Globalive Court Decision

Thank goodness Canada still has an independent judiciary. The Federal Court overturns the decision by a tyrannical Prime Minister and his cabinet to allow Globalive into Canada. No doubt, the tyrant will appeal and/or nullify the court decision by changing the law.

Hey, the Liberals also changed the law with respect to Jake Friesen's successful SC ruling over an Income Tax Act provision concerning write-offs in speculative land investments that went sour, which I quote a tax expert as saying was 'mean-spirited'.
 
I like Tony Clement (helped in his campaign one year) but the law is the law, even if I hate fucking oligopolies like Bell or Rogers or the Big Banks.

That being said, couldn't Globalive get a ruling from the CRTC before spending millions? Are they stupid? Then the CRTC lends uncertainty to foreign investors in this nation of ours more than Fidel Castro would in Cuba! What's going on here?

It is not a hard and fast law, the question was one of INTERPETATION. To meet the Canadian Ownership requirements, the majoirty of VOTING shares are Canadian owned. The common equity is mostly owned by Egyptians. Industry Canada ruled this satisfied the requiements of "Canadian Control" and allowed them to bid. CRTC stuck it's big fat nose into it and said no. Industry Canada IMHO has a bigger say in here. The mandate of the CRTC is as follows:


"The CRTC’s mandate is to ensure that both the broadcasting and telecommunications systems serve the Canadian public. The CRTC uses the objectives in the Broadcasting Act and the Telecommunications Act to guide its policy decisions. "

So how the FUCK does their ruling serve that mandate? The judge is an IDIOT imho.
 
It is not a hard and fast law, the question was one of INTERPETATION.

I think this issue also arose in the failed takeover of BCE a couple of years ago. Let's face it, there are ownership restrictions in all kinds of industries such as airlines (Air Canada), banks, etc. Let's not forget that Tony Clement also killed the buyout of Potash without allowing the shareholders to even cast their votes on the matter. Didn't Tony Clement also kill the sale of MacDonald Dettwiler?
 
I would agree in the sense that opening up the marketplace is done better through lasting structural changes (i.e. deregulation, reduce barriers to FDI, etc) rather than through ad hoc decree by the executive branch.
 
I think this issue also arose in the failed takeover of BCE a couple of years ago. Let's face it, there are ownership restrictions in all kinds of industries such as airlines (Air Canada), banks, etc. Let's not forget that Tony Clement also killed the buyout of Potash without allowing the shareholders to even cast their votes on the matter. Didn't Tony Clement also kill the sale of MacDonald Dettwiler?

So what, are you saying we are the only country that does this? The US refused to allow an oil company to be sold to a Chinese company. They refused to allow their ports to be run by an Arab owned company.. WTF.. Do you think the US would allow a Chinese company to buy GM? Would they allow a Chinese company to buy Lockheed Martin? Exxon? Would Australia allow a Chinese company to buy BHP?
 
They refused to allow their ports to be run by an Arab owned company..

Wonder if the U.S. would allow an Egyptian company to ..............................? Doesn't matter how one dresses it up, it is an Egyptian company.

I have no problem with Bell and Rogers making a decent profit. Paying taxes to Canada, providing good jobs to Canadians, paying dividends to their Canadian shareholder base and re-investing the rest.
 
I have no problem with Bell and Rogers making a decent profit. Paying taxes to Canada, providing good jobs to Canadians, paying dividends to their Canadian shareholder base and re-investing the rest.

LOL, any smart money would probably invest their money on BCE/Telus and Rogers/Shaw a year ago or so.

Nothing beats oligopoly while collecting dividends and generating capital gains over time. :cool:
 
So what, are you saying we are the only country that does this? The US refused to allow an oil company to be sold to a Chinese company. They refused to allow their ports to be run by an Arab owned company.. WTF..

LOL, CNOOC was lucky not to pay top dollar on Unocal last time. Let the Chevon had the has-been business.

CEO is savvy this time to have JV with heavily indebted CHK on shale gas development, instead of trying to repeat the same mistake by paying top dollar on company, say ECA.

BTW, looking forward to having PTR or CEO or SNP take over Talisman Energy.

WRT those ports, the Americans were dumb in retrospect. The Americans should sell their ports at a premium to the ME and buy back the ports on the cheap when Dubai 2009 debt standstill hit and the DP World's debt got downgraded to Junk. :cool:

Do you think the US would allow a Chinese company to buy GM?

