Generator question

Although Edison's admirers hushed it up, the main reason his championing of DC current distribution sytsems lost out to Westinghouse's AC was the difficulty of collecting all the electrons that spilled out of unused electrical sockets. In a horse and wagon era, the clatter of wagons and the calls of their drivers making the rounds every morning was a huge nuisance. Having to keep the maids who were supposed to be expendable thanks to Mr Hoovers convenient machine and having to train and equip them to manage kilo-vaults full of electrons until the Edison Man came was a great disappointment to those managing great houses, and the minor silliness of cute little Westinghouse electrons popping alternately out and tidily back in was almost enjoyable by comarison.

so old jones does have a sense of humor
 
I think the crucial issue is realizing that there is a difference between static electricity (where charges move), and electric circuits (where energy moves.) In electric circuits, a return path for the electricity always exists. However, with static electricity, electrons are stored and moved.

With either DC or AC electric circuits, no significant movement of electrons occurs. The DC generator at Niagara falls is almost identical to an AC generator at Niagara falls, except for the addition of a component that makes the AC into DC. Additionally, the rate of movement of electrons is known as the drift velocity. With AC, the electrons move back and forth about 0.002 mm every cycle, on average. With DC, at a drift velocity of 0.1 mm/s (or less), it takes hours for an electron to move about a circuit of any size.

There is also a problem with the explanation for a battery. People like explaining batteries in terms of electron flow, however the explanation is fundamentally wrong. The terminals of a battery are at two different energy potentials (voltage is energy potential), and the differential between these potentials is what drives energy around a circuit. This effect becomes particularly obvious when you realize a battery only does work (lights something up or makes something move), when a complete circuit is present between both its wires.

With electricity, at some point it becomes necessary to make the jump from practical comparisons to theoretical descriptions. Electricity doesn't make proper sense until you use the appropriate mathematical descriptions. Grade school teachers love descriptions of circuits with electrons moving, however theoretically, it isn't a correct description. Yoga Face is confused by the grade-school description of electricity, because once you start thinking about the grade-school description, it makes no sense whatsoever.

The grade-school description conflates static electricity with magnetism and electric circuit theory, when they are fundamentally different concepts. This is really obvious when reading any proper physics and electricity text, because different units are used for static electricity (charge transfer) and circuits (current/voltage/energy transfer).

your grasp seems decent to me





i am reading

http://www.physicsclassroom.com/Class/circuits/u9l2c.cfm#p6

and you are correct about drift flow ( drift velocity) it is the charge that lights the bulb not the flow of electrons

this charge is created by an electric signal that travels between potential difference (once the circuit is closed) at the speed of light IE it is not the charge that flows at the speed of light ( charge means the stimulation of electrons )



I found this

" In a solid metal the moving electrons all occupy the conduction band (which is shared by the entire metal) and easily flow everywhere throughout the metal. This happens in both AC and DC circuits. The only difference is that AC circuits alternate the polarity of the voltage and thus the direction of current."


current is electron charge not electron flow


however, i still wonder where the drift flow of electrons goes in DC

however

in post 31 Mellendorf states electrons do flow destroying my new found belief that it is the charge(electron excitment) that lights the bulb not the flow of electrons :frusty:




"You never need to replace electrons because they always come back.
This is why you need two prongs on a plug for it to work. Electrons go in one and out the other. Passing through the device is what allows energy to be transferred."

Dr. Ken Mellendorf
Physics Instructor
Illinois Central College
 
Last edited:
The drift flow in a DC circuit goes around in circles. The quoted professor is correct. For every electron that leaves a section of a circuit, another enters.
 
The drift flow in a DC circuit goes around in circles. The quoted professor is correct. For every electron that leaves a section of a circuit, another enters.

ok


let us review shall we ??? (dare we?)



1

in DC electrons do flow (this is called drift) but literally at a snails pace

as they go from atom to atom

they drift around in circles in the case of DC therefore are reused by the resistance and do not need to be replaced

when "potential difference" is used up (my analogy is gravity pushing a rock down a hillside) there is no more electricity

IE a battey cannot be "recharged" because it was never charged in the first place as it is the electron that becomes charged. Batteries have a potential difference(voltage) which cause a energy flow (at the speed of light ) that charges the electrons in DC



2

In AC electrons do not leave thier home atom as they move back and forth



why does he say

"Passing through the device is what allows energy to be transferred."

