GM -more layoffs

Being a past GM employee, I will offer my opinion (in point form), if anyone cares

1) Price of gas is insane causing people to reconsider purchasing large trucks as toys, which is pretty well what they are if not used for work.
2) Canadian dollar is so high is is making Canada less attractive for manufacturing, especially with the added transportation costs of shipping 90% of the product to the USA.
3) USA is nearing recession status (if they haven't already), scaring people shitless and keeping them from spending on large ticket items.
4) The GM Sierra and Silverado trucks are among the most expensive on the market.
5) The wages of the GM line worker are far above the industry standard (about $35/hr.). Add to this the comprehensive benefits package, the SPA/PAA/Vacaion days/4 day holiday weekends/summer shut down/ christmas vacation and they get about 12 weeks off per year. Where the hell else is that normal????
6) The PERCIEVED quality of GM compared to the foreign manufacturers, (not even talking about real quality) means declining sales.

That's enogh for now, gotta go have dinner.:D
 
Union bashing at it's finest!!! I will try and clear up some of the misconceptions posted here...

Gm employee's do not get 12 weeks of holidays a year...
2 weeks shut down
2 weeks spa
christmass
3 weeks more after 20 years
5 days long weekend days
Now some of the above holidays take in Stat holidays so if you deduct those ... A GM worker might get 4 weeks more(after they reach 20 + years) than the average worker.... How is that there fault .... The Big 3 agreeded to these holidays as thier workforce aged and neeeded time to recover to be able to perform the repititious work involved.... I challenge anyone to go work in a Auto assembly for a year with out time off and not sustain severe injury from the work involved...

This anouncement stems from the fact that trucks are not selling and GM has overcapasity in trucks.. Better to stop building them sooner than later and not have to have fire sales(IE: huge incentive"s) to sell them ....
All other truck manufacturerers have also cut back production forcasts for this year so this is really not GM specific it is a fact for all truck makers..


Yes Buzz and Chris Buckley are crazy to blame the government... They are only doing this as bashing the company won't help there cause.. LOL ... They seem to foolhardly think if they can shame the government into more "manufacturing assistance" that will help the cause... It's all about union revenue to them and they been hit hard in the last year so be patient with them as they are just a tad "hurt" at the moment... The union had it's day when it was needed but i do believe public pressure and a couple of good labour lawyers could replace the union for a fraction of the cost. They try to paint themselfs as responsible to the moral majority but in most cases it's all about protecting union income which is going to be a thorny issue in local 222 these days with the masive reductions over the last year...

The cost of wages to assemble car/trucks in a North american built vehical is about 9% of the vehical cost,so wages per vehical are hardly killing these companies... Althought the media and the big three like to paint a much different picture.. When car companies are one of the biggest buyers of print and electronic advertizing it isn't hard to see how reporting on the "issues" is very one sided favoring the "gospel" of the car companies... I highly doubt media outlets are going to jepordize there biggest customers by not towing the company line!

Funny how the same day GM announces these lay offs they also announce that they gave there top exec's a 30% raise over there previous years compansation.. The Pres of GM was given a compansation package worth over 14 million last year .... Not bad for a company that has been in the ditch or so they like to portray for the last few years..
 
avguy said:
Union bashing at it's finest!!! I will try and clear up some of the misconceptions posted here...

Gm employee's do not get 12 weeks of holidays a year...
2 weeks shut down
2 weeks spa
christmass
3 weeks more after 20 years
5 days long weekend days
Not union bashing at all...

2 weeks shutdown
2 weeks SPA (scheduled paid absence)
2 weeks Christmas (last year from Dec. 21 - Jan. 4)
3 weeks PAA at full seniority (56 hours 2x Paid Absence Allowance in 4 hr. intervals)
4 weeks VN (vacation at full seniority)
+3 '4 day' weekends through the year.

Add it up my friend.. 2+2+2+3+4=13 weeks. I don't begrudge the union, as a matter of fact I wish I was in on this, but anyway one slices the cake, it is still 12 weeks, mostly paid and not including Christmas bonus, benefits, pension plan, daycare subsidy, lawyer subsidy, employee purchase discount, cost of living added, 5%-10% shift premium, 30 years and retirement, huge buyout packages, blah, blah, blah.

Tell me anywhere else this is the norm? And especially how they can expect to remain competative? As I heard one long term employee say "Hide and seek for a grand a week, God bless the General!".
 
S.C. Joe said:
Stop blaming unions for everything bad :mad:

They are not to blame for everything bad
I do not think they are responsible for
1. Global Warming
2. Over-population
3. Famine in Africa
4. Corruption (Oh sorry, they did have that Jimmy Hoffa thing)
5. Infant mortality
6. A couple other things

Unions did serve a social good @ the turn of the 19th century ( they acted as a counter balance to greedy owners & unsafe working conditions)
However they took it to extremes
$75 /hr + benefits on an assembly line & they did not heed warnings the North American Auto Industry would be uncompetitive with Japanese car makers
Guess what. They are not & the unions will have to greatly reduce the wage & membership
I have heard multiple stories of management being upfront with unions indicating they will need to shut the plant down unless they get relief from Union demands.
The unions called what they thought were bluffs and would not agree to concessions & demanded large increases.
Guess What. The plants closed.


