G-20 Most Wanted

So it doesn't say that one has the right to block traffic, create a nuisance, prevent people from going about their work, vandalizing personal property, and creating a riot.

Hence some people got arrested. (There are laws in Toronto against all of the above.)

And Yeah, I do pay my taxes and until the crazies do the same I doubt they understand what that means. (Or care for that matter.) I have a lot of sympathy for a hard working guy who WORKS HIS ASS OFF to buy a Starbucks, or a McDonalds, or any other business along the street only to have his property destroyed in riot by morons and good-for-nothings. I do not weep for the crazies and those who were part of a mob that accomplished NOTHING, absolutely nothing in their fun little riot that got their asses tossed in jail. All that they accomplished or changed was the wasting of a billion dollars and the destruction of public and personal property of hard working people. (And yes, I do consider those people who work, who take risks to run a business, who work and employ other people to be superior to the crazies.)
LOL I can see you have it all figured out Kirk. Those people protesting pandemic global poverty and climate change, which threatens to make the earth uninhabitable...they are "crazies", "morons", and "good-for-nothings" who accomplish nothing and waste a billion dollars. They don't work. You do. How nice to live in a black and white world. I imagine that right now, you're feeling a bit like Alice. Hmm? Tumbling down the rabbit hole? Don't worry Kirk. Just keep taking that blue pill every morning and you'll be fine.
 
By the way, I find the violations of charter rights more important than a few broken windows.

There are damn few times when I agree with Danmand, but in this instance he has found the mark and the real issue. What the Premier did was illegal and unconstitutional as far as I can tell. We do not live in a state where the state is allowed to secretly pass laws that arbitrarily suspend the constitution.

The police created a public relations nightmare for themselves by not stepping in and trying to do something about the vandalism and the arson. People in shops that called 911 were told that there was nothing that the police could do and that the police could not reach them. One of the public relations officers gave the excuse that they could not leave the G20 Leaders unprotected and therefore could not leave their assigned posts.

However, the very next day, the police managed to engage in mass detentions and arrests, using the excuse that they had found DISCARDED weapons and black clothing and that they felt that that constituted an immediate danger. I'm sorry, but when I discard something, it means that I am done with it and do not plan on using it. Further, the arrest of people that were "witnessing" the events at the temp holding centre was completely unnecessary. Not giving people access to counsel is unconstitutional.

Don't think that the Toronto cops were unprepared or did not have a game plan. Toronto has had it fair share of large public protests and civil disobedience and the police were always prepared to give access to counsel in the past. Why did it change this time?

It is certainly necessary and reasonable to have a security zone, just as it is necessary and reasonable to have a police presence to PREVENT or take SWIFT ACTION if criminal activity takes place. I don't know of anyone that feels the "Black Bloc" were engaged in legitimate dissent, peaceable assembly or acts of free speech. But the lack of action by the police deserves answers. And the illegal and unwarranted police response on Sunday smacks of a state that completely has no regard for the rule of law.

I don't agree with many of the stances that the protesters were yammering on about. I will defend their right to have their say. Not because I love them, but out of self interest. Anything that chills free speech chills my rights and everyone else's rights as well.
 
And where does it say that anyone has the right to block traffic, create a public nuisance, and prevent people from going about their day to day business in order to get their point across? A point that many may not agree with.

Lets get something straight here. The state blocked traffic and forced individuals to jump through hoops to get to their own homes and properties. The state forced people to justify going about lawful activities.

When it comes to roads and traffic, driving is a privilege. Freedom of assembly, freedom of speech, freedom of movement are RIGHTS as granted by law. Rights trump privilege.

You are quite right when you suggest the protesters were making a point that many do not agree with. Personally, I don't agree with them either. But they were protesting because they feel (and with some justification) that Big Money, large MNC's, and well connected political hacks get heard easily and given serious consideration, but that the people who are affected by policies have little or no voice in the process. For them, this was their opportunity to try to be heard.

Since you feel it is your right to demand that protesters be sent to some distant place where their voices can be muted, how would you feel if the government came along and told you that you were going to have to move to Wawa Ontario to set up your business and that you had no recourse?

The rights that you wish for yourself must be bestowed on all. If not, you are no better than the feudal lords of the middle ages.
 
