Going on a Kosher Diet

JamesDouglas

Active member
Nov 10, 2011
1,219
0
36
The next big trend in healthy eating is going on the kosher diet i.e. buying kosher meats that are supposedly healthier than conventional meats, and avoiding pork and shellfish. Only 15% of those who buy kosher meats do so for religious reasons, the rest buy it for health reasons.

I've been on the kosher diet for the past month, it's a bit tough not eating shrimp, crab and lobster but I'm managing. I haven't eaten any pork products for the past few years so that's been easy to avoid, mostly because I don't eat processed meat, so not eating bacon, ham, sausage etc is easy.

Has anyone else tried the kosher diet?
 
Raised in a kosher household, I wouldn't say that a kosher diet is any more healthy than eating a well balanced diet. Actually, traditional jewish foods are very starchy, very fatty and salty so I wouldn't say it's that healthy.
 
I grew up with a diet that imposes the same laws for meat, but different religion. Had phases when I ate only kosher/halal. Then switched back to eating non-kosher meats. But I've always stayed away from pork, and alcohol for the most part (Hate the taste)

The good/bad part about staying kosher is that a lot of fast food and otherwise unhealthy food becomes unavailable. You're restricted as to what you can go out and eat, so you end up cooking a lot of food yourself.
 
you have a tendency to roast people. not giving a sausage for what they post. it might be better instead, to liver-age all the knowledge here

I klick ed on your post and thought it was spam.
 
Only 15% of those who buy kosher meats do so for religious reasons, the rest buy it for health reasons.
That one doesn't sound right either unless if one were to understand "health reasons" as meaning that kosher meats are cleaner cuts from cleaner animals and butchered differently.

And even that does not hold as true as it once did in light of meat inspection standards in countries like Canada.

In terms of calories, heart health, diabetes etc., it is far from a healthy diet.
 
That one doesn't sound right either unless if one were to understand "health reasons" as meaning that kosher meats are cleaner cuts from cleaner animals and butchered differently.

And even that does not hold as true as it once did in light of meat inspection standards in countries like Canada.

In terms of calories, heart health, diabetes etc., it is far from a healthy diet.

Here's a good summary of the health benefits of eating kosher meats. Of course there are a lot of very unhealthy processed kosher foods, but I stay away from those, it doesn't matter if a hot dog, salami, chips, cookies etc are kosher, if it's processed it's not healthy.

http://www.helium.com/items/1543396-health-benefits-of-kosher-food
 
When it comes to Kosher......the only thing it means when discussing meats....

is that the death of these animals is MOST BRUTAL.

Not like North American ways, where the animal is first stunned...and thereby does not feel or sense the pending death.

With Kosher, surprisingly in Canada, the animal is strung up alive and kicking, and the knife is drawn across its neck, severing the carotid and jugular veins.

The animal is left to thrash and kick and slowly die, all the while realizing the trauma that it is undergoing.

Shocking really, that this is allowed to happen in Canada.

Enjoy your healthy Kosher.


FURTHERMORE, an animal should be stress free when being butchered. Stress free means the meat is relaxed and will be much more tender. If an animal is under stress, thrashing about, and releasing adrenaline, (also a fear hormone) at time of death, the Meat becomes much tougher.

So Kosher meat I would argue is no more healthy, is likely tougher, and certainly came from a brutally butchered animal.

As to that link to that post above, there is nothing earth shattering about the meat process. Pork for instance has come a long way, and that article draws on some old thoughts of pork that no longer exist ( yes, centuries ago pigs were gutter and swamp dwellers, fattening on swill and garbage....but today they are grain fed animals, in clean well run farming operations...no different than beef.)

And the article comments on the kill being quick. again, some old school facts there. I have been in slaughter houses. Witnessed the technology first hand. Today's animals are purposely kept calm leading up to the butchering point. They are relaxed at time of stunning, and then hung for bleeding. The kosher way strings then up first, then slices their throats. I would argue with that article on other points as well.
 
When it comes to Kosher......the only thing it means when discussing meats....

is that the death of these animals is MOST BRUTAL.

Not like North American ways, where the animal is first stunned...and thereby does not feel or sense the pending death.

With Kosher, surprisingly in Canada, the cow is strung up alive and kicking, and the knife is drawn across its neck, severing the carotid and jugular veins.

The animal is left to thrash and kick and slowly die, all the while realizing the trauma that it is undergoing.

Shocking really, that this is allowed to happen in Canada.

Enjoy your healthy Kosher.


FURTHERMORE, an animal should be stress free when being butchered. Stress free means the meat is relaxed and will be much more tender. If an animal is under stress, thrashing about, and releasing adrenaline, at time of death, the Meat become tougher.

So Kosher meat I would argue is no more healthy, is likely tougher, and certainly came from a brutally butchered animal.

From the article I posted earlier:
"Kosher slaughtering rituals also leads to healthier meat. According to kosher law, the slaughtering of an animal must be immediate and painless. This means that the animal will feel no fear, and therefore will not release a hormone linked to fear. Studies have shown that animals slaughtered in the conventional way have elevated levels of this hormone, which leads to a range of health problems in humans, including cardiac disease, impotence, and fatigue. As the ritual slaughter rules also dictate that the animal must be killed in such a way that it does not know that it will be killed, Kosher food is also healthier for your conscience."
 
James...I added to my post above. That article is wrong in some respect.

Quick and painless is relative. That thinking meant get to to the carotid artery quick and get it severed WITH A KNIFE.

That happens in regular conventional butchering too.


BUT...The animal must be strung up....head down..to release all the blood. This happens in abattoirs...even Kosher ones. It's that stringing up that is the difference. In conventional killing...the animal is first stunned while relaxed. Once strung up, then the throat is slit usually almost decapitating the animal with a power saw to ensure a complete bleed. The stunning does not kill the animal, and therefore the heart continues to pump, as desired, to further push blood out.

The kosher way is slower in two respects.....first getting the animal into,the air....no doubt thrashing, and secondly using a knife to sever. Conventional killing is painless, faster and offers a more complete bleed.

I get that kosher meats must be only butchered on tables where kosher meats are butchered. That goes back centuries when killing was a much dirtier business, and in those days, 'kosher' had set a higher cleaner standard.

However, in today's kill houses, standards of cleanliness would more than rival the standards of Kosher kill houses of yesteryear.

The below video shows a 'Halal' killing house ( have not looked up the rules on Halal) but this demonstrates how the animal walks into a chute and is stunned before being butchered. (It is NOT shot dead as many people think..the heart continues to pump) During their life, animals often walk into these chutes, for various procedures or when needing attention perhaps from a vet, so it is somewhat normal.


www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMhuXdS0e3I