Globalive Court Decision

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Thank goodness Canada still has an independent judiciary. The Federal Court overturns the decision by a tyrannical Prime Minister and his cabinet to allow Globalive into Canada. No doubt, the tyrant will appeal and/or nullify the court decision by changing the law.
 
Thank goodness Canada still has an independent judiciary. The Federal Court overturns the decision by a tyrannical Prime Minister and his cabinet to allow Globalive into Canada. No doubt, the tyrant will appeal and/or nullify the court decision by changing the law.


Do you own shares in Bell or Rogers?
 
Do you own shares in Bell or Rogers?

I own shares in this great country call Canada that still has an independent judiciary and is not yet ruled by administrative fiat.

(Winning the 'bawdy house" case in 2010 was also a great day for Canada. Unfortunately, that case has been appealed.)
 
A low blow to Globalive Egyptian billionaire investor who bankroll this venture, just in time when Egypt is descending into chaos. :rolleyes:

BTW, does anybody notice both Globalive chairman and Minister of Industry first name is Anthony/Tony?
 
The parent company of Globalive (Orascom) has interests in Pakistan, Egypt, Bangladesh, Zimbabwe, Central African Republic, Burundi and North Korea. The Canadian presence makes that a rather disparate group of countries. I wonder if Orascom will ever want an American subsidiary.
 
Why is Globalive coming to Canada bad?

There is something call the Telecommunications Act in Canada that applies to telecom companies. The Harper cabinet circumvented that Act by allowing Globalive into Canada. We have rules and laws in this country that applies to everybody, even prime ministers cabinet ministers. Obviously, Tony Clement and Stephen Harper are making policy decisions based on kneejerk reactions (or maybe the Egyptians have undue influenence).
 
Bad news for competition, the consumer and the Cons, good news for the entrenched oligopoly.


Court scraps cabinet ruling on Globalive, dealing blow to new entrant
IAIN MARLOW, RITA TRICHUR AND JACQUIE MCNISH
19:16 EST Friday, Feb 04, 2011

The federal court’s stunning move to overturn a cabinet decision that allowed Globalive Wireless Management Corp. to operate in Canada throws a new obstacle at the largest of the new independent cell phone companies, just as it was beginning to build a critical mass of subscribers.

Globalive, which is backed financially by Egyptian communications giant Orascom Telecom, was denied a licence in 2009 to operate by the federal telecommunications regulator on the grounds that it did not meet Canadian ownership requirements for phone companies. Weeks later, the Harper government vetoed that decision, permitting Globalive to launch under the Wind Mobile brand. In about 14 months of operation, it has acquired more than 200,000 customers.

But late Friday afternoon, the court said the government erred and gave Globalive 45 days to comply with the law. The shares of the country’s three main wireless providers -- Rogers Communications Inc., BCE Inc. and Telus Corp. -- all jumped on the news.

The court decision capped an already tumultuous week for Canadian telecommunications, during which the Prime Minister and the federal Industry Minister publicly questioned a recent CRTC ruling on Internet pricing that had led to a vitriolic consumer backlash at the regulator, the government and the sector’s largest phone and cable companies.

In an interview, Globalive chairman Anthony Lacavera said he is exasperated by the ongoing battle but will fight to prove his company is in compliance with the “control in fact” section of Canadian telecom ownership rules, which determines whether his company is overly influenced by its Egyptian backer. The chaos in Egypt has, at times, made it difficult to reach Cairo-headquartered Orascom’s executives, including its billionaire chairman Naguib Sawiris, whom Mr. Lacavera said is obviously distracted by the violence engulfing his country, where he is one of the most prominent citizens.

“I've got another fight on my hands,” Mr. Lacavera said.

But the court rejection is unlikely to result in an operational shutdown of Wind’s cellular business. Legal experts said Wind can pursue a handful of legal strategies, including to seek an extension of the stay. But the company would have to convince the court that more time is essential. Wind could also sidestep Friday’s ruling by returning to the CRTC with a new financing structure that satisfies the regulator’s original concerns, which focus around the vast amount of Globalive debt held by Orascom -- though it would likely have to find some new Canadian investors to do so.

