Guns in State Capitol.

But my point is the Maple Leaf represents Canada. And Canada has a history of murdering native Indians to take their land.

Thats a fact that cannot be denied

Which is why Canada has started doing things like land acknowledgements as very a little step.

...

And the dates I am referencing are between 1867 and 1887 which is when Canada fought its last wars against Native Indians before defeating the permanently:...
Were you not aware that the Canadian flag has only been our flag since 1965 or that it was only added to the National coat of arms 1921?
 
The difference is the Confederate flag crept into the cultural psyche well beyond the issue of slavery. ...

You're right, it came into vogue as a symbol of rebellion against the Federal government pushing desegregation and the Civil Rights.

Looks like a Klan meeting.

carter-flag-e1534723854101.jpg

The history buff in me sees the fringes and can identify it as a battle flag, quite possible taken at a civil war battlefield memorial (especially since it looks like swords on a plaque in the bottom left corner).

Having the battle flag at what is essentially a war cemetery (BTW. Swastikas are on graves of Nazi POWs in the US) is a lot different from waving one at a Michigan anti-government protest. Context is everything.
 
Maybe not the modern Canadian Maple Leaf flag, but the Maple Leaf has been used as a Canadian emblem since the 18th century. It was first used as a national symbol in 1868 when it appeared on the coat of arms of both Ontario and Quebec In 1867, Alexander Muir composed the patriotic song "The Maple Leaf Forever", which became an unofficial anthem in English-speaking Canada: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Canada

And the dates I am referencing are between 1867 and 1887 which is when Canada fought its last wars against Native Indians before defeating the permanently:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Canada

  • 1867 Grouse Creek War
  • 1869 – 1870 Red River Rebellion
  • 1870 Wolseley Expedition
  • 1870 Battle of the Belly River
  • 1873 Cypress Hills Massacre
  • 1875 Jubilee riots
  • 1885 North-West Rebellion
  • 1885 Battle of Duck Lake
  • 1885 Frog Lake Massacre
  • 1885 Battle of Fort Pitt
  • 1885 Battle of Fish Creek
  • 1885 Battle of Cut Knife
  • 1885 Battle of Batoche
  • 1885 Battle of Frenchman's Butte
  • 1885 Battle of Loon Lake

I wasn't debating the events. I was questioning the timing of the Maple Leaf FLAG that you claimed was being used officially when the slaughters occurred. Those were your words which I am glad to see that you have walked back. The maple leaf itself may have been some type of symbol but not THE flag of Canada, the way that the Confederate flag was flown during slavery and during a war which the south fought to continue the use of slaves.
 
I thought that was the rhetorical device you set up with the pick a statement game. You just ignore other's points of view in your response.
I did it that way because nobody wanted acknowledge the link between the flag and slavery, just other places that the flag had been used. And those other uses also did not acknowledge the link, otherwise they would not have been used.

I really don't want to have a history discussion on the Civil War. As an American and a student of history, we can have a long, bloated discussion on the Civil War and I will concede slavery was the most important cause of the war.

While I don't agree with displaying the Confederate flag on govt. buildings and I understand the reasoning for removing Confederate statues from public land, I know full well the flag has taken on many meanings over the course of 155 years. I have provided cultural references outside your narrow view that everything about the flag is and always is about slavery. Once a symbol creeps into other aspects of our culture, it's hard to snap fingers and say it's evil, it must go away and anyone who doesn't comply is a racist.
Reasonable reply.

I would suggest that maybe in light of today's views of how much the Confederate flag was a symbol of support of slavery, that the way it was displayed in a show like Dukes of Hazzard would never be allowed to be shown on TV now. And that flag was put on display in spite of what the current views of society are regarding that flag.

BTW, I am glad that we did not get into a discussion of the Civil War because you probably know a lot more about it than I.
 
To be precise it was the flag of the military fighting to preserve slavery. The Confederacy flag was the Stars and bars.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flags_of_the_Confederate_States_of_America

It was the most popular flag symbol, though. There is a reason the other armies also took it and the later CSA flags Incorporated it.