Sure. Not going to be surprised the powers that be in the US government would "use" the Chinese to once and for all, inflict a mortal blow on UAW.

Would they allow a Chinese company to buy Lockheed Martin? Exxon?

Horse shit! No sane Mandarins in Beijing would waste their time and money to do a takeover bid like you suggest.

Perhaps you do but don't recall you work as i-bankers desperate for fees.

Would Australia allow a Chinese company to buy BHP?

Again dumb question. You know the answer for Rio Tinto, right?
 
Wonder if the U.S. would allow an Egyptian company to ..............................? Doesn't matter how one dresses it up, it is an Egyptian company.

I have no problem with Bell and Rogers making a decent profit. Paying taxes to Canada, providing good jobs to Canadians, paying dividends to their Canadian shareholder base and re-investing the rest.

No one does, but wireless adoption rates and usage are the lynch pin of many other new services. So while Bell and Rogers rape consumers they also prevent many other content based services delivered over wireless and slow progress in our economy... like I said before, are you really that slow or a troll?
 
LOL, CNOOC was lucky not to pay top dollar on Unocal last time. Let the Chevon had the has-been business.

CEO is savvy this time to have JV with heavily indebted CHK on shale gas development, instead of trying to repeat the same mistake by paying top dollar on company, say ECA.

BTW, looking forward to having PTR or CEO or SNP take over Talisman Energy.

WRT those ports, the Americans were dumb in retrospect. The Americans should sell their ports at a premium to the ME and buy back the ports on the cheap when Dubai 2009 debt standstill hit and the DP World's debt got downgraded to Junk. :cool:



Sure. Not going to be surprised the powers that be in the US government would "use" the Chinese to once and for all, inflict a mortal blow on UAW.



Horse shit! No sane Mandarins in Beijing would waste their time and money to do a takeover bid like you suggest.

Perhaps you do but don't recall you work as i-bankers desperate for fees.



Again dumb question. You know the answer for Rio Tinto, right?

That was a merger, not an acquistion, and it happened in 1962 and was finalized in 1995 as far as I can tell. I don't think they would allow BHP to be bought now. In either case most of your arguments are MOOT, the fact is it was not allowed by the US regardless of how good or bad a decision it was. You are saying the Chinese would not waste their $$ on buying Exxon, yet they tried to buy Unocal. Why would they not but LM or sections of it? After all they have 3 trillion in US bonds that they need to convert to some sort of value.
 
That was a merger, not an acquistion, and it happened in 1962 and was finalized in 1995 as far as I can tell. I don't think they would allow BHP to be bought now.

WTF are you talking about?? Are you getting high on weed or something? Dyslexia?

CNOOC was not existed in 1962, the year China and India had border clash in Tibet.

Don't recall any Chinese SOE try to takeover BHP. Rio Tinto OTOH did ask the new "sugar daddy" like Chalco to invest money and fend off hostile takeover by BHP.

In either case most of your arguments are MOOT, the fact is it was not allowed by the US regardless of how good or bad a decision it was. You are saying the Chinese would not waste their $$ on buying Exxon, yet they tried to buy Unocal.

Funny you fail to recall CEO attempt to take over Unocal has to do with the majority of the Unocal Asset is in Asia. Are you really that slow?

WRT Exxon, again you make no sense to suggest the Chinese will buy the granddaddy of the Integrated Oil. Don't you know the market cap for PTR is the 2nd largest, right behind Exxon?

Why would they not but LM or sections of it?

LMAO, yet again you just prove yourself to be really slow.

Instead of taking your most stupid suggestion, the money the Chinese have could buy the whole Russian/Former Soviet MIC, twice and if the Chinese could get their way, they could just tap the best and the brightest Russian minds in MIC and have them teach the Chinese to work on things that might become fruition in the Soviet days. :rolleyes:

Pretty much explain why the Russians try everything to stall the Chinese attempt to pay their way to narrow the gap between the Americans and themselves.

After all they have 3 trillion in US bonds that they need to convert to some sort of value.

Funny you fail to notice the Chinese spend the Uncle Sam currency in overdrive by buying influences, resources in Africa, even Canada, while paying the "banksters" at Wall Street to do their bidding for the sovereign wealth funds worldwide.
 
