Greatest NFL Coach

unassuming

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2017
14,234
5,457
113
Popular opinion has Belichek as the GOAT, but what about Joe Gibbs, he won 3 SBs with 3 different QBs?
 
Don Shula - who died yesterday - R.I.P still has the most number of wins I believe.

I know someone will look it up and post all the numbers.


They did name the Super Bowl trophy after Vince Lombardi.

So there's 2 more names to consider

Never was able to get Marino a ring. One of Sports biggest disappointments.
 
George Halas.

2nd most wins. 6 NFL Championships and a career .683 winning percentage.
 
Never was able to get Marino a ring. One of Sports biggest disappointments.
Maybe Marino was not good enough to get Shula another ring. One of those guys who did not get it done in the playoffs. Like a Dave Winfield or a David Price in baseball.
 
Huge Phins fan here.

Shula was a great coach but later in his career Shula the GM betrayed Shula the Coach. The main reason Dan never won a ring was Shula whiffed in the draft a lot especially after drafting Dan. Most NFL fans would know of the Bosa brothers. Well Don drafted their Father and he was the worst of the Bosas by far. Just too many early round misses to compete with the power houses that were built in the NFC at that time. Plus there was one hell of a Bills team within the same division that probably should've won at least 1 Bowl. Dan was truly a beast for his first 5 seasons. After that multiple knee operations then the torn Achilles made him the least mobile QB in NFL history by a lot. He still had the quickest release in NFL history though which made him difficult to sack plus an innate pocket sense that only Brady has matched and probably surpassed.

Shula is still on the Mount Rushmore of coaches though. He's still the only coach to end a season with a zero in the loss column and one aspect that's different about him was he won with different QBs over different eras with different styles (He took a team to a SB with David Woodley as the QB FFS). Noll and Walsh won with primarily the same group of players. Once the great draft classes of the late 60s and early 70s left the Steelers Noll coached for another dozen years and didn't win squat

A few years from now the glow around Belichick could be dimmed. If he crashes and burns without Tom then his greatness will be lessened. Got to give it to BB though. There was a 10 year gap between his 2 sets of 3 SB wins. Except for Tom they were mostly 2 different teams

Of the coaches I've seen I'd rank them 1. Walsh 2. Shula 3. Gibbs 4. Parcells

Belichick is still undetermined but will likely end up at least at #2. If he shits the bed without Brady then he could fall off completely. His legacy is that closely tied with TB. BB will never be as influential as Walsh though

Tom Landry and though they're before my time Lombardi (Might be #1 all time) Halas and Lambeau are all 1st tier coaches as well
 
Hi guys. I like Jimmie Johnson




It's Jimmy unlike the Nascar driver.

Jimmy burned out too quickly. If he and Jerry just could've gotten along who knows how high up he would be. Ego is a fucked up thing at times
 
Maybe the best coach to never win an NFL championship is Bud Grant. He, and the Purple People Eaters, took the Vikes to 4 Super Bowls but lost them all. He had a .622 winning percentage in the NFL. As well, in 10 years in Winnipeg, starting at age 29, he went to 6 Grey Cups and won 4.

Just found out that he was drafted and played 2 seasons in the NBA.
 
Maybe the best coach to never win an NFL championship is Bud Grant....

Marv Levy would like a word.
May not have won a Super Bowl, but one of the greatest coaches of all time.
 
I think it was mainly the Miami Dolphin's defense that couldn't get it done in the playoffs, not Marino. I'm sure you can look up his stats somewhere

In the end though, both Winfield and Price got World Series rings. If I remember corrrectly, Price actually pitched OK in the playoffs when the Red Sox won a couple of years ago.
Yup. But that was the knock against them.

As for Marino, I was just trying to be a devil's advocate.
 
Considering the salary cap era and roster turnover every year...hands down Bill Belichick.