There is always talk of having a partnership with unions
Why would anyone who is investing their capital want to partner with a group who is not putting up their capital & who does not understand if it costs more to make than you can sell it for the future is not bright.

Sure these cases may be isolated, but if I had a choice to run a business with or without a union. I would certainly not wish to expose my capital to the risk I might be negotiated out of business.
I would rather treat employees well & pay them what the economics of the business will allow, However the decisions should be left to those who are putting their money @ risk
 
I can only say that it is the combined stupitiy and arrogence of North American car makers, Goverments, and Unions that has put the auto sector where it is today.

A little forsight would have put us in a place where the manufacturing of hybrid cars and trucks, small and large ,cheap and expensive, could have prevented most of this. Gas is going to become more expensive. The best way to offset this is to use less gas. I am looking at buying a Toyota Prius
4.1 liters per 100 km. This is 1/3 of the use of gas for my existing Car.
One third of double the price equals a net saving. Also if we cut our consuption that much where would gas price be.
However the Goverment,s lame attemps at getting better milage, lame because of the auto lobby, is going to cost us now and will continue to do so untill the consumer responds with a demand for better milage. This does not mean cheaper junk cars.

Finally the auto industry has been betrayed by the oil industry. Will they respond and change or die.
 
I heard something on the radio which helps more to explain what's going on here. An automotive industry expert was talking about the layoff . His comments were :

1) demand for the vehicle manufactured here is down so the cutback was obvious

2) Ontario is now the most expensive place in the world to manufacture cars so don't expect any new vehicles production to be switched here

3) there is not much that governments can do about high wages and land costs. We already have cheaper electricity so all they can do is reduce corporate taxes and property taxes. Reducing corporate taxes is only an effective incentive if you are profitable.

4) CAW has priced Canadian labour out of competition now that the dollar is at par. Their brothers in the UAW actually play this up and actively campaign about bringing jobs back from Canada. The UAW has given Ford major concessions in their new contract while the CAW has chosen to only blame government.

What exactly would you have the feds do? They have already reduced corporate income taxes over a 3 year period. What would you have the Provincial government do ?
 
JohnLarue said:
I have heard multiple stories of management being upfront with unions indicating they will need to shut the plant down unless they get relief from Union demands.
The unions called what they thought were bluffs and would not agree to concessions & demanded large increases.
Guess What. The plants closed.

It happened to me at Consumers Distributing. :(
 
The Molsons Plant in Barrie, same thing. Union wouldn't back off so Molson said we are outta here. Guess the union showed them who was boss.:D


.
 
We in North America are to blame because of our greed and total disrespect of the environment around us. We have continued buying these gas guzzlers at fuel prices that are half our European counter-parts. This in turn was a lucrative market for our north american car suppliers who exploited it with bigger and bigger SUVs and wagons with more powerful and thirstier engines. We use more gas per person than any other region round the world, and most car manufacturers offer the same cars as in Europe and universally but with more powerful engines as standard. We have come to expect that over the years. If you listen to the CP24 car show on Sundays, you even hear Mohammed Bouchama recommending cars with over 200 HP engines over the more tinnie engines that the same model also offers. With our speed limit that is a paltry 100 kilometres an hour it is no wonder that we are at the same time paying record amounts for speeding tickets and higher insurance costs as a result. I am not saying that OPEC and the Multi-national Oil companies are innocent parties is this whole insane commodity call oil. However, even today there is not a slow-down in oil consumption here, but it will hit home at some stage when gas reaches the expected $2.40 in a couple of years time. That is why GM expects future sales in this sector to nose-dive and has to make a firm decision if it is to survive as a car manufacturer. Just my two cents.
 
lavameltme said:
I can only say that it is the combined stupitiy and arrogence of North American car makers, Goverments, and Unions that has put the auto sector where it is today.

A little forsight would have put us in a place where the manufacturing of hybrid cars and trucks, small and large ,cheap and expensive, could have prevented most of this. Gas is going to become more expensive. The best way to offset this is to use less gas. I am looking at buying a Toyota Prius
4.1 liters per 100 km. This is 1/3 of the use of gas for my existing Car.
One third of double the price equals a net saving. Also if we cut our consuption that much where would gas price be.
However the Goverment,s lame attemps at getting better milage, lame because of the auto lobby, is going to cost us now and will continue to do so untill the consumer responds with a demand for better milage. This does not mean cheaper junk cars.


Finally the auto industry has been betrayed by the oil industry. Will they respond and change or die.

