Guns and crime

james t kirk, I bet if you somehow found yourself walking down a dark street at nigh, in Washington’s inner city, you would be wishing you were packing one of the biggest, nastiest looking guns available :)
 
James t. Kirk would be too SMART to walk down a dark street in Washington.

If everyone has a gun, the fact that you have one too does not make you safe.

If you wanna play with your six-shooter go south young man, the Yankees love that gun-porn.

I have no quarrel with the sensible use of guns for hunting or target shooting. It's not my thing but ok for others. The idea that private citizens should be allowed to carry handguns in a non-rural environment just strikes me as dumb, dangerous and
a violation of others rights to a safe environment.
 
Clipper brings up another interesting point.

Violence porn vs. sex porn.

How ironic that if you shoot a woman in the breast, that's ok, but by god, if you kiss her nipple, that's obscene.

I am stilling that analogy from someone, i just don't remember who she was.

In the good ole us of a, you can walk down to ye old gun shop and buy a semi automatic weapon specifically manufactured and sold for killing people, but if you sell a woman a dildo to pleasure herself in several states, you are going to get your ass thrown right in jail.

Something is wrong with that picture.
 
bear 23.

Love your post. Just because it's so chock full of all the bad logic gun advocates use.

No matter how many slanted stats you cite, it doesn't change the basic fact that more guns means more killing. If you don't first acknowledge that the U.S., - where there are more guns- has a much bigger problem than other areas of the world, then it's hard to take your subsequent arguments seriously.

Besides the few used for target shooting on a range, what possible use is there for a handgun other than to kill someone? By your logic, the world would be a much safer place if a law requiring everyone to carry a gun were passed. That way, if everyone knows that everyone else is armed, there'd be no killing. That isn't the way human beings work though. When something's available, guns, porno, churches, anything no matter how silly - we use them.

Doesn't it make much more sense if no one had a gun? No guns, no shooting.
 
As far as guns and violence, the Royal Canadian Air Farce summed it up as well as can be IMO:
"Guns don't kill people. IDIOTS kill people. so lets not register guns lets register idiots."
Let's be honest. Most attempts at gun control are useless as most guns used in crimes are illegal or stolen (no stat, just logic), so making my grandfather register his rifles however many different ways really wont make a difference, if somebody steals it and shoots someone with it your still at square 1 as far as finding him. only solution I can think of is one that noone would agree with. Mass destruction of all firearms, new ones issued to army and police, an exact count kept and rechecked regularly (daily at police stations) and if someone's found with a gun they get life in prison. people will still kill each other it will just take more effort (stabbings, beatings, building bombs etc.)
 
Guns and Crime

For those of you who have shown such sincere interest in this thread, which admittedly draws serious and honest differences, perhaps this link will help:

www.stats.org/crime.htm

I think that the Center for handgun Control, like the NRA, is a place, but not the place to go as each is an advocate for its poit of view.

As to the poster whom I challenged to a High Noon event, I was happy to observe that he'd seen the movie, unhappy to not have him take up the challenge, embarassed to say he was right and I'd not accurately read his post wherein he did not call me an idiot (though that may change) and that i have had all the posts printed so that i may kind of poke around with PMs answering the various points. This may take awhile but I shall try.

One thing: I regret that some of my countrymen have gone off the deep end as to Canada. Our differences are not at all substantial and, when we merge, as we will eventually do, I am sorry I shall likely have passed on to Paradise, where all the women are clones of Samantha Jones and I am, once again, young.

Cheers, Chaps, as we say down here.
 
no guns no shooting.... go back to your fantasy world....

It doesn't matter what stats you want to look at... a gun doesn't kill... the person does... If you can find stats that contradict my numbers please post your results...

as for what use they serve.... I'm a target shooter and the incident in Orangeville this past weekend is a prime example of where a private citizen could have made a difference. But 50 on lookers watched a women get grabbed pulled into a van and beaten then when she escaped he ran her over, twice.....


Kirk accidental shootings??? 3 in Canada last time statscan updated their site....

Hell it's not worth the effort to take apart each of the post following mine....

Do you folks not think that a billon dollars could be better spent??? Maybe on things like education and healthcare???


From the posts following mine.. I don't think you folks understand what gun control is or the issues around it ..It has nothing to do with saftey.... If you think it will make you safer more power to you...
But if you look at the way the laws are written and realize what powers it gives the politicians and from that what they are doing with other laws you'd realize that we no longer have a democracy....

I won't make anymore comments.
 
Only 3 accidental shootings in Canada, wow, our gun control system is working better then I thought.

bear.23, do you want everyone that wants to, carrying a loaded hand gun? Given that you are, “a verifier, a firearms training instructor, a competative target shooter and firearms owner”, you know that some of the people going through the clubs are not the people you would want carrying a loaded gun all the time, and you see them when they are sober.

