Goodenow steps down from NHLPA post

Sheik said:
Good riddance and I hope Bettman is next.
Bettman delivered exactly what the owners, his bosses, wanted. They have a new economic structure that limits their costs. No reason for him to leave.
 
The fans got screwed last year... and it was Bettman

... who locked the players out. Yeah the owners got what they wanted so screw the fans? Nope, I hope the fans stay away in droves until Bettman get's canned. NHL punished the fans... now maybe the fans punish the NHL.
 
shack said:
Bettman delivered exactly what the owners, his bosses, wanted. They have a new economic structure that limits their costs. No reason for him to leave.

So did Goodenow. It's kinda hard to get the deal you want (or promised) when your constituents are telling you to settle NOW....
 
Had to fall on his sword.

He was outmanouvered and underestimated the resolve of the owners and NHL administration. I remember what Eugene Melnyk said a few months ago on RSN, "I can go a decade with the lockout. If I run out of money I'll just sell 1% of my pharmaceutical company to make up the difference".

Orders from majority of the players was probably, "resign or be prosecuted".
 
and Goodenow did not get anything that he promised for the players...
 
It was inevitable that he is gone. The only surprise is that it happened so quickly.

Goodenow really screwed up. I think he let his enormous ego get in the way. First he refused to even accept the possibility that the NHL was in financial difficulty. It doesn't take a brain surgeon to realize that the NHL doesn't have nearly the revenue that other major sports have.

Second he stated from the outset that the players would never accept a salary cap. He had players going on TV shows saying the same thing, only to make them look like fools later on. Not only did they accept a cap but they also lost a season of salary plus gave back 24%.

He also didn't seem to have a plan B once he realized the owners were not going to crack.

It looks good on him.
 
northerner said:
It was inevitable that he is gone. The only surprise is that it happened so quickly.

Goodenow really screwed up. I think he let his enormous ego get in the way. First he refused to even accept the possibility that the NHL was in financial difficulty. It doesn't take a brain surgeon to realize that the NHL doesn't have nearly the revenue that other major sports have.

Second he stated from the outset that the players would never accept a salary cap. He had players going on TV shows saying the same thing, only to make them look like fools later on. Not only did they accept a cap but they also lost a season of salary plus gave back 24%.

He also didn't seem to have a plan B once he realized the owners were not going to crack.

It looks good on him.

I'm happy he and his confrontational approach are gone, but the problem was the players didn't have the balls to follow through with Goodenow's plan. His plan was to have the players continue to sit and he figured the owners would crack by mid-season of the second year and cave in to the players. I suspect his plan would have worked but we'll never know, thankfully, because the players panicked and told him to get a deal done, no matter what.

I believe his biggest mistake was not his plan but his lack of understanding his own constituents. That is a major mistake for someone in his position.
 
northerner said:
Goodenow really screwed up.

While I agree he screwed up on this lockout and deserved to be fired. He did make a lot of mediocre players rich millionaires when they really didn't deserve it. During his 13 year tenure average salaries went from $250,000 (1991) to $1,200,000 (2003) according to TSN. Maybe that's why the players supported him back in September but cut him loose now. The whole, "what have you done for me lately" attitude common with unions and their members.
 
shack said:
I'm happy he and his confrontational approach are gone, but the problem was the players didn't have the balls to follow through with Goodenow's plan. His plan was to have the players continue to sit and he figured the owners would crack by mid-season of the second year and cave in to the players.

Assuming that the players would have "won" if they were willing to sit out 2 years, what exactly would they have won. It would have been like winning a nuclear war.
 
Goodenow and the players were in no position to play hard ball. When millionaire players decide to go into battle against BILLIONAIRE owners and corporations, who do you think would win?

The players and Goodenow were fools. They got paid large before, but; now it's time to accept the truth.

The owners were tired of forking out that kind of dough - so, when billionaires decide to bang cash registers with millionaires, the latter loses.

I would have loved to see the PA not settle. I would have bet money to see who would cross a picket line when the owners bring out the replacement players in October. The union screwed it's constituents - they got less now than in the beginning plus they lost a years worth of playing time and salary.

Either way the fans suffer - in the old system it was too pricey to even watch a game. Now, after a year off; the Leafs will still keep the prices the same - and their fans get screwed again.
 
northerner said:
Assuming that the players would have "won" if they were willing to sit out 2 years, what exactly would they have won. It would have been like winning a nuclear war.
Don't ask me. It was their plan, not mine. All I'm saying is the owners very well may have relented on the cap and linkage if the players had hung tough.
 
bob

I liked goodenow as i still was and am on the players side. he serves the PA well and the more time that passes the more you players will miss bobs contribution. Ted saskin not the right man