I'm far from a constitutional expert but is my property not protected by the Charter also? If not, then we need an amendment to the Charter. Even the U.S. Constitution has 18 (more or less) amendments.

Property is not protected as such, but is protected by law including the criminal code. No one should be suggesting that breaking glass, looting or arson are protected by the Charter or by law (unless the state is doing it).
 
The cornerstone of a police state is to have the citizens inform on each other.

In matters of political expression, and legitimate dissent you are very right.

But reporting criminal behaviour, and standing up to be a witness for criminal behaviour is civic duty and should be encouraged.
 
The cornerstone of a police state is to have the citizens inform on each other.

The cornerstone of a democracy is to have the citizenry assist the police in catching lawbreakers.

The true cornerstone of a police state is that EVERYTHING is made illegal so that it is not really possible to be a law abiding citizen. The police then arrest those they dislike, while turning a blind eye to "crimes" committed by their friends. It's worth understanding this point--many people don't. We are in fact on a slipperly slope towards being a police state, with an increasing number of people not caring whether the law is upheld or not, so long as bad guys are caught.

If you fear a police state you should get your back up every time you hear someone justify some poorly written law by saying that the police will figure out how to enforce it properly, or "prosecutorial discretion" will fix the fundamental problem with the law. That's dangerous--it leads to more and more laws that everyone can't help breaking, and eventually it just boils down do who do the police and prosecutor want to go after, applying principles that aren't written into law, that are in fact probably quite arbitrary and personal. In fact the fundamental principle of fascism is that the government is meant to be run by people of "good character" who can be trusted to make the right decisions. The fundamental principle of democracy is that we do NOT trust the people in positions of power, we tightly constrain it through the rule of law.

However this isn't an example of that--these people committed acts that are criminal in any country, in the most democratic country. Arresting and punishing them for their vandalism, their assaults, their intimidation, and their rioting is an important part of maintaining a healthy democracy. People need to know that it's safe to walk down the street in this city, to open up a shop in this city, to go about your own business, even if there is a protest underway.

Shopkeepers ought to be able to step out and watch the protesters go buy, wave, and try to understand what they are about, without fearing that their shop will be burned, smashed, or looted. Families with their kids ought to be able to stand by the wayside watching the protesters march by without worrying for the safety of their children. That's a cornerstone of a democracy.
 
Property is not protected as such, but is protected by law including the criminal code. No one should be suggesting that breaking glass, looting or arson are protected by the Charter or by law (unless the state is doing it).

you are bang on in every post in this thread
 
Well said Fuji.

We'll make a Libertarian out of you yet.

Anybody care to answer the question:

Whenever an issue with the police comes up, there are always a large group of terbites that argue that the police is always right and they should be able to do whaever they find necessary, i.e be given absolute powers. I find that the average canadian are much less willing to give absolute powers to the police.

Why is it that people who see SP's for sex are more willing to give the police absolute powers? Is it because they are vastly more right wing oriented? is it in psychological terms an example of over compensation becasuse they are doing something that is not legal? are they latent homosexuals? are they americans? are there a lot of policemen here or what is the reason???

Danmand, no one is addressing your question for the same reason that no one here will argue with a wino in a bus shelter.

You're spouting deranged drivel.

Furthermore, your progressive-thinking associates may be embarrassed that your veneer has slipped, and you have said something that could possibly be offensive to homosexuals.

A willingness to give the police absolute power might be a factor of homosexual latency?

WTF?

As I said, deranged drivel. But tellingly, your posts often do suggest that far from being a holier-than-everybody-else-liberal, deep-down you're just a garden variety bigot, anti-semite, anti-American, bush-league homophobe.

Very few people here argue that the police are ALWAYS right. Hell, not even the police. Nor is there evidence of a meme toward giving the police more power. Plenty of crazy stuff about how to deal with child molesters, and the like, but radically expanding police powers? Not so much. Nothing, that I've noticed, at any rate.

You on the other hand, ALWAYS argue that the police are always wrong.

But then you're clearly nuts.
 
It appears that the police strategy is to prosecute only the ringleaders of the riots. 20 are currently in custody with another 20 to be rounded up. Most of the "peons" have been released without charges but that doesn't mean they didn't commit an offense.
 
Anybody care to answer the question:

Whenever an issue with the police comes up, there are always a large group of terbites that argue that the police is always right and they should be able to do whaever they find necessary, i.e be given absolute powers. I find that the average canadian are much less willing to give absolute powers to the police.

