I've gotten the "you look young for your age" more than once.
And the handsome routine, once. That was nice.
The big cock routine, I don't think you can have a small cock and have this said to you. Probably anyone who is average or a bit better would hear this. (Actually it would be interesting to know if a guy with a small dong got a big dick line).
The biggest compliment by far was a Korean SP told me her full name and wanted me to add her on Facebook lol. Whatever her motivation for doing that I took it as a big compliment even if it was a really bad idea.
My opinion is that genuine or not, it's an attempt to be good to you, so any way I look at it it's still a good thing. You don't have to be gullible, but at the same time whose to say they are not genuine people?