Once Birth of a Nation used it that pretty much cemented it in the popular imagination. It has been primarily the major US symbol of white supremacy ever since. But, as Wyatt Earp rightly says, symbols aren't easily controlled and so it has also bled into popular culture as both a symbol of broader Southern identity and general "transgression".
 
Having the battle flag at what is essentially a war cemetery (BTW. Swastikas are on graves of Nazi POWs in the US) is a lot different from waving one at a Michigan anti-government protest. Context is everything.

I know that wasn't your main point. However, that is exactly what some of are saying. Context is everything.

In my opinion, a political protest in Michigan is a lot different than a protest in Mississippi. It's a subtle and subjective nuance. Is it culturally insensitive for Michiganers to wave the Confederate flag? Probably. Are they racist? Hard to say. I'll give them the benefit of the doubt.
 
I wasn't debating the events. I was questioning the timing of the Maple Leaf FLAG that you claimed was being used officially when the slaughters occurred. Those were your words which I am glad to see that you have walked back. The maple leaf itself may have been some type of symbol but not THE flag of Canada, the way that the Confederate flag was flown during slavery and during a war which the south fought to continue the use of slaves
Fine I'll walk it back, I didnt grow up in Canada so I wasnt aware the flag wasnt officially adopted till 20th century.

My point still stands however, if you look into almost any country's past you'll find a history of genocide or other bad behaviour.
Canada is no better, we murdered native Indians and we also had a small amount of slavery: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_Canada

So if you're gonna point fingers at the confederate flag you might wanna look at our own country's past as well
 
Fine I'll walk it back, I didnt grow up in Canada so I wasnt aware the flag wasnt officially adopted till 20th century.

My point still stands however, if you look into almost any country's past you'll find a history of genocide or other bad behaviour.
Canada is no better, we murdered native Indians and we also had a small amount of slavery: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_Canada

So if you're gonna pint fingers at the confederate flag you might wanna look at our own country's past as well

Astounding whataboutism all in the name of basically defending Trump.

What next, "Dat Flag Ain't That Bad: early Neanderthal conquest, slaughter and enslavement and it's relation to the symbolism of the Confederate flag"?
 
Astounding whataboutism all in the name of basically defending Trump.

We must be following different threads. I have no idea how you read the recent comments and thought the discussion was about Trump.
 
This thread is about defending white supremacists and their leader, Trump.

The lockdowns and the political dynamics behind them in the U.S. seem to be lost on some members.
 
...

So if you're gonna point fingers at the confederate flag you might wanna look at our own country's past as well

Flags represent the entirety of a country's existence. The difference is the entire existence of the Confederacy was the battle to keep slavery.
 
And the Civil War was fought over the issue of slavery which the south supported. The flag undeniably symbolises slavery.

It didn't symbolize slavery. It symbolized rebellion. The only flag that I consider racist is the Nazi flag because it was the flag of a party and ideology. Let me ask you this shack. Do you consider the flags of England and France symbols of oppression and slavery along with many other countries in Europe? They all had slaves. The English have even been accused of genocide on many occasions. Why aren't these flags considered flags of oppression?
 
It didn't symbolize slavery. It symbolized rebellion....

Rebelling against the federal government wanting to ban slavery.

Again, the flag of a country represents the entirety of that country's existence. The battle flag of the confederacy existed explicitly to war against the elimination of slavery. There's no comparison.
 
It didn't symbolize slavery. It symbolized rebellion. The only flag that I consider racist is the Nazi flag because it was the flag of a party and ideology. Let me ask you this shack. Do you consider the flags of England and France symbols of oppression and slavery along with many other countries in Europe? They all had slaves. The English have even been accused of genocide on many occasions. Why aren't these flags considered flags of oppression?

It's always symbolized slavery and white supremacy. It was the symbol of an army and "country" that explicitly said they did a rebellion in order to preserve slavery and white supremacy. The CSA and the individual rebel states stated specifically that slavery and white supremacy were the ideology they were supporting.
It has also been used at times as a general idea of transgression and rebellion, but it has never been completely separated from that history.