Dr. Ken Mellendorf
Physics Instructor
Illinois Central College



is it not the charge that tranfers the energy into light, heat or whatever not the flow of electons?

is saying the drift (electron movement) allows different electrons to enter the resistance and use up their charge ?


do electrons become uncharged ? after transferring energy to the resistance?



Questions and questions

Decisions and revisions

Decisions and revisions which a minute will reverse
 
this is an extension of post 31


Name: George
Status: student
Grade: 9-12
Location: IL
Country: N/A
Date: 10/2/2005



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Question:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Recently I took a tour of a hydroelectric plant (a dam) on a river in Montana. The question I had was where did the electrons come from in the wires to provide electrical power to the grid. More specifically, why did they not have to occasionally replace the wires in the generators because they would eventually run out of electrons? They indicated that they hardly ever replaced the wires (usually if the insulation were to break down - which was very seldom). I was later told that the electrons really did not flow in the conductors. They stayed in the outer orbits of their respective atoms and only "bumped" the electrons in the neighboring atoms which caused the perception of "current flow". This is why the electrons in the generator never depleted their electrons.

This answer seems to contradict everything I have to date learned about electron "flow" in a conductor, but seems to answer the question of a net loss of electrons in a conductor (exhausting its electrons). What is the correct concept to understanding electron flow in a conductor in the example above and will electrons eventually exhaust?


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Replies:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
George,

The electrons do flow through the wires, but they never leave the wires. This is why you need something called a complete circuit. The power plant pushes electrons through the wire. Electrons do not like to be near electrons because they have the same electric charge. The electrons that were moved forward in the wires then cause more electrons to move. This continues around the circuit. Also, electrons from behind tend to be attracted by the metal atoms that are now missing an electron. They fall in behind to replace the first electrons.

After a very short time, the electrons throughout the circuit fall into a regular pattern. Energy goes from the power plant to the moving electrons. Energy goes from the moving electrons to the devices, such as the light bulbs and televisions of the area. More energy is given to the electrons. More energy is transferred to the lights and TVs. All the loose electrons move at the same time, almost like water flowing around in a circular tube. The power plant tries to speed up the electrons. Electric devices try to slow them down. They quickly reach a balance. You never need to replace electrons because they always come back.

This is why you need two prongs on a plug for it to work. Electrons go in one and out the other. Passing through the device is what allows energy to be transferred.

Dr. Ken Mellendorf
Physics Instructor
Illinois Central College

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I think you are right, George, it does contradict. Electrons do move down a wire when current flows. They just do in a very hair-brained, randomly zig-zagging fashion. The zig-zagging due to thermal motions is so much faster than the net downstream drift that if you watched one electron you would not be able to see the slow progress in all the frenetic bumping around. But it is the same with water molecules in stream, or gas molecules in a breeze, too. If you can see the molecules collectively, as a fluid, then you can see the drift.

Unfortunately we have no way to tag an electron or drop a leaf in its stream. So we cannot see the electric fluid move; we can only measure the effects of the motion: the magnetic field around the wire, and the energy transferred downstream or the charged-up voltage on a capacitor.

The electrons do not "come from" anywhere. They were always there, part of the metal. The metal is always neutral, with just as many electrons as metal-ions. Having a 1% mismatch in a solid costs more energy than vaporizing the metal completely. Electrons can leave at one end of some metal _only_ if they can come in just as fast at the other end. And vice-versa too: electrons can only enter if and as others leave. This is pretty much why electricity only flows in closed loop circuits. A loop is the only way all parts can be happy with the motion. There are no wire-ends getting robbed or crowded.

Out of almost 10^24 atoms and electrons per cubic cm, it only takes an imbalance of ~10^4 electrons/cm3 to charge the wire up another volt. (Look up capacitance of a wire, charge/voltage in a capacitor, and electrons in a coulomb.) So in 120 volts AC, the wire stays neutral to something like 1 part in 10^18. That is an extremely small mismatch. A million volts might be 1 part in 10^14 imbalanced. Still a really small mismatch.