I seem to recall that the new ( at the time pres of Ford a real Ford believe it or not) wanted to go into smaller green cars about 10 years ago. Both his division managers and the union insisted he stay with the suv's and pickups due to the profit margins. Right about now he looks like a hero with clairvoiance.
 
train said:
I heard something on the radio which helps more to explain what's going on here. An automotive industry expert was talking about the layoff . His comments were :

1) demand for the vehicle manufactured here is down so the cutback was obvious

2) Ontario is now the most expensive place in the world to manufacture cars so don't expect any new vehicles production to be switched here

3) there is not much that governments can do about high wages and land costs. We already have cheaper electricity so all they can do is reduce corporate taxes and property taxes. Reducing corporate taxes is only an effective incentive if you are profitable.

4) CAW has priced Canadian labour out of competition now that the dollar is at par. Their brothers in the UAW actually play this up and actively campaign about bringing jobs back from Canada. The UAW has given Ford major concessions in their new contract while the CAW has chosen to only blame government.

What exactly would you have the feds do? They have already reduced corporate income taxes over a 3 year period. What would you have the Provincial government do ?

A lot of it comes down to the Canadian dollar being unnaturally high because of resources. It kills Ontario.
 
Meister said:
A lot of it comes down to the Canadian dollar being unnaturally high because of resources. It kills Ontario.

True but I think we lived on the cheap dollar making us competitive for too long and are now stuck.

I'd like to know what the CAW expects the Feds to do or the Province for that matter.

I would be against a direct subsidy to GM to build a truck nobody wants. I might be in favour of incentives to retool and build hybrids here but that would take a year or two to happen. The fundementals would have to change too, we don't want another Quebec Hyindai situation. The CAW would have to play ball too.
 
train said:
I might be in favour of incentives to retool and build hybrids here but that would take a year or two to happen. The fundementals would have to change too, we don't want another Quebec Hyindai situation. The CAW would have to play ball too.
The plant is already tooled and ready to start production of Hybrids.
 
GMs problems are the Big Threes problems and they started long ago. Arrogance ruled the automotive sector in North America, before the Japanese invasion, you thought they only bombed Pearl Harbour. When the Japanese entered the NA market, the big three laughed them off saying that they would never get anything but a sliver of the pie being served and they would always have the lions share from the market. That was true in the begining and held for a number of years until the product being sold became better. The Japanese management style has led to their strong surge forward.

Now, on the NA side of things, with our bloated sense of things, the unions, while needed and helpful to the workers at one time, started to carve themselves out more from the pie. Yes you can blame the Big Three for letting it happen, but in a sense there was the thought of striking unions and that sends car sales flat when there is no product. That is why you have the wages and benefits so high. A worker is entitled to a fair wage, but when his wages and benefit package add thousands more to the price of a car it will eventually have an impact on their market share.

Unions also ovestep the bounds of reality by protecting workers who should be fired for their non-existent work ethic, shitty job performance and their demands of more more more, when the market clearly cannot handle such requests. The union should get a grip on reality and look at Honda's way of doing business with their line employees. Although they are non-union, they are paid well for what they do and receive a fair benefit package as well.
 
a 1 player said:
The plant is already tooled and ready to start production of Hybrids.

Really? They spent a bunch of money on tooling and didn't fire it up?

If that's the case there is no hope and the CAW can smoke their pipe for as long as they want the Government can't bail them out of this one.

Has the CAW asked for something specific or is it just more of the usual bleating ?
 
GM today posted a $3.3 billion first-quarter loss, and the stock is UP over $2 a share :p

As for unions bring GM down, well the unions were still around 10 years ago when the SUV's were flying out the door and GM stock went over $90 a share-its $23 today.

Its mostly the sky high gas prices and the weak home sales thats hurting GM. They didn't think gasoline would be so high and did not see small cars making a come back. You can't blame the unions for that part. The unions don't decide which cars and trucks to make.
 
train said:
Really? They spent a bunch of money on tooling and didn't fire it up?
In order to bring a car or truck into production is a very labour intensive process. Though the tooling is there and functional, employees have to be trained, quality has to be brought up to standard and the supply chain has to be bang on. It usually takes several months to test, train, and bring up to speed full production in any automotive environment.

I guess the next question would be, would the Trucks sell at even a higher price than their straight gasoline counterparts with all the shit that is happening? And will they sell in quantities to bring back 2000+ workers (including midnight shift)? Keep in mind there are a few other plants making this exact truck.

I can't see that happening at all unless something drastic changes, which I do not believe it will for at least the next couple of years.
 
Its the "big shots" at GM who drag their feet on building Hybrids. And now instead of building Hybrid cars, they build Hybrid trucks which get half the gas mileage.

But the "big shots" still making muti millions to hundreds of million of dollars every year-oh BTW, those are non-union workers.
 
S.C. Joe said:
But the "big shots" still making muti millions to hundreds of million of dollars every year-oh BTW, those are non-union workers.

Time to quit the union eh Joe, they have been holding you back. :D