Guns in State Capitol.

I believe that there were also some Confederate flags there. What did they symbolise?

It depends on who you ask I guess. In the south to some it's a symbol of their history, to others it's hate. To me it's neither. That just happened to be the flag of the south during that time. I don't think it symbolized anything at the the time except it's representation of south.
 
It depends on who you ask I guess. In the south to some it's a symbol of their history, to others it's hate. To me it's neither. That just happened to be the flag of the south during that time. .
And the Civil War was fought over the issue of slavery which the south supported. The flag undeniably symbolises slavery.
 
And the Civil War was fought over the issue of slavery which the south supported. The flag undeniably symbolises slavery.

In order to shoehorn this protest into a political narrative, you're completely dismissive of the idea that symbols can have multiple meanings. You can see Kid Rock (and Lynyrd Skynyrd before him) use the Confederate flag to symbolize Southern rock. The flag as a symbol of rebellion has also had a transgressive meaning in our history.

Transgressive - involving a violation of accepted or imposed boundaries, especially those of social acceptability.

Since the protests are very far removed from the issue of race, the protesters were simply violating accepted or imposed boundaries to make a point against the Governor's lockdown decisions.
 
It depends on who you ask I guess. In the south to some it's a symbol of their history, to others it's hate. To me it's neither. That just happened to be the flag of the south during that time. I don't think it symbolized anything at the the time except it's representation of south.

And the swastika just happened to be the flag of Nazi Germany in the 30's and 40's.
 
In order to shoehorn this protest into a political narrative, you're completely dismissive of the idea that symbols can have multiple meanings.
.
Which statement is incorrect?

1)Slavery is widely regarded as the main issue that sparked the civil war. (The first response in a Google search--The Civil War started because of uncompromising differences between the free and slave states over the power of the national government to prohibit slavery in the territories that had not yet become states. )

2)The Confederate flag was the flag of the south, the side that supported slavery.
 
And the Maple Leaf was the flag of Canada when they slaughtered the native Indians
 
In order to shoehorn this protest into a political narrative, you're completely dismissive of the idea that symbols can have multiple meanings. You can see Kid Rock (and Lynyrd Skynyrd before him) use the Confederate flag to symbolize Southern rock. The flag as a symbol of rebellion has also had a transgressive meaning in our history.

Transgressive - involving a violation of accepted or imposed boundaries, especially those of social acceptability.

Since the protests are very far removed from the issue of race, the protesters were simply violating accepted or imposed boundaries to make a point against the Governor's lockdown decisions.

So if someone likes the Swastika's design and use it as something different, then what?

Even though THEY lost, do you know why Confederate symbols were later installed all over the south? Surely you know why.
 
"The flag made its first official appearance on February 15, 1965; the date is now celebrated annually as National Flag of Canada Day".
But my point is the Maple Leaf represents Canada. And Canada has a history of murdering native Indians to take their land.

Thats a fact that cannot be denied
 
Which statement is incorrect?

1)Slavery is widely regarded as the main issue that sparked the civil war. (The first response in a Google search--The Civil War started because of uncompromising differences between the free and slave states over the power of the national government to prohibit slavery in the territories that had not yet become states. )

2)The Confederate flag was the flag of the south, the side that supported slavery.

Which statement is incorrect?

1) Kid Rock and the band members of Lynyrd Skynyrd are just fun-loving rockers celebrating the music of the South.

2) John Schneider, Tom Wopat, Catherine Bach and everyone involved with the TV show Dukes of Hazzard were just trying to put on a silly, innocuous TV show.

3) Undo focus on the Confederate flag out of context is race-baiting and overly judgmental.
 
So if someone likes the Swastika's design and use it as something different, then what?

Even though THEY lost, do you know why Confederate symbols were later installed all over the south? Surely you know why.

The difference is the Confederate flag crept into the cultural psyche well beyond the issue of slavery. It didn't hold the same meaning to all people. Here is an article on how the car from Smokey and the Bandit was rejected by last year's Autorama hot rod show coincidentally in Detroit.

In many ways, the controversy about the car represents how attitudes of public officials – and society – have changed in just two years, as the public has been wrestling with offensive images in popular culture.
Burt Reynolds, who was born in Lansing, died on Sept. 6 at the age of 82.

Just two years ago, Autorama staged a stunt with a replica of the General Lee, the car in the "The Dukes of Hazzard," a popular TV series from the early '80s.