Another thing that might prompt a power-station engineer to tell this story is A.C.: Alternating Current. Since there are roughly 10^24 electrons/cm3 in the metal, and only about 10^19 electrons in an amp-second, It takes about 1 amp x 1 day to move all the electrons through 1 cm3 of metal. In AC current this flow, though very real and quite stiff, turns itself around backwards 60 times per second (or should I call it 120?). You could have 100,000 amps in a 1cm2 wire, and at 60Hz the full oscillation distance of the "electron fluid" in the metal would be less than 1mm. In this case it is very much like oscillating water pressure in a pipe: the pressure and some work would go downstream fast, but the water never would. It might be interesting to try to visualize a machine that uses energy from alternating water pressure to do some intense work. So he is right: AC is just a game of very fast, really hard-shoving musical chairs.

But it is also true that at every moment power flows only when electrons are drifting left or right.

I would not say they stay in their respective atoms, though. That implies they never get to move even 10^-8 cm. That is hardly moving at all, and it is just not true. They are moving past many atoms very frequently, even when there is no net current but only random thermal motion.

Another caveat: In a metal, stationary atoms share a sea of mobile electrons. That is what defines a metal. The mobile electrons in a metal have diffused locations: each electron can be considered spread-out over thousands of atoms at a given time, and the sum of partial presences of many electrons is what keeps a given atom neutral. A spread-out electron generally cannot get stuck to any one atom. In an insulator it is different: each electron is concentrated in, and stuck to, one place in one molecule most of the time.

Sheesh. Sorry if that is too many perspectives at once.

Jim Swenson

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

wow, I see several points I can help you with there...

1) the electrons DO flow. Their actual velocity depends on the amount of current, but it's typically about 2 cm/second. However, they are also displacing the electrons from the atoms they are moving to, which causes a wave like effect. This moves at or near the speed of light.

2) A generator or alternator is relying on magnetism to push electrons around. It is not so much pumping the electrons out of the wire though, as simply forcing them all to move along it. So the electrons being pushed out one side of a piece of wire are coming back in the other side.

In the case of an alternator, the current is repeatedly changing direction. So there the electrons move briefly one direction, then right back where they came from. Since they 'bump' each other all the way down any length of wire, electrons very far away can be manipulated even though the specific electrons in the power plant never go that far.

Ryan Belscamper

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The electrons do indeed flow. When the circuit is closed, an electric field is set up in the entire wire from the generating plant to the user and back again on another wire -- a closed circuit is required! A wire is a conductor precisely because some of the electrons are free to move when pushed by an electric field.

The closed circuit is required so the electrons can flow in a closed circuit; no electrons are lost!

An analogy may be helpful. Consider a water pump driving water through a closed loop of piping. The pump never runs out of water (any more than an electrical generator runs out of electrons) since the water pumped out by the pump pushes on the water already in the pipe all the way around the closed loop and so drives water back into the pump.

Best, Dick Plano, Professor of Physics emeritus, Rutgers University
 
from the above post


"The electrons do indeed flow. When the circuit is closed, an electric field is set up in the entire wire from the generating plant to the user and back again on another wire -- a closed circuit is required! A wire is a conductor precisely because some of the electrons are free to move when pushed by an electric field.

The closed circuit is required so the electrons can flow in a closed circuit; no electrons are lost!

An analogy may be helpful. Consider a water pump driving water through a closed loop of piping. The pump never runs out of water (any more than an electrical generator runs out of electrons) since the water pumped out by the pump pushes on the water already in the pipe all the way around the closed loop and so drives water back into the pump. "

Best, Dick Plano, Professor of Physics emeritus, Rutgers University



i am ready to shoot myself


i am right back where i started


electrons do flow and need a complete circuit back to the generating plant which is WTF i said in the first fucking place !! (is he talking DC or AC or both??)
 
i am right back where i started

[/B]

And until you abandon your preconceived "beliefs", you won't "get it".

Let me ask you something, Yoga Face. (please nobody else chime in until Yoga Face answers as I want to make a point)

Let's say an airplane requires an airspeed of 60 mph to take off.

If the airplane were to attempt to take off on a runway that was one big conveyor belt/treadmill/moving sidewalk that would immediately and exactly match in the opposite direction the speed of the spinning airplane tires, could the airplane take off?

(No searching google for an answer!)
 