There is no reason for people in suburban Canada to be carrying loaded handguns. Giving the incident in Orangeville as an example of why we should be armed is poor. For one thing, stuff like that is so rare that it is insignificant. The chances that the right person, would be in the right place, at the right time, with a loaded gun, are even more remote. Further, people are beaten up on the subway, and others stand around and watch. What makes you think that an armed good samaritan is going to risk death, by stepping in and starting a gunfight with someone, knowing also that if the law looks at him the wrong way, or he happens to shoot one of the bystanders by mistake, he could be spending many years in jail. It would be much better if we all had to carry cell phones. In emergencies, it is amazing how fast the cops can respond.

Our registry system does seem somewhat pointless, but it will, if nothing else, prompt people to store their guns safely. Also, nothing has really changed for restricted gun owners, so don’t worry, the shy is not falling.
 
Last edited:
Nice site

Master Muse said:
For those of you who have shown such sincere interest in this thread, which admittedly draws serious and honest differences, perhaps this link will help:

www.stats.org/crime.htm

I think that the Center for handgun Control, like the NRA, is a place, but not the place to go as each is an advocate for its poit of view.

Master Muse: Thanks for the url. If you come across any other useful sites pertaining to these issues, please post them. There's a lot of crap out there and sorting through it is very time consuming.

vvv
 
Re: Guns and Crime

Master Muse said:
For those of you who have shown such sincere interest in this thread, which admittedly draws serious and honest differences, perhaps this link will help:

www.stats.org/crime.htm

Master Muse:

I think that Iain Murray states a possible common ground for many in his article "Both sides need to pack more truth in gun number". He writes:

"[snip] By moving away from dueling quibbles, we can ascertain what is undeniable. The underlying truth is that there is a serious problem with violence in America. The murder rates suggest strongly that the problem is not nationwide, but concentrated in inner-city minority and Southern white microcultures. It is stupid to deny that guns exacerbate the problem, but whether their stricter control across the board would alleviate it is another matter. Official figures, for example, clearly show that guns are a minor factor in the nation's unacceptably high rate of infant murder (our non-gun homicide rate for small children is four times that of comparable nations - something moms should really be concerned about).

Meanwhile, the gun-related anti-crime programs which have had the most effect are those, like Project Exile in Richmond, Va., which get guns out of the hands of those most likely to abuse them. Untargeted gun amnesties and buy-backs, on the other hand, have little effect, being used predominantly by those uninterested in breaking the law. [snip]"

vvv
 
Canadian liberalism & self-righteousness

Ah Canada, we are so much better than our cousins to the south. I almost gagged reading some of these responses on gun control and how the liberal element has so many of you readers believing the propaganda.

Point 1 - Someone is breaking into my garage at 3:00 a.m., the police have been called but don't show as this is a high crime area and they have better things to do. I grab the twelve gauge and head out to protect my property and well being. I warn the culprits to stop and desist and let a warning shot off at the ground. Several pellets richocet and hit said criminals. Who goes to jail? Answer, the gentleman protecting his property. No one went to jail for the B&E given they were young offenders.

In Canada, I feel that we do not have the right to self-defense. The criminals have no fear of reprissal beyond the law and this depends stictly on being caught. I respect Americans on this point - if someone threatens your ass, he has got himself a fight. Canadians on the other hand would whine; "But we are peace keepers not warriors. Take what you want but please don't shoot me."

Another thought on gun control. . . I apolgise for not knowing the actual ammendment number but the right to bear arms arose from the militia and the need to protect government from tyranny through revolution. It is given that this outdated law is steeped in tradition and nonsensical at best. We would never have to worry as Canadians about one party rule where the head of state and the leader of the government were not elected to their position. We also would never have to worry about corruption in government at the national level or the lack of accountability to the voting populace. Our government leaders are not elected for life due to the fact that we have a multi-party system that allows choice. No, definately not.

It is only those totalitarian regimes that require it's citizenry to register firearms. It is only those corupt regimes that would require a database of law-abiding residents to license their weapons and give police the right to kick down your door with impunity. No fellow Terbites, I do not possess a gun by choice and I have no intention to insight revolt but if you ever come through my front door without first knocking I will bust your fucking head wide open with a two by four. Now you liberal idealogues better set up a registry for softwood timber.
 
Last edited:
Re: Canadian liberalism & self-righteousness

Challenger:

Feeling a little self-righteous today?:p

vvv

P.S. Ah WTF, I shouldn't be so critical. It's an important issue for the citizenry, isn't it? If one can't get worked up about this, what does one get worked up about? Better some heat than some apathy.
 
Last edited:
A sidebar

It's beginning to alarm me how far apart Canadians and Americans are drifting on most issues. What is deemed foolish here, is perfectly acceptable, honoured in fact, south of the border.

I used to remember how a David Frum editorial used to make me roll my eyes and laugh out loud. He was such an unabashed right-wing wacko you'd question the sanity of anyone who took him seriously. I lost track of him, I figured that he would find Canada a bit too pinko for his liking and move south.

Imagine my surprise - and unease, when I learned that he had written President Bush's "Axis of Evil" speech! Has the USA gone THAT far to the right?
 