And yes, I do know why Confederate symbols were later installed all over the South. While I would not wave or fly a Confederate flag, it's one thing to say it's now inappropriate and another thing to condemn anyone not as sensitive or sophisticated as all of us as racist.

And don't call me Surely. ;)
 
But my point is the Maple Leaf represents Canada. And Canada has a history of murdering native Indians to take their land.

Thats a fact that cannot be denied
But that is not what you said. You clearly had a timeline to directly link the Maple Leaf flag with killing of natives.

And the Maple Leaf was the flag of Canada when they slaughtered the native Indians
What dates were you referencing?
 
Which statement is incorrect?

1) Kid Rock and the band members of Lynyrd Skynyrd are just fun-loving rockers celebrating the music of the South.

2) John Schneider, Tom Wopat, Catherine Bach and everyone involved with the TV show Dukes of Hazzard were just trying to put on a silly, innocuous TV show.

3) Undo focus on the Confederate flag out of context is race-baiting and overly judgmental.
What a joke of a response.

Absolutely ZERO to do with my two statements. It means you concede the argument.

The confederacy fought a war based on their desire to maintain slavery. They proudly waved the confederate flag to emphasize their point of view.
 
But that is not what you said. You clearly had a timeline to directly link the Maple Leaf flag with killing of natives.

What dates were you referencing?
Maybe not the modern Canadian Maple Leaf flag, but the Maple Leaf has been used as a Canadian emblem since the 18th century. It was first used as a national symbol in 1868 when it appeared on the coat of arms of both Ontario and Quebec In 1867, Alexander Muir composed the patriotic song "The Maple Leaf Forever", which became an unofficial anthem in English-speaking Canada: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Canada

And the dates I am referencing are between 1867 and 1887 which is when Canada fought its last wars against Native Indians before defeating the permanently:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Canada

  • 1867 Grouse Creek War
  • 1869 – 1870 Red River Rebellion
  • 1870 Wolseley Expedition
  • 1870 Battle of the Belly River
  • 1873 Cypress Hills Massacre
  • 1875 Jubilee riots
  • 1885 North-West Rebellion
  • 1885 Battle of Duck Lake
  • 1885 Frog Lake Massacre
  • 1885 Battle of Fort Pitt
  • 1885 Battle of Fish Creek
  • 1885 Battle of Cut Knife
  • 1885 Battle of Batoche
  • 1885 Battle of Frenchman's Butte
  • 1885 Battle of Loon Lake
 
Absolutely ZERO to do with my two statements. It means you concede the argument.

I thought that was the rhetorical device you set up with the pick a statement game. You just ignore other's points of view in your response.

The confederacy fought a war based on their desire to maintain slavery. They proudly waved the confederate flag to emphasize their point of view.

I really don't want to have a history discussion on the Civil War. As an American and a student of history, we can have a long, bloated discussion on the Civil War and I will concede slavery was the most important cause of the war.

While I don't agree with displaying the Confederate flag on govt. buildings and I understand the reasoning for removing Confederate statues from public land, I know full well the flag has taken on many meanings over the course of 155 years. I have provided cultural references outside your narrow view that everything about the flag is and always is about slavery. Once a symbol creeps into other aspects of our culture, it's hard to snap fingers and say it's evil, it must go away and anyone who doesn't comply is a racist.

Phil has taken up the point that the Canadian flag has been associated with oppression. There was a lot of oppression going on in the Nineteenth century in many Western Democracies. Some of this carried on into the following century. Obviously, there are a few people that think the American flag should be replaced for this history. Good luck with that.
 
Looks like a Klan meeting.

carter-flag-e1534723854101.jpg
 
Maybe not the modern Canadian Maple Leaf flag, but the Maple Leaf has been used as a Canadian emblem since the 18th century. It was first used as a national symbol in 1868 when it appeared on the coat of arms of both Ontario and Quebec In 1867, Alexander Muir composed the patriotic song "The Maple Leaf Forever", which became an unofficial anthem in English-speaking Canada: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Canada

And the dates I am referencing are between 1867 and 1887 which is when Canada fought its last wars against Native Indians before defeating the permanently:
]

Well phil, you better start protesting the Maple Leaf wherever you see it, if that's your views.
I suggest a double tandem protest for you, go out and wear the confederate flag while you burn the Canadian flag and have your views known publicly.
That will really show the strength of your convictions.