And until you abandon your preconceived "beliefs", you won't "get it".

Let me ask you something, Yoga Face. (please nobody else chime in until Yoga Face answers as I want to make a point)

Let's say an airplane requires an airspeed of 60 mph to take off.

If the airplane were to attempt to take off on a runway that was one big conveyor belt/treadmill/moving sidewalk that would immediately and exactly match in the opposite direction the speed of the spinning airplane tires, could the airplane take off?

(No searching google for an answer!)


"I know that most men, including those at ease with problems of the greatest complexity, can seldom accept even the simplest and most obvious truth if it be such as would oblige them to admit the falsity of conclusions which they have delighted in explaining to colleagues, which they have proudly taught to others, and which they have woven, thread by thread, into the fabric of their lives." -Tolstoy


without looking it up the answer is no


this is because the airplane is standing still

the plane needs to move to build up low pressure on the top of the wing and high pressure on the bottom and it is this pressure difference that forces the plane into the air which is why wings are slanted

(Kinda like potential difference in electronics if you stretch your imagination)

the propeller only causes forward motion not up and down motion
 
Last edited:
without looking it up the answer is no


this is because the airplane is standing still

as the plane moves it builds up low pressure in the top of the wing and high pressure on the bottom and it is this difference that forces the plane into the air which is why wings are slanted


The correct answer is yes, of course it could take off.

Your answer comes from your frame of mind attributing automotive propulsion to that of an airplane. A car moves as a result of power being driven to the wheels. An airplane does not deliver power to the wheels, they are free spinning. Airplanes achieve forward movement by the thrust of the propellor or jet engines through the air. The propellor is decoupled from the treadmill.

But your pre-concieved "beliefs" that were developed as a result of your lifetime of exposure to automobiles make it hard to grasp the concept of the propellor thrust making the treadmill irrelevant. Until you can abandon your automotive driven wheel frame of mind, you will struggle with this in your mind. It is a form of cognitive dissonance.

And so goes your difficulty in understanding the difference between alternating current and direct current. Most of us think we understand direct current, and then try to apply this theory to alternating current. When someone refers to "ground" or positive or negative when speaking of alternating current, it is hard to get them off those irrelevant DC terms.

And the more one tries to explain it person-to-person, the more the mistaken guy digs in and tries to justify his long held "beliefs". It often becomes a personal conflict rather than one of physics. You proved this when you asked about my credentials to make my assesment of why you needed to start from scratch. In these cases, it is better that you start from scratch on your own, and learn from a book or other one-sided source that you feel no need to defend your "beliefs".

This is why I simply said to try to forget what you think you believe or know, and start from scratch.
 
-I think you almost had it in post #44.

ok

let us review shall we ??? (dare we?)

1 in DC electrons do flow (this is called drift) but literally at a snails pace
as they go from atom to atom they drift around in circles in the case of DC therefore are reused by the resistance and do not need to be replaced
when "potential difference" is used up (my analogy is gravity pushing a rock down a hillside) there is no more electricity

Yes.

IE a battey cannot be "recharged" because it was never charged in the first place as it is the electron that becomes charged.

Note quite. Primary cell batteries cannot be recharged, because the voltage differential came from a chemical reaction - and the chemical reaction completed (was used up.)

Batteries have a potential difference(voltage) which cause a energy flow (at the speed of light ) that charges the electrons in DC.

Yes. The potential difference (voltage) is what causes the energy to move. The "charges the electrons" is formally current flow where current is formally charge / time.

2 In AC electrons do not leave thier home atom as they move back and forth
why does he say

"Passing through the device is what allows energy to be transferred."

Dr. Ken Mellendorf
Physics Instructor
Illinois Central College

As the charge (current) passes through the device, energy is transferred.

is it not the charge that tranfers the energy into light, heat or whatever not the flow of electons?

Energy is current * voltage * time or charge * voltage. To get energy, it is necessary to move a current for a time (charge) accross a voltage potential (energy difference).

is saying the drift (electron movement) allows different electrons to enter the resistance and use up their charge ?

I think the answer to the next quote explains things best.

do electrons become uncharged ? after transferring energy to the resistance?