Why is it that people who see SP's for sex are more willing to give the police absolute powers? Is it because they are vastly more right wing oriented? is it in psychological terms an example of over compensation becasuse they are doing something that is not legal? are they latent homosexuals? are they americans? are there a lot of policemen here or what is the reason???
Not even tboy goes this far yet you claim a large group of terbites does?

At least you are consistent.
 
Danmand, no one is addressing your question for the same reason that no one here will argue with a wino in a bus shelter.

You're spouting deranged drivel.

Furthermore, your progressive-thinking associates may be embarrassed that your veneer has slipped, and you have said something that could possibly be offensive to homosexuals.

A willingness to give the police absolute power might be a factor of homosexual latency?

WTF?

As I said, deranged drivel. But tellingly, your posts often do suggest that far from being a holier-than-everybody-else-liberal, deep-down you're just a garden variety bigot, anti-semite, anti-American, bush-league homophobe.

Very few people here argue that the police are ALWAYS right. Hell, not even the police. Nor is there evidence of a meme toward giving the police more power. Plenty of crazy stuff about how to deal with child molesters, and the like, but radically expanding police powers? Not so much. Nothing, that I've noticed, at any rate.

You on the other hand, ALWAYS argue that the police are always wrong.

But then you're clearly nuts.
Perhaps there may have been a danmand post at some point in the past that I might have agreed with but I can't recall any and it seems like 99.9% of them are total bullshit. :D
 
deep-down you're just a garden variety bigot, anti-semite, anti-American, bush-league homophobe.

Is that all?


On days like this, I miss Lancslad.
 
It appears that the police strategy is to prosecute only the ringleaders of the riots. 20 are currently in custody with another 20 to be rounded up. Most of the "peons" have been released without charges but that doesn't mean they didn't commit an offense.

Nor does it mean that those illegally detained were given their constitutional rights, nor does it mean that they were not wrongfully arrested, detained or held in the first place.
 
At the end of the day, no good came of the riot. I mean absolutely nothing was acomplished, nothing is better than it was, a lot of personal and public property was damaged, people trying to do their thing were intimidated, threatened and harassed..

All that happened is a bunch of yahoos forced the government to spend a billion dollars on security so that no-one was killed and the city was not lit on fire.

What a collosal failure.
 
Saw on TV that 2 more of these culprits have been apprehended. Back in the glory days of The Empire, these two fellows would have been pressed ganged into the Royal Navy and sent to fight the French or Spanish.
 
At the end of the day, no good came of the riot. I mean absolutely nothing was acomplished, nothing is better than it was, a lot of personal and public property was damaged, people trying to do their thing were intimidated, threatened and harassed..

All that happened is a bunch of yahoos forced the government to spend a billion dollars on security so that no-one was killed and the city was not lit on fire.

What a collosal failure.

No matter which side of the debate you are on, I think most everyone can agree that what happened was a total shit show and the G20 should ner have been held where it was held.
I think the biggest thing we can all do now is to try and make sure a disaster like this never happens again.
 
No matter which side of the debate you are on, I think most everyone can agree that what happened was a total shit show and the G20 should ner have been held where it was held.
I think the biggest thing we can all do now is to try and make sure a disaster like this never happens again.

Now that's well said. And while we're sorting out who pays for the windows, and rounding up the last of the vandals, let's ponder why our democratic leaders think they can only meet behind walls that keep democracy out, and left their citizens hostages to thugs and hooligans because they've drafted all the police and spent spent billions besides, fortifying themselves for a weekend chat.

Who's idea of a good thing is that?

Look up Field of the Cloth of Gold.
 
let's ponder why our democratic leaders think they can only meet behind walls .

Because it takes only one maniac to kill a G-20 leader. Of course, the safest place for political leaders is in a totalitarian country because everybody, including maniacs, are kept under tight control all the time.

Actually, when the Queen was here, I was concerned that some maniac might try to do her harm.
 
When you give in to the terrorists..or the Bullies..you lose.

It is hard fo rme to blame organizers for wnating a meeting...and then blaming them because the true culprits did what they did!

BLAME MUST REST WHERE IT BELONGS....with the trouble makers and anarchists.

Blame the Police, HArper, the Organizers, the location all you like.

Not me!