Dental coverage.

Makes sense as healthy lifestyle, less medical claims. Less sick days, so the thinking. Alberta also has the mental sick days, or what that Sask?
 
If succesful, it could also increase personal expeditures, and therefore economic activity, as people sign up who otherwise wouldn't.
 
Keebler Elf said:
But it sounds like an interesting idea, at least to me...
Is that your "expert" opinion? Sounds like a stupid idea to me and a wast of tax money - but I'm no expert.

1. People who want to partake in a regular exercise program will do so regardless. It may not be in a "Fitness gym": but on a basket ball court or school gym, jogging on the street, or simpy walking to the corner store instead of driving.

2. The gyms are businesses and will charge what the market will bare and remain competitive. If the gov allows a $20-$25/mth deduction, then the gyms will raise their fees accordingly, probably within a year.

If this is proposed to "improve the general health of Canadians", you're going have to show how this program would induce people to begin and continue in an excerise program they would not have started without it.

Keebler Elf said:
most people quit going to the gym after a few weeks/months; so the gov't would be giving a tax break for nothing.
You got any stats showing the number/per cent of people who drop out because of costs?
 
Keebler Elf said:
You can find that yourself by doing a simple search on the net.
Why would I bother researching support for your "expert" opinion, especially when I don't think it's worth anything?! You've been sitting in a manager's chair for too long - you've become a lazy s**t!
 
Keebler Elf said:
. Actually, there's a third problem: most people quit going to the gym after a few weeks/months; so the gov't would be giving a tax break for nothing.

But it sounds like an interesting idea, at least to me...


I like the idea but would prefer a gasoline tax rebate. Actually the fact that most people quit the gym after a few weeks or months would not affect the scheme as you would only get a tax credit for fees you paid.
A lot of people pay memberships and don't go so they should still claim gym fees . You really can't force people to actually go.
 
booboobear said:
I like the idea but would prefer a gasoline tax rebate. Actually the fact that most people quit the gym after a few weeks or months would not affect the scheme as you would only get a tax credit for fees you paid.
A lot of people pay memberships and don't go so they should still claim gym fees . You really can't force people to actually go.


Why don't you claim gasoline costs. You are allowed to. You can claim your car maintenance, gas, insurance etc. ...but it has to be prorated based on business use.