No, in electric circuits, matter (electrons) and charge is conserved. Energy is voltage * charge. When the current flows through a resistance, the voltage falls to zero. This can be seen if two light bulbs are connected in series (one after the other). The voltage accross each light bulb is 1/2 of the voltage in the system.

Subtle Point:

In classical mechanics, something physical is moving. However, in electricity, this analogy does not apply. From wave-particle duality, the electrons exist as electric and magnetic fields. Thus energy can be transmitted at the speed of light, while the electrons themselves do not move anywhere (significant). Formally, charge moves as a field, not as a particle. Which is why it becomes so confusing when people say that electrons are moving in a circuit. It is energy in the form of fields that is moving in the circuit. The electrons are (annoyingly) almost stationary. If you start asking questions about DC, AC, and batteries, it quickly becomes obvious that the net movement of the electrons must be zero (or some small number) - because any other solution would violate the law of conservation of mass or energy.
 
The correct answer is yes, of course it could take off.

Your answer comes from your frame of mind attributing automotive propulsion to that of an airplane. A car moves as a result of power being driven to the wheels. An airplane does not deliver power to the wheels, they are free spinning. Airplanes achieve forward movement by the thrust of the propellor or jet engines through the air. The propellor is decoupled from the treadmill.

But your pre-concieved "beliefs" that were developed as a result of your lifetime of exposure to automobiles make it hard to grasp the concept of the propellor thrust making the treadmill irrelevant. Until you can abandon your automotive driven wheel frame of mind, you will struggle with this in your mind. It is a form of cognitive dissonance.

And so goes your difficulty in understanding the difference between alternating current and direct current. Most of us think we understand direct current, and then try to apply this theory to alternating current. When someone refers to "ground" or positive or negative when speaking of alternating current, it is hard to get them off those irrelevant DC terms.

And the more one tries to explain it person-to-person, the more the mistaken guy digs in and tries to justify his long held "beliefs". It often becomes a personal conflict rather than one of physics. You proved this when you asked about my credentials to make my assesment of why you needed to start from scratch. In these cases, it is better that you start from scratch on your own, and learn from a book or other one-sided source that you feel no need to defend your "beliefs".

This is why I simply said to try to forget what you think you believe or know, and start from scratch.

always willing to admit i am wrong


but asking for deeper explanations is how one becomes untrapped from preconceived notions



the anwswer must be the the wheels are moving at 120 mph

one must disassociate the propeller speed from wheel speed ( as you said)



the propeller has no concept of wheels

its job is to move the plane forward

newtons third law will still fly the plane


His third law states that for every action (force) in nature there is an equal and opposite reaction.

For aircraft, the principal of action and reaction is very important. It helps to explain the generation of lift from an airfoil. In this problem, the air is deflected downward by the action of the airfoil, and in reaction the wing is pushed upward.




good question
 
Last edited:
-I think you almost had it in post #44.



Yes.



Note quite. Primary cell batteries cannot be recharged, because the voltage differential came from a chemical reaction - and the chemical reaction completed (was used up.)



Yes. The potential difference (voltage) is what causes the energy to move. The "charges the electrons" is formally current flow where current is formally charge / time.



As the charge (current) passes through the device, energy is transferred.



Energy is current * voltage * time or charge * voltage. To get energy, it is necessary to move a current for a time (charge) accross a voltage potential (energy difference).



I think the answer to the next quote explains things best.



No, in electric circuits, matter (electrons) and charge is conserved. Energy is voltage * charge. When the current flows through a resistance, the voltage falls to zero. This can be seen if two light bulbs are connected in series (one after the other). The voltage accross each light bulb is 1/2 of the voltage in the system.

Subtle Point:

In classical mechanics, something physical is moving. However, in electricity, this analogy does not apply. From wave-particle duality, the electrons exist as electric and magnetic fields. Thus energy can be transmitted at the speed of light, while the electrons themselves do not move anywhere (significant). Formally, charge moves as a field, not as a particle. Which is why it becomes so confusing when people say that electrons are moving in a circuit. It is energy in the form of fields that is moving in the circuit. The electrons are (annoyingly) almost stationary. If you start asking questions about DC, AC, and batteries, it quickly becomes obvious that the net movement of the electrons must be zero (or some small number) - because any other solution would violate the law of conservation of mass or energy.

thanks a bunch


more fodder for thought

a lot of my problems stem from incorrect everyday understanding

"Since a current is a flow of charge, the common expression "flow of current" should be avoided, since literally it means "flow of flow of charge."


what would be the consequences if the English language had no word for "water", but instead we called it "current"? What if everyone actually believed that rivers and plumbing pipes were full of "current?" What if we believed that "current" flows in rivers... yet we had no name for water?
wouldn't people tend to acquire many serious misconceptions about the nature of water?
For example, we might imagine that water vanishes whenever it stops flowing.