And yet another rant from Mr. Heston

Maybe the more appropriate answer is has Canada moved that far to the left.

We've become a country of victims! You only have to look to the recent newspaper articles on prostitution to see that some in the media would portray women selling their good will as victims - victimized by those with power specifically men and the social system.

Look only to our system of justice. We, in Canada, believe that all people are inheritently good and those operating outside of society's norms can be rehabilitated. Canadians also feel that adolescents cannot make sound judgements and should be forgiven all of their sins prior to their eighteenth birthday. We are victims of abuse at the hands of our fathers, the clergy, the coaches, the hunchbacked uncle from Timmins. It's everyone else that is to blame and we need compassion, an eagle feather, a group sing along. We need to save the Palestinians from the Jews and the Jews from themselves. Be forewarned - if you don't toe the politically correct line then you are an anti-semite, a bigot, a racist or an inbred, knuckle-dragging Neanderthal.

I still feel though that the majority is silent. That there are people that understand right from wrong. That a person from a minority can be evil not because of their skin colour or race but simply because they are a prick and you should have the right to say so. That's what I like about Americans, they want to be the fuckers and not the fuckees, the victimizers and not the victims. They may each have a different handgun for each day of the week but at least they can defend themselves personally and as a nation without hiding behind the skirts of any other country on the planet.
 
Last edited:
I hear ya.

Challenger I agree.

It's good to be a fucker. Like charging into South East Asia, guns a blazing, and stepping on a Bouncing Betty, that's how Uncle Sam kicks ass. A few irrelevant Canadians got in the way, so what.
 
Re: A sidebar

Aldo McDuff said:
It's beginning to alarm me how far apart Canadians and Americans are drifting on most issues. What is deemed foolish here, is perfectly acceptable, honoured in fact, south of the border.

I used to remember how a David Frum editorial used to make me roll my eyes and laugh out loud. He was such an unabashed right-wing wacko you'd question the sanity of anyone who took him seriously. I lost track of him, I figured that he would find Canada a bit too pinko for his liking and move south.

Imagine my surprise - and unease, when I learned that he had written President Bush's "Axis of Evil" speech! Has the USA gone THAT far to the right?
Aldo:
Wouldn't you say that the drift apart on political issues isn't so much between Canada and the US as it is between the US and the rest of the world?

vvv
 
Look only to our system of justice. We, in Canada, believe that all people are inheritently good and those operating outside of society's norms can be rehabilitated. Canadians also feel that adolescents cannot make sound judgements and should be forgiven all of their sins prior to their eighteenth birthday. We are victims of abuse at the hands of our fathers, the clergy, the coaches, the hunchbacked uncle from Timmins. It's everyone else that is to blame and we need compassion, an eagle feather, a group sing along. We need to save the Palestinians from the Jews and the Jews from themselves. Be forewarned - if you don't toe the politically correct line then you are an anti-semite, a bigot, a racist or an inbred, knuckle-dragging Neanderthal.

Extremus....is that you?
 
Guns and Crime

1. Challenger: It's the Second Amendment, NOTE: Right after Freedom of speech/religion - the First Amendment - the Founding Fathers posited the Second. One purpose, inter alia, was to preclude the government from having the only force in town. That is consistent with the First A. which denies the Government the right to curtail speech of a citizen or one's religion. As a private citizen, I can discriminate as I wish so long as the goverment isn't involved. Once the government (ANY level thereof) is involved, no discrimination. E.g., because I need a state license to serve alcohol, I must serve all, not just thirsty or horny Canadians.

2. Aldo McDuff: Which war are you referring to? If Vietnam, we should have ddone it right or not at all. If Afghanistan, what do you want us to do when they blow up our people? Suppose it happened in TO? and you lost several thousand Canadians. Would you turn the other cheek? Go to the UN?

And who would be the first non-Canadians in TO helping out with people, doctors, use of hospitals across the lakes, helicopters etc etc?

You know the answer to that one, don't you. It wouldn't come from London or Paris with that speed, quantity, quality or anything else.

You know, if our military had the relative strength of Canada's, we'd all be speaking Russian, even the Quebecois. You guys can get away without a heavy-duty military because we do it and you can get in under the umbrella. Okay; that makes you smart and lucky. But then don't complain about ours. What would you all have to gear up to were we, say, Mexico?
 
More sanctamonius american crap.

The second ammendment, how it get's twisted and used by the far right.

The right to bear arms (or is that arm bears). Isn't there something in there about the public, raising militias in times of conflict, blah blah blah.

The second ammendment does not say that thou shalt have the right to carry a concealed semi automatic handgun.

Speaking russian, or Quebecois that's funny.

Tabernack.........

Tu pense que je ne peux pas parler francais maintanant.

J'etudie francais en ecole, et maintanant, je travail a Quebec quelque fois.

J'aime quebec beaucoup aussi.

Mengez du la merde mon ami Master Muse

Ka-leese.

:D