Another option is to appeal the decision to the Federal Court of Appeal, and if that fails, the Supreme Court of Canada. Such a course could take months, possibly years, forcing Wind and other telecom companies to operate under a cloud of uncertainty.

Public Mobile, another new wireless company, asked for the judicial review of cabinet’s order in council last year, with CEO Alek Krstajic saying at the time that he didn’t want to shut down Globalive – that he simply wanted clarity on the policy. Many, including Mr. Krstajic and Telus, have argued the cabinet decision of 2009 amounted to a change in the country’s foreign ownership rules.

“If the order in council had said, ‘We’ve changed the laws, and anybody who is a new entrant like Globalive can have the same kind of structure as Globalive and can get foreign capital,’ I can tell you right now this application would not have been brought forward,” Mr. Krstajik said during a cross-examination. “But the fact that they tried to say… ‘This isn’t in a change in the law, so look the other way, this thing isn’t really a change in the law and it only applies to Globalive,’ made it a direct impact on me.. They’re allowing Globalive to have access to foreign capital that I don’t have.”

However awkward a prolonged court appeal would be for telecom companies, regulatory sources said it would be politically expedient for Industry Minister Tony Clement and the minority Conservative government, given that election fever is in the air and foreign ownership is a controversial subject. Some suspect that Mr. Clement, when he threatened to overturn a CRTC ruling on Internet pricing that could raise bills for Canadians who download a lot, was doing so because of the likelihood of an election soon.

The court's decision on Friday took financial analysts by surprise. Some elaborated on a variety of scenarios ranging from Wind gaining Canadian capital more easily thanks to its strong brand presence, to a last-ditch merger with rival Mobilicity.

Jonathan Allen, a telecom analyst with RBC Capital Markets, suggested in a note to clients that it would be impossible for the federal government to allow Wind to collapse amidst billions of dollars of investment and Conservative cries for more competition.

"[The government] will look exceptionally bad to the public -- allowing/encouraging a company to invest a billion dollars in Canada, add a quarter-million customers, and then let the rug be pulled out from under the company," Mr. Allen wrote. "So with the Conservatives potentially losing face just a few months ahead of an election, we believe the government will move quickly to resolve the situation and avoid a disruption."
 
There is something call the Telecommunications Act in Canada that applies to telecom companies. The Harper cabinet circumvented that Act by allowing Globalive into Canada. We have rules and laws in this country that applies to everybody, even prime ministers cabinet ministers. Obviously, Tony Clement and Stephen Harper are making policy decisions based on kneejerk reactions (or maybe the Egyptians have undue influenence).


I agree with Mr Rockslinger on this one. Harper and cronies make decisions that are direct contravention of the law. What the judge told Harper in this case was: If you don't like the law, go to Parliament (the lawmaking body) and change the law.

In other words, stop listening to which way the wind is blowing and pandering to noisy interest groups when we have laws and a process to deal with these matters. You've exceeded your authority.

Good I'm glad the court stood up to these bullies. Obviously it will be appealed and the Supreme Court will have to rule on the boundaries of cabinet authority.

This also has implications for the UBB unlimited Internet directive. I think this gives Clement cover ,ie. We tried to protect you weak high Internet users from the evil and powerful Rogers/Bell empires but the courts are thwarting us.

And if believe this crap, Harper will get his majority in the next election.
 
In other words, stop listening to which way the wind is blowing and pandering to noisy interest groups when we have laws and a process to deal with these matters. You've exceeded your authority.

Good I'm glad the court stood up to these bullies. Obviously it will be appealed and the Supreme Court will have to rule on the boundaries of cabinet authority.


.

Exactly. Shocking to see for once the rule of law actually means something for a change. Tony Clement could care less about offering Canadians more choice in the Wireless arena. More than likely he was just pandering to the wishes of some lobbyist representing some huge foreign corporation with, invariably some vauge expectation of reward (e.g. "consulting" position) several years down the line as a form of payback.
 
Exactly. Shocking to see for once the rule of law actually means something for a change. Tony Clement could care less about offering Canadians more choice in the Wireless arena.

Our Tony has been busy interfering with the independent regulatory body CRTC and private industry. He killed the Potash deal without allowing shareholders to vote. In addition to the Globalive fiasco, he is threatening the CRTC on unlimited bandwidth. Thank goodness, we still have an independent judiciary to keep this little tyrant somewhat in check.
 