Wonder if the U.S. would allow an Egyptian company to ..............................? Doesn't matter how one dresses it up, it is an Egyptian company.

I have no problem with Bell and Rogers making a decent profit. Paying taxes to Canada, providing good jobs to Canadians, paying dividends to their Canadian shareholder base and re-investing the rest.



No one does, but wireless adoption rates and usage are the lynch pin of many other new services. So while Bell and Rogers rape consumers they also prevent many other content based services delivered over wireless and slow progress in our economy... like I said before, are you really that slow or a troll?


Rock, when nottyboy calls you a troll, you really have hit rock bottom. Maybe take a deep breath and try not posting into every thread multiple times, it sometimes seems like you are just trying to increase post count.
 
Rock, when nottyboy calls you a troll, you really have hit rock bottom. Maybe take a deep breath and try not posting into every thread multiple times, it sometimes seems like you are just trying to increase post count.

I hear you but then he insults everybody. Best way to avoid his insults is not to post but I won't back down.
 
WTF are you talking about?? Are you getting high on weed or something? Dyslexia?

CNOOC was not existed in 1962, the year China and India had border clash in Tibet.

Don't recall any Chinese SOE try to takeover BHP. Rio Tinto OTOH did ask the new "sugar daddy" like Chalco to invest money and fend off hostile takeover by BHP.



Funny you fail to recall CEO attempt to take over Unocal has to do with the majority of the Unocal Asset is in Asia. Are you really that slow?

WRT Exxon, again you make no sense to suggest the Chinese will buy the granddaddy of the Integrated Oil. Don't you know the market cap for PTR is the 2nd largest, right behind Exxon?



LMAO, yet again you just prove yourself to be really slow.

Instead of taking your most stupid suggestion, the money the Chinese have could buy the whole Russian/Former Soviet MIC, twice and if the Chinese could get their way, they could just tap the best and the brightest Russian minds in MIC and have them teach the Chinese to work on things that might become fruition in the Soviet days. :rolleyes:

Pretty much explain why the Russians try everything to stall the Chinese attempt to pay their way to narrow the gap between the Americans and themselves.



Funny you fail to notice the Chinese spend the Uncle Sam currency in overdrive by buying influences, resources in Africa, even Canada, while paying the "banksters" at Wall Street to do their bidding for the sovereign wealth funds worldwide.

I was talking about the origens of Rio Tinto you dufus Rio Tinto originated from a merger between and Australian and Brit company. NO China could not buy the Russian MIC, because they would not be allowed to. I am sure some Russian scientists would wokrk for the Chinese, but they could also hire Americans more easily. Rio Tinto is now a British company...but Britain could not really block an aquistion because of the history of the company and it's massive presence in Australia.
 
I was talking about the origens of Rio Tinto you dufus

WTF is "dufus"? Do you mean you as doofus? LOL

Plus, wtf is "origens"? Do you mean estrogen or something?

Rio Tinto originated from a merger between and Australian and Brit company.

LOL, like nobody in Canada had a clue. Funny you never mentioned Alcan.

NO China could not buy the Russian MIC, because they would not be allowed to. I am sure some Russian scientists would wokrk for the Chinese,

LMAO, that's the first time I hear those Russians know how to use wok to cook for dinner, while helping the Chinese to develop weapons.

Again, what are you smoking?

The last time I heard it was the Ukrainians and Belorussians who help the Chinese on aircraft carrier and TEL respectively. Both could speak Russians well due to the legacy of the Soviet days but they are no Russians.

but they could also hire Americans more easily.

Hire as paying them to spy in MIC and Pentagon and betray their own country, not working for SOEs like AVIC, Norinco and the Poly Technologies in China. :rolleyes:

Maybe you are deluded to believe non EE, Anglo-Saxon Caucasians working in those MIC over there. If so, where are the sources?

Rio Tinto is now a British company...but Britain could not really block an aquistion because of the history of the company and it's massive presence in Australia.

Again remind us why should we care?

Maybe we should care when Rio Tinto decides to spin off Alcan and have "new" IPO at TSX.
 
I agree with Mr Rockslinger on this one. Harper and cronies make decisions that are direct contravention of the law. What the judge told Harper in this case was: If you don't like the law, go to Parliament (the lawmaking body) and change the law.

.

exactly the right decision