Global Warming is a Lie

Berlin said:
So would it be fair to say that you support green but will not change the way that you have been living all along ?

Only if you also acknowledge that I was interested in living green long before it became popular. I have always attempted to minimize my effects on the planet, but not at any cost. Before I adopt a new method I study it to determine what the costs and benefits are. For example, I traded in my gas mower for an electric because it was better for the environment and Home Depot had a sale on where they took the old mower and recycled it for you. I haven't gone to a reel mower because my lawn is not (yet) smooth enough for that. Hopefully by the time the electric mower dies I'll have completed the landscaping so that I can go to a reel mower.

Berlin said:
At the expense of standard of living ? How can you be so sure that the way we have been living, consuming, is the proper one ?

Well, I think it's better than living like a 3rd world country.

Berlin said:
You see, the problem I see in your argument is that you don't , as you stated, see that there is a global crisis there, where as most others see it . It's like folks who believed the earth is flat arguing with the round globe believers, ain't going any where.

Flawed example. It's easy to prove the earth isn't flat. <grin>

The fact that we have all these arguments proves that there are a significant number of people that disagree on the extent of the "crisis" and/or our ability to actually do anything about it. Unfortunately a large number of these people that are adament we are in panic mode get all their facts from news articles. For example, when the papers trumpeted the study that showed that Greenland's ice field was likely to melt away completely they didn't point out that the study said it might melt in 1000 years

Berlin said:
Anyway, as I said, you brought up interesting perspectives, but are they relevant ? I'll let others judge for themselves.

Me too, like I said earlier; in the 70s everyone knew that we were heading into the next ice age.
 
pussylicker said:
What snow?:D

Well I don't know about you, but I had a couple inches of wet stuff on my walks and drive. I believe in getting it up before people have a chance to pack it down into ice patches. Use a lot less salt that way.
 
You see, the problem I see in your argument is that you don't , as you stated, see that there is a global crisis there, where as most others see it . It's like folks who believed the earth is flat arguing with the round globe believers, ain't going any where.



Moraff said:
Flawed example. It's easy to prove the earth isn't flat. <grin>


Speaks volume.

FYI , it's been proven yeeeeaaaars ago ,NO ?

READ my post again, what tense is that verb " believe" in ? Do you know how to read and comprehend other than pick apart other's comment just for the sake of it ?

<ZZZ...>
 
Berlin said:
Speaks volume.

FYI , it's been proven yeeeeaaaars ago ,NO ?

READ my post again, what tense is that verb " believe" in ? Do you know how to read and comprehend other than pick apart other's comment just for the sake of it ?

<ZZZ...>

I'm sorry I thought we were having a discussion of our views. Perhaps I misunderstood your flat earth reference. I thought you were calling those of us who refused to jump on the crisis bandwagon flat earthers. If that was not your intent then I apologize.

All I intended by my comment (since I was working under the assumption that I just mentioned) was to point out that it was easy to disprove the flat earth theory and therefore it was a poor comparison to our competing global warming theories which have yet to be proven one way or the other.

Yes the Flat Earth Theory was disproved long ago, by Aristotle if I remember correctly. I never said it hadn't been, I said it was easy to prove the Earth wasn't flat.
 
Moraff said:
Causing? No way

Causing, yes way. That's the consensus these days. Any other position is highly controversial. The only people who seem to be saying we aren't causing global warming are people who don't really have the right credentials, and only a tiny minority of people who do.

Contributing? Yes, but I disagree that we have any idea on how much or what effect it will have.

We do have some idea how much. The jury is still out exactly what effect it will have.

Notice what a high percentage of "no such thing as global warming" promoters take extremely anti-scientific viewpoints. Things like, "Science has been wrong before so it must be wrong now" and so on. When your position requires that you take up a stance against logic, reason, and empirical measurement (ie: science) it's time to admit you're wrong.
 
Moraff said:
I'm sorry I thought we were having a discussion of our views.

Perhaps I misunderstood your flat earth reference. I thought you were calling those of us who refused to jump on the crisis bandwagon flat earthers. If that was not your intent then I apologize.

All I intended by my comment (since I was working under the assumption that I just mentioned) was to point out that it was easy to disprove the flat earth theory and therefore it was a poor comparison to our competing global warming theories which have yet to be proven one way or the other.

Yes the Flat Earth Theory was disproved long ago, by Aristotle if I remember correctly. I never said it hadn't been, I said it was easy to prove the Earth wasn't flat.

Errr... dude, I was not into discussing with your rhetoric . I just wanted your stand on global warming crisis to be known clearly.

Once you stated the following,

Moraff said:
Do I believe we are in a "crisis"? Not really.

What I do believe is that if we are in a "crisis" there is nothing we can do to mitigate it's happening, mainly because we have no idea of what the results of our efforts would be.

the relevancy of you logic pretty much went out the window.

Mind you, you can still keep trolling on , beating the dead horse. I for one will still read for laughs.
 
james t kirk said:
Well put.

The celebrity hipocrits like Al Gore, and George Clooney and the rest of them are well known private jet users.

George Clooney for example regularly flies to his luxury villa in Italy on a private plane. With the fuel that he consumes to fly his singular ass to Italy, he could drive his Toyota Prius to the moon.

READ THIS:

http://www.tmz.com/2006/10/18/celebs-who-claim-theyre-green-but-guzzle-gas

The only celeb that I am aware of that flies coach is Leonardo DiCaprio, believe it or not.