Thank goodness Canada still has an independent judiciary. The Federal Court overturns the decision by a tyrannical Prime Minister and his cabinet to allow Globalive into Canada. No doubt, the tyrant will appeal and/or nullify the court decision by changing the law.

What is it with you and your fetish for taking it up the ass from Canadian telecoms?
 
Thank goodness Canada still has an independent judiciary. The Federal Court overturns the decision by a tyrannical Prime Minister and his cabinet to allow Globalive into Canada. No doubt, the tyrant will appeal and/or nullify the court decision by changing the law.

Did some wonders for my RCI.B. Gave me an 80-cent boost (on NYSE).
 
Funny how all these people seem more intent on preserving obsolete laws when the government acts according to the POPULAR WILL OF THE PEOPLE. Tony Clement acted to make sure the CRTC did not make Canada look like a banana republic. Here is the sequence of events as I see it:


Globalive was 100% honest with it's corp structure and ownership when it was qualified as a bidder for the auction of licenses.

It bid and won the licenses paid the feds millions of dollars

It invested millions more to build it's network....

on the brink of going live the CRTC chimed in and said the ownership structure was NOT acceptable and Globalive could not operate

Tony Clement (and lord knows I will never vote for Harpo) intrervened and allowed them to operate.

One has to wonder, how will Canada look if we allow foreign companies to invest MILLIONS of dollars into our economy and then yank their operating license at the last minute? What does that say to foreign investors? I say Tony C. did the RIGHT THING, and now the courts are going to force the govt to change the Telco act which will pretty much result in US companies flooding our market. It is a game of brinksmanship. Notice Bell and Rogers did not mount this challange, they understand what the stakes are, it was lauched by a much smaller player and I assume they are hoping a change in the Telco Act will allow them to be bought out (at a HUGE profit) by one of the US giants.
 
What is it with you and your fetish for taking it up the ass from Canadian telecoms?

He has subbed to the Rogers Butt Fuck plan.. a vibe shaped phone that you can shove up your butt and is permenantly set to vibrate...lol
 
Notice Bell and Rogers did not mount this challange, they understand what the stakes are, it was lauched by a much smaller player

It was launched by the much smaller player because they were playing by the rules and Globalive was not. The rules apply equally to all players and there should be no double standard. The court made the right decision by applying the law and not pandering to the mob.

Of course, the "mob" wants free Internet, free cellphones, free downloads of movies and music. Yes, the mob will resort to insults to try and get what they want (just look at some of the posters here). Thank goodness our courts are above that nonsense.
 
Funny how all these people seem more intent on preserving obsolete laws when the government acts according to the POPULAR WILL OF THE PEOPLE. Tony Clement acted to make sure the CRTC did not make Canada look like a banana republic. Here is the sequence of events as I see it:


Globalive was 100% honest with it's corp structure and ownership when it was qualified as a bidder for the auction of licenses.

It bid and won the licenses paid the feds millions of dollars

It invested millions more to build it's network....

on the brink of going live the CRTC chimed in and said the ownership structure was NOT acceptable and Globalive could not operate

Tony Clement (and lord knows I will never vote for Harpo) intrervened and allowed them to operate.

One has to wonder, how will Canada look if we allow foreign companies to invest MILLIONS of dollars into our economy and then yank their operating license at the last minute? What does that say to foreign investors? I say Tony C. did the RIGHT THING, and now the courts are going to force the govt to change the Telco act which will pretty much result in US companies flooding our market. It is a game of brinksmanship. Notice Bell and Rogers did not mount this challange, they understand what the stakes are, it was lauched by a much smaller player and I assume they are hoping a change in the Telco Act will allow them to be bought out (at a HUGE profit) by one of the US giants.

I like Tony Clement (helped in his campaign one year) but the law is the law, even if I hate fucking oligopolies like Bell or Rogers or the Big Banks.

That being said, couldn't Globalive get a ruling from the CRTC before spending millions? Are they stupid? Then the CRTC lends uncertainty to foreign investors in this nation of ours more than Fidel Castro would in Cuba! What's going on here?