A glass of water would seem very confusing, since the glass would be full of some weird kind of "stationary current." Students would ask all kinds of questions about the confusing nature of "current," and their teachers wouldn't know how to answer.

As far as elementary textbooks are concerned, we have no name for the thing which flows inside of wires. Yes it's true that this entity, whenever it is flowing, is properly called "an electrical current." But when the stuff *stops* flowing, what do we call it? It's still in the wire of course. But it's not moving anymore. Refer to advanced physics texts, and there we'll find its correct name: Charge. An electric current is a flow of charge.


Electric current is not a flow of energy; it's a flow of charge. Charge and energy are two different things

An electric current is a flowing motion of charged particles, and the particles do not carry energy along with them as they move.

Electric energy is different than charge. The energy traveling across an electric current is made up of waves in electromagnetic fields and it moves VERY rapidly. Electric energy moves at a completely different speed than electric current, and obviously they are two different things flowing in wires at the same time. Unless we realize that two different things are flowing, we won't understand how circuits work. .
In an electric circuit, the path of the electric charges is circular, while the path of the energy is not. A battery can send electric energy to a light bulb, and the bulb changes electrical energy into light. The energy does not flow back to the battery again. At the same time, the electric current is different; it is a very slow circular flow, and the electric charges flow through the light bulb filament and all of them return to the battery.


I have another question

What causes the filament to light up??

Energy flow (waves in the electric magnetic field) or charge flow (movement of electrons)?


it is stated

"A battery can send electric energy to a light bulb, and the bulb changes electrical energy into light. "

so what is the job of "charge flow" if the electric energy does the actual work?

btw post 48 is a damn good question is it not?
 
Propeller speed? Where in the question does it say anything about the plane having propellers. I assumed it had jet engines

I would have called it air speed as opposed to propeller speed.

Another spin on it... If we had these large conveyors for runways, we could have much shorter runways!

it is a plane not a jet


no the runways are the same length


think about it

the plane is still moving forward

the only difference is the wheels move faster on the tread mill
 
Last edited:
What causes the filament to light up??

Energy flow (waves in the electric magnetic field) or charge flow (movement of electrons)?

Energy is Current * Voltage * Time, or Charge * Voltage. You need both the current flow and the voltage differential for the bulb to light up. Also, in terms of energy and magnetic fields, the fields contain the energy, however they will not light something up until a potential change (voltage) in the field takes place.

In short, energy causes the filament to light up, however one of the components of electrical energy is the existence of charge flow (current).
 
Energy is Current * Voltage * Time, or Charge * Voltage. You need both the current flow and the voltage differential for the bulb to light up. Also, in terms of energy and magnetic fields, the fields contain the energy, however they will not light something up until a potential change (voltage) in the field takes place.

In short, energy causes the filament to light up, however one of the components of electrical energy is the existence of charge flow (current).




l liked it better when there were just a bunch of electrons flowing downstream at the speed of light commiting suicide on the resistance

in electrical misconceptions http://amasci.com/miscon/eleca.html#cflow


it is stated


"When lightning strikes , the spreading electric currents in the ground can kill anyone standing nearby"


so what kills you the energy (charge flow ie current * voltage ie potential difference) in the electro magnetic field or is it the current (charge flow) alone and separate from the energy ?

he does not say the current times voltage (energy) kills you

he says the current (charge flow) kills you
 
Last edited:
umm... far from all contractors and government agencies use Honda generators

For heavy duty government/commercial/construction use, you will often see Honda generator, water pumps and other motor driven equipment. You will see other brands used, but they will often be manufacturers that specialize in contractor or government use. I think Honda Corp. have learned a thing or two about motors since Soichiro started bolting motors on to bicycles in his back shed.