Interesting quote but one hopes what these celeb are doing are making a positive impact instead of turning people off. If their so-called go-green movements are perceived as hypocritical and self serving, then it will create more resistance to the needed change. Yes they do look like hypocrits even if they drive a hybrid but keep flying around on their private jets.

Celebs, especially hollywood stars are highly visible people and sometimes trend setters. If they all start to abandon the gas guzzling cars make driving fuel-efficient cars a cool thing to do, many (I mean many, many) would follow and that's where they could make a real impact - not by the fuel saved by this small number of individuals.

What should they do about their private jets? If the continued use make them look like hypocrits and turn people off from being motivated to do their share, these people should give serious thoughts of getting rid of them - but not necessary overnight. Same thing as we can't get rid of all of our energy inefficient appliances/vehicles/light bulbs overnight either. If the jets are really important for making important things happens, they have to weigh the balance and use them less liberally.

Some people criticized Al Gore for jet setting around the world to spread his messages and he does not yet have the most energy efficient houses on earth, so he is a talker but not a doer - hmmm......well, if his present travel really translate into efficient delivery of the messages and truly influencing people in changing their ways of conserving the environment, may be there is a net benefit. At the end, impactful result can only come from people all aligned doing the right thing, so it would be important for people, scientists/environmentalists/government etc, to figure out what are the right things to do.

Haven't we made progress already? Take an example, mass recycling was a strange concept only less than 30 years ago.
 
hmm

lay-mann said:
Some people criticized Al Gore for jet setting around the world to spread his messages and he does not yet have the most energy efficient houses on earth, so he is a talker but not a doer.QUOTE]



As a result of his energy consumption, Gore’s average monthly electric bill topped $1,359. Since the release of An Inconvenient Truth, Gore’s energy consumption has increased from an average of 16,200 kWh per month in 2005, to 18,400 kWh per month in 2006.

Gore’s extravagant energy use does not stop at his electric bill. Natural gas bills for Gore’s mansion and guest house averaged $1,080 per month last year.

Al Gore probably knows that Man Made Global Warming is a big steaming pile of BS. He just wants to institute a socialist style, command and control economy run by people like…Al Gore.



http://anti-strib.blogspot.com/2007/02/al-gore-hypocrite.html
 
Esco! said:
Well then............ I guess we're F*cked!!! :D

Yeah, that little experiment in the video is cute but seems pretty flawed. Reasons why it appears to work but doesn't reflex real life situation include at least:

a. ice volume goes down after it has melted into water (ice is less dense than water) so it cancels out the extra volume from the part that sticks out of the water
b. water volume also goes down a touch on heating but only when it is happening around 0 degree Celcius (strange eh !) but it expands at other temps upon heating. So when the melted ice warms up to just a little above zero celcius, any further warming will cause water volume to expand. The warmer it gets, the more expansion for the same amount of "heating".
c. the ripple and waves generated was to climb up the glass, a vertical wall. In waterfronts, water only had to climb a little to flood the neighborhood.

They should AT LEAST try doing the experiment in some bigger containers, say the kitchen sink (with drainage plugged of course).

1. add cold water to near top of sink,
2. then add the ice chunks, not little cubes,
3. then fill the sink to the top. Allow ice chunk to melt and hopefully create some ripples.
4. Watch for spillage over the sink onto the countertop.

Any tiny amount of spillage (either from overflow or from ripples (waves)), even just a fraction of a percent of the total amount of water, would translate into disasters if the same happens to highly populated, flat dry lands by the oceans.

The images of how the waves from Katrina pounded the waterfront came to mind. I hope the original little simulating experiment is not considered as superior to the more sophisticated computer modeling scientists are using.
 
Last edited:
fuji said:
Causing, yes way. That's the consensus these days. Any other position is highly controversial. The only people who seem to be saying we aren't causing global warming are people who don't really have the right credentials, and only a tiny minority of people who do.

I'm sorry we must be using different definitions of "causing" it seems. Since the last Ice Age ended well before humanity popped up something else must have started the current warming trend. Since that trend was going on when we started building things the most that we can be doing is "contributing" to the trend.

As for being in a "highly controversial position", hey so was Galileo <grin>


fuji said:
We do have some idea how much. The jury is still out exactly what effect it will have.

Definately true.

fuji said:
Notice what a high percentage of "no such thing as global warming" promoters take extremely anti-scientific viewpoints. Things like, "Science has been wrong before so it must be wrong now" and so on. When your position requires that you take up a stance against logic, reason, and empirical measurement (ie: science) it's time to admit you're wrong.

While I'm not one of the "no such thing as global warming" promoter I would like to point out that all of the scientific studies quoted to support arguments in this thread have come from people who decline to accept the level of doom and gloom the newsies put out.

I do agree with the argument you put forth earlier btw. Changing our zoning regulations to allow a mix of business/residental/light industrial so that we can cut down on the requirement to use a car to live is an excellant plan.
 
Berlin said:
Errr... dude, I was not into discussing with your rhetoric . I just wanted your stand on global warming crisis to be known clearly.


Since I have been arguing that things weren't as dire as the newsies made it to be from the beginning, I didn't think my stand was unclear. However, I'm happy to have been able to clear it up for you.


Berlin said:
Mind you, you can still keep trolling on , beating the dead horse. I for one will still read for laughs.

Just as you can continue your wanton cruelty to the common comma. :)